← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3133/2001disposed of

Shivala Talab Rania v. Mc Rania

2017-07-28Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat17 pages

     

 !

"#$%"%&' ( )

) *$+,-,.,/0,1,2,&$, 33"--,&4 +"1565 6&$#$3,-22$44""

"53&%"&4 1,2'

78 9 1"5"&4'

 

     

       

 ,:;$1"*1,<,4= 1,-!

        

 !"# $%#&&'

! "( ((#&&

)*+",'%,#&&

)*+",(-##&& )*+" -&((#&&      . 

   /         1

 

   2   

.   

/

 

      /          )

  0   

0    3 .  0  1

/      # 40   0     /     .   / 0 

  . 

 / (  .   .   /0      

 

 .

, 5  /    . 

  . 

.     &&   / 

6 

7     &$2&(2 $,#3 /0/.

 /7 / 8-,  0  6+ / ! 9"0 :

    ;  0        0





  <  2+ 6 )" 6 = 

 

 .

/

  0 .          .

6+ /

!  

<+

: =9+ >

;

  / 0  #82 &2 8%, 

  / ?          0      <+

  : =  9+  >

; 

 9  .8' . + @      ; - 7 

 )

      .:

)

  

   .8' .+ 9#8   ;

0  

   .,'

  $    /   /4   

         .,'

  $

.     

     % 7 

 +  A /

9?

.+  /! .

;

 8-#

  .5  

00 . 

0 / . /

 / ! 0

 0  0  /0

   0

   

 

  1  /         / . /

 / /

  

 2   #82 &2 8%,         



 0  1

 

( -  2  +  A /

9?

.+  /! .

; 8-# ./      

    "  (% ,       &$2&(2 8%'3

        

 0

    ' 40 .  2   #82 &2 8%,0 .

   .,'

  $

 0

  0 0 

   0  3  0   /1   .('%  % ! 

/   .8- #    0   6+ / "    0/    .8- #    0 

.

 0 

 $ B .  ..   /           0    /    

   )    

/ . .8- # 6+ / 0 . 0

        (&2&$2 8%$  

  

C   /

   6+ /  0   .    .8- # 0 

   /    .   0

 

    #-2&-2 8'&40 

0 

 D+

: E

  0  8 :   2        

0  .C    1

/ 8'#2'(

 6+ / !   0  

 0

   

&A   

    

  6 + /  !         

    ' +  ? .) >  8%

.

 40  

 / 

) 76  -2 #2 88#

 6+ / ! 0         )

  !   4       )

  !   .      



.

  

, - ' 4/ +  +

 8'#    

     



.

  

  /  )

 !     0

 /) F    #2 &-2 88,  /  )

! 0 

 /

)

 ,2 #2 88,

#  .

  / 

. .

  )   " 82) #%2&(2 88% . 

 6+ /

 8%82'& 2 3.       .8-2#    )



 .    .



 )  "

, 8880 

 / 0    .

 &,2&-2#&& 4 

     /  

(       

  

.

.   . .0   

  ,2:,5  )   "#8- ( &-2 88%.

   0 

   .$'2'9   8-2#   ;



   #82 &2 8%,   / +

:     &$2&(2

8%'0 0 ./

 0  0     . .

   /  B2   +   />     )

#82 &'2#&&(      . /

 

 .



   

    

  .       :

  C.   0 ) 0 

%2&-2#&&'  0   +

: 

0  /  #82 &2 8%,   &$2&(2 8%'

1

 

0     0 .  . .

  :

  C.    *$+,-,    (>

)

,7 



       

.

   ! +  B22 9   

8+   />    ;   0 ,2

&2 88'   0 

.

!

 / 

)  

  

)  0   

  / )  &2

88$7       !      

 0  

  / )

 &2&-2#&&& !A!0

 / B   )

 (2& 2#&&  9  

    /  2   ,2:,5 )   

         .



 : > 

)  * +

>

->  .   )   "-% 2) #,2 &2 88% .

   0    .8'2#0 0    

   &$2&(2 8%'  

 #82 &2 8%,9  

  /  ; 1

0      0 .    .  / 

 .



 (&2&82#&&#   >  .  )  "8& #2

2#&&#  :

  C.40 0 



2& 2#&&->

 . 



(40  !  

 / )

2#&&8

%7   

                 

 .

>  .  B22 9    8+   />    ;   0 ,2 &2 88'

  0 

.

>  .   / 

)  

  

)  0   

  / )  &2

88$7 

 ! 

 /)

&2&-2#&&& !A!0

 / B  )



(2& 2#&&  9 )> 

     /8,#**2,&$&?* "4#       

 

'   

 0  /  .

,2@,1,&"4# . .   .8-2#  .

!   

 .

   

 /     9 

40 /  )   

) ) .0     



$A      

 0 

         .    0     0

 >       0  . 

   G   >0A



 )

4



  

,2&#2#&&-     . 

  0     3 30



 

 

87  0  2            

      

    0    1       



 !.      / * +

 

 

 / 



* +

   /

  

     

 .

 3 

 /   .



:

6 

)   " 82) #%2&(2 88%30 0   /    . 

6+ /

.    .8-2#

 8%82'&      

 

 



 .    .





)  "

, 8880 

 /0   

.

 &,2&-2#&& 4  

  

  /   # 

  





(    

  .,'

  $

 

 .!  ! :

      C    / 88#2 8(A

   .8-2#  0 "-''

  "''##   .('%2 %  0

"-$'(   "''(8 '',#A  ,'

2 $     0 ./

 6+ / !   0          .8-2# C    / 8%'2%$40 . 

. ('% 2 %

 0  . / 0    

        0      C        /  8%'2%$ ..  0 .

  )   ",-

#82&,2 8%$

0  /    (&2&$2

8%$  ./  ",,,-0   #-2&-2 8'&



        .8- #40  30   .C    / 8'#2'(.

 6+ /

  .  

0



   C    / 8'#2'(

 .  3

 / 8%82'&  0 .3 G

3 

0 6+ /   0  

 / 0  / 





    / 0  .

  

  .     



 .

 0 .

7   6+ /  .!    

  .



.    ' +  ? .)

  8% 30 0   /

 -2 #2 88# / 

) 

 6    

   

  .



2&(2 88(    3 

 , - '4/ +  +  8'#   /

  

  /  



 / )  F     #2&-2 88,  7   0           /       3 6+ / ! 



2



 

  )

 .



 /  0 

  ( 7   / $,# 6 

7   /0/ .

.   .8' . '



 "',8 9#'2 ,;

',8 9 #2&;

',8 9#82&;

',8 H%-,9#(2

(;

%,%9&2 %; 

  .!       



 3   .,'

  $0 



 

  

0    / 

8%#2%(  7  0         

     0     

  0/

 



 



 . 





 / 8%82'&     .  / +

  , A   

  0





. .

 

 / 0 

 0      

    )

  0            . /    A 

0  

- +      %     )

  /

  ) 

 

 .0 / 8'#2'(3

 

     /    (/    0 (/

   

 



       2   .  /      

 

       -#      4/        8'( 9      ; 0 1    

 

  

     

 

     )



       

  

 

    40  

      

     

       

  40  /   

 



  / ' ..  .

.

 

 /   )



   0 ) 40 0     )     

      /    .    

 /  ) 0 )    

 ) !  0



    /



   /  0  )      / 0  )    .  /   

   0 .   

3 1   4/ 4/        3      .   

    0



  $ * .   

 

  

 



 0. 0 0"

. . 

 / 

 07 

  

   G



0      .   0 

   

 / )

/ * 

 .    

        

.   

  

0  3

  

 .   ! I

   

  /

  

  !            0 ./      0 

     4      

   

   3  

   3 /  0         / /  .        . / 

0   0 ./



.   7   

  /

/ .    

 /  





H

     



  . 

    

 / 

 

/0  

 

 1 





(/ 

 

1  

(/   .   

 / 

 07  

 



   



      . 0 1 



.    

  )

   )

0 /         /    )

 

  



    /  +  +   8  

     

 / 







0   

  A /

9?

.+  /! .

; 8-#

.

  .

0 / ./

 / 

 

4   

 

 / 0 / 1

 /    / 

 

4  

  .0  



      

0/ /  

 / 

6+ / 

  .



 =



   

  !  !"#



 $ " 

 

 



  

 3    /4  

  



    / )

 0

&A    

   

 

  /

0 2   

  .

 / 8'#2'(  1     (/  

    0  2     

   . / 

 / 0



   

 

  . / 

  



4 .  )

  

  0    

 ) 



 

 / 

 

     )

 0 .  . ..

0   

H

    0    



    

 / 

  F 

   . 



 

#      /

 

      0   /

0  )

1  

   /

.40  0

   G1



0   

 .  

/       

 A /     

   / 

)   ..         

 D

 E  )

0  . 

 ! I /  



 

    

/      

  G /

   

 2   /  

  

  7    

    /    G / 

 .  0 



  .  

 .  0      .

/  /   G /    

     

   /     /40

0    / I 

   0



 . 0/   2  . 0

      .

(7 

     .        

7  

0 

 0   



   / 

 /   /     0   / .  

/0  

0 

01    .   . 0 3 0 

0 

   

 1

 

  /

1    /    4 

   

 0 

  / G1

 

01

    

0 4  1

  1    

 /

 

 /  .

 

 / 1

 

  

4     

. 0 0

 /

 / .  

  /   / 0    . /

     0  

,A 0 

  . 

0 ./

      .

         G





0   / /

 . 

 

0 

/    .  0   3 

1 



 / 3    . 4  )  



  1  . 



   /     . "

/

0 0

. .  .

 

/0 

..  

   

  

      

.   

  7  



  

  0     

.     

 1   

  / / 

./.

I 



 

 

 /0   

 

/  

4  0     . 

/3 

  / 

 

/  /

      

 / /7  

  .

0  1   0 . .

I 



   6 

! *  :) 7    /A 

! .

?

.>05 

  

   /   .1 

  . 

  .

0 4  /  

/0       





 

2 ./ 

.

 .

 0 7    

 0   

  

.           

 

/  7  

3    

/     . / 0  / 4  .

/

  

4  

 

/    



/.

 0  /    B  /

)

 0 .     

-0 )  . 0 0    / 

  

        

  -# 4/    8'(7

> /1   1



     /            )

     /    

  /   /  H     )

0   . 4  0 1 

 . /    

  )

  . / >0 ) .      

% 

1    /  

  

/    

D E

 D+ 

E  0  /

 / 

 / /7    /    .D  E  6

5   ( +  A /  

 9?

.    +  /  ! .

;   8-#    D+ 

E   /

:   

)       



     D+ 

E 

 A /

7      D+ 

E      2G

 0    . 

        +  A /

9?

.+  /! .

; 8-#  

.   

   4 D+ 

E

    0   



.

 0 / .  )  

  !  !"#



 $ " 

0

   +  A /

9?

.+  / ! .

; 8-#D+ 

E  /   / 05 !'#2 +  > ! ! !    / 

  

)   4  

H

D E

     4   .

40     0   .

D E   / /  /

. 0    

'   

    

/  0   

D E.     6

 /  %&

'(

 ) $ ""

# *+ ,     

2#&&8   /

  /



   . / / /

$" .

  / >)

  

87  0   



.

 

 / 

 0    / 

D E  

(4*6-0=

)  B9C 5*,;*,   *  

.H  J

*    J