Rajender v. Sita Ram And ORS
!"
#$!
%&'& ( &")& &&
!"
#$!
%&'& ( &")& &&
!"
#$!
%&'& ( &")& &&
!"
#$!
%&'& ( &")& &&
& ( &"
& ( &"
& ( &"
& ( &"
(*+(+ ,#+-./01 (*+(+ ,#+-./01 (*+(+ ,#+-./01 (*+(+ ,#+-./01 "2+3+ 45 *5."
$+**+ 6+
4*3*5+
"+
"& , 8'9 "
%!4
%
( "4
(
(4& "& , 8'9 "
%!4
%
( "4
(
(4& "& , 8'9 "
%!4
%
( "4
(
(4& "& , 8'9 "
%!4
%
( "4
(
(4& $+ +* $+ +* $+ +* $+ +*, 5*%::1&3; *+*5+7+**+
53+5 )3;1&3; *+*5++
<=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<=
%
( "4
(
(4&1%
%
( "4
(
(4&1%
%
( "4
(
(4&1%
%
( "4
(
(4&1%
" 0 >*5 *5+ +* *5+ + 77+: *5+ 7*+ 1*5+3*+?+3*5+ + 7+7+3 **3/3*5+ + *@+.75+:*3/* +
&77 * 3 7 +3
7. . + * 7* +3 -/ *5+ 7+ +* 7+**+17;*++ 5++A++ .+3* *
+ +7. 5-+.3+4+ B1 B1 B01 1 BC1 B1 C *5+ 3 $+ 3+ ;3+
.:3+3*+3 B7
+3-/*5+4.-(; %.3 : **+1 53+:5 7*D7+**++3 77 *3*+3C .3+4+ $ +3.+ .:( 43++71( 41$
"5*@A53+*+3*5+ 5 + *A5+ +:.+1 +/1 ( (++7@1 +3 +1 E/ (+7*+*1 $ "5*@3A553 *+3*5+?/*5+3*5+ *5+ 7*
5+ **7+**+3.3+4+ *B*5+3+ $ +3.+ 3+ *+3: *3+3*+3 * &+?.+ $ A5++-/ *5+ +* +3 77 * .3+ 4+ +3.+5 -++3+ +3
'+ *5*+*+*5+7+3:
+ 3 + *5* *5+ 7* A 3:+3 -/ *5+
7*D7+ +* 7+**+ +* * *5+ +:+3
.+ + *5* *@ 7 + 3 A5++ *5+
7* 5 *5+ 3 *5+ 3 *5+ A++
.*+3-/*5+
+37*/D7;*++ 5++ *5+
.+ +17**5+ 1'(+; *5+*5+
7* **+3*5;+-++5*-/ *+ '(+;
*5.A5 .++3 2.+ A+++++3 *$ "5*@
&77+*/1 ?/ A 3+ * $ 4 "5*@ 3 A5 +;++3 *.+
5+77 *53-++7+++3-/*5+ 7* .3+ 4+ * *5+ 3+ $ +3.+ *5+ :.3*5*( (++7@53+*5++7/+*$ 35+ A5++-.* +*@A31
3:/1( 43++71( 41 $ 4"5*@A553-++A@::A*5( (++7@-+
.+3*3+*/5+ 3A*: *7;+ *5+++;*+3 + 3
$+.
*5+ 7.:+3 3+ 5A *5* 4.-
(; %.3 : **+1 53+:5 A5+ 3+ :
77 *.3+4+ +3.+ 5 - +;+3*5**5+ 7* +*5+;+/ +7*A
A+ *5* ( (++7@ 53 *+3 ?/ ' -.* +* 53-++3+*7;+*5+?/+7* 7*
**+3*5;++3*:;+5 *77 +3A*+
3 A**5+ *:+A5+ 7*8 +;3+ + * +32.
* :+ *5+ 7 ++3:
1 *5+ 77 * 5 -++ ;+3 * +?+ +*5+( **7;+*5+?/+7* ++ :1*5+7.:+33+5 -++7
+3
9++3 +*5+7*+ 5;+-++5+3
4+ +3.++3
.3+, F $A+* .*+A*+
1+?+ $A+* .*+A*+
1+?+ $A+* .*+A*+
1+?+ $A+* .*+A*+
1+?+ 7+ 7+ +*G 7+ 7+ +*G 7+ 7+ +*G 7+ 7+ +*G&/.*/1*/ *:+/ H./1 * *5+ 7 ++3: .3+ *5 3+1
. / 7+ A*+
1 +?+ / 7+ **+3 +1 *5.:5 * .+3 A*+
1+ 3++?+/7+ +3/ +?+3I3*5+.* 5 .3+?+ + 3 ++?+ / 5 7+ 5
+;3+ + 77+ * * * -+ +
+* * *5+ 2.
3+ *5+ J
5+7+*+ +?+ +7A+ .3+4+ *5+3+$ +3.++AA+ +**+3 *5
-+++7+*+3/5+3*5**5+7A+* ./7+ A*+
-++?+ +3*5++?* 5A*+
+**5+2.
*3+ *5+ #.*5++1 7A+ -++?+ +3*/ *:+*
&3;+*:- @**5+ *5+7+ +* +1*/ -+* +3*5*:A*5*5+ 7*1*5+ 7*53
.-**+3*5+ *A*+
*&+?.+$3A5 5*5+ +( (++7@1 +3 +1E/(+7*+*1$ "5*@:.+3*4
( (++7@A +;++?+3
>0 * *5+ *:+ 7+ .: +;3+ 7/ *5+
**++* >0 ( (++7@ 3*+3 7 +3 + 33 *5+A:*+ , F>0( (++7@+ 3+**5+3+7*+*"3 3: $ 41"5*@ 4&
5;+3+?/'AD *5." 3.3 *.++*3.
-+ 5+
+*+3 7//?/+7* ?
(>0D&A5 -+ / :*.+ 3 *5+ + 3/
*+3*5+?/ *5." D'59 .3 *.++*3.
37? 75:+::+:5*53 5+ +*+3
7/ / ?/ +7* ?
>0D'
*-+ /
5;+ -.:5* *5+ : ?/ +: *+*3/*5+.*
"+ 3+3.3+/ .7+; 33 **
"& 43D( & 5@K. 43D(++7@ &(% 1 D 5 (* J
5+ 77 * .3+ 4+ * *5+ 3+
$ +3.+A ;+3-/*5+ 7**5+-
*5*( (++7@5 +*5++7/+*35+A5++-.*
+ * @A &
3:/1 *5+ 7/+ A * . ( 43++71( 41$ 41"5*@3A553A@+3:A*5 ( (++7@3A5 .37
-/3+*/*5+ 3 A*:( (++7@
*5+ 3++3;+A*5 .*1*5+77 * ;+3 -/ *5+ 7* .3+ 4+ * *5+ 3+ $ +3.+A -+*-+
+7*+3
B
5+ -2+ +3 -/ 53+5 )3;1 ++3 + 77+: *5+ 7;*+ + *5* +3 + 3 7+7+3 -/ *5+ 7* + 3 - *+33*5+ 7*A*5.*+*;+A* * +?+ *5+ ( * * 7;+ *5+ ?/ +7* +:+3/
*+3*5+7+ >'(+;1/*-+:+* *5+7+ +*7+** 4. +**- +;+*5 +:3*5* +;+( 43++7 .+3-/;*.++?+ +7A+
.3+4+ +3.+1*A.3 A/ -+7+*5+
+37*/* +7+ /-+ ;-+**5+
3 +A*5A .3: 7+ A*5 +:3**5++;3+*/;.+*5+3+7 *( 43++7
C
#*5++ + 3+3-;+1*5+7+ +*7+**
A+3 5+7.:+33+3*+3 7
+3-/*5+* .*3+ :*5+77 *.3+4+ $ +3.+ +* 3+
.* 3+ *+3*
+7**5+7/+3+-/ *5+ 7*D7+ +* 7+**+ *5+ 77 * 3*+3
C 1&+?.+$B1+3.3+4+ $ +3.+ 3 * 7 ++3 .*5+ *5++*+
3 +A*5A
$+** A+3 3 3 7 +3 *5+ + 3 *+
%
( "4
(
(4& %
( "4
(
(4& %
( "4
(
(4& %
( "4
(
(4& #+-./01 #+-./01 #+-./01 #+-./01 %!( %!( %!( %!( 4"
4"
4"
4"
*+,
*+,
*+,
*+, >5+*5+ 7+@:D+ +3L )+ >5+*5+"+7*-+L )+