Ajit Singh & ORS. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.
!
"
#$ % # &'( '$)'
'
'
'
* "'$ +
$ ,- .
/+ +
, 0 .
+
$'
! " #
$+ $'
/ % & ! " #
$'.
1(2!
$+  !
3#$!3 '$ '4#$
1(2!
$+  !
'$3 (# "!$ ' ()* )+,- ./+01
1- ./+ 21 ! /
+3.4++4- ./+01
++4.'1- ./++
3++4++4- ./+
21 +
5 +,-
,- +)++01
++(1 +'- - +)++
. 1- ./+ 21 6 3#$!3 '$ '4#$
&+ $'
$'
/ 8 /+,,1.09/+,,'+,/+ ! +!1 /.0 !-.,./44:2,+0-1-1) ++4+(,( / 1'1+/44
10 ! +!-11+2;+/
+ <=<$ <<>1+(+5 (.0 9/+,,'
!"
#
$ %, 6 ,
7
6,
9,5 6 ,, 0:,
6 ;, : 0:,5 ;6 6 6
7
:0 7 ,- ;5
06 ,<< ,- ;+ $ 1 4++2+,,0'1+,/+ ! +!4 1' -1+1+ /+)-1
/,++2,+0-+4+ ()1 ?(,; -/+, + 13 9 ( 6, = *6 , , 40>,15 / 3
+ 12?>
6 = ",> 6@15 3 -01-1+( /,+ -1+1,)+.24+5'+ .+, /1+,,'1,+/1'2+/:/ '-1 1#+ /:/-8@=> 1+221/+,, +1?/ 28@=>?!-+11'1-+0/+ /,
A21 2 +-(/4'2 (21 '1 > /:/- 1 +!- 01/1 (
1 /,++2,+0 +!-+4+ 1. / +!-+/1: (6/+,, + .0 + +/1 B 122)'+24+5'1+(.//, '+-2412+/4-1+011 !4-21 +!-+// 1/., // -12,2+5 1+'+ 10 !// -1/('
+// 14 0.-011/., !// -0+
/,+ (4+++(,-1421. / +! A
.-011+ 4+,. / !-+4+ 1+ !-()1,+ ., '// -1+, +++,(/4'2, 1+'+(21,+ ,,+ // -+,22 ++,52+ C +
-011BC82 <8 -+(/+4
/ 1+'++,22 +. /2 4+,(/4'
4+ 1 <@<C < <- 01+2? - 1 # /
1+'+-(/+4 4 1'1+ 4+ 1-
$88 < < ;68@! @ /:/-011()1 !+ 0,2014 )+0++,+' 14 1
/+,, +! 12- 2 ' 1+ 1 !+,24 ),-+ 2./4'1+ ,, +- ,+/ ,+/ . / !- /+ /.,), +130
< = 0- , =,
, "0: 6, A 3 / 1
36C6, $ ,
> #
< , D = #
9
, +1 3 1'
(6<< 6, = *
, 8
,5 6 C 6,1
'
$
-1()--1 / /+,,9.01 + <=<$ <<>-++ 1 0 ! +!+ 141/.'+, 4(1/,// +,/ +
+'4 142+/1210 ! 5
/ %' #'2 ('4"$# * = 1+52(.)-12+/2 D6A>=6 <<$+ +512 / '1+/.) 8< 1 ! 1 0 +! +
14,.(02,+ 4+'BA5++,8$4+,++
,,+'E +-1,+ /'+4-+ +,+ 1+.// 1+ /1, ??/,+//!1 +/2+2/+ />21#+ /:/- 8@=>-1+221/+,, +1?/28@=>? 88 1,+ 0++/: . 2/+ +
8B<B8==C-+ />21?/28@=>?-01/10+ 2,,0 ()+ /,++4+ /A21?/28@=>?+
(:1++0+ + 8$<B <<<(/+4+ 1+
/
,+ 0+ +/: 2 1 (,/ +4,) +,- /44/+,+ +,++-/6B8-'+4 1 ! 2,) /1+,,' 1 +/: / '()0+)22,' D6B@><6 <<<-01/10+ 2 . + <>8< <<<-01 / !1+14+) (4+ 12 4+- "
-01/11+,,( / +2'.')21+' 8$ 1+2, ()12,+2 1,+ -0+3/ 1' -1+1,+ 21 0+.+/++142+/22/+ />21 ?/28@=>?+ 1+4-1/+(,+ 24+/: 8> 1++23/21/,+421-1) 2, 1+0() '12+/-1+1,+ :-0+.+/++142+/2+2/+- / > 2 1 ?/ 2 8@=>? +1 1 ; ?? /,+ //1+/2+/>2/+- -1 ?/28@=>? 8B 1+2-1 1'111+(.;+/
+ <=<$ <<>- 210-(),'+'1 1 +)/.,4 )-21)(+ . 8A .021 + <=<$ <<>-12,
+2 /,+++ 4+3/-(21,+ ., ' .!-'+1+. 3 '4+ / +
=8< <88 ;68B!-1,+ +, 4 1 ! - () / ' 1 2 4+++(,) 2 1 ++1+'+1,+22 8C ,' +''. 1+'+- 1 ! 2, +
++,(21,+
+, / '-'+1 + ++,(/+4 4 ()1,+ ,,+ - 1'1+ 4+ 1-8 <8 <8 ;68A! 8@ 1 !+,'011,+ 0++, 1 +2 (21 1'112,'BC82
<8 1 + +, (/+4 4 () 1 - <@<C < < ;68C!-1' 1+1/., 4+++(, 8= ,' 6+2 241+2 -1 !
2, # .,!8$ C=6 < <(21 ?(,4 1'1+ 4+ $88 < < ;68@!-1+ # (/+4 4 ()1 ?(,;
< +411+11+, 2, D6>B8>6 <8A-01()1).5 14+ +2/
> !21'1+ 4++ ++/)#+
/:-1+(,++ ,4/- <8$ 1+22 12+1?/2 <8$?!-011//+. +124+5'1+,,+/1 +/:/ ' 1?/28@=>?-(+4+(,(/4 /,+ ,+ -(
/ 2 + /1+'' . /- .6+6.- 1 2 +++4-1()1+/:'+1)//
8 0.-1+ .0213 '421 E/121 ?(,4 +1
, *-<:> '06, @ -+ 6, 2< 6,
+5 '
$ 3
5(/+4 4 -1'1+ 4+ ()1 <@<= < <-
9 6 <, 3 0
<
A
1,+ +/,(41+1/1+,,'1 + !-+1()1./2 ,+)+ ,+/1-+1 + ! 2, () 1 ! .0 2 1 ,() +// 14-+10+3/ <A<= <<8
$ 1 !1+ /1++,1+ /,'
! 4+ 1 + ! +1 2 0 )+ +
1+2?1+.(,+ ,)2, 1+0 !-1()- 4+5'1(,+ /1+,,'(/41()1(+2 ,+)+
,+/1
> 1 2 1 ,+ + +5 1'1 ++ >8$ + 8$<B <<<+ /4++4 :+- 1 (/4' +.+,+(, (/4 ,+ 1 ,+ , // 12- 1 +/: / ' + ,+02,,) /4, +,,/+ 1)/+( /,+ (/4,+ '-,>
9 6 <, 0
< 9, 6 : ,
9, 9 6
0,+
B 1,+ /,++'21 !1+. /,+4 ,2 2 :+1' 2 1 4' 2/+ ! +
8B<B8==C+ 8><B8==@-/.,) />+ A 21?/28@=>?-+ -212+/2+01+2 4+ +4-1 /'1 ,+1(3/,+ 24+/:
A 1-++)21:+1'21 -++ () - 012-+4+1 ! '+ '3/21+-+(/+44+ ()1 -1 6+1-121,+21 ,+
C ++1+1 ,+' /,++(/4 (+5 +. // ()1 ?(,; /+ , + 1
, *-<:> '06, @ = 6,<< 6, '
$ 3
+ / 1+ 1 // 1++
/ /,/1' /1+''. // 2* +!
1++21+/: ,+ (/4'
+4 (!
1 4 /4++4(/4' +.+,+(,2(/4' ( 1,+ ,//
@ 0.-1+(.,+' /,++/+(/,+4 - 4,)21+1+++,0(+' D6 >B8>6 <8A- 1 + + /,+4 (/+4 3/ <@<= < < :,)-16+'21+ 3/ /,+4-((+ () 1'/,2 .10-1+ /,+4 1214+5'2+,+' /,++-(/41' + ( . 24 + + ' 2 ,)- +22 +.- 1+ /,/1'
/1+'' . / +1 1+ ( +
/ / 2 +(, 4,)421 2++4-,+'++2 1+/: ,+ (/4'+4 -1'1++>8$ +
8$<B <<<- + - +, :+ 1 4 /4+ +4- (/4' +.+,+(, 2 (/4' ( 1 ,+ , //
= 662+-+1/1+,,'4+ 13/ 4+ <A<= <<8- 1 1 + + 2 1 !-+1// -01()1 !/,+42 1 +/: ,+ - (/4' ,+ 24 +/:- (/+4
3/ .1+ /,+4+,/+(+// 1 ! $< 1+24+5'1+ //,-+241 2+/4-1+1'11+ /,+4-(+5 ,+('4+ 4,+,)+ ,+ ,// -(++++ '
21,)21 10-1+1+ /,+4+46 2 /,+4- + ,5 ,) 4,+,) + ,+ , // - 01 (, +/: +- (/+4 ,+ 24 +/:-114:+1+ (,,+ + ('+ 1+/2/>2/+-+11 !,+ -0. ,).+/++1,.++' $8 41+F',)-1// !-2+)-1+/:
,+ -+ +, 1,)-+22 +.-(/4+ ( 1+/2+2/+ />21?/28@=>? :,)-/1+ // !1+/: ,+ -1 -1+/2/>2/++(/ (/4+1F ,)+ 1-++1+ +'-10+ (''1-,.1+/: ,+ -1,+
,// $ 1 21 + 2 /,' +) 1 !011,+ ,// -01+(/+4 ,+ 24+/:-2 12+/4-1+24++, 2,)-+22 +.-.+, 1+1,+'2/1+/:
,+ 04+ 1,+ ,// -14-1+1) 01+.',/-01/1(/+4 -+1.4 ,/)-01,111+ -011// !01/10 + 1 +/: ,+ 0 1 +/ 2 / >
2/+-11)0(+1F ,)+ 1(3/ ,+ 12-1/+(+)+)61 ! 01 /1 ,+ , // - 01 +/: + (/+4 ,+ 24+/: $$ 14-++ '21+(5.+,-1+ 1+/2/>2/+-10'+
)2,(3/ /B621?/28@=>?
+ 1+1+,+.+, 1+ ) 0.-1 (3/ !+(/+42, ()1 !(/+4 / +'+ 1 - 1 ,+ ' 1 4+5' 2 1 4'
2/+9 /,++ /A21?/28@=>?12- 1/,21 !/+/ -1+13/ -+-4+ 1(3/ !++(+,)4+ 1)/+/ 1+13/ 0(+/121,4 /,2 $> 1-1 1,)6+22 +.-2, +,,10 ! +!-+0,,+1+'4-24,) / 1+10,+ !-0+/: 221'1: (,/+ 1+1,+ ++'+,/42 1,+),+-,+'1 /4,21,.+(,/ $B / 4+/(+' 1(,/ 1+ . +,21+1, // ( 011 /+5011;21'' ,, 2 1 +/:' +1)- 01 + 1 ,+) ,+ 12-1 2++,,01 !/,+421 +/: ,+ (/4',+ 24+/:
%
'2 $*!$ ()
#$ + $A +24+1- 1 2 4 1 0 !-+ -011+(.(.+-1+4+ 4 1 4' 2/+ !- + /: 1 +0+ + 4++ + +224 $C +/ $@ /14+/+,21+.( / -1-+,,1 '+,/+ !-2+)-+,+ ! 2
3#$!3 '$ '4#$ &#*"! '$3 (# "!$ + &#*"!
5+.'1 D11+5'9+
*
9 D11+(, *
9