High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17455/2026dismissed

Kuldeep v. State Of Haryana

2026-05-04Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel9 pages

7777 !"#$%

>7'.'.(,* * 9*" +, &'' () *+ >7%(,$,'

(-.'

>7'.'.(,* * 9*" +, &'' () *+ >7%(,$,'

' () .

' () %#( ' () %#( ' () %#( ' () %#( / / / / *,'/ *,'/ *,'/ *,'/ ..(,/ .(,/ ..(,/ .(,/ + + + + 3

($.,0/ ($.,0/ ($.,0/ ($.,0/ + + + + 3

1 7 & & :

1 7 & & 1 1 1 1 *7 1;-<.,$* &.,0- ,,3

*7 .'- -"-, $9( ' )

$9( '3 )(* '- %'.'.(,*7 *7 "*6' &.,0-3

*+ ,7 *7 7&7 '+3 $9( ' )(* '- - (6%#.,,'7 ===== ===== ===== ===== 1 1 1 13 1 1 1 1 & & & &

+ '-. (66(, (*$*3 '- )( *.$ '<( %'.'.(, ).#$ ",$* * & '.(, 2 ( () &&3

*'<-.# & '.( (, 42 *7 77 ;.,0 0*,' () ) ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# '( '- %'.'.(,*3 ,6#+ +3 !"#$% ,$ (-.'3 ., 5*.,0 (7422 $'$ 7

3 *0 0.'*$ ",$* & '.(,

3 ? 4 ,$ 444 () '- &3

& '.(, 2 () '- & $#'$ ,$ & '.(, 2

() '- & $$$ #'* (,3 ' (#.

&''.(, -(,$.3 .'*.

' "*"0*63 * 5.,0 $.%($ () '(0'-*3 '-+ 6,' )*(6

(66(, 7

- 0*96, () '- ., @"'.(, . '-' '- (6%#.,,'3 ,6#+3 9.,$* ##0$ '-' (, 47

3 ' 5("' ?/4 %7673 &6.'3

6.'3 &'%#3 %;3 9'*3 # -,$3 66.3 -*65.*3 -.63 .A,3

.##"3 6*A3 &'+3 .,'"3 (55+3 &(,"3 &,A+3 B.

;+3 !##"3 (-.'

%'.'.(,* -*.,3 (-.'3 -"#3 .,;"3 !,<* &.,0-3 &-#3 '3 ,$ !"#$% %'.'.(,* -*., )(* .5#+ ,'*$ -. -("7 -+ <* *6$ <.'- .*(, *($3 <(*$3 C3 ,$ ('-* $$#+ <%(,3 ,$ (6 () '-6 <* #( **+.,0 %.'(#7 -

"$ %*(, (## '.9#+ "#'$ '-

(6%#.,,' ,$ ('-* ., 5*"'# 6,,* ,$ '-*)'* )#$ )*(6 '- %('7 - .,A"*$ %*(, <* "5@",'#+ ';, 5+ '- ,.0-5("* '( '- -(%.'# ' "*"0*6 )(* 6$.

# '*'6,'7 1*,$ (",# )(* '- %'.'.(,* - *0"$ '-' '- %'.'.(,* -9 5, )##+ .6%#.

'$ .,'( '- ., @"'.(,7 1*,$

(",# - *0"$ '-' '-* . $#+ () 6(* '-, -("* ., *0.'*'.(, () ., @"'.(,7 1*,$ (",# - )"*'-* *0"$ '-' '- '(*+ %"')(*'- 5+ '- (6%#.,,' . '('##+ ( '$ (, ,$ $( ,('

(,'., 9, , .(' () '*"'-D ., ) '3 .' < '- (6%#.,,' E .$ <-( < 00*(*3 <-( 09 5'.,0 '( '- %'.'.(,* ,$ ('-*7 1*,$ (",# - "56.''$ '-' .' . () 9*.(, ,$ *(9*.(, '- %'.'.(,* E .$ - #( 0(' #($0$ , (742? $'$ 7

0.,' '- (6%#.,,' E

.$7 1*,$ (",# - *0"$ '-' ,( % .).

*(# (* (9*' ' - 5, ''*.5"'$ '( '- %'.'.(,* ,$ '-* . ,('-.,0 (, * (*$ '( -(<

(6%#.

.'+ () '- %'.'.(,* ., '- ()), ., @"'.(,7 1*,$ (",# - *'$ '-' %* 1 *%(*' $'$ 7

() '- (

"$3 ,6#+3 -"#3 .' . #*#+ * (*$$ '-' - - * .9$ 6"#'.%# )* '"*3 5"' (, '- ('-* -,$3 1 *%(*' $'$ 47

-(< '-' (, () '- %*.9' *%(,$,' - "))*$ .6%# .,A"*.7 477 1*,$ (",# - "56.''$ '-'

(

"$ () '- %'.'.(,* 3 ,6#+3 !,<* &.,0- F !9* &.,0- - 5, 0*,'$

.(, () *0"#* 5.# 5+ '-. ("*'3 9.$ (*$* $'$ 7 7

8 %$ ., ?

7 1*,$ (",# *' '-' '- %(#.

-9 ,('

(,$"

'$ ).* ,$ .6%*'.# .,9'.0'.(, ,$ '- .,@".*+ (,$"

'$ ( )* . ,(' (,#+ ., (6%#'3 5"' #( '.,'$ <.'- 5.7 1*,$ (",# - *'$ '-'

,('-.,0 . '( 5 * (9*$ )*(6 '- %'.'.(,* 7 (*(9*3 '- "'($.# .,'**(0'.(, -("#$ ,(' 5 "$ %",.'.9 6"* ,$ . A"'.).$ (,#+ <-, 5(#"'#+ , *+ )(* '- * (9*+ () 6'*.# 9.$, 7 "*'-*6(*3 '- %'.'.(,* * *$+ '( A(., '- .,9'.0'.(, ,$3 -, 3 ,( ")"# %"*%( <("#$ 5 *9$ 5+ ,$.,0 '-6 5-.,$ '- 5*7 , '- )(*.$ "56..(,3 '- 0*,' () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# . ,'*'$ )(*7 7 * (,'*3 #*,$ &'' (",#3 <-.# *)**.,0 '( '- ''" *%(*' 5+ <+ () , )).$9.' $'$ 27 7

83 <-.

- . #*$+ (, * (*$

83 - (%%($ '- 0*,' () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# '( '- %'.'.(,* E !"#$% !"#$% !"#$% !"#$% 5+ *0".,0 '-' '- ()), (66.''$ 5+ '- %'.'.(,*

. *.(" ., ,'"*7 #9,' () '- .$ ''" *%(*'3 ., *% ' () '- %'.'.(,* E !"#$% !"#$% !"#$% !"#$%3 *$ '-"/

1 !1 1 !1 1 !1 1 !1 - *(# ''*.5"'$ '( '- %'.'.(,* !"#$% ., '- (66..(, () '- %*,' ()), . 9.$,' )*(6 '- 6'*.# (, * (*$3 <-.

- .,$.

' '-'

- < , '.9 665* () '- ",#<)"# 65#+ '-' )(* .5#+ ,'*$ '- (6%#.,,': -(" #(,0 <.'- 9*# (

"$ %*(,3 ## *6$ <.'- $$#+ <%(, "

- *($3 <(*$3 C ,$ ).**67 , )"*'-*, () '- (66(, (5A ' () '- 65#+3 '- %'.'.(,* '.9#+ %*'.

.%'$ ., "#'.,0 '- 9.

'.63 '-*5+ (,'*.5"'.,0 '( '- 0*.9(" .,A"*. "'.,$ 5+ '-63 "5','.'$ 5+ '- 6$. # 9.$, 7 , '- 9.$( () '- @"**#3 '- %'.'.(,* < #*#+ 9..5# ,'*.,0 ., '- -(" () (6%#.,,' ,$ 5#(<.,0 '- #'-. (, '- .,A"*$ %*(,7 . %*, 3 (,$"

' ,$ '.9 %*'.

.%'.(, #*#+ '5#.- -. .,9(#96,' ., ()), %*'.,.,0 '( *.('.,03 -(" '*% ,$ ".,0 0*.9(" -"*'7H 77 &( )* '- %'.'.(,* (-.'

(-.'

(-.' . *,$3 #*,$ &''

(",# - ).#$ ''" *%(*' 5+ <+ () , )).$9.' $'$ 7

83 ., '- ("*' '($+3 <-.

- . ';, (, * (*$7 ..,0 "56..(, ., ',$6 <.'- '- .$ ''" *%(*'3 #*,$ &'' (",# - (%%($ '- 0*,' () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# '( '- %'.'.(,* E (-.'

(-.'

(-.' 5+ *0".,0 '-' '- ()), (66.''$ 5+ '- %'.'.(,* . *.(" ., ,'"*7 #9,' () '- .$ ''" *%(*'3 ., *% ' () '- %'.'.(,* E (-.'3 *$ '-"/

1 1 1 1 - *(# ''*.5"'$ '( '- %'.'.(,* (-.' ., '- (66..(, () '- %*,'

()), . 9.$,' )*(6 '- 6'*.# (, * (*$3 <-.

- .,$.

' '-' - < , '.9 665* () '- ",#<)"# 65#+ '-' )(* .5#+ ,'*$ '-

(6%#.,,': -(" #(,0 <.'- 9*# (

"$ %*(,3 ## *6$ <.'- $$#+ <%(, "

- *($3 <(*$3 C ,$ ).**67 , )"*'-*, () '- (66(, (5A ' () '- 65#+3 '- %'.'.(,* '.9#+ %*'.

.%'$ ., "#'.,0 '- 9.

' ,$ '.9 %*'.

.%'.(, #*#+ '5#.- -. .,9(#96,' ., ()), %*'.,.,0 '( *.('.,03 -(" '*% ,$ ".,0 0*.9(" -"*'7H

7 .9, '- 9*.'+ () '- ()), 3 '-* C.' "5','.# #.;#.-(($ '-' '- %'.'.(,* 6+ 5 (,$ (* '6%* <.'- '- 9.$, 3 .) ,#*0$ (, 5.#7 1*,$ &'' (",# - .'*'$ '-' '- "'($.# .,'**(0'.(, () '- %'.'.(,* . .6%*'.9 )(* '- %"*%( () )) '.9 ,$ ).* .,9'.0'.(, ,$ '( ",*'- '- () '- %*( "'.(,7 , '- "56..(,3 $.6.# () '- %*,' %'.'.(, . ,'*'$ )(*7 747 1*,$ (",# )(* '- (6%#.,,' - ).#$ *%#+ $'$

83 ., '- ("*' '($+3 <-.

- . ';, (, * (*$7 ..,0 "56..(, ., ',$6 <.'- '- .$ *%#+3 #*,$ (",# - .'*'$ '-'

'-* * *.(" ,$ 0*9 ##0'.(, 0.,' '- %'.'.(,* .,9(#9.,0 )(*6'.(, () , ",#<)"# 65#+3 )(* .5# -(" '*% ,$ 5*"'#3 %*6$.''$ "#' <.'- $$#+ <%(,3 <-. - #*#+ '5#.- '*.,0,'

%,# '.(, 0.,' '- %'.'.(,* 7 #9,' () '- .$ *%#+ *$ '-"/ G7 -' )(* '- ;.,$ %*"# () '-. (,:5# ("*' '- '5# () * '"* ,(' ., #"$.,0 ('-* 9* .,A"*. . *%*($"

$ ",$*/ &7 &7 &7 &7 (7 (7 (7 (7 6 () 6 () 6 () 6 () #'.(, '( #'.(, '( #'.(, '( #'.(, '( (6%#.,,'

(6%#.,,'

+% () +% () +% () +% () * '"* * '"* * '"* * '"* 1( '.(, () 1( '.(, () 1( '.(, () 1( '.(, () $.

# $.

# 9.$, 9.$, 9.$, 9.$,

,,C"*

,,C"* ,A"*$ ,A"*$ ,A"*$ ,A"*$ * '"* * '"* * '"* * '"* A.,$*

*('-* () (6%#.,,'

&.6%# * '"* 1)' %*.'# 5(,

;"## & , () $ ,$

*.,

A.,$*

*('-* () (6%#.,,'

.%# $ * '"* .'# -)' () "#,

)(**6 I+ J $.

# C6.,'.(,

&,'* ('-* () (6%#.,,'

&.6%# * '"* 1)' ,# 5(, & , () 4 *., &(, () (6%#.,,'

* '"* <.'- C',.(, 1)' .#. 5(, <.'- )* '"* #., C',$.,0 '( ,'*.(* .,)*.(* %., %#9. & , () #9.

(, H 77 1*,$ (",# - )"*'-* *0"$ '-'3 ., 3 '- %'.'.(,* * 0*,'$ .(, () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.#3 '-* . ## #.;#.-(($ '-' '-+ 6+ 5 (,$ )*(6 '- %*( () A"'.

#( .,'*)*

<.'- '- %*( "'.(, <.',J 9.$, 7 , '- '*,0'- () '- "56..(,3 $.6.# () '- %*,' %'.'.(, . ,'*'$ )(*7 7 -9 -*$ '- #*,$ (",# )(* '- *.9# %*'. ,$ -9 0(, '-*("0- '- 9.#5# * (*$ () '- 7

%* '- %*( "'.(, ,$ "%(, *)"# %*"# () '- 6'*.# 9.#5# (, * (*$3 .' %*.6 ) . 6*0 '-' *.(" ,$ 0*9 ##0'.(, -9 5, #9##$ 0.,' '- %'.'.(,* 7 ' . )"*'-* *9#$ '-' '- %'.'.(,* 3 #(,0 <.'- ('-* (

"$3 ., )"*'-*, () '-.*

(66(, .,','.(, ,$ ., %*6$.''$ 6,,*3 )(* .5#+ '*%$ .,'( '- -(" () '- (6%#.,,' <-.# *6$ <.'- $$#+ <%(, ,$ .,)#. '$ 0*.9(" .,A"*. "%(, '- 9.

'.67 - %'.'.(,* * ''*.5"'$ , '.9 ,$ % .).

*(# ., '- (66..(, () '- ()), 7 - .,A"*. "'.,$ 5+ '- 9.

'.6 ',$ $"#+ (**(5(*'$ 5+ '- 6$.

# 9.$, 7 ' - 5, )"*'-* *9#$ '-' '- 9.$( )(('0 () '- ., .$,'

#*#+ $%.

' '- %*, () '- %'.'.(,* ' '- %('3 ,'*.,0 '- (6%#.,,': -(" ,$ "#'.,0 '- .,A"*$ %*(, <.'- #'-.7 - ,'"*3 C','3 ,$ 6"#'.%#.

.'+ () '- .,A"*. )"*'-* ",$* (* '- 9.(#,'

(,$"

' () '-

"$ %*(, ,$ *)# ' '- *.(", () '- ()), ##0$ 0.,'

'-67 877 ( " ,+ %#".5# " - 5, -(<,3 ' '-. '03 )*(6 <-.

- .'

, 5 $ .%-*$ '-' '- %'.'.(,* - 5, )##+ .6%#.

'$ .,'( '- %*,' 7 - ,'"* () ##0'.(, *' *(,5# %%*-,.(, '-'3 .) 0*,'$ ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.#3 '- %'.'.(,* 6+ 5 (,$ )*(6 '-

%*( () A"'.

#( .,)#", %*( "'.(, <.', (* '6%* <.'- 9.$, 7 - %# () #,$ (",# )(* '- %'.'.(,* '-' '- (

"$ () '- %'.'.(,* - 5,

(*$$ '- .(, () *0"#* 5.# 5+ '-. ("*'3 . () ,( -#% '( '-6 ., $6.''$#+3 '- .$ (

"$ < 0*,'$ '- .(, () *0"#* 5.# ,$ '- %'.'.(,* -*., -9 ("0-'

.(, () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.#7 ' . <(*'- '( ,(' -* '-' ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# . 0*,'$ 5)(* **'3 <-* ("*' 6.,#+ <-'-* **' . , *+ 5+ (,.$*.,0 '- *.(", () ##0'.(,3 '- *(# () '-

"$3 %(.5.#.'+ () 5 (,$.,03 -, () '6%*.,0 <.'- 9.$, 3 ,$ '- ,$ )(* "'($.# .,'**(0'.(,7 , (,'*'3 *0"#* 5.# .

(,.$*$ )'* **'3 <-* '- ("*' )( " (, <-'-* (,'.,"$ $','.(, . A"'.).$3 ';.,0 .,'(

(",' '- C.', () %*.6 ) . 3 9*.'+ () '- ()), 3 9.$, 3 #,0'- () "'($+3 $#+ ., '*.#3 ,$ #.;#.-(($ () 5 (,$.,0 (* .,)#", .,0 <.',7 7 "*'-*6(*3 '- .,9'.0'.(, . '.## ' *"

.# '03 ,$

"'($.# .,'**(0'.(, () '- %'.'.(,* . (,.$*$ , *+ '( ",*'- '- (6%#' ) ' ,$ '( *'., .,9(#96,' () ,+ ('-* %*(,

(,, '$ <.'- '- 7 - %'.'.(,* * +' '( 5 **'$ ,$ 0*,' () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.#3 ' '-. '03 6+ %*A"$.

'- (,0(.,0 .,9'.0'.(,7 - %%*-,.(, C%*$ 5+ '- %*( "'.(, '-' '- %'.'.(,*3 .) *#$ (, 5.#3 6+ 5 (,$ (* ''6%' '( .,)#", <.', #( %%* '( 5 ,('

<.'-("' 5.7 .9, '- *.(", () '- ()), 3 '- '0 () .,9'.0'.(, ,$ %(.5.#.'+ () '6%*.,0 <.'- 9.$, (* (5'*"

'.,0 A"'.

3 '-. ("*'

. () '- 9.< '-' '- %'.'.(,* $( ,(' $*9 '- .(, () 5.#3 '

'-. A", '"*7 ' . 5).''.,0 '( 6,'.(, -* '-' <-.# (,.$*.,0 %# )(* 0*,' () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.#3 '- ("*' - '( @".#.5*' 5'<, )0"*$.,0 .,$.9.$"# *.0-' ,$ %*(' '.,0 ( .'# .,'*'

7 - ("*' ("0-' '( * ;(, <.'- '- 60,.'"$ ,$ ,'"* () '- ()), D '- *(# ''*.5"'$ '( '-

"$D '- ,$ )(* ).* ,$ )* .,9'.0'.(, #( '- $%* ,$ <.$ .6% ' () "

- ##0$ .,.@".'. (, '- ( .'+7 %*().'5# *)*, ., '-. *0*$ . 5.,0 6$ '( '- $. ' %$ 5+ '- (,:5# &"%*6 ("*' '.'#$ &'' &'' &'' &'' 97 ,.# &-*63 ?? & 2 / ?? & *. ,.# &-*63 ?? & 2 / ?? & *. ,.# &-*63 ?? & 2 / ?? & *. ,.# &-*63 ?? & 2 / ?? & *. 4?

4?3 '- &"%*6 ("*' -#$ ",$*3 *#9,' <-*() *$ ",$*/ G87 K ).,$ )(* ., '- "56..(, () '-'

"'($.# .,'**(0'.(, . @"#.''.9#+ 6(* #.

.''.(,(*.,'$ '-, @"'.(,.,0 "% ' <-( . <##, $ <.'- )9("*5# (*$* ",$* & '.(, 42 () '- ($7 ,

#.; '-.3 )) '.9 .,'**(0'.(, () "% '$ %*(, . () '*6,$(" $9,'0 ., $..,'**.,0 6,+ ")"# .,)(*6'.(, ,$ #( 6'*.# <-. - <("#$ -9 5, #$7 &"

., "

- .,'**(0'.(, <("#$ #"$ .) '- "% '$ %*(, ;,(< '-' - . <## %*(' '$ ,$ .,"#'$ 5+ %***'

5.# (*$* $"*.,0 '- '.6 - . .,'**(0'$7 B*+ ()', .,'**(0'.(, ., " - (,$.'.(, <("#$ *$"

'( 6* *.'"#7 - *0"6,' '-' '- "'($.# .,'**(0'.(, . )*"0-' <.'- '- $,0* () '- %*(, 5.,0 "5A '$ '( '-.*$ $0* 6'-($ ,$ ,(' 5 (",',, $3 )(*3 "

- , *0"6,'

, 5 $9, $ 5+ ##

"$ ., ## *.6.,# 7 - ("*' - '( %*"6 '-'

*%(,.5# %(#.

()).

* <("#$ (,$"

' '-6#9 ., *%(,.5# 6,,* ,$ '-' '-( ,'*"'$ <.'- '- '; () $..,'**.,0 ()), <("#$ ,('

(,$"

' '-6#9 ()),$*7H

' '-. '03 '-* . ,( 6'*.# (, * (*$ '( -(#$ '-' %*.6 ) . . ,(' 6$ ("' 0.,' '- %'.'.(,*7 - 6'*.# <-. - -

(6 (, * (*$ ,$ %*#.6.,*+ .,9'.0'.(,3 %%* '( '5#.- *(,5# 5. )(* '-.*

"'.(,7 -"3 .' . ,(' %%*(%*.' '( 0*,' ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# '( '- %'.'.(,*3 .' <("#$ , *.#+ " .6%$.6,'

., )) '.9 .,9'.0'.(,7

(*$.,0#+3 '-. ("*' . () '- (,.$*$ (%.,.(, '-' '- %'.'.(,* $( ,(' $*9 '- .(, () ,'.

.%'(*+ 5.# ., '- ) '"# 6.#." () '- ., -,$7 (*(9*3 "'($.# .,'**(0'.(, () '- %'.'.(,* . , *+ )(* , )) '.9 .,9'.0'.(, L '( ",*9# '- '*"'-7 - %'.'.(, *3 '-"3 $9(.$ () 6*.' ,$ * -*5+ $.6.$ $.6.$ $.6.$ $.6.$7 ('-.,0 .$ -*.,5(9 -## 5 $6$ '( 5 , C%*.(, () (%.,.(, "%(, 6*.' () '- J.,9'.0'.(,7 7 ,$.,0 %%#.

'.(, 3 .) ,+3 -## #( ',$ $.%($ ())7

& 1 & 1 & 1 & 1

+ + + + 3

6-9.* K-'-* %;.,0J*(,$/ J( K-'-* *%(*'5#/ J(