Narinder Paul Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS
-1-
!" #$%&'"
'
%'( %' $
! "
# !
!
!
" $
%& '
# ! () '
! *) + ,,,,
'
%'( %' $)#*+
$ !
-!
+!
.
!! ) "
#
$ !
//01//2 + 3
!" "!"!# $ %&
' ( ' )
*
+
-2-
&
, +
+
)
- !- "!"! &
&
&
*
!" "!"! # ! !
454//4%6 &8 $
-!
+!
) ""
.
!! 9 ! 3 .
. / 0 : !
! $ ;
/54//4%6 *44 +
<
/5 !$ !
%6 ! 7 (8 ) " !
!
! %(45/4%6
.
!! 9 !! !+
!%47%8 .
!! ) " ! /4%(7
!*/4%*8 1 "!
2 3 $ !
!
# $
%%%4/4%6 $
! ! !+
!4(7 8
= %5%//4%6
!
" /1&
!
+
!!
!
-3-
! ! "
.
!! 9 !
$ '
'
$ ! "
!+
"
+ ;
#
%64//4/4
! !
! 40
$!$
> ! 424(/4/4"
+
/5 ! $ !!
!+
! "
/($
<
=
!+
/040/4/4 42 ! !
%242/4/4%%44 =4642/4/4 !
'$ 42! $
!
! 4642/4/4 28$ !
! !
<
" !+
!
!
$ !
"
$ !
!!
-!
+!
$
! # %64//4/4 $ " !+
$!
$!
) +
?
!
.
! !
! ) +
!
@ 9 ! /4%4 3
-4-
"!
! %* A /% !
"
'B
$
"
!
$ 3 !
!
%242/4/4 !
.
!! 9 ! $ %&$ ' ". %546/4/4
$! !+
$! %64//4/4" # ! $ !
; !
!1 !!
!
3 " 3 $
! +
$ ! > "
! 424(/4/4 7/8
! !
!
!
<
#
! 42 ! C ) +
/4%4 "
" <
"
/4%5
"
) " +
7
?
!
.
! !
! ) +
!
@ 9 !8
/4%5 3 "!
4 $! " !"
"
"
$ $
$
) +
/4%4D
/4%5 $ "
! !
"
) +
"
-5-
!!
" /( " ) " ) + "
!
! !
!
454//4%6
42 !
<
! !
+ !
$
" ! ! '
+ !
" 'B
!
$D
42 ! $ " %& $
$
'B
C !%4 ! /4%*
-!
+!
) +
!
!
& ! !
!
+ ) + " 7 8 " (1) "
$ ! +
$! "
!
# -!
+!
) " !! !
$ !%47%8 !/4%4
-6-
) ! "
) + " *) + $ ' !
! %/7 8 /0 ) " +
! %6*0 1
2$ $ ! ) +
) "
! !
!
! $ !%6*03!'$
%542/4%57 ;
*1%8
/4%4
2& /4%5
!!
! +
-!
+!
" + ) + !
! <
$ !
) "
" ! '
" ) " 3 !
! %64//4/4
! $ !
+ ) + !
" + 2&4
/4%4 ! ! "
.
!! 9 !
-!
+ # $ + 2&78 ) +
! !
!
!+
= !
! # %64//4/4 7 08
$ "
!424(/4/47/8
!
$ " !
! !
! $
"! " !+
-7-
/040/4/4
42 ! !
! !
$
! %64//4/4
! $ !
!%242/4%6 !'
$ "%*42/4/4 $ "
! -!
+!
"
$' ) " !
-!
+!
: " $ ! /& ! /4%* " !
" ! 1
! <
"+ :
+
() "
$ +
*) +
+ ) + "
! !
"! !+
! @ +
' '! !
$ !
! ! "
)
&6 7
& )
8 , &
!" "!"! & 6
-8-
3
$
! $ + ; ! ! !
" "
" "
!
" " " !
# !
$
!
!/ %4 %/ %& ! /4%* $! E 7
1 )
8
,) 9
9
+ 9' 9
' (
+ 9&9&
' &
1
/
& &
(
* (
&
'
*
& &
* ( / &
& &
' : # ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; ;;;;; /
&
8
8
;;;;; / &
)
:
' ( ;;;
-9-
/ '
)
) 8 &8 & /
*
* #<& &
/ #* ( #<&). / 0 7 / &
/
' /
&
'
&&
):
&
7 + &
+
&
+
&
/ &
08 &):
) = < 3< * * /
)'
+
) #<& /
) > + * ( #<&) . ?+ . ) / 0 7 /)#<&+
@
5
) 1 7
/ 0 )
+ #
77 + . 77 / )3
-10-
!%47%8 '
-!
+!
$ !
&
&
' +
&
+ &
+ &
' + + &
( )
"
!
$ ! " #
%%%4/4%6 !
$4(
* )#<&
" #* )?) =& ( #<& A * )/ 0 B =& 7 /)#<& C =
= ) =& =.
#<&) / D *<=<D "
"
+
%5%//4%6 $
/1& !!
!
+
"
#
%64//4/4 !
$40 7;8
* )#<&
" #* )?) =& ( #<&
-11-
A * )/ 0 B =& 7 /)#<& C . )77/)3 08 =& 2 . )@7///3)
08 =& $
)(@.
)1 08 =& ! % ! %4 7&8)
> ! 424(/4/4
+!
"
! !
'$ D " ! %64//4/4'
" # 7% 8
!/ %/A%&&
# " !/4%* ! "
D$ ) "D
" "
#
"$ 3 !
! %/40/4/4
/5 ! $
! "
/($
!
/( ! ! ! # < ! ; !
! ! ;
/040/4/4
" 42 ! $ $
! $" ) + "
! )
"
$ 4642/4/4 $ " + ! "
$
-12-
!
!
) 8+ # +
A2 ) 8
#<& (@.
) 1 + *D70/)D 7E(#/ )> + . *D70/) D + . # 7E(#/ )>
""+ # / 0 * #<& $-!!!
- !!!?&) "!
! + "
$! " ' $
" !
! # !
+ ) +
D $ !
> >427
8 ! 3 " 46424/4 !
$ D $ !
+ ) + ! %64//4/4$ >$
"
$! <
"
$
> !
"
424(/4/4
!
!
"
%*A/% $
" !
"
' B
$
"
!
$ ;!
-13-
F /
&
& *
)
%
*
G
- !- "!"! 7
%
*
-
"
&
&< 0
<
& &
/ - &
<
&
, 8
&
!"#!$%"
&'
# ( ! ) "!!* )"!+!" * "
#+ ! * )"
+ , $ "" "" * "
#"" ! - "
" # ! " **". **" #!$ %"
&'
# ( !)"!+! !$ "" * "
#"" ! / "* **)"!$"
)"!+!** "
!"*!". "# "!
** ! $ + + #
/ " "
)" !!+! * "* " * * #. ) ""
"! $" !) !$
!
$
"%*42/4/4 $! F7 ) )&
"4 ) & &
-14-
& - - !- "!"!)
&
"!
2 0 ""!!*!!+*!$*" ! !! $ " , " ( "" 1 "$. " 2! "
1324+ !" H
" !!
"
!
$ ! ! '
!
'$ !
' B
$ !
$ $ # "
!
<
'B
$ !
" ! !
!
! !! $ !
%*42/4/4 ! $ /5 ! D !
$
" !
$ /5 ! <
D ! "
/($
"42
! $ . ! + '
!!
'"
3 $" ! * ! %4 &) -!
+!
E! ;
!
!
! !
) "F <
" !
"
D '
-!
+!
" @ ) "
$ !>
! "
; '
-15-
"$" $!!!
" ! ! ! + $!
+!
"
!
!!
$
"
$ !/040/4/4
42 ! " ! +
+ <
"
42! $ !
! %242/4/4
" $ !
'
! !
$
! # %64//4/4 !
;
"
. + "
" " " ! !
' !+ 3 $ ! !!
!
!
!!
$
#
) &
!- "$ !$ "!"!)
+ #
!" "!"!
%&
' )& &
+ @ !- !C "!"!) &
( #<&)
*
) &
+ @
!- & + 1& ) @ 2B"
) & C !- "!"!
-16-
. 1 %E# & 2 !- "!"!
) &
3 $
!
!!
<
$
" " ! %64//4/4 # $ ' ; " !+ !
//01//2 +
% !
$ !
%
!
; /
!
!
! !! "
$
" ! <
%*42/4/4 " ! # ! + !
!
" ,* -)
'
%'( %' $
#$("