Harbhajan Singh v. State Of Haryana
!
""# $ % & ""'( )))) #
*# +,-.(/ '
# /+ (%-..*- &
% + ,-.(/
'0 1-.(/ 1', ))))
'%( 3 # !
( 1 ' & , ' 45 6 33- (( 3 %( ( + 5#- ! ( #, +,(/6! - .1 , 738 - (+ % 9',( ' ,,9! (
!" # $ % %% #
-2-
# & # " #
" ' () # * + , -.-
/ % & " &
0 " & %" & 1 " % 2# #
3+, 4-5 7 : ( %, ' !%( '
- ' ,,&1',(- ' 9 ''
(( '(/ ., !6
- 9 9 %( 11 - ,!
%(6/;%1 5% 1( '
%/ 1',-9 9 '(, 9,,( &
' / ( %01( 1%3-< - .2 (-( /!,-.( ((1 ,'
/! ( 1 1 !
,& (% %,- ' 9 9%,( 9 11% 9%,(,, '(, ( 0111 ( < !5 !%( /' '
% / - 1 , '
( 1% -< (
/ ( 1 %(.1;%1 (-9(
/ / ( 1 6/ ;%1 5 % 1( ' /,/(& ( 1(
-3-
' !
'
( 3 , '', ,( % =%(!-.1 , ' ( 9 ',(9,,, ( >%11! ,,!(-( 2 (' !
'
'
(%( ,9 + % " 8 /' " # # " 9-:
% 0% ! #% &%" & # 4% 8 5 # ; < = 6" = !"% #
#)
3&2 20 % " # % 8 /< > # 4?
5 6 1 @ " #& & 8 ; < = 6" = ? !"% # #)
2&...0 % %@<' #
%
% )
-.&...0 # 7 5 % % 1( ,,& %, 9 ( %( % ' 9 1',( ,,!((,% 11( & %((, 1 ,, ' 5 !%( 1 ,& (,% 1- ' %,( 1',(
-4-
: ( %, ' ,( %' %(!1'(- & (+ % (( 8,(?
( %(!1 '(
!"
# $%
-( 1 ,& (,% 1 %( ' %,( (( , 2 ,/ '
& %(!1
'
(%( ,9 ?
#
"()*
++-3
-.
< - *6<'6 < = & ; - ) #%#"/ 6 < &66<& # < 6 & < " < & ; 4) 5 < &% +
> < %
9 A
B? & % 8 # 3 =
# % " %
-5-
2 & <
"% # #" " " () * 3+ - -.
D <
2& - & -- *6< '& 6 < < =E () * 2
-.-. <
+.9& ,D&++-&+2+&--3&--2& 3-9& 3,& 6& 6 < < = F ()*
+
+--
-.
<
2&- &-2&- *6<'&6 < A D "
"
9 % " # "
&
# " # % % '
%
&
" # % "
#
, ?" %
#
&
-6-
" 1
#
' 0 " ?%" &
1 " % % ' 0 " #
" < 3+,4-5
%" 1 " & " #0 " 7 ,/ ' "
& 5 %(!1
'
(%( ,9 ?6 # < 3+, ()*
,, ., .3 -.-. <
2& ,&-9'&- *6<'& <
3.& ,,&- D&3
&3-.&3D9& 3D,&39 &3936 < D < '6 < 6%& A 6 %-3, #
& A2..
A
% " () % &
-7-
8 * %
-9 .2 -.-. %
" 1 "
-9 .2 -.-. G ? "
"
< 3+, 6 # () *
,, , -.-. < 2& ,&-9'&- *6< '&
,2 6 < 6%& A =
# # % " # -3, #
& 2..
% " " # %
# () 8 % % " ? " " " #
-8-
* .
-.-.
& / < / &'H &? # / % & 1 " " #0 " &
0 " &1 " % #
< 3+,4-5
'()*(+ ),#- .(-/0
*-"1,
& % 1 # < < % % % %
#" %# = <
& %
% % <
" ! "
-9-
6 1 " & <
# ?"
& " " " # > )1 # 2
3
4 ) 5 $4
(66
) 7 %
" % " % % < 2+ *6< ' % < -2 " ' '
#
% # < -2 " ' < < D9*6<'
*6<' "% &% 1 -9 .2 -.-.&% # # ?%" & 1 " % 8 # " #
" < 3+,4-5 6 7 @/9 ' 1 ,,-, (%,
-10-
' % 1( ' %, ',& (( 8 .A% # 3-1 -' !
'
( 9 ,( & 5. -.1 ,&-9%,( 9 ' 90(
& %( 1 ', ,,!( ( 5 % 1( 9 - ' (& '& 1%-< 1',9 %'
%(! !
,1 '
5,% 1( /' '
%- .2 ( %(( 9, .2 (- % ,&- ' 9%,( / %( 12 ( /!,( .( ( % ' (- %- 1 9 '- 1 9%,( / ((/ ', : ( %, 9,, %, 1',-
/ ''( , '', '! % %(
/' (! ( ' %,( !
( ' & ,5% % 1( , %!
11%( 1 ,'
/ / ( % .2 (-( /!,- .( (( ,1%-< & / ( 1 ' 5% % 1( ' (1 /!( 9(( & 1', ' /,/( (5 !%( 9 , 1 ,'
' ,(( 9'
' ( % ( , (%, ' ' (%,&>%,('
,(9 0( @A%/1'&B 0'% ( ( 1'%
-11-
.'',(/ 9 ' 9,,>%,(( ( /( + 1 & 1# C/ &- (!
( ''( @A%/ 9 1 ,& , & D-< (,9 0!9 C (1'& ' 19 0 1 1 '9 ( (( 9, &-< ' 1 -,% 12 ' /,/(& 2 / & 1 , '
1',9,, 1% -< , (&
( 1 %(2 9 %' & 1', 9 ' (, ( 9 ,,( 1 ,'
(91( /, 01 9 11(- 9 ' 9 1, (-9/,/( 1 ,@/9 ' 1 ,, ' - ',&(( 8 .A% # 3 ,( & 5. , ( & ( / & , ( 1 / -!- 1( ,,(,( !%1 / 1(9 ' 9 , ' ( 9 (&'& 1% -< 1',-9 %'
%( !
;'!/9 / ( ( %1- '
' ' & ,,,9(( 1 ( (( 38 1( ,% ' - % 1(-9%,(% ( -< 1 1',9 ' (90 1 ( ' ( '& ( - , ( %, 1', ( , ( %, 1',
-12-
9,, (/ 1 1',2 1',9%,( , & 1 ( '&1 9 % '
%( !
' ,,15- 9/ -1(, - ((1(( !/9 '%,(' (- '
' ,, (1( / (1( However, nothing stated above shall be construed as a final expression of opinion on the merits of the case and the trial would proceed independently of the observations made in the present case which are only for the purpose of adjudicating the present bail application.
!"#$% &'&(&) (' '0!< ( F<6 ' , F<6