High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2122/2003disposed of

The Punjab Small Industries & Export Cor v. Chuhar Singh And ORS.

2019-04-25Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia34 pages

!"#

!#!

$$!

#"&&'(!#) &

! "

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

$#0%/'*0%&&) 340/&0 0%&/. $#0%/)&0%&&) 340/%+0 0%&/- $#0%/%%0%&&) 340/%-0 0%&/- $#0%/%.0%&&) 340/%.0 0%&/- $#0%/%*0%&&) 340/)&0 0%&/- $#0%/'+0%&&) 340/)/0 0%&/- $#0%/)'0%&&) 340/)%0 0%&/- $#0%/)+0%&&) 340/))0 0%&/- $#0%/'%0%&&) 340/)'0 0%&/- $#0%/*&0%&&) 340/)*0 0%&/- $#0%/'/0%&&) 340/)-0 0%&/- $#0%/).0%&&) 340/')0 0%&/- $#0%/%'0%&&) 340/''0 0%&/- $#0%/',0%&&) 340/'0 0%&/. $#0%/)%0%&&. 340/*0 0%&/.

$ %&'$

( ' ( ( )& 5 6$ ( 718 6 7 ( 718 6

" ( 718 69 :

( 718 6;

( 718 "<101 6 ="

"(= 6 ; =7( 71 6;=( 71 ( ( )&*

>/? @ .- /- 101 1 *' A 1B 1( /.,' 1 &+</&&'/,,% "

! " 1B 7

@ ; 91= @ 7

B(= (= 6 ; 7

= 7 @ 1B"

=" >%? @ A 1B

17 " )&&*/,,' 7

!//),+1 "1B

=" (" 1

" "

" 1 ! 17 " /)&/%&&) 1 "

+ +,(-.+ +//!0*& 0- 10 "

1 )' 1 ( 7 "50 &, !2 --0- //!0 3! 0 39 '*&&&<0 *+%*&<0 $ '&&&&<0 *&&&&<0 3: /&&&&<0 /%*&&<0 =6 ; *&&&<0 +%*&<0

>)? ! 7

= %%.& ; %.*1"

1B 1 " !

1 7 " $/ )&&*/,,' 50 *'(-&&<0 3< *'(-&&<0 =6 ; *'(-&&<0 39 34 =6 ; >'? " /,//%&&* 1 ; 7 ( 1 // 1 7

= * . 7

1 11

1 ; "

" 1B ' - 7

6 7

" 1 @ 1 !

1 ;

+; /.; ' " 7

3 9 !/,,/ 1 7 ! (" !1 @ ;7 7

: /'&&<0 7

: 1 /+&%/,,/ 7

@ 7

" 7 " @ 1 " "

1 " 1 "* /

* ; 1 ";1

"1 "

1 " = 7

"11 ! >*? " %%//%&&* "

1 ! /)

1( 1 "

" 7 @

1( A 9 ( 7 7"

" " /,//%&&* ; 7 >/?"; >+? ! ) ! %*//%&&*( ) 1 "

= "

* /; 1 7 1 " 7

6 @ 1 " ; 7" " A0/&%,>; 7 ? >-? ! ,+% 1

6 ;( 7 " %+//%&&*( 1 1

! 1 " ! A 1B

1 1 ,-1 (-.+ + //!0* & 0-10 "

;7 50 39 +%&&&<0 =6 ; >.? " &-&)%&&-

6 ; 1" 1 7 1 1 !

+ >,? @ /-&/%&&."

1 + 1 1 "

" ,45- 6, + (0,0 3 4,5( 1 7

= 6 ; /+&&<0 >%(*+(&&&<01?! !; 1 /'&&<0 " /&! ( (11 7 ( ;7 " !("

1 1 /&A1 1,!+,(-.+ (0,03 4,5&, 7#37

1 /-&/%&&.( 1 1 !"

! 1 1B 1 "

" 1B 9

1" " 1 1B !/% 1 "

1B 9 7"

" 1@ 1B" 7

!( 1 1 "; @ 8 8 (0,03 4,59 +,,-:; 1 &%//%&/. " ! 1"

/+&&<0

!" # # "

$%&'

"("%!!%") " *!!!+&')%, "# " !%

>//? @ " 1 - " A $,./ %,0//0%&&& 7 @

1( A 1B 9 ( %%//%&&*" 1 "

! 1 1 1 " 7 @

11 1 B 1 1 "

! 1 ! 1 &%&%%&&.(&+&%%&&.(&-&%%&&.(&,&'%&&.(%/&*%&&. >/%? B ! %.&/%&/+ 7" " ; ! 1 ; 7 " C /+&&<0 >%(*+(&&&<01? !

1 A1$' %.-%&&)4

7 1 /.//%&&. "

" 1 7

@; : "

" 1 9 1B !(&7$,++ 00 4,5(0,0>+? " 1B 9 7 " %*&./,,. !A 1B

1 >/)? @ ; 7 ; 7" " 11 &,&'%&&. &!, # 3#

00(+,<, 4,5(0,09

&/&)%&/'&,

-4&,/ 4,5 (0,09 "

" " &-&%%&&. + (-.+ 4,5(0,0* " ,/5-(-.+9 //!09 /-&,%&//( ;7 1 C/+&&<0

>/'? !( " 11

1 1"

7 1 /)&/%&&)( /-&/%&&.( &%&%%&&.( &+&%%&&.( &-&%%&&.(&,&'%&&.(%/&*%&&. %.&/%&/+ >/*? 0 7 ! "; 1 1 7 " /)&)%&&) >/+?

0 11

! !( " /)&/%&&) "

1 "

" 1 !7 1 1 "; 1

1 C%(*+(&&&<01! B" >/-? "( ( 7

1 " 1 7 1< "@ "

!1 " "

" 1 1B @ " 9 1 =" 7! " ; 7

:(/'&&<0

D ;7 "

! B " ! 1 7 1 7

" 1 ( "7 1 ! 7

, 1 7

" 1B 1

1 1 1;( 1

! >/.? " /)&/%&&)"

" 11 " "! 1B " "< "

9 1 " " " 1 ; 1! "

1 ) ;

1B " ! 1 1 7"

* /; "1 7

= "

! !"

! ! " 7

@ " "

" 7

: 6 @ ; 3 " .,;

1B 1

" A 1B

1"" " >/,?

" " 7

7 1 ! "! "

/,//%&&* 1 1 1 7

= D"7( 1 " 7

= " "* /; 1"1 E 1 ! " + ; %/ ; + " "

1 " %+(++/<0%,(&+-/<0 39 !/,,/ !( " " !A 1B

1 "*&&&<0 *'(-&&<01"

@ " 7

- : "

;7 " C/'&&<0 " 11

!1 " 7

>%&? " %+//%&&*"

1 1 1

1 ;7 7

F 1 1 7

= " 1 ! B ! " >*? 1 1

1-3-, ,-

,/ (-.+ :

( "#8 (1!-,/ &, !2 --0- 33-! 6,-.=,:

;"(>? +,,, -<,!+,/ ,+ -.,5,/1<0 0+-0@:

; 7(7?"

;7 7

1 ;1 1 "

11 1B1

7 >%/?

,- ,/(-.+1>?( 1 " 1 "

" A

! 9731 ! 1 1B *7

" 1 1 !( 1 "

@ 1 11 ;

11 ; 7 1 1B1 11

" 1 "1 1" >%%? !( +,, , 1 >?( 1B " D 3 !

@ 1 1 1 A 1B

1 ! 1 1 !) "

" 7@ "

1 (

" 1 1B

11 7 1 7 1 7 ;7 "1 "; 1 1 "

1 ! 1 "

! 1 "

! 7 1@ 7 50

1' !

" # # # #

1 ' $

# " !

# "

1' $

& '

" '

(

# "

)

# (

1%) %'

& #

( ( + >%)?

6,-.=,%1>?( " 7

B " 7 D"7( 1 7

G 1"

; 7 ! " 1 1 "

1 7 17

11 ! ! 1 7 1 1 ! 1 "

" ! 7 11 1;1 1 17

;7 1B

@ 7 50 ,

# # - % # (

./ '

# "

(

# 0

1 2 3 % (

(

# #

# 3 # #

.4 '

# (

" 3 # " % #

$ #

(

# 3

(

# ( .5 3 "

# "

3 &

(

!"#$ %%#&''( .. '

(

% %# # (

# '

(

" + >%'? ! <=,0- -3-,:

7;>(">( ;7 "

" ; >%*? @ 1 7 " ! "

" ;7 "

7 "

1 1' 1 @ 1 "

; "

1 "

7 7 1"

7 ! 7!!"

1 !! 1 "

" " @ ! 1 1 "

;

+ ! 1 1 1 1 7 ! ,-(-.+ -3-,:

(""

! 7 11 " "

! 0 7

1 >%+?

, -. , ,<+!+,, -

,=,A,:

; (7> ("

7 1 %) %' ; 1 " +-<,/,/ ,.-, (1!-,/&,!2 --0-//!0* ,*:

??;7 (>"

1%'( ; 1 ! 1 7 1B "

; ! 11 "

1B @ ! " 1 " !

! 1

1 11 1 :

>; @

! 1

1 ! ( 1

1 ;

@ ! "< 11! !11 "

"! 1 1 71! 7 1 ( 1 1 " 1 "

7;11@ 1"7; ! 1"

1 C/+&&<0

! 1 : : 7

1 1 " "

1 1 @

? 3

B&A+=, 00 + (0,0 3 ,@,, , ,0+(

1 /+.%&/&

" 7 1 B 7 1 " "

1B ! 1 ! ; 1

" 7 1 7 ;7 "

! ,,06 <,9 :

;

( "# ( ,3, $,,5, /1<0 0+-0@ :

>; > ( # (1!-,/&,!2 --0-33-! 6,-.=,:

;"(>?

>%.? @ &.&'/,,% %/&,/,,%"1

/(,%(&&&<0 " 1 .;

@ " 11 1 ! " 1 /&"1 ! "< 7 "1 !" 1 7 1 ;7 1 1 D"7( 1 7

= 1 7

6 " 1 17 # ("

1 ! 7

= "! 9 1 "

6 "

9 1 ! 11 ;7 7! A 1B

7 D"7( 1 7

= ;7

! 1 1 = 7

"! 1 = "

"1 ! 1 7 11 1 ! 3 1 7

= " 1B 1 G

$ < <3 ! A 1B

1 "

1 1 7 >%,?

1 11 1( 7 1 01 ;7 "

" >)&? 7 1 1 A $'+,+<,.

1(A 1B "

" ;" 1B " 7 "

! 7 9 1 " 71! 1(D

1 (3;31 ( 9!( @ 1 ! 1

1 17 ! 1 "

; #1!< ( = 7 ( F 3 ( 1 1 6 = 1! " !

! # !( 9

= #1!(:63 3 " 1 1B @ " ! "

";"

"7!"

11 ! ( 71 1 7

6 ;( = ( ( 6

1 ; " " "

" " 1 9 1 ("

D 1 4: @ "! 6

: > 9? 1B 11

! 11 %&&&&<0 " ! >)/? @ 1 9 " ";1 " 1 1

1B " ! 1 7 1 @ " "!

B !" @

0 " " #1 H E@

; 7" 1 B ! 7 1 ! /,,% ! 9!

( = "

7 ! #1

(7( >)%? F/ ! : ( "( D B 9 "( 7 ;0 / "

1B " "

1 @

" 1 1 ( 1

1 1 ( " 1 1 1

! @ " 1 7! ( ! 1 7

@ 9 1 1B ! "

6 6

@ " 1 ' :6 " 1B 1! ;@ 7

= 1B "

" 1B 1 7! !

" /( " )&<'& 1B " 7

1B 7

= @ ;

- 9

< "

;04

9 1 "/D 7! 1 11 0 ( 1B ( 1"1

!7! 11 " 1

71! 1B 10 (" 1B "

1 " !

" 1B ! 1B 1@ 1! ;"

1 ':6 1B >))? )*"7 !6; (" D B"

1 ; +"

! 1B

" 1 1 ( 1 1

@ 9 1 " ; 6

" "

1 " 0 0" 1B @

1 @ 1! " / ; 1 @ !

"1 " 1

1 1 ( 1(1@ 9 1 6

$ D

"!@ 1B " 7

1B "

"1 @ 1"1 ):6 1 ;@ "1B 7 " ; 1 "

1 7

= D "

1B " ! !%&&/ " ! >)'? @ "

F' 1/.D 1 1 "%I:6 "1 1 1( 1

1 ( @ 7

( (:( (6 "1 1 1B 1B/'&&<0 " 7 - 6 (/'&&<0

7 . 10 ! 7 7 1B @ " ! 1B " ! 1 D " "7 1!" 1

>)*? F/ 6

" ( /

" " 11 7 1B @ 1 / 1 1 1 %'"

!1 @ 1 " ! 1 "1

!" 1! 71! 1 " 1 "

1 " 1 1B@ 1 " )I;

1B D 1B " 7

( (6 ;( 1 1" 1

1 1 D 7

1 "3( (31@ "%<)

9 1 D " 1B 1B

" 1

! 1 1

1 7" >)+? F%!: ( 1 */%10 (

1"" 1;

7 7 ";"@ 1 ," ! 9 "

71 ; +&&<<0 B! "

1 ! >)-? F) "

97 D 9 >/'? '/)*+ 1 ( %)&%. 1 " !( %&)- 1 " D ;06

1 B ;""

"!D ;" 1 6 B ! B 1 ; ! 1B D ;""

6 =

6 " 1B " B@ "! 1 1B @ " 7 1

1 *" 7 !F*: 4 " %-&-/,,. 7J - 7

! 1B G1 9 1 "

@ 7

" 1 /:6 ; 1 " %%&%/,,/ : 7"

1 6 "

1B /'&//,.-( ;7 1 '!" 1 !(. /-&,/,,&4

7J ("

6 "

"1B 7 1 /'&//,.- ; 7 " C/'&&<0 11 1 1 %%/%/,+,( 1 1 )+& ! >6;2</? >).? !(7 2</ %'&/%&&&3" " 7J ( ;7 " "

" 1B 1 < ; 7

$ ;(3A ( 0=($ $ 3 (A ((6G( "

7 C +&&,&& 7! >),? @ 7 1 " %%//%&&*A$,./ %,0 //0%&&& 7 @

1( A 1B 9 ( ( "

" 1

" 4

" 1 ':6 6 "

" 1 D

" 1 +0- :6 ; 7 1 ':6 ; D

" 7

= " >'&? : "D BF%"

1 ;

>)?( 1B " " !

"( (

"1 @

" 9 1 "

"/&& " " 1 1 @ 1

#1! " 1; 1 D " 1 )0':6" 1B 1! ; @ ! 61

1B " ;7

= @ ! 7

: 1B

@ 7

= (: ( (:(: ( 6 1 7

= " 7

10 !%&&)(

1 " = 7

1 D ;""

1! "; 1 1 " 1 " 9 1 6 6

" " "

D 1B 7 " 1 -<. :6 ; " 1 ':6 1" >'/?

1 +<-:610 " 1 % I :6 D 7

= "

" >'%? 6

F/" !9 1 " 1B 1!" 1 )I:6

B// 1 %.&-%&&& $; 7J "" 1%%&%/,,/

: "

/'&&<0 " 11 " /*&)/,,) 7

: / " " /,//%&&* ; 7 ( 11( 1B >')? # " %*//%&&*( F/ 4

(10 (" 1 1B " 1 ):6 ; 10 F% :

( " 1 ! :

;

"" "

" 1 ! ! /,,) @ ! " "

! D ! 7

1 ! 7

6 7

= 1 ! 6 @ " 1 *:6 6 "

1 /&:6 ;D 1B " 1 .:6 ; 7 ") :6 ; >''? : " D B = F) 7 ' ;

" 1!

! " @ " 1 /*0%&1@ 1B " "

1 1 /:6 F%6

" 1B 7

" " 1 1 " 1B >'*? @ 1 " %+//%&&* "

" F/7 : "D B7 ; %

+ 9 1 " " 1 " "! BF)D

" :" 1 ':6 B 10 1 " %-&-/,,. >'+? # " &-&)%&&-(7 1" 1 11

(

" " "

7 7 1 1 ( 1

71 " 11 >'-? # " &+&%%&&. F/ ;

" 1 )0* :6 61

F% : 10 " 1 /&:6 1 >'.? @ - 1 %%//%&&* 7@

1(A 1B 9 ( ( 1 1 1 C /+&&<0 " 7 1 7 1 1 " 17 >',? ; : " 7 ; ' 1B " !1B

= " 7

( 7

: 1B 7

= ( 6 ; >*&?

1 ! 7 1 7 1 1 7

:(: @ ! " 1 1" " /+&&<0

!1 1 1 1B 1 9

: 1 1B 1 ; @ " 1 1B

1 11

7 1

! 1 " 1 7

0 >*/? # 7 1 1 "

" B" 1 '0*:6 1 "

! 7 7

7 6 1 "

1 ! 1 11 1 1 ! ;7 1 11 1 ; 7 "

1 "! 1 !1

! 1 "! 7 1 >*%? 111 1

$,4 6 <, (0,0 3 ,@,, :

(&' >7 "

1" 1

! ;7 "

! 17 !7

<" B 7 ;! 1 7 7

11 1 %0):6@ 7 50 5 3# (

3 # #

(

. 3 # )(

3 (

)# "

& '

# )(

( '

# )(

# #

9 3

# (

# "

;

< #

, #

1 '

3 -

= 3

# ) (

(

) #

(

#) (

# )(

)

# )(

(

# #

+ >*)? @ 7"" &/6 <,0!

(0,03,@,,9 :

?;>(&'"("

- 7;1 1 1 " " >*'? ; 7

" 1 "7 " 1"

7 1 @ 1 50 (

'C+-5-0 ,0 , &!,0- (,/1-! / ' +/%,& &0/+6 6 '&(&&&<0 % * %+,,& /:0&6 = *.(&&&<0 ) + ),,& &0*6 = %&(&&&<0 ' - %).., &0%/6 6 ,&(&&&<0 * . %,*,& /:0&6 = *&(&&&<0 >**? ! ' %+&,/,,& 7 1

= /; "

"1 -&&&&<0 >*+? 7 "

" %!

1 *&&&&<0*.&&&<06 !1 1 ; "7 1 " 1 "

" 7 " " 11 1B "

" 1 @

1 1

1 1 1 ' 1 &+&'/,,% 1 11 1( "

7 1 1 ; 1 ! 1 11

@ ; 1 1 C **&&&<0 / ; ( 1 7 1 "

"; '('&(&&&<01 1

7 11

7 1 -*K

+,,+A,:;@& 9&,!2 --0-33-!9 :

; (7 >*-? @ ; 1 " = *."

/; 1 1 1"

! .&&&<0 1 ' /; " 1 !%+&,/,,& 1 1 1 ;7 1 C-&&&&<0 1 71 "

" 7 " "

@ "

! " ; 7 "

! C**&&&<0 /; >*.? @ 1 11 1 " "

/,,& 1' 1"

&+&'/,,% 1 " 1 71

11 !11 1 1 1 " 7 1 7 >*,? 1 1 1 ) *))" + ), " -./" * 0. 1. #$) 2 3.)" % &'' (

(4 "

1 !1 7 71!(11 "

"( ! (" !

@ 1 !"

7 " 1"1

!11 7 ; 1 71! "

7 1

$D ,,,/- 6+,5+,- 9 ( (0,0 3 4,,0 :

";"(#

1! 11 171 *&K ! 1

1 "7 "

1 1 11

!+&K1 ! D

" 7 1 1 1

&,/ +, - 3 -, :

; " ( > "

1 7 1 ";1 !( "

" !

-" )*&B! 1 ! " !"

1 '&K11

" 7 !

;" 1 #+!%

>+/? ! -*K11 " 1

7 1 "

"; /(/&(&&&<01@ 1*."7 1 " 1 7"

-+,/, ,-9 (0,0300,,!+,/9 :

;(#> @ 7 50 = 3##

" "

(

# # "

( '

# &

# 3 % 8 "

! > ?

-(@ ;::/ ; %%//4A

# 3

+ >+%? @ "

! %)1 (1""; %+(++/<0 %,(+-/<0 "

" 1 " "

" " ! A 1B

1 1 %* A 1B 1( /.,' " "

! 1

1 " >+)? 11

!( "

( ;7 "

! ) 7

" 1B C/(/&(&&&<01 "

!( 101 ;7 11

! >+'? 1"

1 1 1 E 1 117"

' 1 1 ( "1 ! 11 "

&-&%%&&."

1" 1 !%

7 #$/,+)/,+' %&/& =

! 7 " " 1 A $*.% 9 7

A $//& 6

!( " /-&,%&// > #$+*/&+*/+ %&/*? /)&)%&/%>#$+%) %&/+?

7 11 /+&'%&/. /&&/%&/.! " !>,++ ! ! 1 /%-. ! ( 17 !? !( " 7 11 ! 7

1 " "

6 91

;1 11 1

1 >+*? ! " &/&)%&/'3A 7 1

1 ;7 >++?

1 "

7 1 ! "

1 1 7 " "

* 1 1 ! 1 1

!( "

1 ""

! 11 %1 #$'*'. %&/- #$-' %&/. " /,//%&&* >+-?

7 61 1"

7 ( 11

: ( (,+,=,/-,;