High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22028/2022allowed

Saurabh Verma v. State Of Punjab

2022-11-30Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary14 pages

! !"# $$%&'

( "# ) **+,* - .( ! ! / *0*,1,2*3 *4! .!( ! !-!+ !

- .- !5!*+ ! - 6*.!7 - &8 9 , * : ;

, 7! ! - . 3+! 1*53+!7 , <;

".!*- -*= . =#,7! * +! * !>!!! , '*+*.*,? ,.*7 . * <

,? , *

,? :(*34 . !*+ !5!!7 **((+!* !-!+-!.*7,-*5!7-.*7*

, ? <*.*7 . *

,? ; ! .!+4( , .( !!! .* !7*(!* .!+(* ++!7 .)3*+5 , .80.0*( * . 0).(.0)!* !-5* ! .* .( ! !,*! - &+4,'*+*.*,.*3!73 !7!) 5* .-5 .+* -04**.*)( .*4*5 *-5 .*5% .*

*4*+.0*!73 !7 .!) 5* .3 0@ 8! *7+*0.!+! !7* .!.,0.*3*330! .+*( (, 53!+(.*0! ..*4*5 -8!*4$.*!80! . (+!--!!*+*! ..- .( ! !* 9 (5 :;

***5 -, ,:

*++7 37*53+!754 -5 .! (! *+70! . +*( ( * 53!+ (. $. *5 0*(! 0! . .85$*?>(* 5 &!*+( ! .*0*( ;

B*+35! .* .*((+!* !-!.*7 0*!5!34 . !*+ !*

.7 .* * . !5--*5!7- ..*7+4(!5*-*!*! 3 $.*- , ..*7*7*! .( ! !0-*5!*

,? ;, ! -$.3+!1*53+!7 ".!*- - *C$. D# B*+- .( ! !((.!*75 34 5*)!7*- .+ - .0.! .+*!-!* ! - .--*7*! .+*0! .,*5 !,*( 0.!. .--(!.*3+0! .!5(!5 -+ .*4** 7!E*3+,3*!+*3+* !*3+34 *7! * B*+! - .3 * !* .! *- .*++70 .* !- .! 3 ! - !::

0.!.* .

C:: 8-5* ! * 7!E*3+ * * ! !7* !-.* "#@.!-5* !!7! *--!!.*7-* (+! * !- .55!!0! .! .+!5! -.

* !-* 7!E*3+--,..*++ * 3 .3 *- .!-5* !!* 3) 3)( 34.--!!.-5* . * 15 5*4(!3! .!3.*+-,*- . !-5* . *7! * "

#(+!--!.*++! !7* * 7!E*3+ *0! . .-* *7! * .*!7(0 4.*55! .*- !*+D B* + - . ( ! ! ? .* . --(!.*3+ ! - . 0.!. .&80* +7*.*7.*3-*5! 7!E*3+* .(!3 !5(!5 -! !( 5 .-!-: - . !0*5*,0.!.* .

C1*5!7* !73!**!5*+ -!7. ! (3+! F(+!--!5*4*((.0! . 0** F*4(-(+*4!7-54 . *+*3+ .!7, 0! . *, !, . ! 5 -7*5!7,!(+*4!7*47*5 3!7*7*5-5)!++,!*4(3+! ,(+* .7.-*! * 0! .! .+!5! *-*!,*4 ( !7*43!*!5*+ -!7. !*4(3+! ,(+* .7.-*! * 0! .! .+!5! *-*!,*4( .( *!!7**3 !7 .(3+!-!7. !7-3!**!5*+.( 0.*((..*++337. 0! . +*43- * *7! * ,*.*++3+!*3+ *-! ?!7 -!- 4 (, !5(!5 , ! . !5(+ !7,-*4 5 ?!7*+*5 .G > !-! 5 -7*5!7-!(3+! F4 . (+! --! 5*4 !E *++ ! 5 -7*5!7-!.(3+!(+*

.(- .0.5..*++* ,* . *7! * 5*4,! ! - .--, .! 5 3- .0! . 4 $$ > $ "*5#F8 !,- . 0 C-!- 4 (D, 3 ! . 0 C .(DH*5 -9;

,<"0- 9

#I !5*.*+*.F8 !,*5 * .* -2*3H !5*.*+*. -9;<, ;"0-:

9;<#I *.4**.F8 ! F"!#- . -! . (**7*(., 3 ! . -++0!7,*5+4FC+!%--!5*4*((. * *. 0! . 0** F"*#*4 ( - 7*5!7**3+4( 37*5!7!*4 (3+! , .7.-*,!*4(+* 0.!. .(3+!.**(5! .**G"3#*4 ( !7*43!*!5*+ -!7. !*4(3+! , .7.-*,!*4(+* 0.!. .(3+! .**(5! .**"#*4( . ( *!!7**3 !7.(3+!-!7. !7-3! **!5*+D 8 0* . .35!!-+*+ .* .-- 0.!.* 7!E*3+* (5! 3! !7* 0! . . - . *7! * ,0.0*.*!7 .(0 4.* 55! .*- !*+ B*+- .( ! !! 3 * !* .* .80* 5( .*!* ..- .( ! !, - !:- . ,0.!.* .

C0 ** .!(+! **. 8- . *7! * -*! ! .--!! 0! . .-++(0- * *7! * , .>! ! (! -+!,(!3+!-5* !,*

*- .6!4*.5*4 .!)*4,.** 3+! .* *4.,0*+++,5 (+*,!**557*5!7 .,.5*4! .!5+- ,34.!0** * .!E*4--!- (+!, 3+0.*)* . * 15 .*++*((! ! .!3.*+- 0! .*! * *5*43-*4,34!7. 34*4,*34 -!-*4,*4..,0*+++, 5(+*,*5*4! .!5+- *)! 4, * .!E.--! *)! 4,*++( 0.5..--!-! .!,0. . .* *++47*5!7G *5*4!E* .!E. --! !E*++! 5 -7*5!7,**++54 * ! - 54, * * !+ - *+, **3+4( .*3! 3 - .

((-7*5!70.!.*- .! *5*4*.* .!E.--! *.*++ (* - . ., 0*++ +, 5 (+* 0.!...--!.*++.* 0.. .--!.** 3+! .* *4! 5 -7*5!7**+ .!,**+ .(- .0.5..--! *)! 4* 5*4!E* .!E.--! !E* *) (!-*++! 5 -7*5!7-(. *.D @.!+-!7 .*-*!(!!, .+*+ 35! .* *( .*! ! !+4 . *7! * -*>! ! .--!>0.(!3+!-5* !**- .!6!4 0...** 3+! .* .(+*!**557*5!7 .5*4! .!5+-34.!0** * .!

E*4--!-(+!

*! .* ! .( *, .(*!*7.* 3

-++0!*5.*0** 03 *!34 .*-*!8 3- !7 .*!* ..- .( ! ! $. +* + - . -!! ! - 55 7*5!7. 35! .* .6!5 -*--! .* ! .- . ! 5 - 7*5!7 * -, 0.!. ! . * - . ( ! 4-, ,:

0* --!! 5!

*.*!737*!(-! -50*7!73 !7! 5- . *-*!-!! ! 35! .* .*!*5 0* .+7*++4 *!5- .( ! !,*-0*5* (!- . 85 $*? - . 4*

*+7 0! .

*.3), 3*+* . * *? *! ( 34 7! .* * ,? 9 ,*(0.!.* :;

,* *5 -, ,:,

0*.0**.!.*- .( ! ! $. ! -$.3+!1*53+!7 , <;! .! ( * ! +*-! . 5557*5!7 .,0.!.* .

C 8 ( * ! +*F8 .! F C55 7*5!7 .DFC557*5!7 .D5**4 .,0*+++,5(+*!0.!.*, !, *3+ .! 5 -7*5!7*)( - . (-! 7*! - . ( 0!7, (4!7, !7 )(!7 . ., +, 5(+*,0. .340*4-.*7- .- .! 5 -7*5!7,- ..,+, 5(+*, .0!.0D B*+- .( ! !35! .* .-- *++73!7 7!E*3+, .&8+ .*3+7*7*! .( ! !G6 +4! !7* !+.* *)(+*,+

.0**5(+*! 35! !: 3- .8++*6* *7! * 34*>! 5- !:- . ,+4 0.*- , .! !7* !+.* .* *- - !6!4B*+- .( ! !+!(275 ! . *- !!"#$ % !& ( *

#@B "*2#"#:,!' ' !!"#$(&, :< -

;

"* *#,))*+)),, !!"#$- !.+ 9:-

"/** *)*#,*'()( /& !!"#$ * %0

#!&",( *

#"!5!*+#< B*+- .( ! ! .* ! .(+4 -!+ 34 . * , . ! ( . 7 *! 34 . ( ! ! !(* !+*7*!7 .+7*+! .* !*-

7!E*3+--,&8*6 (!7+ .*3 *! * .*!! +--5 .4!( !0*0! . 2!! ! %((!7 .( ! !,+* * +5**- (***:- .(+4 35! .* .3 !70*7!7 0. .( ! !0**((.$.*!(*** . C$.* .*- 8.) .+*( (5*) *J* *((+!* !0*.*!7*5!(*0 $.*!+*( (0*( !*+ .(*+*0**+ 0! .*+ *53!+(. %< < +*)*

+*)0**+( ! .+ .(*+* 0* *+ 0! . *+ *5(+ *+ 0* ((* (** +4*+0*.**- 8*2! *+ !7. . . (*+ 0 *) ! (!!(** 455*0!

( .!0! ! :$.* !7! 7* !***3. 5*K !5**-!*+ * 5 3- .8 .* .*5 0.!..**-53 !7 .!) 5* ., . .* )( . *! *5 ! . 0 *+5!*.+4!7!.!35!*4++03*73* . .+ . )0*3 .*5**7 . *5**3.5*7 * 4++03*7-5.!*+5!*.+4!7! .35* (! 3- .88! .(- . (+! --!!*+ +*). :

.*0*$.*!*5 0* ( ! .*54++03*7*0* *)! (! !(** 455*0! ( .! 0! ! ( 0*!( ! .(- . (+! --!!*+ * ! (+* 0* ((* **3. 5*K!0** ! .*

: ;

* .*75 **34 .+*+- . (* ! 8 !!*4 *(! +* .+*0*!* 34 =3+$.(5 -8!*!*--" & )&.* !!"#$(&12234(5627,0.!! 0*.+* C@ 7! .6 !0. .! .-* - .! * * .*3!0- . !7. ! (( - .!5(7(!7.*7 3 6*.*! . .(+!0* ! + ! !7* ! . -- ! 6 ! . .!- '!!*+ *7! * *)7!E*( .( 35! 5(+ ! - . ! !7* ! % . 0 .0!7- .(+!, .-- !-

. !7!E*3+* .- .(+!+ .* 7! * * - . * -- ! :> - , . (+! ! ! + ! !7* ! * 7!E*3+ -- (* * - * 5( *7! * !::"

#>3 ,*5! +4,.

0*(*! .! * *$.* *!+4 5*, .* ! . .(+!+! !7* ! . --!6 !35! *( 0.!. . 6 !- *)!77!E*+.**!@.!+ .!(! ,! 5*435 ! .* !!0- . (! ! "# > , 0.!. -! =5(+*! =, . (+! ! ! + 35! , *- ! !7* !, * ( * +* !7 * 7!E*3+ --!0.!.*.*( ! 3 * ** =5(+*! = - . (+! --! , 3 .* ?(+** !0!++ 3**!+*3+ .( !. * .* +* * * 0. . (+! !! !* ! !7* ! ! * 7!E*3+ -- +!) . ( 3 + !5* +4 -! .* +4 *

7!E*3+--.*35* D 8 .*- "(*#, .*2* .* !7.

+* !7 .1*53+!7 .*.+ .

C;- .*!7+- .(* !, .! -! .* . * 7!*++4 5 ! +*!-!* !---*7*! .+*0* -!! !$.--(!.*3+0! .5 .* ;4*3*+4*7!E*3+--* 3 ! 34 ! 0.* . -- .*!7 !5(!5 4* ( ;4***+ 7!E*3+ !*3+34 *7! * -! +** . -- (!.*3+ 0! . !5(!5 - +

.* .4*0! .-!* 7!E*3+ -- !*3+34*45*7! * $.--- 7!E*3+--.0 .* .* .*++ 35*! .7!E*3+--0! . * 0** $., . 3!-* ! 3 0 . 7!E*3+* 7!E*3+*( . ! .* . + -- * .+ ! . +*!-!* ! - . .*++ 6! 5 7 !434 .'!!*+ *7! * * .-, ! . -!! ! ! +-, . - 0** -* .*3(!38 !- . .* !::-3 ! - . *+ +*+4 * .* ! * -

7!E*3+*, .! !7* !* 3 34 .(+!0! . .- . *7! * .*!7(0 4.*55! . *- !*+

$., . .**+*-++4( . ! - . *2* .* 3+! 1*53+!7 %!* 99, 0.!. !(+* . -! -

*!5(!5 ( 5 .$., . -- *++7 -*++ . * 74 - 5!!557*! 4--**(.+- . .*++ 3 ! . * 74 -

7!E*3+--* !! +- (!3* 0. . .--!7!E*3+ 7!E*3+ %, .! ! - . (!! .* .--! 7!E*3+ . .! 5 ! *(((!* *++0 . ( 5! ( ! ! 34 6*.!7 . ( (!7 ! &8 ;;A

: 7! * +! * !, / 0*+! !7*7**7* - . -- - . *2* .* 3+! 1*53+!7

%!*,99**5! +4 .( ! 5*)*(! .* *((0*3 *! -5 . *7! * 3- 5*)!7 *4 ! !7* !! .( * 98!0- .*3, .(!7!! * ! (* - . !5(7 &8 * 3 *! * * +!*3+ 3 *! 6 +4, .( ( ! !*( * . !5(7 &8 ! 6*. *+7 0! *++ 36 (!7 0, +!3 4 ! 7* .5( * .!%--! -!+ *5(+*! !**0! .(!!- +*0,!-! ! 3*34+!5! * !D !*((* -5 .(*+- .*--(!! * .275 .* .! !7* !!* 7!E*3+--* . .*- .(+!0! (5!!- .5( *7! * ! !

5(5!!3+ !7 .-* - .*!.*,!3! *3+4! .* 3 37. 34 . * .* . (+! --! 0* * .! 340*4-!*-*0** **. ..- .( ! ,0.!.!5** *( !:- . ,*( 6!! -0.!.! .* ,(!( -!3+!-5* !, .--!! 0! (0 - *7! * >! ! (! - +! *- !76!45*4! .!5+-340** * .!*4 . (+!--! **. .(+*$.(+4- . * !+ .* .0**(*34 . *7! * ! !7* . 7!E*3+--*6!3 ! - !

$.(*+!-!5! 4! .!*7 . - .5* ,

! * !7 .(!7 .!! * & .5, .!(!-! (+434 . * 2 !-4!7 .5( - .(+!--!,0. . *! 3* !-5* !, 0.! !( 0! .*32!$.(**- .( ( ! (* !+*+4: : 0.!7.*3*! 3 * !* .* .&80**+**3-(-+*0.* 3(!-!*++4 ( ?( - * !7C .* .(! .**+*43?(+*! ! .-7!7(**7*(.D,0.!..*3(.!*3! .!275 ,0.!.*+5+45*)*- .*++74, ! !7* !*-!*+ * 5 3 .!72 !-4!7! . 5( - .--! .7! * !-&8!* 7!E*3+ -- .* .*!0* !

(*-*- . *7! * ,(**- 6!4.*!7!!3+ !-5* ! $. +*!-!* ! 3 0 7!E*3+ * 7!E*3+ --*(.+ -!(!* .+-- 6! 7 !434 . *7! * , .! .6!5 - 0** -* (!3! .-!! ! +-,0.!.* .

>-!! !F8 .!,+ . ? .0!6!,F"+#C 7!E*3+--D 5**---0.!.,*C 7!E*3+ *D5***!0.!.,*(+!--!.* * .! 4 * 0! . 0** GD

L3+$.(5 -8!*! .*- */" & "&/) &'

&"( /&#/(( *"

9#< ,.*.+ .* ( *3-(-+*0* -2 !, . (0 !

*3!+, .(***+* *

. C<$.? 6 !-!* !!0. . ! .+!7. - .*- 5 !-* *+(! !, *(2 ! .5(+*! ! +-,! 0**-! * 0. . !7. .+ .* ?! ! 2!! ! !

- .M ;$.(**53! -(0- . !7. !

- ..*3!* * ! * 34 .! !*! - !!* *+!5 *0.!. . !7. * ?!2!! !!6*.!7(!7.*3 5* $.-,! !*4 3 . 275 345*)!7- *++ .!! . (! 8 0+--! * .* .7. .(0 (34 . !7. .*!(!! * 4 0!, 3 . .+ 3 ?! ! *(((!* *, ? 3! 2 ! * *+ * 3 * !*+2 !- .*5!! * !-0.!.*+ . ?! $. !. (0 - * *3! *4 2!! ! . !7. * *!7 0.!5 *(!$.(0.* 3?!(*!7+4, 0! !5( ! * ! .

* - * *, 0. . !!, .3*!-5* !*+ , .* *++0!7 .(!7 !0+ 3**3- .(- . .* .- 2 !6! .* .(!77. 36*. 9+ .7.! .*2*B*+=*"(*#, . 34 0*4 - !++ * !, -5+* * 5*4 * * 7!-*,0.! .? * !*4(0 .*- * (!!+3?!34 . !7. ( *3-(- . 4 ! 0*+*!-! .* ! 0* (!

(!*!-+?!3+7!+!*4!7!-5+* 7!*?.* !+! - .!5 *!0.!. .(0+3?!D $. !*+ .*55! 7*!(!7 -*5.*73*-!*+( ! .!*0.! .! !7* ! +.*3+4*- 5(+4!70! . .(!!-+*0,* 5(+* 8!0- .** !++ * ! .*-! !!, .(!7!! !* *7*! .( ! !* *3+,(!*++4 0. .*!+*!7 +7!7-&8! +-0*-5 . ..+ 5*34(*+!7+*! 4$.*5!*7--!! 6*. .&8*6 (!7! ( *3-(- +*0*--2 ! 6+ . , .( ( ! !!*++0&89 * :;

,? * .6 (!7 *!!7 .-5*.346*.

4 5 7 @. .(*)!7A* NA @. .( *3+ NA