High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8994/2024dismissed

Ms Mohinder Singh Govt Contractor v. Union Of India

2024-04-22Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma7 pages

122

#$% &"'( $ $ ) $ * + ,# #"$ )- .#

$ $ %#.% &"/0#( $". $ 111

2 34 "&$3 # " .$( # $

.4 $ 34 5 "

5#" 5$# 4#$

, 6 #

.4 $ # $ 6 7 # 8"

($ $

98"04"$ 6/ 4"$ :#$.$ ( #" $ 8 "$$

&4"

$"; 4 8$7/" "339$ 3(# 4#$

""$9$ 55 5$#4$ &".$&$

$< !$7$$"$5 /9#5$ 9$ " " / " #

.4 "33/ "

/9$$$#$ 35"=& $" 8$7 # " "33/ 8 .$ #

;6 #6 $ 9 & $>4 # 8$ & 96 " $ # /

(6 "

" $ %4 " #

($6 5$ $$$# "33/ 49<

"$ $ .$( ##/ 9 3 # 9 4. " $ $ , " 8$7

3$#6 .$

/" $ "33.$ #8 ""; 4 " 8$7 $ . " #

" =& $ $ #8 "33#4# & /8""$6".$ $>4 $9 "$ $.$( ##$

,"=& $" (6#"

" $ # 5 $ $9 " 9 3# 96 "

$8 .$ #

;6#6 $5"$ . " 3$ 554

& " #

/ " # #

"339 3#9 &4." $#8 33 9 49< 5$$9 33

( ,"=& $ (6"

8 .$ #

;6#6 $5"#8"

"" #$>4 8 5# 96 " $/ " 56 $$ " #

.4 $ "$ $.$( ## ( 033 #

.4 $ # $ $ 8"

" " #

( "33/"$>4 "$ .$6 5# 554

"$4&" $&

$#0 . /9$$$#" 3$9 %4.$ # & =& $ '$$ A4#"

0$ (3.5 04"$ 6 & " " 5 $$ 43

#9$$#$5 & 0$9 $$96 $#$"04"$ 6/ 8"

"(/"=5.36$

"33.. 6"$

$"#.$5 $9 $$$ .$>4 $5 "$ .$6

B" =5.36$ "33 "( " 4"$ 6 "& " $$..3

96 "$" $$" =& $ $>4 "& $9 $$ & & $ "$/ "$ 9$ " $ " $9 .$ $#4$ &" 4$ ".$ B" .$ 843# # .## ..3

$ "&0$9 $$

3#9$" =5.36$#

& (96"..3

"0$9 $$ B"=5.36$$"$ &9"".$ 56 .

.7 & $#$ $< & " ..3

. & "& " $9 $$ $

5434 36/ .. &

$ 0$9 $$ 4#$ "

B"8$9 $$ .. #56$4. "$$ $ "$"56 4""$ $5 " . " 8$ .## 9$ " .$( 4 $$

B" $$ " $9 $$ "33 9 5# 96 "

5.$68 "4#$#86#6 $5" # #

.4 5 $

#4$ & " ; 4 8$7 , " 5 .$

$ $ $ ($

$#4 # " 39 33/"$$ "$9 $$

"3395#8

; 3#$5"

$5"# .65" 39 33" $$$5"# $&

" $ " ""

39 33

$#696"=& $8" #

$ "33 9 3 # 9 & 8"

"($

$3 $

, "339

3$5"

" $#$ ( #$ (34 /".$6 (7 &$9 "33

6 " #

.4 9 # 4. # 3 43

& " 54 5# 4#$ " 5 # "33 4$

" C#.

33C $ .$ "54

5#/

"#43# 97 " 5 " 0$9 $$/96"

& 8" "337." 54 #.

33"4 5"8$# , " ( 8$# (4$ " 5/ " #.

"33 9 $4## "

5 .$.$ " 548$##8 "$ "54 5## "93 / 6/ "339$ ##. #""$ .$6

; B".$(

"0$9 #-

0 / 2D $ 6 "$ 4$6 "$ 4#$ $ 5#

"$#$" 59 $ "33..36" .$ 4#$"

; B" $9 $$ "33 8$# .$36 & & "

8$# &

" 5 5 # #

.4 # 4$ 5 $

#96 "$.$6& &$ $"

8$# 06 345. 458$# "3393&336$ 93 ;

B" #.# " .$6 "$ "

7 &$9 3 " 4$ 6.$6

"339$ #96"$9 $$ ;

B"(4$9 "339 ".3 $.3 4<9$"# &$" 569 ;#96"$9 $$

? @

3 #

$ B" 8$7 4#$ " "33

4#4$ &"$9 .$ ;

B" 5.#4"8$# "339.69396" .$6 #

$#96"0$9 $$# "( " .$6E #43/ " 5. "33 $ ($93 $5 "$ 45 #4 " .$6 4#$ "

$ 6 "$

;

( F "$ .$6 "33 9 3# 9$ & 5 $ /

33# .$" 5.$ #3$#6

#$8

;5"

"338 & "# 5.3 "8$7 $ #96 "=& $$ 9"#9#5"8$7$9$ "

4#$6 /$

55 5$$ 45. 8$7 2 #6 8$

$ 55 5 $ 45. ..3

93$ # " 33 / $5 $ 8 "#$83 " 8$7 $5 " $ 8"3 $ .$ # ! $ $(

$ 3 4$" /$ $ & 5 $5"=& $"" 3.65#4$$ ($$5" $"#9 #$5 #/ $ " .4$. .65!#<4 5 8"

"($

" 3 , " 5$

$$$# 8 " .$ # .$

9# 9(/ 33 " &" # "$.$64#$" "33

?D@

9#5#"(9$ ##9 34369$$#96 " 5$$9 #($

33 & ;( F >4 $3 & "

"33 9 9$4&" 9$ 6

3 4$ 8 "4 (7 & #

5.3 & " $9 .$ / "

($#96"

.$9 4#$" B" .# & $9 .$ "33 #

3 " =& $$5 " #573$ $$&5$ 5.3 "8$7 ;( B" $9 $$ "33 9 #5# "( $# " $$ "#6/"

".$ ;

" #"$ & B"$9 $$56/$5 5 5/ 8 " " " .$ 3$& "

3 5$57 &#.493

&"8$# ;(

B" ;.

$6 " 43 5 3 / 8""$ $ 336 ;# $ ;##/ "33 (3 # " .$(

;(

B" <4$

3 4$ $ 5$ 4#$ #

"339"9

"3 "

" =& $ G.

( 8"$ #/

..$"".$(

0$9 #

0 /2D/8 33"(..3

/ "$

.4$

&98".$ 6

4 $3 "$5 #

# "

A$# 4 3" # 34 $3 &"

"&!($ ; # 5.3

# "

"" "& "$ ; $52H2 H/ 55 ""

=& $/"3#5 & #&$#$3 " ## 3 54 96 ..36 & " # $ 3 5. H 8($/ .

7/" 5" 9 5.35#

$ " . $ #

$# &36 " " ..$ "# "

7 &5#54 #"" $# 98".$

4$6 #8$ . $ 5.35 # " 843# 3 # 843# 9 5 93/ ( 8 " <4#&5.

#96"I93%4.$54$ " 8$ &55.6A# ( !

%768$%4" %3$,# ( A# #"$ % 3 #" "$

$9 /"#

.4 ($6833974.96". $9$"..$.$ $45 ,"

/ $$

5#4 D , ( 8 " 9(/ " 8$ .

# 8"

3 &$ &3 9$6". $ 9(

033.# &5

..3

3 ##

. #

$< " 2 ""$ .7 &!$ #J K !F ""$$.$93J K !F