High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12200/2022dismissed

Kirpal Singh (Dead) Though Lr v. State Of Punjab And Others

2023-11-30Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari15 pages

# $ !""

%! &'

%( ( (

) &'

%( )'

# "$%& '

()"*+( ,-! ''("#-) ) .($ ' /-."#-)"*+( , !" 0 ( (

) * 2 - #-- (3!)(!(% 4(",- ( 54 , 6 70) ( ) $+(4 !(

" $% - 55+ ++")-5(6+ #.

"+ "+8,- .($55(#44("

# 5( +)29:2 -(,,

-+(55"( -;+,29:2<)$ " ,-= ( -#,-" 6 78!(

"$%-5("44

)3-$%-5( (,,4"6 70 >

-4)(4("(4

(5 ( /"$4(" ! +7 !" ?,("#-(".

"+(") ")+ 22,-;+,29:2<)( (= ,5 *5*"-

? - #--($*4!

#"6 )-!

3""$*+",4-!5(" -!5("

(+4! "-3(-(( >@A?0-( ( 22AA20A> B7 2?)>?A>A >79)>0A?

27:(50/((5@4(5()(")( (" *55(#-(4!

(4(+-(%("- 3(5 0 !

(5,-4!

#"" *(5 )-(- ++ (" +

)-(-* %)( 4(" !+,- " " 5("

) 4+5( " ( C

C -(,, - +(55"( C

-4+5(

!((

$+(4(

#"-!5("

)3( 4(")-,(5D"

+ 5"( +-4)( $+(4!!("$%-+ 5"(,,+ ++") ( ! - !* , C- ( .($ 5"#

5"(("*, (#4(+)290@ -(, , -+(55"( -C 5"(+)290@C E -,) 4 , 5 2:

, - ( .($

5"# 5"(("*, (#4( 5 )2909

-(,,( -C 5"( 5 )2909C)-($* * " #()-

4!("-!5("

)(-4(/

-4 +4 " - +5 (" 4((#4 , - (4 (+-(%( ++") -

, # 5(# - +44 !

! , 3-+--!5("

$+(4 *")$ -3 -!-, + * -!! +,- . / 0 1, $ 1.1#1. 2-.13 0 1, +

.. 0 1, & -.

21. $1*456&2 1,& -.

21. #-*454& : - #--* ,-C 5"(+290@C( 355(

,-C 5"( 5 )2909C)!(+ 5(5%-!* = #

- 5"(( - (-(!!5%(!7((+ )- -5"# ,-!! )-

,+(#C

C 5("

)$+(4+-(55#")$ - ("!* $+(4"+5("( * -+ )- #-(.

"#44("$%- <$5!6 +( 5"( &2 7.1(. /,2 8(1210# 729 1, &!" 4:;<(=:" 8 -!4 , !-5"#-+ (5%,- ("

!* )

" ,4 - ,(+

4) -( 5("

3- - ("

* " #() $+4 +(") ( ( 4(

, (#(( ,4 )("-

$+4!+"$%+5?27,- ,"()( -5("

3--($*" #()( 5D",- $, , - *55(# +44 % ( ( 3-5) -$% - "* 4,3 -!-, = ((% (-5"++" 8

.$1. 2 >2,(. /,&$2?2>1,--$1 $ 1.1#1

+$1.

-3# 1, 1,# 729 2?2 $,2321<??

# +'2

.$1. 2 1$ 3=$1*4@:<, . 201

, 1$2-- 2&1,4@:$1&=*2 1,--$1 $ 1.1#1

# 1,# 729#9-.$ ?.2 '2 <

.$1. 2 1 $ 3=$1*4@"<, . 201 0 , 1$2-- 2&1,4@"$1&=* 1 7329-7# . .$1. *1?2> 2-.

0 .$1. *9#1.

$2 2 .+#1 A#1. 0 1.1- 9$? 2. * 90 1, 2#1, .13$ 1?+-21 # 1,& -.

21. $1*456&*1,# 1,2.

A#1. . 119 $.

931,2.

2#1, .13*9#11, 2.

A#1. .192/.121 90 1,.

.-# 1$ $ @ !+

5% -$%) - * " +!

!( 4!("-" )-

4 ,-*"+"")$% - )+( 5"( &2 >2,(. /,2 1, 8. 1 -+? 1??.. *# 7292 1, C3-+- "6 0 $+(4 (

#") "+"" B@22>B2?) 5*(

!((#(!-3-,)-

4(/ (6! 5(- )-(,- ! ,4(/#*+,+(+- )= (-5("

+(")(

+-) "

# + 5"() * - 55+ + ") !+*5% "C-298:+C)(")C-298?+C

-)-(- 4"%, /#*+,-+(+- ,4-5("3-- " #(

!() * "-55+ "-!* , +8,-C+,29:2C$ * "-55+ + ") !+*5% " C- 298: +C) (") C- 298? +C - ("

6! 5( ,5(3(6(+"-(,

"# #!##

!#' #

%&$ #()#'

' $

% * ! !

$ # ()) # + ,! !

$ #()) #),$

%& $ #()#'

)

- #!

. # # !

/ '# !## - -# " !## # * 0## #1''!

--*- #2 ! "& &"

% # ! $

% $ #3#'

# !

-- # # !

%& $ #4-

/ #'

# - #-

# " !

! $

%#'*/ "## #

%& $ #+#'

- #/ '#

##' #!!- #

!&#'/

# / /

* "

$ #6#'

!#'

#- -!

-# ##'$

%" # #

%& $ # 62" !#'

#' -- -#

0##

& $ # 7 - #/ '# / #' , ! / -# #$

%& $ #- #/ '# ##'!# & $ #

!##'!#'

% -#

0# #

# .!

* !"

" #

%& $ #

# #

!#'

0# # # ! -

- #*

/ !## #* --*- #2 ! & &

%& !"# $%

& '# ()$* %*%+, #,, (-$ + , ! "# #,.

-# $/ # ,#,,

.,. ' , ()$ * %*%%& 9 (-5*(!((#(!-( +("-.

"#4

!() !(( 3-, ("

6(+" -(,) " +(% ( 6! 5( , 5(3 * 7F7* ) +( - 4!(# , - ("

* " #(

!(-" ++")$+4

+ " $% - !! ++") -$% - . "+ "+") - (" ( " + ) * (- - ( -% + " "-C 5"(+290@C)$ * "-+*5 ++" 8 --#

'# # !#!#'

#- #/##'

5. 9 5!

* )0## 5 -# :

! ;/!

# !#/

* !

" 6 )

6 !

#'5. !#!##'

% # $

%"- #!

'# /!

# # '# ! ##' !#

#' 5. !

6 !

- #/ '# /!

# '

# !

!## #&$ #(3#'

6 !

- #/ '# /!

# '

/ '#

!##- -# #'/

$ # 7(32 #'

9 5!

* !

&$ #3#'

6 !

- #/

5. 5! 5

: );/!

# !#/

" 63" --* #!

#'5." !

6 !

*" #

0# #

! -#

$ #

! -#

% #

"' #- #/ '# '# !!

# '*

'# "-

# # -

* --* - # ! #

/ '# !## - -# !## #"

#-- #!

##'

" '#- #/#

6 !

0## #!

- #/ '# # -

# # !

- "

#'*'# '# !!

# * / #-- #!

0/0#

$ #44#'

0## # !

- # 0/ 0#

9#/

*#''!

0## #!

# -# #'&$ #44" # /

"!#

#- # 0/0#

# ! ##'

% - #

* $ # 44

' #

. !

##'$

9#/

# #*#''!

0## # !

# ! &

0## #!

# # !#'

9#/

#''!

# ! ##' &

. !

##'0/0#

*$ #44#'

0## #!

#*'# / #-

# -

- !-0#

#'!/. !

# / . !

"- #/ *$ ##'

0# #'0/5 #!

"& &"0/0#

& / '% , ()$* %*%+ #0& &., # 1#.2,# ##,# / -# , #, # $ - , , $0 3 /, ##,.'0+ ($1. 5<=01,& -.

21. $1*456&92 +2 1.1. 0 1,-2 B.1,1,29 # $ .+1. 11,+ + .1 $ $ 2B '*) + + 0> ( +!(" - ; 5"( +) 290@< !* 3-, $+4 6(+"

-(,) $( 7!( , - 5("

(- 3- - ($* " +!* 7F7* -!! ++")-

"+ * ", /#*+,(+(+-) !)-" ) -

+ * -55+++") ( ) !+*5% + " "C-298:+C("C-298?+C

4 <4(& 5 # # # -

/ '#

!##- -# &2=#

# *#

'# "

# *. "

# !##'* !#

"# *

# *"# *#''!

/ '# !## - -#

- !'

!## # !

# # " # -

# #

- #-

# #'

/ "

'# !##- -# &> 22 '*- #--* ,- ("!* )$+(4 +-(55#"$,- )$ ("+ ""$%- ) +( 5"( C%2,212?(. /,2 1, 8(1210# 7292

1, &3-+-G 2EEB9,>BB8$+(4(

#")-

("!* $+4"+5("$(* - 2> '*)-6! 5(,5(3 "+( 5"( C%.1,#(. /,2 1, 8(1210# 729& 3-+- @5"6$+(4(

#")("-6! 5(,5(3) ( )4("+( 5"( C,B2 .)#?2 2 1, 8.

# 2- -+? 12 $,2321# 729&)3-+-5@64" $+(4 (

#") -

( +(""5% ! ,+(%) -( * 7F7*

" (-+(%#-($** " #()-$% - .

"+ / *+ -,4 , - +(+-

++") * " - 55+ ++") !+*5% + " "C-298:+C("C-298?+C 2? = 5%) - 5(" + 5 (!!(# , - !(# )-(- ,(!,*+)$, -55+++" "-C+,29:2C)3( (55+ "

"(* ,-5*(!

! -,)-+"

-(-

" ,*+!(

"(#( -!$= ( -"(" ( " ? ? 111,&$104:&29 #/,11, #/,1,# 729$1

40*B, 93-2 B.1,1,29 # ./ 21.

. $-# . 1,,2?-21 ,2 .?+2$11, 0 20 - .($# 5(*

4$5%- #-- .($+ 29,>B>>(--( 4("((4"4-;+,29:2< 3-$%+ >5(

#)(,

$7+5(

E)-,553#

$7+5(

:-( $ " )

/ '#

!##- -# #'/

$ # 7 #'

; 5. # )0## # 5

/ # #' ?

# !

47); 5.!

+@#' 47"

#' /

9 5!

$ #(32#'

51 06,# , #$ / #, . ()$ *% 7 . 3,"8 &9,+()$*%+ (* %*%+&$ ,/ $. # :+ 2E -,

)$ $*

5%3--($*" #(

4!("-" )-

4(/ -4,(553--(4$, -",,

5(5%-$%-.

/-*+,-+(+- !-5("

)3--* " #(

!()3" * )-55++ " " -C+,29:2C)-(-55+

"C-298:+C("A C-298?+C 2: +- ("(4"4 ,+(-43--

-(#- (3!$ " 3-- (3 ! ( + ( , - #(5 & -,) 3- -

(4"4 3,+)(

+-)#*-+ %,- $,- )-$%- ("(4"4" -(*+ = (5 4!) ( )!4(,(+)#(-++ 5%4("" , *+

B *.

+$1.

01,29 *0 1,0# 1, 2 19 2./ , . 201 .2 .1,. 12 1$2*1,2.

0 .$1. $2 19. 1 0 B.1, 28 -( ,4(/#-($*++5

4 ),4 -,(+ 4)-(- #-4 ,-!* ++ #+8 2 , - C+ , 29:2C) !* 3-, ( 6(+" -(,) 3-$%5*(#3( $ 3") !-!( (= ,5)("4(%$)

+-(= ,5$#( " !+, -" )-$%-55+- $.+*+4!5( 4(%-(*"+"-5#(++")-

$4- +5(4 " +22,-;+,29:2< 2@ *"5%) +-($*4("(,- ("!* 4( (*(5" -,) (*(54 , - (" ( % !* )+ 3(*("+ = - !!5)(- 3/#(#( -! !)-

(- $5(" (#)-

/-$ 34= (-4-+-$,,--(, 6(+" ( %!* < 0/ #' -$

, )

!# # "#--! # #

*-!

* "# *#''!

# - ! #

>"'

' !!# !

- #!

* -

* -# # #'

# #

#/ - #-

/ #

# /

'# ##

!# # * ,

/ !#

# #

, ! ##'

'# -# ##'

!* !

776& <5 #/

' '

- #'

--! # '#

* - -# ##'

#/ - #-

" # #'

" #

# - #-

* **-

#- '! ! # --#

#'"

0# #

# #

# # !

$ #

--! #

- & #/ '

#" #

##'

" #

"' # !

$ #

0# # -

# ##'

" #

/#/ - #!

* -# ##'

# #

#/ - #-

&> 29 ' 4!(*5% 3- ! (*(54 , - ("

!* )$,-( - $53$%-!)-+ 5"-(* (5 "(+5(4,5,-

5("

$ !+*,-($* * " #($+4#4!("-

5("

) !+(55% 3--, + ,(%,-6+! (*# +5(

-",,-

&("5%3-- ("4"% 4(" (*(5"3-$ $*

5%(%*"+

!!*, -!(-$+4#3555") (*(5"+5(4), $ 34,5* 7(7* -" )-

-!4 , - " *#-"34,-$,,-5*( (*#

+5(

+ = +)$ $*

5%3--!(++! -

* 4,#-)5(" * 7(7* -" - *55(# !! ++" -,) - (4 (+-(%( ++") 3( 355 ($5" (- , ,+#) $ " ) , # 5(#-+44#- ,-*55(#!! ++") -" )3554(((!,*+)("(5

/(*(5"",*+$#4("(#( -! !) -

$%- ( %( - $53 >B ("") +("(5"" +

4("- ++ 5%4("4!

#"*"+ )-

, ""-!4 ) -(- (+4!55(+/,+4!($5%7 -5"/-( ( 4$ (-3--35%(

#"/-( ( 4$ -" "

5("

'*)3--( (5 $" +

"-4!

6 )-(- (+4!5,(5 -!(,-!) .

,%- *(5"5%3#("!

#-" )-

- #- ($5 * ++ # - * +"

++" = 5%)-++ 5%4("*"+ ,*+ (-+($= ( -"(" ( " >2 - #--55+ + " "C-298:+C (")C-298?+C3* "3-

44(%.

"+)

*+,+(+- ,45("

(-3--* " #(

!()$ +- (".

"+ $

44(5%6+ ")("

$ 3- *(,#--(##*"( -$,( = ,5-,)3-- ("= ,5 *" 2 2>,(. /,&$2<(#+ 2= $(#("$%-(##*",4

+- (-$,-*5 ++"+ = +) ((5#+(5(!!5+(,- ("!+!5- ("

44(% !+"# )-55+ "-+

!()(%

!+"# $,-4),-3 4((($5*3,- (4"4)(-4(%!+" *5$%-(##*",4 - (" )-

4(((+*5

$,-*5 ++" >> -(( 4(%)-55+++")!- +4#,+,-(4"4

!(( 4("-;+, 29:2<3-$%5("

" #("(

" 3 +5 "" - ", , -

" "" .% ( ($5 .

"+)-

4(/" ,*+-5*(*+ ! 3*)$-- ( C-298:+C("C-298?

+C) 5/-!*

!(( ++ +8 2,-;+, 29:2<)- + !"#!* )3-$%- !

+(+-++")-

+( (/(($5+5(4,5- " )(-3--* " #(

!( >? +2 >2,(. /,C$2<#+ 2=) !+,- ($** " #( )- #-3( "+5("-(((##*"

,4- ("* %)+(4(/(+ - #-- ( #)(

$,-+*5 ++"'*)- #-- ("5$% 3( (

#" !+,-$#(

"+- ( -%+ " "-; 5"(+)290@<-C+, 29:2C)4(/

+-("+5(()$ *,- ("#-+ ) $ 3" "C-298:+C(")C-298?+C) !- 5#((##*"),4- ("%)%4(/#(((5#+(5 (!!5+(-)*3- !+- (

!()(-- ( - "- ("+

)4(%-(*(5(5 "$("- (##*"),4- ("%)( (" 3- !+5 * #) -4A-(- - #- - ( # (+*5 "

( #(! "+22,-C+,29:2C B! #'

#/ !

" ' #

/ #'

)- "

# # -#

/ '

*& >0 -,)- #--" ,*+!(

"$%- 55+

"-C-298:+C("AC-298?+C)4(%$ "")-

*3- (%(".

"+($#4(") !)- = ,5)%,-(##*"++")-("4*"(5

$,-*5 ++")$ !-+!(,- (4"4 - C+ , 29:2C) 3-$% 5(" 3- - * " #(

!($+4"+5("(

5("

5(5% - , - ("

4(% $ *(5") ( ,,+* (".

"+(

$%-55+ "-+

!()(-+($ 4("-= ,5 >E '*)-"+5((

#("-+*5

$% -*5 ++")-

3 5"!4(,(+#*-*+ " !(

"$%-55+ )( )+ " "-+

!( >: "4(5%)*3,-(4"4

!()( 4(" -C+,29:2C3-$%5("

3-* " #(( C

(- $+4 +5 "" - ", ,

& = 5%)-$%.

"+ !+,5("

) 3-- ("* " #()( 5(#*+

)$#4(" !+-, )-

(#( -+(+- ++")(-3 +($6+ "$%-55+ "-C-298:+CC- 298?+C)$ $6+ "$%-55+

"-C+, 29:2C

. 2-

01,.# 1 >8 (,4(-)- ,"

4-3!) (")3--($*$ *( )- (4 " 4

"-4!

" A(6 (4(("("(,,4" >@ "( + >9 +-4(+( 5,-( $"+"")-

)(55- !"#(!!5+(

),(%)(5 ("

" ! ", <( (

)= <)'

= ""

/(* #- ,1, +2>. /D 2

,1, + 129- D