Union Of India And Others v. Ex Hav Vinod Kumar And Another
!
" #$$
&'()
$%#$%
'*+,+(-$%$0$%
'&+&+(-' ,
',1(-2'- -&, . /
. /
.
-/ / .
! 0- " *23"( !& -1! (
444
( ** 1*
2 $ * % * 5 9 1 1 !
"" # # $
%& ""'
()% %*: + "" +& "
6 "
-"*
7 ** "" *1 1 , * -& "
1 " *
" ""& )%* * -
"" - ) %
& -
1
1 %8) % 1 " "
## '
()% 7 " * " - )%"" % * 1 % - " " & )% * * " " % & - % 0-1" (
-
6
7 " * * * *"1 1 " * ) "
- " * -
% . :6;+1*$""&
1 %- """
% * & " " "" +
+* %* * )
1"
!
"#$%&'&( %*+,-. $-01- < """'
()%%* * 1%= 8
" ** - $"** >?
%
7 " * " 1 - " " "" " '
()% & % * ' - " * -
"&
## ( "
=*
, , / " @ 11 A 1& *" %" % 0-1"(
* )% 1%
% " 6;+ !1*$ -
1 % - % * 5 & 5 ( =*
, , )%"" %* % 1 % - 1& - & *"1 " 1 % % 1& *
, , = "
)%"" %* **& *"1
* 1 2 1 %- & *
, , % 0-1"(
;
B ,* -& "
* &
6
& - % 0-1" (
)%"" %* % C$ & * 2 "$2 %3
#0#
! "# $#% &' (
) * + + & & *,) - & &++ ..-'
. &- *-*, ((/& .- 0 . 1,, * * &,) .( 2& + ,, 1 3 "( ) 444 ( ) 4444 "( )" 4444 "( ) 4444 "( ) & *,) ( -, +3 34 4 4 4 4 #
.,,) +&*) / ' + '' '#5 * " -& & )%"" % * 1 %-& *
#=*
, ,E 1" "& )%*%* &- %C & * & "" )% *
% % &
- " * < "" """ % *
1 % BE/*1!"(
!
"#$%&'&( %*+,-. $-01-*& 1 * "" ""&
%* *-"
#3# "
& -
"-
" * 1*" "
1 "" "" "11 %&
- % . %- - * " )
1 %5& * $
2 $# ) +, ,, 6 7 8- 0 1 0 &/&-,01 & ( ( + -
- . ', + - + ((' 0++ - & * -++ (+ ' '& *,)1. *-*, ((/& *) ',) /.0 ,& * ( & * + + - & ( ++ + & *,)
# ,, 6 7 1 -,& .
& 0 * +".-, #%697 :;
6 "7
-&*)< ) + + .0 / ' + &0 && =%#>%#9>>%0 + & * + '& /,*, ,) '& .
, 1 /,&& - + /.0 & ) .( ) + '& .
, ' & * /# ?# @/&, &. -
,+ , # A# @ & ) '-( & B-&(' 6 7 & &6 7 & + ,, , 1. .
. + - & ( ++ +& *,)
& '
&0 1 & .
# ;# & '
, + ' 1,,* +*) ( " - 1,, *) *- , ( (
#%# ,+
*+ '0+ )01 ( ( ,& & *,)
#5 7 " * * ** " & - % BE /*1 !"( %5&6 &$&78% "" *
"
% "" * %" + "" +""
)
1 ' /88$ / (--9-- !+,+:" "/$
&
!
"#$%&'&($$" 2#
"#$%* $6 $ ,-(,;(+,+:
BE/*1!"( %* * %5&6 &$&78% & < =$
$% 2#'&(
!
"#$%&*+,+: $>;:
"" "" % 1 % *
A* -& "
1 " *
& **" & %5&6 &$&78% & $$" 2# 6 &$ &78% 1 " 1 * 5 & 1 % 1 & " "
* & % -* * & " "" "1 %"
( % 1 % - " % ""& )%* * % "" %"1 + +
#4# 5" 1
B " %*-% * 1*
2 $= 5 6" 6 " "
**"
" %"% ! "
1 " * &5'6+&1'&+&+(-+, **(2+-7 82+,9+,,'2 ** $ " % * "
;2 2 ; * 0%
5=C ' * , 8 HC/ ' * 5=