Balkar Singh v. The Postgraduate Institure Of Medical Education And Research (Pgimer) And ANR





    
 

  

 !"#$% "

&"' ()*+%"

+,    

 

 "

"+%' #%"-./& "%," "/-0%1./& "%", 
 

 3%("')'  *'+"% ()*+
%$"%.%$"  &'" %," ,"4

4',4&$-% "," 56" /'$' 73% 58 "," 6" "-  9: 9 )5",%;   $%"" 9 : /8'" :,;6%/-"&

".* "% ).()*+.
%$"%"- 5%%% 

&'" %,""-;6$&$: 6 "   %  ,"  %  ;  "    &  %      "  ; " : 
'  "%,"% "$'% % % ",  '    "-$  %      %  ,"     &  %,",  '" 1')'"$%,,"'6

  %"$5$"%,",""' %-,'$ "-""4/8'" :<'"%""$'%%   "-    %    5  ;  ',    ","    %  /" ), 
--    5%%    5   &$'    !$   "6,"' "  "$ 6% "- % ')% '"%";"$'%% ,"    56".%,"%;-,5, 

-, ;'%-5",""%$" 8 % '%.'%, ;!" 5% "-$%  %,"$&$%8,"  %  /&,6 %5",,"

;!% "6; "&',%", )'."/-0%1./&.%,' ,,"% -& ;  ","'  %
'"% "$ "" % =&$%"'  "%,"%&$,"'% , $    "".  % 
'"      %  "  &5  %   "&%-"5"" /%$ $"   "% ," 56"    9 7/8'" %;"
' 7.> 7 %?5' ;" &%"&"6 %"","'%"

  


  

  ! "#! #!  $# # #$ %  %##!    !%  #  # #  !&

'

: (!" %%# (#$

"  !

 !$

#

%

 #)!%)!! #) # #

* "#  # 

%#

" #  %##!#  #  # #   #(!

#  # $ #+ (%##! #   ","$ # #( !* $ # #$

!

# " #!( #!(!#

#+! #" #!( ## (!$#   (

##

    ("  %*         #    !! ##  ##  #(!

+ #( + 

# #$ -  # * +#(!

#,!!( $ '#.( #'

# # ! $ $ , # * #! #'+      $ #'    #  "  #+!*     #

 , % #(!  #$ #  # $#

#

 #!#$

*+, #" $##+!"  * !# +, #"

!"  #

 #/ 0"*   .( !$ "

 #" #$ #

$) $* 1*       #$  $(   #      !  #

% !%#! #! $ # #!'$ #

(#$23'43!53#$ #  $+"  #!  ( #      $#   '  2! !  4 ! ,# #

  , "   #

# * !



  #  "  # "   !  "    -  # '  6*   !##$ -  # ' 6'!% ' " $!"!%* "+#  #   ).( )"

!

 "!)( # !!#  %

  %       $7!) #!'  $%  ( "

 )$+" #!$# ,  "  --#$

6
 '!% *   $# #!$# ,# #( " ! # !+   ( ! #!$%  823+"  %!* 9 )
   2* # +  !% %# !#! #:4 "#,' # " "

#   "

%,%4:!  # !%+  7  #$  #  #$+ #( %%  #+ #, * #+, '

    " %,%:! 

# !%+  7  #$ # #$*   )+"!"

!$#

 % !

##$ #  $# 2  ) (".( # ) , ## !5:3#$ ## $ +" %!)!!( !$ # ! +" !!( !$ #) (  ! # ("& #(#$

*2:':::);!7(#$ *5<(!% # #$ ;

! %*

#+, ' -  # ' 6  , % ##



 # 2! # 4 ! % "!! '   #

 #     !( % #!

#$ #  #$ *0 /,"
'7;% 5;"" "-"$6 -,6,!$";!"6$"6%"-" % ,,"'%,"-"6%",  "-5%"'%$ "-" -6;&;  "-%' )5 " 6,'  %"%%" " %,"-% ;"%', "' "6%",'",%"%%,'; ,$)"-

'>  '"%"5%6 % , '"% . %' @.:@ @  %-% 6  5 ; ;-,',%  "

% .    :"   &   ",& 6 ;6 % * -- 
--"  
'>  '"%""6 A%-"%'"

'%'%" &'" % 5  ; ; "-;6%"".()B"
' 7.% "() 5 ;"6"-% ;6$&$: 6 " $5%%8,"6 %-%C' 3%",'"$"% ' ,"-%%  %;$" &'" %," " ," 5 6"    /'$'  7  '"$  %    ,"    5  6"   .

,"%;-,, 5&" + :74  +:

-, '"
'> % 3% , 64 -,5' 6, D "  9 9.

% ,"%;8 "," 6" "-  9: 9 :  9.,"5-,%:"

7 , 6 +7 *&%'$%%""&"-%5", '$$%%-, %:", 65";""6'1'6 % $%; %-%,"5",3% "    8     9 9  %  ;  ,     ""   ,,/8'"

 $5%%5", 3"-4 :'% " 85' ;& "

 5

/    !  #! #  +           ( ! !!)#  

#* 6) ;

)2:);::2:2! !*:=*2:* % " 6-"$%%8,"& "   9 9/8'"

5' %"- %"$   )%  % ,".%,"5' ;&5%" ' "=% ;-,, 5&"'"$% ," %  %" "%:", 6'"$%," 8 %  ," B"'%"'-.%",'%"5"5 5%%"$%"-% ;6&"' ," 
' > / %?/8'"  3%";6' 5%"$"&  % ,",  '" 1'5  '/," "--,

%",", ',%,".,"%;"& ',    --'    9  /8'"  

  !$   8, ,,"$%-%'"$'","%!$;6%/"

> ),
-- :  .%;;"&%%"

"    %  %,  %  ;  "%  ',    %  ,,   5" -, $"$"$,"C' 6 "'%, -  ',%",'%" "',, 6 %,6 %"," ';-  ;6  %  /"  ), 
--   D  --  

/8'" .%"," %/"),
-- 5%"$"%%!$ :  5' 6',, /,"

 %"," %/"),
--.%,"

" %4%, "5%%%,"%;$"%  %; ';"%',3%,"%","% %,, "-, $"$"$,"C' 6  3%,"%",';-%()'%" &%5",6"%-+%" ' 5' !%%,",'"'%  %&$;$"%!%E



 !"!

#

$ *& '%5' '"%;  %,")% -';% %,"%6$';C' % %&$;$"%-% /'$' 7%% ;"'$%% %-,'%"6'"%", '  %  %"  5   "6  "  "%-    "    % 4%,C' )%"&5 %
'".%-,'$

"- %  %,"%;! "$&$ C',,"'6%,"%- "-65% %"- %   9 7 % "  9 9/8'"

$"$8%,"

9  -" ",- %
 

&  

+ %%",!$4" F4 %%"",";  F4