High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/527/2023disposed of

Yogesh Singhal v. Arvind Singh

2025-08-28Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages

! "

##" $%&

%'(!

)% % !&* ('! + ('( % , -.+ ('% ##"

% * /&-%! %-+ ('%%#(

00000 !"#$% %!&'(!")

*&!+,

1 ##" "( #%##"&(%! 2% %%"'"##" -#&( %(%((

#(.3"%(,&("%4"+ 5%(.(+6 %.3+ %"&% 7&(%#( &( -#"&(%! %( 6 !2 8." 4%&- +

% %+9 :

% * /&-%! %-+ ('+ &(##% . "%#(( "( )6% %3+6 * %%(

;:."!&#%-&% -$

#+#$./01 /2!23/!+ 4$

2!2!$#5!&!2 .3 * , *&/1/2!+, 6) % (%."

(&(-#%'%#%! ( 2 % +"&(( '- % "##"&(%! % .% &%! "'#% ( <&(-&(%

= 1 %% .'(%% (.".%(""6 5%"3+ '-%--& '."& % #%%##"6 .%&-%.( .33(#%( 4 +'- &(%! + +#3% "(% 7&#%6 &%( -# --(.3#%6 %( +-"3+ &(+6 7& . ( &%( !("3+ % '-%--&. #"(#%6 % &(6 &%('+6 +-%% #%% ##"&(%!2 %

#% '(%- % #%%##" &(%!2-%% (. &.<( 3 ( !-"%"3+ '- %-+ 6 '% . &% %-+ &(""3-& '% #%%##" 1 %("3+% % )%"- & % #%'&.

6 &-(3(#%(.&"""( .3 '- + 6 >#% " "&( ""%#%'(('- 6 #%%##"

%%3+%(%7&"+ !+ %& )&.")%&%#%%

##"' -#"(#%%& ##"+ & &%& ##"6 "' &% ;6'%+"63%3% !%-#"#%%##"

?&6 - '-@ % #%% ##"+ *#""'##"%- ; &%&(%! 2 % 6&"(. %%36 .((.3 )%"-.3 % #%'! % 5&% "3+ )%"- -((! %&-%. '-@% #%%##" <& 6 %%(-#"% ! "##"

% (+ )%"- %( #%'! ' &#%%% % '-#%% ##" %&(-( %-#%( -#"

5 "3+ '"'- !%# &(%! #&& .3. 1 .& -#""(&(% #%' &%#%'-#" #%! % (!2 .3>#%%#% #%' % -%%"& (-( %(%-" 1 %%+ -#"+ 6 '-( &% 7&-&. %&(.'-%- #%'! %(6 ('-&(%!

6 %

5&% %+ ##"3 (% #%#' '%%&"+ ;:."!&#%-&% /&#3.7&!.# #4#20#

2.#++/9#23# 4$

2 :01!& &7&!

/2 &/1/2!+ ;;#!+ 7

< 8

(/.% &/1/2!+ ;;#!+ 7

= '#3/'#'

= ) 6 ""%3 <&(- "".##"."%%#'"3+ "(&(% =B 1 ("%&("6 &.' % +.3 ""&%+(%(.#%#'&" >#%"3 % .3 %3 -#" -( ' %%#'#% 1 ""->-C8'& 5&&%5%-4-#%.+8)%%C( 6"6& %&"6 ""6( #+%%6 #%&-##%#'3( #%&-#%""3(#%&" %%3 6 .3 >#% #%' & % %%#'3 %6 (%." %& %3 -#" 1 .

& & & 6&"( ' 7&'(% +-#6.&%(% -#% > ." ;6'%+ 6 ( %(%#%%( %#%#" #%'&.7&"3'%%&"(.3 ("%% . + 7& '%%&"%*"3(% (.3(&"+%%#' %/$ /$ >#3!0$# /.

/$ $#..+#'

+!( .%!.

.%# +!( '#3+!&#'

.%/$ 70&.

/$ &#.&7$;#3./4# !2'

/$ 27&1!++?

!$$01#'

.7 ># .%# +!( 8&71 .%# /23#;./72

1 #%6"3(&%%&"-&. &( 6 <&(- "0'91#2.

7& '#3/$/72 (%/3% /2.#&;&#.$ !

$.!.0.# 7& ;&74/$/72 .%#&#78 '#3+!&#$ .%# 1#!2/29 .%# $.!.0.# !$ /.

$%70+'

># 372$.&0#'

8&71 .%# '!.# /.$ #2!3.1#2.

7.%#& (7&'$) .%# "0'91#2.

'#3+!&#$ (%!.

.%# +#9/$+!.0&# %!'

$!/'

.%# ./1# (%#2 .%# +!( (!$ ;&710+9!.#'

!2'

.%#&#87&#) /.

%!$ &#.&7$;#3./4# #88#3.

%%3+ &% %&" 6 #%&-(.#%#'&">#%"3-(

%%#' D ""6%- -+ (% <&(-&#%#""6##".""" %%#' #(3.%(% %&-6 .&( - "66 >(%- # %(& %#%' D .("%(. "6 "( -&. "( '"63. "6 "( 1 "&"-%- %" (&3 &%C#%&6"6.&-( >#&( "(C -# (((

1 %%+'6 <&(-%(%(.3 ;:." !&#%- &% #+#$./01 /2!23/!+ &#% ( /&#3.7&!.# #4#20#

2.#++/9#23# &#%+ "%( ! ,&(+ %(+ (%(% #%"'##"##""(&(%! % (%& - ##%#%&%%(#" -%

%3(%(( -#"##%.*( %%( "%(!,&(+%(+% 6

#(+%("3 )(##"+3+" ((#(

* , 6

D %!#*F (

F8 D % #%."