Birla Century v. Orient Craft Ltd
!
"#$# %& '(() * * + * *
,*+ ++ *
*
& -*
( + + +
!" !
# $ % "
&&&& + +
.
( /
' # ( ) " ''
* ( $ ) '++* , -
! ") ( . ) ) ( )
(! ./
(0 ( (
1 2'
$))0 0 )0 (
(
!# )) !
))0( ! !( 3 ))
( ! $) '. ( ))( ! 3 0 !0) ( 4 ! $ ! 5
(0 " (! ) ( )) ) 6 7 ) (!
(0
(0 ! ! ) ( ) ! 0! 3 ))0 ( 0! 8)0 ( )" (! 0
(0 ( ! ) (0( (
( ! " (! ))0
0! (! 1 29/:/../..# ) 1 2+.:/../.. )! ) 8
) ! ()
" (! 0
8)0 )!)0 (
) 0!
" .' 1 2'6/;/../.6 <$) '.) ! ( ( ") ( ( ! " (! ! ! ! ( ) ( ) " '' ! ") ( (0 $ : " (! ./
( ! ) (
) ( !0( (0 ./ ( ) # () " ! 3-() " ! $
!"#$%% ) 3 $ &'( &) ' )*+ , -+$
- ! $
= ! " ! ) ) ( ) ) % " 0 )
(! $) '. (0 ) )
( ! ( " (! ./ (1 ! ( ! !" (! )) ) $) '. (0
1 ) ) ) " ) (!
(0 !0! ! ( ))0 ( 0! 8)0 " (!
(0 ! ( ) " (! !() ( (
( )) (
) ( " '' )( !()" (! ( (00 $) '. )
! (00 0
)) !
( ) )) ( ( (00 0
)) !
! ( ( )
) " '' !()" (! ( ( ! ) $) '. * 5 ) ) ; # ) $) '.
) ) (
2
) ) (
2
+./
!" #$
%
&
'
! # 9 ) $) '.
) >
( >))( ! 3 0 55 ( ) !0) ( 4 !
$ ! 5
(0 + 5 ! ) )
$) '. ( ( ))( ! ) )0!
1 ( ) ) ! ! ( 3 ! )
) ( ( 00 (0 ! ! ( 7 )
) ) $) '.
( ! (00 0
!
(
) '/
0 1! )) ) $) '.
( '' 7 ) )!
3>()" !$
0- '" (0
!! ) ! ( ( !
! )# ) !
2 ()
$*
& !( +
$ * , -.
$ /
$012#.
$
$
!*3 11#4 3
5
* $6
3
!+
#
$
1 ' + # 2 3% " & 0 ' 4%$ & $
$
4 3
&#( 2 #5 &2& 65 - " & 0
'
%
& 5
5!*7
#'
'. 3-()" !$ ( 6*&'( +6 7 8 (
"#%4% )
!))01 ( ) ( ! ( ! '6 # 3 $ &'( 0- '") ) !) ( # ( &'( 0 - '"
?. 3 $ !
)) 2 89
"
&
'
': # ) !
2 :4
-&
4 &
-
$
$ ;
$
$
4
4 & 8
3
;
. $
<
< 8
"
&
$
*
(
3 %
;
$
"
&
'= # ! 3 $ &'(
0- '"
)( 3-()" ! $ "7?;.9: ./.' '6/;./..
2
$
4
$
;
"
* /
$
=
3
$
'
' '* 5 0 ( ! 3 $ ( !) ) <
2 ( ( 3 -
> ?<
!" #$
%
&
'
89
"
&
'
'; 3-()" !$ ) ! 3 $ " )7 3 8 ) < '9 5 0 ! 3 $ &'( 0- '" )
)! ( (
( )(0 3-()" !$ '+ 3-()" !$ 1 & 6* 6 '
" # ) $ ) !
)0 ( ! ( !
( )@ ( A ./ $!
./!( (
(0
! !0 ) <) ( ))0
0! 8)0 # ) ) ! )0 (0 )
(0 1 29 )0 1 2+ (0 ) !)
!
5 0 ) (
(0 ( )0 ( ) .' ! (0) ) ) $) '. ( (
! 0 (
)) !
!
))(!( (
0 ( # ! (0 ) ) !
0) " ;
:
2 9#- % $": 6
@ !# A !# .
$.$
B
C
A ! # .
.
'
.. # ) (
(0 3-() " !$ & -5 &#( (& (
#; & # < ) 0 ) )() 4 ! ) $) '.( ! 0 ) 1 ( ) )! ! ( $ (
)
! ( " ''
!)0 1 (
(0
.6 ! ( )) " '') )! )))0 ! ! )
!0(! ! $ 3>()" !$ 95 '& = 6
-& - 334
#'- <335 >
$"4# ) ( ) )0 ) .: # $ !
) ( 0 ( )# () B) () 2 " ? 4/"5 $ /6 / (
' 34C///////.;6B#./C/9C./'+ . 34C///////.;:B#./C/9C./'+ 6 34C///////.;;B#.6C/9C./'+ : 34C///////.9:B#.:C/9C./'+
= 34C///////.9;B#.:C/9C./'+ * 34C///////.9;B#.:C/9C./'+ ; 34C///////.+.B#.9C/9C./'+ 9 34C///////.+6B#.9C/9C./'+ + 34C///////.+:B#.9C/9C./'+ '/ 34C///////.+=B#.9C/9C./'+ '' 34C///////.+*B#.9C/9C./'+ '. 34C///////6/:B#.9C/9C./'+ '6 34C///////6/=B#.9C/9C./'+ ': 34C///////6/;B#.+C/9C./'+ '= 34C///////6/9B#.+C/9C./'+ '* 34C///////6/+B#.+C/9C./'+ '; 34C///////6'/B#.+C/9C./'+ '9 34C///////6'9B#/+C/+C./'+ '+ 34C///////6.6B#/*C/+C./'+ ./ 34C///////6.:B#/;C/+C./'+ 3 ! ) ) ") ( )) ! !)) 0 ( .= $ 8)0 )) 3>() % 0# ! % $ 3?6/69 " .'2B$ D29# 4) <E1 ? B) () ?+;9///9':' E!) 5B 0 F!)
! ! ") ( ( ( !) 0 )" '.
.* ( ) ( !) ( 1 !! (0 ) ( .; 4 ))( ) (
4 "
) ( !
.9 7 ( ) 8 !) !)!
( " .+2 .+ 8 ) ) 0 ( 3>() % 0# ! % $
G < H C? G () H C?