← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1951/2004disposed of

Gopi Etc. v. State Ofhy.

2025-09-02Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja8 pages

    

  

  

 !""#$%&& 

       

  

 % '(  & ) * )  

   

 



 !"!#$%%& %&''((%" )   



 !"!# *+%*,*+%'$'('-"      )

.

  

 !"!#$'/+*'-(0 '-*($'((-" 1 

23)  44444 * )  & +,-

* 5   667 .6  

1   */ 

#   

1 .    

 8

 

 

  

. 

 

.6   *'

#   

 

1 . 2  6 

 ' 9 

    .

1

   ':(%'((-

$ 6$  )   < .

   2 

1 

   !"  

   

  

 .2  *0

=

  >   *0+-  



 

 / Brief facts of the case are that

 

      

     5.

 

,)   2  >

     **(&*++& 1

('(:*++&

*0+- 

    **(/*++:

&



1

 6  

9=  *8

  

 > *'&%

8

= >  ;     (&(**+++

 6   

**((((?$

  !%((((?$

 "# $ "% & ' ( '#') - ..

   

       1 

 =   >   ;

. 

2  

 !"

*0

*0+- 

2.   6  @ 

 

1 



    ':(%'((- 

*/0%((?$

  ! 1  .

 .

  1    .

   6 %

.  ..

 

 

        1 





   



6   

 

7 .6   6.

    6

 6   & A6 .. 

 

           

 !" 16 

   2    

  

  2 1

 

*

   

 

>

   2  6



/*(:*+0&

    



./*(:*+0&=    16  

*0+-   1

 ('(:*++& 

 6  

 

  >

  

>

  1

  

 1      ('(:*++&



 2.

  /*(:*+0& &* =   

 



.

   .

   **(&*++/!BC$*"

 1

.

 6

6

.*0 6 =    16  

1

 6 1



  D+ , 



.      6    





6BC$*       6

   1

6 

 16 

 1



1  1 6

 .

 .

 1     



  

 : E



   

 $ 

16      >      1  6         1 





. 

   BC-



6 .     

:* =        

 $ 



.



1  

  6

 2.

 

>

  /*(:*+0& 

.

  

 (&(**+++

    

.



 

  2.        

 

  

 

  /*(:*+0& .

**

*0+-  0 A

   

 .



12A 1  

 166 1



 + 

    1



BC



B.

9 F

 )9 1 

    6

 



 2 

1

 /*(:*+0&



  



 2     

  6  6

 

 6 .

 < *+++8

    '!1"

    



 

$ - + . / 0 + 1  1

 

 

 .

'/  1 2#





3    1  0$ $  /  1  !$  04 $  1 " 

 0 $  1 )

1  . /

 1 



)  *0 4056 

  1  

/3  *04056 

/  

/ #0 . ') / 1  

  ' 



'   

+ 3 +7 

/0 8

   ') / 1 2#



 

 1 2#  

 

  

/ 0 8

  '     1 2#



 +

  ' 1 ) /

 00  *0 40560 8

   /

 

 7

'/  1  

'0 .

+%  1 /

1 

39# . 9

   '

  2#



 

 2#  1

'/  1  

'



  0:

+* ; 



. **!*"

*0+-  



 1   

 1     

-!*"

*0+-  **!*"



$ -0 ;2#7 



+7 ! 0 < =



7

 19 $   7

7     2#7 

+ %# $  ! 

 / 

 2#   +% 

1 7   7 /  





/# #   3 # 

   ' #'

' # 

 5$ 

  3# 1  

< 

 1  /#+  1  1  # 



$

#+ 

=$ 

   / 3 

1  / 

' 

'/  

 ')  

#  



1

  #  1   >

 

'/     

/

#

+ 

1   > 

  //' 1 



'/  '   / 

)  +3

 + 

   $  '$  1 

'

$  

1'$    7 3  / 37 //

+1 '

?

<@3

  

 + ' +7  !  #  

#+  #  /3#

//3 1  /// (3'  1

 11 

 /// (3' '7 #A  

+1?

@3

1#  

 +

'/ 1  /// (3' 

   !  '7 ')

 

#

 //3 





1

 /// (3' '7

/ 17  

+10:

*( A

   6 

-

6 

*0+-   1

('(:*++&







 1   

  

 2.

  /*(:*+0& *(*

6

6

  1  

 166 



  

  

  



1  

  /*(:*+0& (&(**+++!

.

"

 .

   

  2.        

 6    

      /*(:*+0&  A    

 .

    

    

  

   $ 

 /*(:*+0& (&(**+++  1  1      6.

 

6 1

   G.



 1 

  >   *('

A





6  6

6  

  2.  



   /*(:*+0&



*0+- 

      1

    ('(:*++&        6 

?

  

*'H

 6 

6

 

= >  ; I**((((?$

 D , 

('(:*++&  6   /-+&/+?$

#



 



 16 6 1



  

 



   BC* **(&*++/ 

>

 1  2     1

J 61  

  

  6.

. *:&8



 



   

4



 6

6

.*06 

    BC$-

 6.

. *&: 

6

.-(2*% 6 8

  



   **(&*++&!BC$-" */0%((?$

A



   BC$-

 2

*&:   6    6



1

1 .

D+ ,

.





  BC$-

 .  6. 

*&: 

     ;

. 

 6     

       **(&*++/BC$*1 .

.

  6

. 

  .



 . 6



.  *0  6    6.      2

  *:&    2     

   1  .             %%H    6    1   

.    6

  6

 6  /&((((?$

*(/ A

 

6    2.  

  6

1 

1 





 6

  6 

 

 1  

*0+- ('(:*++&  C6 /%((((?$

  .



    

 

/%((((?$

  

A 

 1     

    

 



*0+- !6  $

5  " **

  

  6 

 $ 



.

$ .

   !"  1

1





 1     . 6   

  6   1 .   . 

    . 

      

 

$ 

J  

   6   

 *' .     ('(+'('%  * )  

2

 2.?

  ?

 1  ? )+& #&

,.#& !/- * #$*+%'$'((- 8@B8;5?88BE#3,  ' #$'/+*$'((- <A=5?8E#3,  / #$'-(0$'((- <I<<,E88BE#3,  - #$'-(+$'((- A;=,E5?8E#3, % #$'-*($'((- <A8,E5?8E#3 )  & #$%%&$'((% )9AA  )E5?88BE#3   )E : #$%%:$'((% <)AA  )E5? 8E#3 )E 0 #$%%0$'((% )A=9,E5?8E#3  )  + #$%%+$'((%  58 )E5?88B E#3  )  *( #$%&($'((% A )BA 5?8E# 3  )  ** #$%&*$'((% B )E5?88BE# 3  )  *' #$%&'$'((% AF )E5?88BE# 3  )