← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/38757/2014allowed

Sandeep Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab Etc

2015-09-23Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal16 pages



   

 !"

#$%%&'(')*  +

,#)-%%.,')/0#)-#)$0%1  %$'$')%1( 2( ,$#$% 3)4#5#)-#)$0%1  %(.)-%)$( *

     

        

    



      !

""""

      ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* + # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

  /

#$%   & '

 ()*  $$+  !, -+ !-$,  

 .-/0., )1 !2 3   

&     4     

'

  

 33 #!% 1 ()*  

6 13  



0 7 

        &  4      2- 8   

    3   5&       98  3 +--   5     9



 :

  : *0  



5 ;7 < 9



0

3 

  : *0

5 3 3

   =

&5  5    8  >8 8

3  5   8 >       

33 8



  5  

  &  3 5    9    

 5  

 

 



 5 

 

5 3    8   8 7     3    &  9 5

  5 8 

&



0 7&

 *0       ?   

&   3

=

 3 3 ()* 5  #.%    



  5  

  &  3  5    8  5

 #,%    $

   8 3

8  3  3

3  85  &

  

  1

  

  #2% 9 @ 5

 5 

,+!

1  1   '

    3   5 

 33

5     3  '



   9 4>  @   

3

%'

-! "0

      / 123'!'42  & ) 0

   " )  )% / 11+'! '564   7 )  8 0

  ')- $ !" )% /

 122'!'431  33

8

  '(-  

/ $ . - 0

  0&  )%' 9 

 )'' )% /+66,:+; :

;356:;

9   33



3

5 36    

              

             

 



     

             

     " "  #  $ 

    "      %

    



  



 "    " " 

       

     !     "         



  "        

    "        

                 !      "

    "     

   

              ! 

  

 "  "%    





      "   !    &       



       

        '    "



  !     

              

         

    !

     !    "

   

                 (      %     

  

#  )* 

+    

  (,    (                       #    )*     

 +                   

 #  -.!      

+        # "

, "

# !

/  0 1  

             " 

    !    !     

  "    "

                      



    !                     "         

 

          

  "

   "          

!    "

 "      '               !!!              

"

     

     '  

'     "  

 

"

 "

    2      



       "    !    ! !

      

           

     "   !           

"   

  

 

 



     "

    

+       

 

 

 !

   !  3 #A% (  7 

7'

$-)%-)( )%

      <')& #  )%  )/  +662:,;   :

;  6=+    5

,+!

1  1   

   5  '

 

    

    

 5 9 5      3 3       5 

  45  5  

@  8  8 

3   9

  8

 5   

 5 

,+!

1  1 9 5

,+!

1  1 



@ 



  

 #/% )

 & ) 0

   " )  )% / 11+ '!  '  564 5 

,+!

1  1  5  

4>  @   3

  ) 5    5  

@     

 8  5   

  

8  

8     3 3  3 @      5  5  

@ 

 4>  @   

58

  5  5  

@ 

     

 5   

  7  8   

!

     !

  !

    "   %   

            "       

   "       !

%       

  

    8    

         !



  !

 

  " !

"

 &9     :

   "

    

"

    #  7;<071       2   

   

#   7;;01  -  8     

!

   &9!

      

  

   !    !!

  " 

!

%    

    )  8   

  &9 

 :

      " 5 :

      !

  "

   

   2     !

   #  7;;01  ;  8    

  !

      &9   !

  

     " 



                    

    <  8     

 

   

"         0      

        1    

                  =  

                                                 

"

  8    

      !

  "

  

!

   =       

 "   

    !   %         

 



  !     

 3

#+% ) @

 5

,+!

1  1 

      

'

 5 

 

    8

'

 5



53 8 3 8       33    3     3 3   )  58   38

 5 5 

 8    

     3



 33 ) - )-)(0

  <')& # )% )+6+:4;

:

;=4, 4> 

3   8

3      

5 36 ;      !  ! 

     !!

 >     '     

      &9    !

 

                 !     

!

           #    -?          

 

 

 

 "

       

 

    

  :@0 1      0

1

  

     "    

'  

  !

 &  9!

"            !                         !                 "    

 

           !          "

     !                 ! 

"  

% ! 

  "   

    "  '             !      !A "                      #               

  " #

" "!

!

    

        

             

  

% +        !!

  "

   %   

"

@          " 

    '    

             B    

         "     5!

 "  

                        '  

 

"    !!! 



  !       

 

    

%                    !

 !"

  "    "      



"   

   

               "

   !

"' 

   



   !

!

     

  !  

"    !  

%

  

         

          !     

   ! "'   

   



  !

    !     !

!

 

    !                !    

      

 "            

    

        

      !

        

  

    !    !

!

        !       

         



  

          

 '  01   !

   



     '  

   3 #B% 9 4> 

3    5 - )-)(0

  <')& # )% )+6+:4; :

;

=4,/ .-!"'& &0

)-)-"'(%!-)-  /

/ )%-(  )% /+6+:5;3+1

    

.-/ )1 9 4>  @ 5  8

 - )-)(  ; <     

5  3        63                 5  3   

 5 9      

4>  @

    5     

  

3     

6 3  



     3

- ) -)(  ; < 9 4>  @   '

           5  3   

 5   5   

 5 8 @3  8     8 9 



 5 5 

3 

 

  3 8 38

5   )  3 6 

.-/ )1 5 5 

3  ()*    '

    5 '

 #$-% 9 '

    

 

.-/ )1 3

    

 4> 



3

 -)%-)( )% 0

  <')& # )% )/+64:+; :

;43+    4>  @ 3 

 3  

.-/ )1  8 

     8

63  

   5 

   '

 3  3

5  

@

 5

,+!

1  1 (5    5  5

 .$

36 -7  

   

   !



"  

 

"             '   !    !   

        #    )*              !    '             

    ! 

     

 

  > 01 +         #   )*           ! 



 !

     #  -?  ,   #    )*                

   '  

           !



   

      !

   !                

  

 " 

   01 8    

             !   

'    

       

       >

 1   

   

      "  8          ! 

   

 

      01 #                               ! 

 "  

% ! 

  "  #              

  "  #

"       

     

  !!

      

   

%   +                   !!

   "  +

  #    %    

"   '  !  "

!

!

     !     0C1 D         

         "     5!

 "  

   

 

"         !! 

              !





 "  

'     

            ! !   0C1 8             

       

"     !  

%    

                 

            !  

           !  "    '     

   0C1 D   #  -?+ 



      "                      

"  

 ! 

  " 



 

           !  "    

!      #    -?  +     &9        !       

  

     

  #  -?+    %                 

             



     #  -?+ &             "    "

    

" 

  

=  



"  

   2 

 

       "   !   

"     D 

     

"          

         

"

                     !  

%  !            !  '  

      

      

!



     

!

       

     !

  !   

       

 

"  "      !   

     !"  ! !

"    



0C1 8               

     #    )*          

  ! 

" 

            !        

!! 

"      

   !!

        !

  

       !

"

     !   '   

  =                        



         $ %

            ! 

      "        

  "     

         

"

        !      !  =!

 

!   

 D                   

!  !

                   !

      !  !

"             

  !

          #    )*          

  

       

"!    !              #    -?  +    !!

      #

"          

"   " 

  !

 

 

        !  !

!

   

  

           !     

' 

    

"    " 

         #  -?+   

"

     !      



'  

   "   ! 3 #$$% )     %"  < %  0

 . 8 )%  / +64:4; :

;+6+ 4>  @    

.-/ )1

     8 

 

   

5   5

   5

 -)%-)( )% 0

  <')& # )% /+64:+; :

;43+ 5     - )-)(0

  <')& # )% )/ +6+:4; :

;=4,     ) 

  5 @

 -)%-)( )%  ; <  

56 &

 5   3   #$!% )     

 

 5 3  C  @

 5    @3  5 

 8  

&     5       

 5   

 8 =

.-/ )1 

8    8



   

0 8  

     3 3  5  



  38

 

.-/ )1

3 

()* 

 )

  

   5

 

.-/ )1

   

  &



()*

)  586

35  &

 

8  

  3 5 

8

    

8  5



 3 3   

  



   

  3         5    @3    5 

 

 8       

& 3 )  '

      

.-/ )1 5   8 

      

 6

;

< C  5  3    

0 8 



 6

5



 8 5

;

<  5   & 



 8

@    @







 8 ;

<   

 

 

 3

 38

     .-/ )1

;

< 

 3 8 3 3 



5  

1      

  3     5  

 8   

  

  3 

5 

  5 

5 @



  5 

 8 5

3   



  6       6     

.-/ )1 

   3 

 33 #$.%

  3    8

  5    5

    5     5

    $

   8 3 4

8  3  3

3 85  5  

3 5   5  #$,% ?

  

   3 )  =     



     3  5 3  #$2% )  5  

   



  

,+!

1  1  

@ 

 5

  3

 -)%-)( )%

 ; < #$A% 1'

8  

5 * 8 ()*  $$+  !, -+ !-$,

 .-/0., )1 !2 3  

&     4     

'

    '



3  !. !-$2

 ,"

 %