Karamdin Munshi v. State Of Punjab & ORS.




   
 





!"#$$ %&'(!)*! + $$,$$ -& *  .

*!/0!( +&   ,$$  1 !(!  




  
 


& !" )&$.$.$+23(4

3

&+1 !&$ )&$$.$.*22&33 *!/0$ )&$ '!)+/!3(4

3

&+

'12!!$ 
 




!& 2 !5 6+ + 



* ( 5(4 .!5+ 6 &(

''!5+

 *!(&. ! 787393 9: &( 6+ . ! #9 !( #
$  -( /*(5'! !(

&(&((:$7$1 (0;+2&!(*( 2)5 &3
 2 3 +5&+ .+03 + 

* ( 6&

(

& +

 *!(&. ! 939:3787&(6+. !7#
 !( !!

( *!(&" . ! 9 &(



&+&'

!+  6+ . 7#  . ! 9: &( .


& < '

!+  !(   1;  !

6+ . 7#

$8=  !(3 ( *2

 1;'!

!3  *&+& *!(&5  .


!'

!+ +$ . ! 787 &(



! ;& !(   1;  !

6+ . 7#

$8=  +3 !( ( *2

 1;'!

!3  *&+& *!(&5  .


!'

!+$

>? 22+ !!

 6& &(&( &*!

*&&!2;$ 55&4(

 + /*(5'! !( &(& 1 ( 0; + 2&!( &2  *&3 6  112 3 ! 0; + 1 !& !( !

+& 0;



* ( 5(4 .!5+3  6& 2( 0

& + 2&!(. ! *(53 +5&+.+0$-(/*(5'!(( $$ 1 ( 0; + 2&!( (( !2 . !  *(53

+5&+.+030 ++ (112 6&( ' (3+&0;

&'!5+/*(5'!!( &(&1 (0;+&2)5 &$ + &'!2 1&  * ! 5!  + 1 !& !( + 



* (36 1*! '

!+0  

 &'!2

'12! 2( 0; +

'12!! > *!/0 !( &;! 5+ *&?36++225 ! +&'!2@& ! $89

:6  2(0; !50&.!5+*!(&& 2

+ ! *


!(

&+&2 

(!* !+ *  (;

)=  $.$ & A %2!3 *(  4225 +3

 . ! (23 + 2 !(  & +5&+ .+0 !( 

* ( %&'(!)*! +

+ (& A%2!$+ (   '*1

&+&!50

&+  *& !$#$:!(+  *&36+2  *!5 !

 '

!3 +( 2  11 !(  @&&!

6+(& ! 5  +1&'  

+& 1 !(! +&!  &

&+(!* !(1& (* +'0

&+ *&$ 

&(!52;3@&&!

&6 11 !(0;+ 5 && >*( 2?$  42 ) $ 112  ! 6  2( ! + 1!(!5 &'!2@& !30;+

*! 2

&+1 !&+&!3 6+&!+  *&1 (+ &(&&5&(!5+&2 

+ (!*  +&!3 !  3 +; 6&

*!( ! *!26 *2

>7? (! !$   64&3 + @&&!

& *0'( +  &1 & ++3 !+4!5& +(+1&'  3+( &4(& 1 !(!  $ +&! >+ 1& ! 1 !&?  6+ + 6&&!   !( 11& ( +'

 + 1*&1

 +  4 $  + ' & .!5+3'(&

+20 *&6 2 1& !+&$ >%&'(!?54!6&!5 +@&&!

&++20 *& +(A!(4!

65  +*!

$3#3=30*+; +( !2;6 &A( +<!

$3=65 $&.!5+ 2  5  &

&(( ! 6&!5 + + 6    A $93=

'+20 *&!(++20 *&! &(& ' 11& 1& + ('

*!3+(5 2(+6&1 !$ !+ A!5

+ @&&!

&3 22 + (!*  >20 *&? +( 0 &(( +

!&! &(& 24+0& AA2!1&'  30*+'3 5(4 .!5+3 %&'(! !( & .!5+3 '(& 2 !5 6+ =8 1& ! 

 20 *& 2 3  11( + !& ' 1&

(!5 +($  1 +4!5 0! 2&2; 11& (

&(& 1 (0;+  *&3+ (1& ! ((!

(   ' ( !5 $  
! +  1&

 3 +  < > !&? (&4& 2  5 !/*&($ + 1  &(   & 24 + '&3 0*   !

 42$
! +  6;3 + 

* ( +( 0 &* (  !( 1&4!( + @&&!

'

'12;!56++ &(& (($#$: 1 ( 0; +   *&  0; * 

&'!2

$ +& &3 +  *&!  &(&(($8$:+(!

(+ + +  @&&!

& +( 0! 0 &* (  0; &! 1& ! 

' 1&

&'!5 +  (*;$ + 5 && >*( 2? 6 3

&(!52;3 (& (   2 (5 

'12! 6+ &5&(   + 

>#? (!6++ *&

&!(6+!:(; $

&(!52;3 +1& !

'12!6  2($  &&

&(!5+1&2'!&;4(!

3+

* ( 6& &(&(   0 *''

!(   + &2$  ! +& 11&!

3 + 

* (  6& *112( 6+ +

1;

'12!$ & .!5+ 

* ( 6  ( 2&(  1&

2'(

!(&$

& +&5 4(!

 +4!5 0! &

&((3 +

* (6& +&5(

 *!(&. ! 7873939: &( 6+ . ! #9  !( #
$ + 

* ( (!( +

+&5 !( 2'(&2$
! &(& 1& 4+5*2 !+1&

+

* (3 ! 1 +&5 4(!

3 +

'12!! +( <'!( 8 6!  3 !

2*(!5 + @&&!

&3 !'2;3 @ .6!(&%*'&3 (&

+  *&$ .'!



* (*!(&. !77&$ $$6  &

&(($+

* ((!(+225 ! !(12(( 2  '12  ! ! + 0  

 + 4(!

 2(3  

( 1& 4( 0

&+2&!(&2 *&++

* (+(* (

 (&+@&&!

'1&

&'!5+ 26 *2(* !( +  '

! 

 + 6!   <'!( 0; +

'12!! +( (*2;

&& &( + ( 225 ! $  

&(!52;3 + 2&!( &2  *&3

( !( !!

( + 

* (   (0 4$+112 1& &&(0;0 ++

* (6& ( ' (0;+2&!((( !2. ! *(53 +5&+ .+0$

>8?
 '; 0 !

( + 

7 2( 0;



* ( 5(4 .!5+3 !(  0(3 4( + &(&

 4! (3!46

+(+

+ (

* ($ +4&; * 3+2&!(

*! 211&!5

+1 !&+ 36+2

!!5+ 1&;& +B*!*'

!!

3 *0'( + + 225( !

(! ! +    1&!  +;&:$+1 !&+ 0!3+* 3 !5 + 5 !;

 &2

& + 2   ;& $   ( 3  *

 +  *0 !4 !!

  ;&3 + 1 !& +  2&(; *!(&5 !  1& (

  11& <'2; +& '

!+ $  +* 3  1&;&+ 0!'(

&&(* !5+ !!

'1 (*1 +1 !& + !2&(;*!(&5 !0;+'$ ! + +& +!(3 + 2&!( .

*! 2 + 3 6+2

!& 4&!5+

& ( *0'

! 3&5*(+0 + +  *&  02 6 +4 &

&((  !(!5 + +  

* ( 1 !&+( 0 &* (+@&&!

'< *!5+  (* 36+ ++(*2'2;& *2(! +!

!

'12!

+ &(& 1 (0;+  *&$ .* !(!5(  !

 *

' !; 1&! 2252; !( +!

3   1&;&   '(

( ' 2

+&4 !1 !$  + +  *&  02 6  & +4!5 &*!C( + 4(!

!&

&(3+4&5+2;

(+1

&+

   *!(& . !  93 9:3 787 &( 6+ . ! 7# $
!'; 1!

!3!

  '( *

&!& &!

!+ /*(5'! !( &(&1 (0;+ *& 02 6 & +

! 1&  

&!($ !

3 +

1 !& *1+2($

>? @+2

'!5   + !!

 1&3 0; !

63 + 1 !&+ 2&(;*!(&5 !11& <'2;7'

!+  *

+  2 *0 !4 !!

! ;&$ A!5 !

! (& ! + +

*&&!

 ! +    1&!   ;& : !( +  + + 1 !& +  0! !5 + 5 !;

 &2

& + 2   ;& 3 ! '; 1!

!3 !

 *  *2 1*&1  6 *2( 0 &4( 0; !(!5 + 1 !& 0+!( + 0&   5!3   *!(&5  + &'!!5 !!

$
! (3 !( 

 /*   6 *2( 0 *02; '3  + *0 !4 !!

 '1 ( *1 ! + 1 !&   &(* (  ! 2&(;*!(&5 !0;+'$
!46

+0 436+2*1+ 2(!5+

+1 !&*!(&. ! 939:3787&(6+. 7#
3+ *0 !4 !!

'1 (*1 !+1 !&  &(* (  ! 2&(; *!(&5 ! 0; +'3 0* *0/   1;'!

$3=   !$ + ! '

*! +22 0 (1 ( 0; + 

* (1 !& 6+ + 5+  *& D52 .&4   ''36+!1& (

6 '

!+  ' (;$

4 ! ( 1 (

!+0 4&' $
  
 


!

#$$ (
@++&.1A!5=  !("  = @++& 1 &02"  =