High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1654/2004allowed

Kartar Singh Etc. v. Secy.To Govt.Pb.

2019-07-02Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia13 pages

!"# $%&'(#)&&

*"( !" # $!" "

" "

%

" "

&% !

"" ''''

)&&

*"( +$ (

"

)*+,-. +,+,*/--,

)*++/+*/-+."

% )* +01-" +01+" +01. +012*/--, )*1,22*/-+3"

"

1,

4 5 "+62,7

"

889"

#

"!

"

/,-//--, /0-2/-+/"

$ .:

,:

"

!

*$ ."0-"---;*

(

$ 26 # 5

,--;//- * ""

, +3"

-,-6+221

#

< ,

/0-.+223"

=

> .:

#

:

(

"

=

"$

"#

$

,

#

"

$

":

#

1$

(

5 # :

$

*

#.

:$# $

#

# # /;.

:$# $

5

#

7?= /

"#

/.+//--,"#

$ +:# +"31"---;*$"

+6-++2217?= *.9 "

$ #

?= ,

/6+/+22, ?= 1

-2-++221

$ @ "#

#

$ #

#

4

5 &

" #

$

#

$ $

= @ ":

#

$*!

$ #

+:

"

"

( 0-"---;*

# # /,-//--,

4&*+,*+226

,

!

#

# # $ $ "

#

$ $

(

(

# $!

5 %(A"B " & )"?

&

7$

: C 9

# ( # $#

$$ (

/

## & $$

"

"/

" # "

" *( " @ D " & @ " A :

$ E $ (

$ # !

& #

# !

:#

(

# $ #

(

# /-"---;* $"

#

./:

? 1-F

"

+0:

"$ +/ :

#$

.

# 1

: "

GB B

$ +-*.*+221 +*- +"20"---*-- +-*.*+221 +*- +"20"---*-- 1*0*+221 -*+.

+",."---*--H

%

+6"

$

> +0:

#

:

#

#

$ 5 (

$ # #$

> +-"---;* .;,

5

"#

4

5 &

+-"---;* "#

$ .;,

5

# / %#

5 " :

$ # #

#

$

$

(

"

"# $

1 A # :

$:

, I*+"!

B&

"!

#

#

+6:$ $

5

#& (

@$

# / :$ $

5

"

# :

& $$

5

$*!

"# #: #

<

%

5

$#

I*/"

"$

#

$$ #

" B ! B @$ :

"B " "# =$

$

# #

.:$ @ $

#& #

5

#

:

# <

#

#

(

#

&- #. "

/ & / -

'- 0- - + ?=*/ +,*-,

+,"13"1--;* +,+-22

6"3+"6.+;* / ?=*.

+

+"20"---;* +-.21

+1"06"---;* .

?=*, -*+/

+"--"---;* 3++23

+.".."...;* , ?=*1 -*+/

+"--"---;* /2623

+.".."...;* ( "#

"

+--.+221

#

?=.#

$:

: +1"06"---;* (

?=/", 1 *

:

#$ +:# "

%

:

$

$

$

$

1-)- /2 0/

3- 43-5%( 4 3-6

7 &

G+,I : $ $

=

5

# 5

$

"

#

% :C I B A E

"7/--29++&&+0," $

$ " "

#

* G%

$$$

= $:

#

$ $

79#

# $

,7+9J 79%

J %

5

5

J %

$ % #

"$

$ 7

4

5 E ( 7% +212 & ,/29 (

<C % 7/--.9,&&,6+H ==== ==== ==== /- I

5

" $ A#

$ "$ "

$ $ "#

$ "

$ )

=

" $

$ #

%

$

$

$

#

$

C$ "

#

$

:

#

=

: "

)

*3 *+-

$ K

$

+221 B

+220"

,7+9 % #"

@ #

:

$

@

?= 3 +-

H %

5

< @ #< +"# : #8

8"

$ #$:

@ # #

# (

$ $"

#

#* $ #

$

+--.+221

$ "

"

=$

:

$

#

$ $

.

8 !

A

=& 3 - !3 6 73-"4 3-5)3 9 :

;/0<=3->43-

67 &, ,%

#$

#

"

$# +1-5 13 5

-3-2+266 /.-6+266

# +0-6+266" # #

=

$:

.-F

G/, C

$ "

& #

#

,

" "

+ E

"+266$

"?= +0#

++ !"+266 ?= +6&#

/. "+266#

<

,

% "

@

:

=

<

,

<

#

/1 (

@ & # $

#

?= +0

?= +6& $ 7+1-5 13 5 9

$

$

5

%

$

5

%" 4 5 E

5

"7/-++93&&3+,#

$ $

% /,

#

#* G%$

$

" $

: (

: # < $"

# $ ( $

$ ( "

&

: $ #

H ?= / 1#

#

$$

+"31"---;* %

#

8

" $

6: %# : #

#

$

$

$B

"+22, !"+221

#

$ "

(

#

#

$

5

36.:+,$ : 26 " " * ( "

$$

#

$$$ #

"

$ %"

/ 3 5%( 3-

67&" ,-F

$

=&

$(

5

#

$$" #

$"3 ?

5& @=1 :43-

6 &8 " $

#

11-

5

% &

" +-F

$

$

L

(

G+2(

$$

1-F

$" #

$

$

$(

!

$

$ $$

=

/"31"---;*

5

"

:

$ .",/"1/3;* I

&

@ @ #$ $

$

/-$

"

:

$ 1/1

< ."

#

( "

:

# " #

#

$$$

< .

#

/+<

"

"#

< . ( "

:

$ $ "

< .* & #

*

H (

"

# "

5

%

$

$

$

$

$#

5

= $

+-"---;*

#

$ .;,

5

#

5

$ $

$" +-"---;*

#

5 / "#

I

"

B& # "

( " + "> /"00"+,3;* .:

"

@ "

4&

.:

$ # #

: # # 5

":

=$

5

(

$ **

"

=$

# (

*

# :

$ ( "

4&

$

#

$ $ #5

(

&

-A - ;/0<=3->+

-A -5 B3=:- &B3 3-

67 & 8

$

"

@ #

% &(( 5@- &=?3 6

7&"#

#5

%

( # $"

=&

$ /- :

$ ( ":

=$

# =$

&

$

+--.+221

=& 3 - 3?

-6 7:>"43-5"

C= -4

3-

67&, "#

31F" &

$ 0-F

7

$ $ 9 +1"06"---;*7?=*.9

$ # : 2",0"6--;*(

5

: > 0"/3"/--;* #

(

$ #

$ #

"

4&(

"

,

" "

= @ " )*1,22*/-+3"

,.00 "

"

#

/0-2/-+/ (

"

$

-/-3/-+2 6)&&

*"(7 $% )#