← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1785/2004allowed

Brijeshwar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-03-23Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia9 pages



       



  ! "## "

$"%& &  "'$ $#() )   

        

   *( +,*  ---., 



    !  " 

      

#   

  " #  

#   

$$$$ --.,  /0 !%12   %    & 

  " '( 

 ) 

* +',-'',-."/((0 " )  * +'.1/'.12 "/((0 " )  .0"3  4  '-105"6 67 ""8 9   /:

(:

/((0 " &  2/;  ,&  9 ) #   " )    "  &

 " 

   & ;!

"  < 2/  4  5 : (( (-(=+  7    (- (:

/(('"0"     /( (, '111    & ;  !

  "             / /( (((=+  )3  48

 

!

 &   ""  '-"   9 ! 5>? +1+'(7  (/ (2 '110" &  ',;  '-&   . 

 4    " /    5 0'

:/=+    4  7     &           2/=+ 

  4  

8 "  )&  &" '(@ )  "   & ;!

  ?!    !), .@ "    "

8 "    )&  "    )   '.@ ; !

 "     )& !  )  )8   

 )& !

    !")""'/@ &    &  : ./ 02,=+ %    "+  

    "!  ':

(:

/(((>?

'>?

0 >?

,   " "0"   "/;   '-&   )     ''  %   "     )"    ) ; !      "      ))"8  8 "    "  

  "

     &

&        "     (1 (- '11."   4      "A +'" 

8&& #      +

5>? +.7

B&  !

 )   4  

" ; !)! "8

   3!4'#$ !-'#5  !&6&%!7%#%- % 

02 , 

/  )   "

 

&   !

"   !  ) ""  ! &   )         !  ) %    ) "      ) "  " )& )! + C'( B     & &

&" '1,2 &  )"       0  "           B       &  &   ) A+/  D&   ;   > &  8 ;    "  

"    ))

>? - '' ) &

&& '1,,     )

>? ': '0&

& !)   )

 ) ;    4 )  ) ;  %"     E

      &&          )       &            ! )         )   "  "   !  )  ! E!"8   " 3 ;&  E   5  7     ;   !          !  )   &

&      "   "   4           !           )    B" ?"&

&    " )!     &&   D   ! ;)  

 E    ) )&"

 "+

 !        !  "  "    & )"

 

&         ) &   

       )        '  ;&     "&    )   "  

#   %    "  )             &   !  8           &      "/  G    )) )      

    )"! &"   

! A+0  ) & " &          %  "  )& "     !") +

5>? +.7 

 ">? +1+'(      "       )

           4 &         4 %   )  )  "   "&  4

>! "8       &   & )3  4 8

      " /(('   " 5>? +/+07 !

    3   4  8

                   >? +1+'(  " &  )   ;"    )  '110    )  

!   )   ?"

'(@  & !)"  % &"

?

8  6& %8 &'4%#9%' % 1 

0 2- 

   

  ) ;  "  & ;!

 )  & !""       )  "   "      !  ) "     & "    !     C''

&       "" +  "   "! &   !  ) " "! &   & "

  B       "

! &!    )         &  D   ) &+)    ! & "    &   "                 !

   & ;   &    &     B& ; )   ! &  & "      !!:(@.(@&      D?& &    " ! &    )    " & 

  &  "'@/@  & %  "  "" & ;!

" ) =&+ )     & ;!

"    %"" & ;!

) =&+ )    )'(@'.@  &  

      ))   ""    ).@, .@  & % "&)"

  )   )"    "!     A        "

       "       "!         )

    &

'/ G&

  ;&"&  & ;!

) !

   ! ! & ;!

" )  ! 5 !)

       47 !"  &      4"&  )

 ) % &  )  "      ++     = 4     ) 4)  "    ""!           &  )   "  !  "          )  A & )   )   "

    "  & )& "   )    

   *? &

 "& & ; !

"   4'11/        &"   4'1,('1-(&   !&  "

 %)  !"   H 6"   &  "      "& ; ""!  "       "" !  "

 

':

& "&& ; !

" 4 ""     4 %

  "& ;!

"   4   '11/       )  &    "           = 4"'11''11/5  "

 & " 7     = 4 "  " '110+1.'11.+12  ; ) 

 & ;!

'11/;) ;)& ;

  "'(@'.@  & "   "ID"" & 

"!

     )4 4 ) " &    & ;  !

  "  4        ! 4 4 ! &     !

! &"          3

  3 &        ! &  !          %

    & ;          )   &&    "  &             4  "   =&& =    

 )

 ! &    & !&      " = &="  ?     "

    

)&&!

 ) >!"

  & !&"     

)   "& !&      "       =&& = 

     "      "   & ; !

      '(@   &  )"    4     "& ;!

"    )

 4  

)&&&  /(@:(@  !& "! &=  ! &

%" "  ) " ! 4=   '(@  &    ) !  & ;!

"" 4=    )'(@  & ) &  &  %     "         )&   ) 8 " !& "& ; !

")4="   >!" )&! )   )   

 

""  "   & 

?????????????

'.

% & ;!

  " & ;!

 &&     A& ; !

 )  "    ;

& )" 4 &          "   " ! 6& ; !

   

    &             & !  

  "

  %"")     &      )   "

  

   5 " '(@ ! )  " '(=+ 4 &7 J  "

   & & !  & '1-,5  J 7 '( (( '( (( '1-- '(K'L''

(( '( ((K'

((L''

(( '1-1 ''K'L'/ (( ''

((K'

'(L'/ '( '11( '/K'L':

(( '/ '(K'

/'L':

:'

'11'

':K'L'0 (( ':

:'K'

::L'0 '11/ '0K'L'.

(( '0 20K'

02L'2 '(

   9 ! & ?&

5>? +'+':7      "       )     )      )   ;     % ?&

  "&'1-1    !

  / 0( (((=+       

  '11:  &

;"   " 0 12 (((=+  " " '11-5>? +27   &   2 (: (0.=+   !" 

   ? ".(@   ) "       

"      8"   )""& ! & )<'/@"&'110 %  "?&

   - -%1 $ $& % -%1  $ ! %&1$ -%1  "#&'$ !%:

'#

% ; !

%"!  '

>?

'='/ :( :

/((( /9+'-

: 1- ,.(=+ '' (( (((=+ / >?

/ :( :

/((( /9+'-

: 1- ,.(=+ '' (( (((=+ :

>?

:

:( :

/((( /9+'-

: 1- ,.(=+ '' (( (((=+ >?

0 :( :

/((( /9+'-

: 1- ,.(=+ '' (( (((=+ >?

2 :

'11- '224 

/( ,:(=+ 2 (: (0.=+ ,

>?

, :( :

/((( /9+'-

: 1- ,.(=+ '' (( (((=+ - >?

-='0 '

'1-1 /9+(

2( (((=+ / 0( (((=+ >?

1 '( / '110 ',9+'-

0/9+',

'. '- ,.(=+ / (( (((=+ '(

>?

''

/2 '11/ (9+'-

: (( (((=+ / 22 222=+ ''

>?

':

/ / '11:

'9+(

2/ (((=+ 0 12 (((=+ %          :( (:

/(((     )   ;              "     !      +

?       !

&    " &    . ? &   :( (:

/((( "

  

&  /;  '-&    !   &      

   )   ;

 E  &    )

8 "   "      ) #%  "  &&         "       )  !

  ?&

    &  &    # %; && "  & && % 4 /;&  "&       "     &    "       )   ;    " &



 ; !'/@& !  ">? +1+'( 8"  )" )

  )  & ;  : ./ 02,=+

 5 ,/ -/  4  7      

  ") &  & &  

" )  

  ?     )"  /:

(:

/('-  0--.,2