Jasbir Singh v. State Of Haryana

  

       

  !" #$%$!&'
()(

  %*$+,$&-. / $$!& +

0 +%1%
State of Haryana   ((( %2!&3 &








 

+ % &' +( + &3 +4

738!#  "!+. 2 $$!& +( +( 8 &419 +,. !+ &7 7 +:

& ;;; 
 



(

%  $% * $&- < & 12 "!+ .

+$&- .+!1-. 0$3 !

!&" + &#$&-31 ! !8$3=2 &3 9$#(
( + : +$&. 2 $$!&1&3 +, #$!&>= +(( ($%"!+-+ !" + -16 + * $6 ! .  2 $$!& + $& # %    3 ?((

7 + -$% + 3 1&3 + , #$!&% 7 =7 >
>7 >
7 
7 ?  7  !6$#  , &3$+!@.$#., #$!&>) @ 33 36  +!&( >( +& 3#!1&% 6#!& &3%.

 +6$ +. 2 $$!& +.

3* & -+ & 3* $6 6!&-@$.!. +#! ##1% 38$3 !+3 +3  3=((

*: . 6 +& 3+$ !1+*1!& 33$$!&!"!"" &# 1&3 +, #$!&>) 7 * $6-+ & 3!. 2 $$!& + &3#! ##1% 3@ %# &# 66 3 &3 6.!1-. %1*% B1 &6:#! ##1% 3.

8 * &+ 6 % 3!&* $6*1. 2 $$!& +.

* &3 &$ 3* $6!& ##!1&!"$&51+: +$*1 3!.$9$( (*6!@@$.$+!& +!3!&. .

3!". %!&!". #!926 &.

%* &3 #6 + 3!* 

C
D &- +!1%!6$" (A +& 3#!1&% 6"1+. +#!& &3%.

. 2 $$!& +$% $&#1%!3:%$&# =(>(

7. #!926 &E%%!&

8$F

8$&3 +.

3

 92 3!!1+ - . 9!3 %:!" 6 97@$" !"4 65 7%$% +$& @!". 2 $$!& +7$&+ %2 #!"@.$#. !(
3  3(?(

7 1&3 + , #$!&% >
>7 >7 ?7 
 !"  7 @ % + -$% + 3  !6$#  , $!&G!9 &!6$# , $!&7 &#.<16 - $&%. 9(. + 12!&7.  #!926 &3.$%"

9$6:

#< 3. 2 $$!& +E%"

9$6: + %16!" @.$#.7 .  2 $$!& +E% "

9$6: + -$% + 3   !(
 3  3 ?()(

 1&3 + , #$!&% 7 =7 >
>7 
7 ?   !6$#  ,

&3$+ - $&% .  #!926 &E% "

9$6:( A +& 3 #!1&% 6 #!& &3% .

6.!1-. .  #!926 &E% %$3 

#< 3 .  2 $$!& +E% "

9$6: !& ((

 :  . : + -$% + 3  "

6%    3 ?((

1&3 +, #$!&%7=7>
>7>
7
7? 7, #$!&>)  33 36  +!&7 !6$# , &3$+ - $&%. 2 $$!& +

&3.$%"

9$6:9 9* +%!".

8$&-# 1% 3$&51+$ %(A +& 3#!1&% 6 6%! #!& &3%.

66. + 9 $&$&-#! ##1% 3.

8 * &-+ & 3* $6 &3 . 2 $$!& +@ 6%!$&$$ 66:!&* $6*1!& 33$$!&!", #$!&>) * $6-+ & 3!.$9@ %# &# 66 3 &32+ : +"!+-+ &!"* $6@ %+ 5 # 3 *:. 6 +& 3+$ !1+!&.  66 - $!&!".

8$&-$&"6$# 3$&51+$ %!& .  #!926 &E% %!& @.$#. @ % 3 #6 + 3 ! *  3 &- +!1% ! 6$" ( +& 3#!1&% 6#!& &3%.

#.

&% &3%2+ % & 37#.

+- % + :  !* "+ 9 372 $$!& +$%$&#1%!3:%$&# 

C>D =(>(

7 &36$%!"@$& %% %.

8 * &-$8 &7 ##!+3$&-6:7+$ @!163 < 6!&-$9 !#!&#613 . + "!+ 7&!1% "1621+2!% @!163*  % +8 3*:< 2$&-. 2 $$!& +$&#1%!3:(A +& 3#!1&% 6.

%"1+. + + 6$ 312!&. 3 #$%$!&!" !!+3$&   &#.!".$% !1+$&

 ?> !"
>  $6 3  



  7 3 #$3 3 !& (>(

(. + 6 8 & H+ #!". % 9 $%+ 2+!31# 3 %1&3 +' I+!9. + #!+37"$&3.

"$+%6:$$% # % !"8 +%$!& &3 #+!%%8 +%$!&($% 6%!%  3.

2 +%!&%7"+!9. 2 $$!& +J% %$3 7 6%!+ # $8 3$&51+$ %(.!1-.7. 2 $$!& +$%%  3! *  .  9 $& ##1% 3 *1 .  @ % &! +9 3 @$. &: 3 36: @ 2!&( @ %%$926: +9 3@$.J3 &3 J &3$&"6$# 3J3 &3 J *6!@ !& .  .

3 !" , & 419 +7 @.$#. $&51+: .

% * & 3 #6 + 3 %3 &- +!1%!6$" (. 2 $$!& +.

6%!+ # $8 3 $&51+:($%%$66!* 3  +9$& 3*:. +$ !1+ %!@.!$% .  --+ %%!+ 2 +:( .  2 $$!& + $% $& #1%!3: %$&#  (=(
>(. +$ 6!". # % @$66 < 6!&-$9 (!1% "16 21+2!% @$66* % +8 3*:< 2$&-. 2 $$!& +$&#1%!3: $66. 3$%2!% 6!". # % (K ( A +& 3  7  +:

& 7 !& $&%+1#$!&% "+!9 , 0$&!37 #!& &3% .

 .  2 $$!& + $% &! &$6 3 ! * $6 * # 1%  .  $&51+:

+$*1 3!.$9!&. .

3!"%!&!". #!926 &@ %3 #6 + 3!*  &- +!1%!6$" ( (  + #!&+ 7 6 +& 3 #!1&% 6 "!+ .  2 $$!& + #!& &3% . .  #!926 &E% %!& .

% "166: + #!8 + 3 &3 * & 3$%#.

+- 3 "+!9 .!%2$ 6(. % 9 $%&!3$%21 3*:. 6 +& 3 7 +:

& (

CD ?( .

8 #!&%$3 + 3. %1*9$%%$!&%!"6 +& 3#!1&% 6"!+.  +$ %( )( 39$ 36:7   !(
 3  3 (?(

7 1&3 + , #$!&% >
>7>7?7
!" 7.

%* &-!+ -$% + 3*: 6 9@$" !" 65 7*+!. +!". 2 $$!& +7 - $&%. #!926 &E%%!&

8$

6$

8$&3 +7!& ##!1&!".$%.

8$&-9 3  &  92!!1+ - . + 9!3 %:7 . + " +7 !& ##!1& !" #!926 &E% "

9$6:

#<$&- .  2 $$!& +E%"

9$6:7 
3  3?()(

1&3 +, #$!&%7=7 >
>7
7? 7@ %+ -$% + 3 !6$# , &3$+($%$& .  "!+ 9 &$!& 3 * #<-+!1&3 .

   3 ?((

 @ + -$% + 3 *: .  #!926 & !& ##!1& !"

#< *: .  2 $$!& +E% "

9$6:( ! 3!1*7 .  $&51+: !& .  .

3 !" .  #!926 &E% %!&

+$*1 3!. 2 $$!& +@ %3 #6 + 3!* 3 &- +!1%!6$" *1.  #!926 &E%%!&.

%"166:+ #!8 + 3 &3* &3$%#.

+- 3"+!9.!%2$ 67 . +  +  &19* +!"# % %
. 2 +$ %76$%!"@$& %% %.

8  * & -$8 &7 #.

+- % +  :  ! *  "+ 9 37 . + "!+ 7 +$ 6 @!163 <  #!&%$3 + *6 2 +$!3!"$9 !#!&#613 ( ( & 8$ @ !" @!  E% .

8$&- * & + -$% + 3 - $&% .  #!926 &3#!926 &E%%!& #(2+$!+$&$9 !. + -$%+ $!&!" . $&% &  &3$ * $&-  3 *

*6 $%%1  % ! @. . + $ @ % .  2 $$!& +E% "

9$6: @.$#. .

3

#< 3 .  #!926 &E% "

9$6: !+ .  #!926 &E% "

9$6: .

3

#< 3 &3 .  $&51+$ % +$*1 3 ! .  2 $$!& +  @ % + %16 !" "+  "$-. !+ $& % 6" 3 " &#  +  :  ! *  3  +9$& 37. + "!+ 7 9!". #!&%$3 + 38$ @.

&!1% "1621+2!% 

CD @!163* % +8 3*:< 2$&-. 2 $$!& +* .$&3* +%( =( ##!+3$&-6:7 2+ % & 2 $$!& $% 66!@ 3(  $$!& + %*$+ ,$&-.$%!+3 + 3!* + 6 % 3!&+ -16 +* $631+$&-. 2 &3 &#:!".  +$ 6!&.$%"1+&$%.$&-* $6*!&3 &3%1+ :*!&3!. % $%"

#$!&!".  +& 3 +$ !1+L .$ " 13$#$ 6  -$%+  L1:  -$%+   #!&# +& 37 2+!8$3 3 .  $% &! + B1$+ 3 $& &: !. + # % (  .  2 $$!& + %.

66 6%! #!926:@$.. #!&3$$!&%#!& $& 3$&, #$!&>)> +(( ($%"1+. + 3 #6 +.

$&# % . 2 $$!& +$%$&8!68 3$& &:!. +# % 31+$&-.  2 +$!3@.$6 . $%!&* $6$&. $&% &# % 7. 2+!% #1$!&@!163*  6$* +: ! 9!8  & 226$# $!& "!+ # &# 66 $!& !" * $6 -+ & 3 ! .  2 $$!& +$&. $&% &# % (!@ 8 +7&!.$&-%  3. + $& *!8 %.

66*  #!&%+1 3 & H2+ %%$!&!"!2$&$!&!&. 9 +$%!". # % (

















 























!"

#$$%#$#&




  G. . +%2 <$&-L+ %!& 3 ' %L!( G. . ++ 2!+ *6  ' %L!(