← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10108/2020allowed

Jarnail Singh v. Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board And ANR

2025-12-10Mr. Justice Harpreet Singh Brar7 pages







   



  



 

   



 





 

!

!

 "# 

" $! %&'

%'

 (# !! %'

   

         

   







  ! "#

)

 * !$

 + #  

)

* !$

 +  



$

% &  ,  #  

  -

  #     .  + !  

 /01+   +2 + 

+ -



 +

3 -

!

!&45

6 7

 !

!1/5

6 7*- .. + +   !

    5 7



!#

  . -

*

!+ 3 !

 

6  #

! 

 ' ( )*#!



++

+

  # - ##

!

  /414

!- # 8!#+  "

 /'44

# 

+"4''( 



 

 7"*44*- 

! 

+"9/-+ /$ ! !

!,#

&41*

! #

!

. + - + 6!

!  !

 .3 * ! -

!

!&4



 

+ 

-

!$

!

 "'57+5 7"*44* # *

.

8!#

&44'*-  .+  . +  +

    # :  # 

!  ++

   #

  

*  

# ! !

!1/-

 



!!

 +6  #

! +"# "#'+"!

& ;

! + # 

!  # <

!  /414

!- # 8!  "

/'44( 



 

5 7"*44*-

! 

+"9/-+/$ ! !

!



&41 +

 .8 !





. + - !  !.8   !-



!.3  -

 



!

-  !- 

  +8 # *+

!

8  #

+# "

 <!8 !. 







!   ! "#!$% &'*

!. 

(# )*(+%

''*.8  + 8



!8#  8#  .+   ! 

, !.

! *  - 

!



!.

,-

-  $!

+ 

+  9  *

! +  .8  

+ 

# -

!$

!

" '57+5 7"*44* # *

. # 8!

&44'*-  ..8  -

- ++ ! + +-

!# ! *

!

 

+-

! ++

#



*!

-

#  $ .<  +  .8  6 # 8 8 !. .

#.

8   .. ! -! .)#'+"

/ ")01!'!

' 



!

! + #



! + # 

 !- 

.  

 

#

 #

&41  ,  - 

 

  -   !    &4 

!  

- # ! 1/* * +

8 2 

#     +8 # *+

!

8 

#

+# , !8  - 

! #

!$ *

# $ +5 7"44 / , +- +

6  #

!

8#*

 .

+

8 # +

! #

+ 8#*

.++ !#

8 *      1

,  ! 

+

, ( +# )  $ -.&&

 - #

  

=

. $! *

2

           

 ! ""#$%#  &  

'   

()"      # *  +   

 ! ""#,-#*+      ! ""#,-#  ()"*   *

        +         (%$     

()"*   +     .

      +

/00#- 1!,.2-#0

3 !- 4 #0 ##-  ,50 3- 3 #.-  !#3 - .3 #

 1 2,#3  !#/  ,-/ - !6-# (#.& 

7* ,  ! 

+ - #

 

 =

. $! * 01) & '*     *  1# -#!1  #0 #,503, !  8!!2 050  2 3- 00  ,#3#  ## -

3#3!, -  0503, 2- ,   3!,#  ,  33!, 1    2# 1  3# 03!  #  0!0 ! 1   3,8!!2 0  #            3#0 !#   #3#   # !8#-#.20   !, - ##   & 



   + +        *+ 2 *. 

       

  +    

3*     *       4  

   .     

*

        

* +   

  * 

*      

   *   

 . 55  +  5 6

 * ((,7 85'&--%9 ((,5

7 85'' %* 5

3 +:  ; <

* (($7185'&1(-9= (($>15''

,1 ?; <

 @ 3 4 * ((-7$85'&,)9= ((->$5''$ -?

:

A  !

 !  B *C * (()7"85'&)19= (()>-5''

"(?' 3 44 =! > A<

DE *71##-8

5'')#(? F C DE  5 3  *1##-7$85'&,") 9=1##->

5''$(1? +  3 4DE  @ 5 D  *1##-7$85'&,)#9=1##->%5''-$) 3  5 G 

3 D  3 

3  D *=1###> #5''((

1% ;+ *.   +



 H  +        

3

 

  4     + 

         <   +

  I  C

 *       *      +   4 



503, -2# !2# 1 #3#  # !233!0 !.#2033!! 0

 !-#3  !#.2!0   2 0  0 .

1!1 0   -  0#!       0!  0 0# -     9 #   (# F  

  +  

 +    +

     "3 1 230 !#0 -0#0  00 - - - ,#-3 33!! :0#.2# 2 #0 #,    3- 5033!! :0#  !- -;

4

,- ! 

+

<12# #-    % ! $     =- 0  !

1  -/- # .



*- #

  

> $  

8 ! +-

. * ?&42 $ -+ 

+<!8 +  * ##

  ! $ !# 

   3- 33!! :3!,3 #  1# 1#3,0! !-

 #0 #- !20:#3#  ## -?

 @  ,- ! 

+ :. #6

 (#>?#  -,@1-2##-.& AB& /@ ''B& 

*- #

  

,

   < . $! *

<         '             + 

  <     +   +2   *         + 

 2       +   < +     

  

4  ,4.1#3,0!21 3!,.2 #

 1#3#  ## -. #0 #,0 0-# ##!-   #,  ! !3!,JJ0  "



 

!8  .#

<!8 !

. :. #6

  ! 3#

!(#> ?#  -,@1-2##-.& AB&/@ ''B & 

!.

 4 # 1 !! 1 1 #0# *(+% -# C&A:'  ,# +  #  $A .< !

#





3    8

$

! # 

 + 8

!8#*#

 - +

! 8 # ! & 2 .

  C! - 6 # 8

+ 8

+ *8 # +

! #

+8#*.-

  +

!$ 

*- 

8

  . 8# #

8 8#  . +"*05!'+"

9  $ -  +    .$*    !    !

!

1/5

6   7  -

      

 

!  

  - -

!

!&45

6 7 + !. 

.

 - '  3 *# -

# -!,-



  !

!  &4  5

6   7 

!    !    !

!

1/5

6 7

 .3 !,

!

!



  !#

!#

+





   !++ ! . + !!#

6 

 8 + 8!

+ #+ + ! #+   / 

8 

 ##

* +

*

!!

#!+ 1 =   % 

&

   3 

 #

0 !

% D0=  # . % D0=