High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/34585/2022disposed of

Ram Kishan And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-11-23Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma6 pages

!" #$%$!&'())(

*+$%, & &- &!, .

(((( $$!& .% / .%0% !" .2 & &-!, .% (((( %3!&- &%

. % &' .(4 5,

6 &- 78-9!# "!., 3 $$!& .%( .( 0.

9 &% 78%%$% &-9!# & .

78 .2 & ( , 3 $$!& .%, 9 "$7 -, 3. % &3 $$!&0&- .1 #$!& .( (("!.% $&: %$- , !.- .-

%% -=2. %3!&- &!( 302!**$%%$!& .8 589$- >,$#, , %0. 2!" %(88?".!* #,!", 3 $$!& .%> %"!." $ -( .$ "72% -, #!&9$#

5 %,1?! %,8> %% .9$&:

7$" $*3.$%!&* &$&# % !(- -);(;() )

. :$% . -0&- .1 #$!&%;8 &-).

->$,1 #$!& &- 1 #$!&!", .*%#8 !7$# 1 $!& , *8$%.$# 5( /$- !.- .- -()( 83 %% -=2 $9$%$!& &#, !",$%!0.$& @ )))A8 "!. % $-

5 %,> %. 7 % -!& .!7 "!. 3 .$!- !" %$< > 5% "!. :.$#070.

7 >!.5( !, , 3 $$!& .%8 & * 728

* +$%, & &- 1 > &8 , 9 "0.&$%, - = $7?%0. 2=!&-%!, 0& !" #,"!., . 7 % !"

#!&9$#

5 %,(0.$&:, 3 .$!-!"3 .!7 8#!&9$#

5 %,> %"!0&- $&9!79 -$& &!, .# % = .$&: !(AA- -;((80&- .

1 #$!&%)8)A88;8) &- 8 !7$# 1 $!& ,0 5= .30.8$%.$# 5 &-> % .. % - $& , % $- (!$# . :

.-$&:"!." $0. !", %0. 2:$9 &=2, 3 $$!& .%> %$%%0 -!

, *=2. %3!&- &!((, 3 $$!& .%, 9 "$7 -, $.. 372!,

"!. % $- &!$# ( , .

" .8 . %3!&- & !( >$,!0 5$&: $&!

#!&%$- .

$!&, 9 .* &%* - $&, . 3723 %% -, $*30:& -!.- .

B0 "!." $0. !"%0. 2 *!0&!"

#,"0.&$%, -=2=!,, 3 $$!& .%( &# , 3. % & 3 $$!&( .& - #!0&% 7 "!. , 3 $$!& .% %0=*$% , $& ,

=% &# !" &2#!&&$9 &# = > &, 3 $$!& .% &- , #!&9$#

5 %,8>,!> %"!0&-$&9!79 -$& &!, . %* &$!& - =!9 8, !.- .3 %% - :

$&%, 3 $$!& .$%9 .2, .%, &-$%&!%0% $& =7 $& >8 %%0#,( &%033!.!",$%#!& &$!&%87 .& -#!0&% 7"!., 3 $$!& ., %. 7$ -03!&, 60-:* &!" #!!.-$& &#,!",$% !0.$&

() "

,0%87 .& -#!0&% 7"!., 3 $$!& .% 3.

2%, , 3. % & 3 $$!&= 77!> - &-, $*30:& -!.- .- && <0.

= B0 %, -( @,$7 !33!%$&:, 3.

2 .!", 3 $$!& .%87 .& -#!0&% 7 "!., 1 9 , * &72#!& &- -, , . $%&!$77 :

7$2$&, !.- .8 %% -=2, 302!**$%%$!& .8 5( "0., .%0=*$%,

%$&# , #!&-0#!", 3 $$!& .%$%>,!772$.. %3!&%$=7 8, 2*0% %0"" ."!., 7 <$2!&, $.3 .( 9$&:, .-, 7 .& -#!0&% 7"!., 3 .$ % &- " .

:!$&:,.!0:,, . #!.-!", # % 8,$%!0.$%!", #!&%$- . - !3$&$!&, , $*30:& -!.- .- 3 %% - =2, 7 .& - 302!**$%%$!& .8 58$%, .%,!&, "

# !"$8 .$#07 .72>, &, . $%&! 77 :

$!&!&. #!.- =!0#!&&$9 &# !"

3 $$!& .%>$,, #!&9$#( @,$7 - 7$&:>$,, %$*$7 .$%%0 8, !&C=7 103. * !0.$& ((

*+ ,!!

* -

() . , %$&3 .

%)!), . !"8, 7- %0&- .'

!!! "

( /) ,"

0"1" 23

# "$

& '

( ) *

% +

,-, # .$

( 2 #

& %

3# & '

(

)

!!!

) ((634 %

)

7 #7 7

8 9-,(: ) )%% 6-- ; < 5

= >

# 6 $%

" / !!

# #

? /

" !&C=7 103. * !0.$&# % ( /) !"

0"1"

23 #5(

!=% .9 - %0&- .' @$

% $

# #

A &6!

!5,$%!0.>,$7 . 72$&:03!&, 60-:* &!"!&C=7 , 3 <!0.$& ((

*+6!

&-9 .$!0%!, .60-:* &%!",$%!0. 77!> -, 3 $$!&

&-% %$- , !.- .. :

.-$&:"!." $0. !", %0. 2 *!0&!"

%()88?(

.0% 7 !" , $*30:& - !.- . - - ;())()

83 %% -=2, 7 .& - 302!**$%%$!& .8 >!07-%,!>, , . > %&! 77 :

$!& :

$&%, 3 $$!& .%, , 2

% * .!""

#8$&%$:

-!., 73 -, #!&9$#8$& &2* && .( &#

&2%0#, 77 :

$!&$%#!&%3$#0!0%72*$%%$&:8, $*30:& -!.- .$%&! %0% $& =7 $&, 2 %!"7 >( &, "

#% &-#$.#0*% &# %!", 3. % &# % 8&! -

=!9 &- ! * , &-% !" 60%$# 8 , $*30:& - !.- . - ;())() 8 3 %% - =2 , 302 !**$%%$!& .8

58 $% !.- . - ! = *!-$"$ - ! , < & , $&% - !"

#,!= "!." $ -!, 1 8, *!0&$%. -0# -!

%(8? #,( , 3 $$!& .% . -$. # -!- 3!%$ %(8?

#,>$,$& 3 .$!-!"!& > 5".!*, - !". # $3!"# .$"$ -

. #!32!",$%!.- .( &- "

07!"3 2* &!"3 & 72>$,$&, %$307 -3 .$!- =2, 3 $$!& .%8, 3. % &3 $$!&%, 77= - * -!, 9 = & -$%*$%% - &-, &$. *!0&!"3 & 72%, 77= . #!9 . -".!*, *8 $& ##!.- &# >$,7 >( @$,, *!-$"$# $!&$&, *!0&!"3 & 72 %$&-$#

=!9 8, 3. % &3 $$!&% &-%-$%3!% -!"(

&-$&: 337$# $!&%$&,$%# % 8$" &28%, 77 7%!% &- -$%3!% -!" ##!.-$&:72(

! "# $% &% '( )*+,-.

)', / '.

$% &% ( &)1