High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37650/2015dismissed

Rahul v. State Of Haryana

2016-01-19Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh9 pages

!"#$ %&'' (& )&$

'"'& *"+"("

!&, (-&('

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , ! "

-.,/) '

1 "2!3 4 !+ #

, ! !

"!'!

1 "2!3 5

-.,/) '

!.$,+ !

,6'

6/ "

1 "2!3 %&&('

"./&&' (0#1-.

"'& '#&,&'' (& &&"23"#+",141*"+"(" 5#2"(+$ (0#1-.

"'& '#& 2,"("(' 7 #&,&&(',&'' (#"5&&(&-$(-& (7 8% 0"(' "(' ,"'

+ 5" ( "&

-"'&- &0'&&-$(-& 1 %"'% & '"' "$9#("0"1 ' '4$0"

( :&"(&- $(& '#&,&'' (& ('&(-'#"''#&,&'' (& #""&+5&&(2, "'&-('# "&-$&' ,"'+" ' (('#&."0&1 ;#&&"1#&#"( '#(0'

- ;'#'#&"&0"' (#& 2,"("('"(- ,&'' (&5& (0'

"2&."0&"(- "'&"(-#&;"('&-'

2"+;'# '#&,&'' (&5$'5&(0(&"' (1'#&2""0& $-( '5& &2(<&-

:&"(&- $(&$'#& ('&(-'#"''#& 2,"("('"2"&-"-+ "(-5& (0'

#&-$&-"'& #&('#&#"5' -0(0"&

2,"(' ",& "'

2, 2&"'& (5+&='" '(02 (&+ "& " #& -0&- " "&

8 -"'&- 7 $(-&

1 %"(- '#& #&-$&-"'&"(-'#&

#&-$&-5&%&.&(' ' '& '1 8 '"'% & '"' ( !"/&(-&"%"9"0"(' (&!"2>#$?

($1;# #;" 2, 2&- "'& ( 2"+"( '#& 2,"(' $'"0(0#&2 -&'+;""

-0&-"0"(' (&"#&(-&'

* % & '"' (!"/&(-&"%"91 4$0"

( :&"(&- $(&" ('&(-'#"', '

-0(0 '#& ,&&('

!1'#& 2,"("('#"-&.&(2 .&-"(",, "' (5& & *1 "#"% & '"' (1!&;"1;#&&(1( "&0"' ",&;"&.&&- #&2"''&;"(.&'0"'&-5+'#&, &5+ "(0&"'.& 5 '#'#& ,"'&'

"#"% & '"' (5$'( '#(0( 2("'(0;" $(-"0"('

'#&,&'' (& '" '#&$52 &"(&- $(&'#"''#&,&&('

! "( "'&'# $0#' "(- #" 5&&( &0'&&- /$' ' 5" 92" '#& ,&'' (& & .&1'#&&;"-&"+ @2 ('#( -0(0 '#&

!1 ;# ## ;'#"''" "& "&2, "' ( '" &" 2'#& "&0"' (&.&&-('#&

!'#"' 2,"("('#"-#&&&'#&# $& ;'#,&'' (&"(-.&-@'".&&-"'-&&('," &"(-'#&&"'&'#&

2,"(';"2"-&

'#(0'

5&& .&&- 2'#&,&'' (&"(-#& &"-+'

/ ('#&(.&'0"' ( :&"(&- $(& '#& 2,"("('$52''#"''#&. '2 &2"(&-;'#'#&,&'' (&""("$"( &'

2"+;'##&;"0.&( 5$''#&",&;" 22''&-$, (#&"&'#&. '2;"2"&-"''#& "0& ;'# $'#& (&('5$'#&--( ' #"5';'##&&"& #$5"(-"#&(&.&;&(''

#&( ";# $& :&"(&- $(& '#&&, (-&('

'"'&$52''#"''#&

,&'' (&- &( '-&&.&'#& ( & +5""",&;"

22''&-$, ('#&. '2 (0.(0"("$"( &'

&2(<&2""0& 5$'$5&A$&('+#&5" 9&- $' 2#, 2&:&"(&- '"'& $(& " $52''#"'"; (0".&2&('#"5&&(2"-&'#"'2"(+ 2,"(' ;&&2"-&5+'#&. '21;#&&"1( $ # 2,"(';"&.&2"-&5+ #& *&"-'#&"0$2&('"-."( &-5+&"(&- $(& '#& ,"'&"(-#".&" 0 (&'# $0#'#&"&0"' (&.&&-('#&

!"(-

'#&- $2&('".""5& ('#&& ,&"&0"' (&.&-('#&

!1" 2,"(';"2"-&5+ '#&. '2'"'(0'#&&('#"''#&,&'' (&#"-'

-#&'#"'( -+ (0 '

2"+ #& 5& "$& ",& #" 5&&( 22''&- $, ( #& "(- "$&-'

2"+#&B, ('#"$"( &15 '# '#&2&2"(&-("

&('&-"

-"' (5$'"'& 2&'2&#&;"0.&(5&"'(0"(- ",& ;" 22''&- $, ( #& "0"(' #& ;#& #& ",& ;"

22''&- (0.(0"&, 2& 2""0&"(-'#&&"'&#&;" #""&-" #& (+"0$2&(';# ##"5&&("&-5+&"(&-

$(& '#&,&'' (&'#"''#&. '2('#&#"5' 2"9(0 "&

2,"(''

5" 92" '#& ,& ( &'#&&"(&- $(& '#& ,&'' (&( '"'&#"5 $0#''

'#&( ' & '# $'"(+ 2,"('

2"-&5+'#&. '2&= &,''#&".&2&('2"-&('#&

!'#"'&"&#& #-2""0&;",& 2&-5$'#&(&.&/ (&-'#& 2,"(+ #& #$5"(- $(0 '#& $& "0$2&(' '#& "&1 ' #" 5&&( 5 $0#''

'#&( ' & '#& $''#"'";''&( 2,"(';"2"-& "0"(''#&. '2'

22 (& % &14$0"

(1' '4$0"

(1 -$+0(&-5+2"(+."0&'"'(0'#&&('#"''#&. '2('#&#"5' 2"9(0"& 2,"('"0"(''#&+ $(0,& (/$''

#""'#&2

7 ;'#'#&#&, #&,"&(' #& 5"- #"" '&"(-, (0'#& "'2 ,#&& '#&."0&

( &'" "& +5"1' "(( '5&"-"''# '"0&"'

;#&'#&"(+ 2,"('2"-&5+'#& 2,"("('"& ( '

'#"" 5&&("0$&-'#"''#&,&'' (&"(- 2,"("('"& &+ &"'&-"(- $-( '5&2"&-'

&" # '#&'#&&"&0"' ("& 2"''& &.-&( &"(- "(5& (-&&--$(0'"

0"(' +5"1'#&("'$&10".'+ &( &" ;&" & '#&" $&-'

5&&&(#&&"& &'"(" '

1;# # "&'

5& (-&&-;#&0"('(05"$(-& (7 8%* (C5& '#&,&= $'("/$-02&('&(-&&-( &, "

6 6'+ &6

8" &

!#.-&& &',&'!

8D#"$22"<&- &'"( " '

5&'"9&(('

(-&"' (;#&0"('(0"(' ,"'

+5"1;# # "&&, -$ &-"$(-& E#&,( ,&;# # "(5& $&- $'1 '#&,$, & '#& ('"(' "&1 "(5&'"'&-"$(-& #& 2,"(' &- "0"(' '#& " $&- (&&- ' 5& '# $0#+ &="2(&-1 ( $-(0 '#& ",& ' ;#&'#& '#&

2,"("('#"&-""& .

$ 2,"(' (&"&

" (#& $'# $-" &="2(&'#&" ';#&'#& '#&& "(+ "2+ -,$'& 5&';&&( '#& " $&- "(- '#&

2,"("('"(-'#& 2,"("('2$'5& &"+'

-'#"' '#& 2,"(' $(-'

5&"& .

$1'#&(' '" ' ( ; 5& '"9&( "0"(' #2 ( "

-"( & ;'# "; '#&

((."( & 5&';&&( '#& 2,"("(' "(- '#& (.&'0"'(0

& &'"5#&- '#&( " ' ( 5& '"9&( "0"(' '#& (.&'0"'(0 &("

-"( &;'#"; #&0".'+ #"0&"(-'#&&=" ' & '#&" $&-

2$'5&, ,&+ 2,&#&(-&->& &"&'1'#&"&'(0

&2$'& -'#&."-&" (;# ##".&&-'

'#& "&' '#&" $&-('#& "&-"+ (&= &,' (" "&1 '#&&" $-5&& -&-22&-"'&+"'&'#&"&'1

'#"';#&-&"(0;'#'#&5"",, "' (1'#&&2"9"(-

5&."' ( '#& "&'(0 & "( " 5& , ,&+ &."$"'&-5+'#& $' ' 2,&"'.& '#& $' '

"&$+ "(- ;'# 2&' $ $ ,& ( &."$"'& '#& " ' '#& "& #& - &' ('

0"('5"2$'5&&=& &- ('#&5" '#& ".""5&2"'&""(-'#&" ' '#&,"' $" "& ( "& ;#&&'#& $' '#& (-&&-.&;'#"''#&" $&-#" / (&-'#&(.&'0"' ("(-#&$+

,&"'(0;'#'#& (.&'0"'(0"0&( +"(-( '9&+'

"5 (-1('#"'&.&('1 $'

-"('& 0"' (# $-5&".

-&-0&"'0( 2(+1 #$2"' ("(--0" &"''" #&-'

"&'&'&"-'

2"(+& $ (&A$&( &( ' (+ '#&" $&-5$' '#&&('&"2+"(-"''2& '#&&('& 22$('+ '

,& ,&- ( '2"9&"(+-'( ' (5&';&&("&'"'",&

(. ' ('"0& , '

(. ' ('"0& .#&&( /$' "' ( &"-(0('

(7 8% '#&2'"' (2&(' (&-( (7 %#&,&(''$-&

( 7 8 2$' 5& 0.&( ' $ ,"+ #&& (

&A$&2&(''#"''#&" $&-2$'2"9& $'"E,& " "&F '#&&=& & '#&, ;&'

0"('"(' ,"'

+5"# .'$"+1&-$ &'#&"$'"+, ;& (&&-5+ (7 %'

"-&"-&''&,& (&&9(0"(' ,"'

+5"' "&&2"(&(''&-'

'#&,&$2,' (( &( &*&

;(0'

$52''

&'"('"(- (-' (#&&- 215+ '#&" &,'"( & (-' (;# #'#& $'2"+-&&2''

2, &1( (-&"' '#&"$"( &'#"'"&'&-1#& #"5&&("0&- (5" . #& , ,& $& " ' ( ( "( ",, "' ( "(' ,"'

+5" $0#''

5&'#"'"'&&."$"'(0'#&".&2&(' "(-" $"' (".""5& ('#&& -'#& $'( (&- '

0"('"(' ,"'

+5"'#&("(('&25"5&0"('&-"(- ( ' &5&$&-'

'#&%$5 % & $'

'&#&"(0'#& %$5 % & $'

'#& $'2"+&'#&&/& ''#&"(' ,"'

+ 5"",, "' (2'#&('" -& 0"('(05"#&

$';

$- &'"(+5&&(''&-'

2, & (-' ( '#& 0"(' "(' ,"'

+ 5" #& %$5 % & $'

'#&

2,"("(';

$-5&"'5&'+'

2 .&'#&"2& $' "( &"' 2 -+(0'#& (-' "(' ,"'

+5""'

"(+ '2& 5&'+ 0"('&- 5+ '#& $' 2$&- #& "(' ,"'

+ 5" 0"('&- 5+ '#& $' # $- -("+ 5&

('($&-''#&'" '#& "& . '"&''&-&0", ' ('#"''#& $';# #0"(''#& 5"" #"'#&, ;&'

"( &'#&- &' 0"(' "( &"' 5" "(5&&=& &-&'#&"''#&('"( & '#&" $&-1'#&%$5 % & $'

'#& 2,"("('1 ( (-(0(&;2"'&" $2'"( &"'"(+, (' '2& . (,$$"( & '#& -& '#& $' & '#& *0# $'1 ( &'#&" $&-&&"&- ("(' ,"'

+5" 5+'#&'" $'1'#&(';

$-5&$(&" ("5&'

2,&'#& " $&-'

$&(-&5& &'#&'" $'"(-"0"(",,+ &0$"5"

. &' (.&'&-('#& $'("2"''&# $-5& &=& &-;'# "&"(- $2,& ' (-&,&(-(0$, ('#& " '"(- $2'"( &/$'+(0'&=& & 2"+1'#& - &' ( .&'&- ;'# '#& $' $(-& ( 7 8 % # $- " 5& &=& &- ;'# "$' ( "(- ,$-&( & ' $((& &"+'

'".&5&+ (-'"(-$5/& ''#&;-&, ;& "(-- &' (&&-5+'#&&0"'$&'

"0 $ -&

& 2, &-2'"' ( =

(&=5& 0$-&(& '"'/" 9&' 2$" "( 5& , .-&- 0"(' &$" +5"5& "$&" $2'"( & "(- '$"' ( $'$& "(( ' 5& &"+ .$"&- '#& 0"(' &$" "(' ,"'

+ 5" (

( ("( &;'#&0"'.&('&(' (1'#&0"(' &$" "(' ,"'

+5"# $-(& &"+-&,&(- ('#&" '"(- $2'"( & &" # "& =G&#"" &, -$ &,"" '#&/$-02&(';#&&( '#& $'-&(&"'&-'#& ;(0" '

"(-,""2&'&'#"'

(&&- '

5& '"9&( ('

(-&"' ( ;#& -&"(0 ;'# "(' ,"'

+5" "#&("'$&"(-0".'+ '#&" $"' ("(-'#&&=" ' &

'#&" $&-2$'5&, ,&+ 2,&#&(-&-5& &"&'

2"-&H 5#&"('& &-&(' '#&",, "('( $-(0'#&" '"'

;#&'#&'#&" $&-#",&. $+$(-&0 (&2, (2&('

(. ' (5+" $'(&,& ' "(+ 0(<"5& &( &H #&, 5'+ '#&",, "(''

&& 2/$' &H -#&, 5'+ '#&" $&-C9&#

&,&"'2"

'#& &( &H

8 &G#&&'#&" $"' (#".&5&&(2"-& (+;'# '#&

5/& ' (/$(0 #$2"'(0'#&",, "('5+"&'(0#2

#&H 2," ' 0"(' +5","' $"+( "& "0&2"0('$-&"& '(0".&+"0&($25& ,& ,&H 0 #& $' 2$' &."$"'& '#& &('& ".""5& 2"'&" "0"(''#&" $&-.&+ "&$+#& $'2$'" &"+

2,&#&(-'#&&=" ' & '#&" $&-('#& "&#& "&(;# #'#&" $&-2, "'&-;'#'#&#&,

7"(-7 '#&%&(" -&18'#& $'# $-

(-& ;'# &.&( 0&"'& "& "(- "$' (1 5& "$&

.&2, "' (('#& "&"2"''& (9( ;&-0& "(- ( &(H #G#& (-&(0'#&,"+& 0"(' +5"1"

5""( &#"'

5&'$ 95&';&&(';

" '

1("2&+1(

,&/$- &# $-5& "$&-'

&&1""(-$(.&'0"' (1 "(-'#&&# $-5&,&.&(' #""2&('1#$2"' ("(- $(/$'&--&'&(' '#&" $&-H #& $' # $- (-& &" ("5& ",,&#&( ( '"2,&(0 '#& ;'(& ",,&#&( ( '#&"' '

'#&

2,"("('H / .

'+(, & $' (# $-";"+5& (-&&-"(-'

(+ '#& &&2&(' 0&($(&(& '#"' #" #".& '

(-&&-('#&2"''& 0"(' 5""(-('#&&.&(' '#&& 5&(0 2& - $5' " '

'#& 0&($(&(& '#& , & $' (1('#&( 2" $& &.&('1'#&" $&-( &(''&-'

"( -& 5"

(.&; '#&" '"2&(' (&-"5 .&"(-'#&"&0"' (

&.&&-('#&

!1'#&,&'' (&( '&(''&- 0"(' +5" "( "&#&&&"&-1#&2"+'+'

($&( &'#&;'(&& & .&1 & $"&0"' ("&'#&&"0"(''#&,&'' (& -(0+1'#&&(

2&'('#& ('&(' ("&-5+&"(&- $(& '#&,&'' (&"(-'#& ,&'' (5&(0-&.

- "(+2&'#&&5+-2&- D"($"+ 1 1 3 ,