Krishan Lal And ANR. v. Commissioner And Director Gen. Sch. Edu. Hy. & ORS


 

       


   

        

  

    



     



     

  
     !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2



 



 



 

 

 



 



 



  

   



  

   



  

4 5

   

"#  6%1$  0#$1$1-+#%,  6"-  7%#  $"#  .18#  *#*/#%,  -8  7+7$7+ "7%7*#+1-%#9-+(7%:9"--.1+("7;#0%7:#(8-%<'7,"*#+$-8$"# %#0-%$,'/*1$$#(/: */'(,*7+-+= = >7+($"#;-$#%,.1,$(7$#( 5 >0%#07%#(/:%#,0-+(#+$- =7,*#*/#%,8%-* - 433$-=54 *#+$1-+#(1+$"#;-$#%,.1,$7%#+-$#+$1$.#($-97,$$"#1%;-$#



+  !  - =3==  -8    $"1,  -'%$  700-1+$#(  7+

*/'(,*7+8-%7+7$7+"7%7*7/"7?9"--.$-81+7.1@#$"#;-$#%,.1,$ 61$"1+  =  *-+$",  ',$19# 

 #"%'  A #$( B  */'(,*7+  (1%#9$#(  $"# (*1+1,$%7$-%-8$"#9"--.
9'*
#0'$: -**1,,1-+#%1+($-0%#07%# #.#9$-%7.%-..,$%19$.:1+9-+8-%*1$:61$"$"#-/,#%;7$1-+,*7(#/:"1*1+"1, %#0-%$  (7$#(  = = >  $"7$  $"#  #.#9$-%7.  %-..  /#  0%#07%#(  78$#%  ('#


;#%18197$1-+-8$"##.1)1/.##.#9$-%,#+$1$.#($-97,$$"#1%;-$#,

=

"#  )%1#;7+9#  -8  $"#  6%1$  0#$1$1-+#%,  1,  $"7$  #.#9$-%7.  %-.. A++#C'%#
B67,+-$0%#07%#(1+$#%*,-8$"# -+,$1$'$1-+-8$"# 9"--.A++#C'%#
B 

!#"#7%($"#,'/*1,,1-+,*7(#-+#1$"#%,1(#

'.#,$-=AB-8$"# '.#,7+( #)'.7$1-+,-8$"#,,-917$1-+ %#7(7,8-..-6,
D
 

        


     

     

   !

"  

"

#$

   $ 

%& '

$   

   ( "



"

  " "$  $ #  

$   $$$($ ! 

 $  )*"!

E

"#%#1,+-(1,0'$#$-$"#879$$"7$1+$#%*,-8$"#7/-;# '.#, 707%$8%-*$"#7$%-+,6"-(-+7$#(?
$-$"#,-91#$:7+($"#.18# *#*/#%,6"-(-+7$#( 
=?
7$7$1*#$"# #*/#%,6"-"7;#/##+ 07:1+),'/,9%10$1-+-8
?
0#%*-+$"9-+$1+'-',.:8-%$"#.7,$=:#7%, 7.-+#7%##.1)1/.#$-97,$$"#1%;-$#7+(9-+$#,$$"##.#9$1-+8-%C#9'$1;#

-**1$$## '/,9%10$1-+-8
?
,"7../#071(-+7+:(7:-80%1.#79"

=
:#7% 

"#1+8-%*7$1-+%#9#1;#('+(#%$"# 1)"$$-+8-%*7$1-+9$/:

$"#6%1$0#$1$1-+#%,7+(8-'+(700#+(#(7,++#C'%#
(1,9.-,#,$"7$ 4=*#*/#%,1+$%-('9#(1+$"#;-$#%,.1,$(#9.7%#(-+5 >8%-* - 433$-=54"7(+-$/##+(#0-,1$1+)$"#%#<'1%#(*#*/#%,"108##-8
?
0#%:#7%07:7/.#1+$"#*-+$"-80%1.#;#%::#7%'+(#%#9$1-+=-8 $"# -+,$1$'$1-+-8$"#9"--.8%-*0%1.$-0%1.>

>

+799-'+$-8$"#07,,7)#-8$1*#7+(.70,#-8$"%##:#7%,7 9-*0%-*1,#(#9%##07,,#(0#%*1$$1+)70#%,-+$-/#9-*#7*#*/#%-8$"# #.#9$-%7.9-..#)#-+07:*#+$-8
4?
1+.'*0
,'*0'%,'7+$$-$"#)#+#%7. +-$19#1,,'#(/:$"#-8819#%+-*1+7$#("7,/#9-*#$-$7..:%#('+(7+$ '9"

7.'*0
,'*07:*#+$$-/#9-*#7*#*/#%,"7..+-$/#79-+$1+'1+)0%-9#,, 7+(,"-'.(/#7-+#$1*#78871%7,0#%$"#7)%##*#+$%#79"#(/#$6##+$"# 07%$1#,1+$"#,'1$

-6$"#$1*#"7,9-*#$-,$%19$.:79$1+799-%(7+9#61$"$"# 7/-;# '.#,7+( #)'.7$1-+,-8$"#,,-917$1-+ -$"$"#07%$1#,"7;#7.,- 7)%##(8-%81+7.1@7$1-+-8;-$#%,.1,$1+799-%(7+9#61$" '.#, "#07:*#+$ *7(#1+.'*0
,'*$-/#9-*#7*#*/#%7,0#%$"#9-+,#+$(#9%##61..+-$ /#-87+:',#78$#%.70,#-8$"%##:#7%,0%#,9%10$1-+8-'+(1+$"# '.#,



+  ;1#6  -8  $"#  7/-;#  $"#  ;-$#%,  .1,$  0%#07%#(  7,  0#%  $"# (1%#9$1-+,-8$"# */'(,*7+,$7+(+-$799#0$#(   #,0-+(#+$- ='/ 1;1,1-+7. 8819#%A B
9'*
(*1+1,$%7$-%  #+1-%#9-+(7%:9"--. 1+(1,(1%#9$#($-0%#07%#78%#,"$"#;-$#%,.1,$,$%19$.:1+$#%*,-8 '.#,$- =AB61$"1+*-+$",8%-*$"#(7$#-8%#9#10$-8$"1,-%(#%7+(9-+('9$

3
#.#9$1-+  61$"1+  =  *-+$",  $"#%#78$#%  +  $#%*,  -8  #9$1-+,  =  7+(  = ,'/,9%10$1-+-8
?
0#%7++'*1+$"#*-+$"-80%1.-8#79":#7%8-%$"# .7,$=:#7%,,"-'.("7;#/##+071(7,-+$"#*-+$"-80%1.



"#6%1$0#$1$1-+,$7+(,(1,0-,#(-8799-%(1+).:

 ! "   

9$-/#% !

 "

'.7$1