Naresh Kumar v. Ut Chandigarh And Others

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH Date of Decision: 20.07.2020 NARESH KUMAR (.Petitioner

Versus

UT CHANDIGARH AND OTHERS (Respondents CORAM: Hon'ble Mr.Justice Deepak Sibal 



 

  



Deepak Sibal, J. (Oral)

 








 



!"#$%
 

  

& 


 





!
'

 
 

(
  
#
&

 
%

 
)*+
 !,
 
-$ - $-$-



-.
"/&
*

01

 

2,
   


 
)*+

3
 
 1'





  4
 
5
5

 



6
 

1
#

7

6%
*
'
$-2"
'
 1

* 

1 

$.

-8 $-2"



1


1  



+ 8

5 
45'9

 


1 

+ 28






 
!

1

+ 22


 

:
1 
'

 
!
5



'





1  
  4




 !
 
 






:
$!

.

$-2"
  4
 

 
1









1
5
'


5 

 





  4
 



6

$, .

$-2"
5
  4
 









 
 
 


  4
 



 



6
5




:
1

5


 


&
)*+




 
!




 





!/
 



 '




;

 


5 
& 
 1

 


 


9
1  
 

 
!
 
11
 
1 


5'

 
1&

 

5'

 


1

1  

*
5 
 1
 
+ 22


 
5
 

 
'




 
!
 






 
5 
5




5


5
 

 
 

+ 22


 
5 



   :


 
 

 


 
!
5
 '
'

 
5
 

 1
1 

5'



+ 22


 1
 

1  

3
 
 
 '

*
'



!-
 '


5




3
 
 




'1



 
 '


 1


5

 
!


1
 
2$&2!
 '






1 


  

 


'


5

 

 
 

 
!
 
4
  

 




45'
 
'
1


1

1  




 

 
1
 '



0
 



 


5
+ 22

5
 
'



 
'

 
!

 

5 


5
 





 
5
 



'

 
!

 1
5 
<


 

5









 

5
 

 



 1
 

 '


 


 
!

<


 


 

5
 
 '



1
 

1  
 





 


 






5 
 5




 1





5

$- -8 $-2"


 
5 5
1





1

+ 2/



 
+ 
5 
 

 
  



 



 
 
 '
 
 
 

+ 22


 
'




 
!



 

 
5'



 1









 


 
!
5 





 

+ 
5 
 

41


1



  

    





!"


1 


2",!
 

&

439. Special powers of High Court or Court of Session regarding bail        !

"

#      $ ""!    

" !  " !  ! !

 

"     $"

!  #"

% "

&%'  

$ "!

( "

" !"  

$$ 

!    #"

)       "!



$!   *    (  $    ! !

!+  
 !!             

 



  $(  ""!    

" ( "   ,"   

    ( "     $  (



$    

 

"   $$ "

    
  "
" 

 

  "!! (

 $    

   $"

"   "

"                 !

"

    $( ! !  $   !!"



 " ! 


1


-    

     ../  %&. 5




  


 '




5'
 
 


&

 1"

      #   "    

   !  ""

      !    " !! ! !  (

  !

     2  "  !(

"

"  ""  ! !

"

  ""

     !   !  3  $4   !  ""

   

!   

! ,

+  "

$    (

 !" !

  

  5

"     

$   !  ! "   1

"   ""  !  ""!      6 

 "

    "       

 $"!   "!   $



    ""!  "!

      1

  ""

   ( " !! 

 ""!   " "  (

  " !  (  $ "

"  "!!

 "!"

    ( ""!    !   1   ""     !  

 7 *

" *    - 

 *  /%  &%
1



!"#$%
  
5&
0%   8     "  " !

    

  !   " $$  

  !  6  1"

 !   ""

  

  $ "

   !"1

"

 !  "

 $

 ""!(    

   !   $ (

   !"  "

!

  !  "  "  !   1"

   ""

    $"

" 

$$! 

""     $1!

"!      $"

 9  !  :     !   "  $ !      "

 " ( 

$    :

  !!

  ""!

 !    (     " "     

!    "



  4 $  (

  $"

(

    

 

   !"! "

!" $   ( !!



7 *
;(

* 

  1 !   

1



!"
  

5
1 &
0 6 "

&%.  !"  ( !$(

  !     !

  < (  

    !     !! 

 " !

 "  6     

   "

 ""

   !"$

!  

 ""! (

  "    "

 ! (

   4 !    ""!     1

" ! $

  

"  $



     $  (

  (

 !   "

  "   1

" ! "   !  : !   4   " !

  =" "

 " $ 

 ($"  "

"  !   "  ! $"    $

" "      4   ""   " 6"   $  ( 

 $

 "

"   ""! 6"     ! 4

",



   !"""

!   $ "!"

     "    !" !$ "

  4  !$  ""!  

  8  ""   ! "

 &%.   !  $

 " !

( "( (

 " (   ""!   4   $ (

   !"    

$    (

 !" 1

"! ! "   1

"  <         6      

    " ""    " (  ! 

 

    



 

" 

  1

"  9   "  

     

!

"

 $

 "

       ""!  4   ""     ( "   "   :

          ""!       

    (!  1

!  ""     " !      ( " >! $ "

$ !   $(     "!  

!  !

 

"    1

" !  "   $  "

"  " "   $$

    ""!  $ (

   !"     1

" "  (!   !

  "    ""     6            ! "" "  !$

"  (   $! ""! !  "

 "

 

   (4  $"

"! !

$"

   "

 ?!        $(  "  "( ! "  :  !! 

 $ "

$  

  ""

   7


41

;(

 *@ " $
 


5



41


1


* 4 - 1  A    

   6 !     '&%

1



&
0B  6 "

   " !! (  

    !        

    "

  ""

     !" $

 !    ""!(

 "   "

! (

   4 !    ""!     1

"!$

 

" $



  

$  (

   !" ! (

 !   "

 " 1

" " =""

" $ 

 ( $"  "

 "  !

 " !$"  $

""

    4  ""    6 "      $    (    $



"

"   ""! C $$  

       ! 4

" ,



    !"""

!  $ "!"

 

   
  

        ' 9

     !

"# #   !   " ""!( 

""!

 

  !  

 "

 "





   (

  "  





 

 

$   $ (

  !"  (

     (

  !  

 "



 ( " (!  $   





     4 !          "     

$   4 

  ""

   !!  "

     





 "  

 

$   $" 

 

 ! "    " 6 !   

 !   ,

  9     

!  1"

   ! 



  ""

       ! "



 (

 

   !

 !!"



       !    9  

(  ""

  " !  "( !

 

   





 

"  1

" 9  "  

     !

"

$



"

     ""! 4  "" 

   ( "   "   :

      ""!          (!  1

!  "" 

  
 

    $ 7




 


1

 



'


=










'


#%




 



5



1


5





1
4

 

#%
 '



 1
5


9

5



 

 


>  +4




&




#%


 
 


  



 '
 

<


 
'


 
5
1 '
5
5



 



 '
 




 
 1
5




5
 






1 

4

 




1








4


'
1 








 

1

;


1 '


 



 




1

1


1  

4




5
 


 





1  



 
 





1 


 


 
 


> 


1 '
 4

  







 
 
5

 
'

 




5



 '



 
1








!"#$%
 



 


1  


 
 



 

 





 
!

*

1 1 

5

 


#1  %


1 
 

 
!

'


1
4?



 

?



 1
5



?


5





'
1 

5

  





1 

4


 '

 

 

 

5
 




 
!
 
 
1  
 
 






 


 











 


)*+

<
 
 
1

1 1 

+
 
!
5

 && 5

1&&

5


3
 
5
51

 
 '
'


5
 '




 


'

 9


 
!
 
4

  

 




45'
 





 
'
1


1

1@ 

1  



5

3
  A

5

 
 

 

 

 
!
 '




 




 1

 



'



 
 
 

+ 22



 
!
5 


 

5 


5
 




 




1
'

 
!

 
5





 
'










 






 1
 
 

$- -8 $-2"


 
5 5
1






1

+ 2/


 

*




 '

 
!
5
+ 22




 
1

+ 2/


5 
 
'




 
!

5 


9>



1  


 


5
5

4 






 
5

 
5
1 '


'















 

5  





 


 

 
 
 

+ 22



 
!


 



 '

'
1


 4


 


.8&


B 

2/,$


 
5
1 '








 

 
5





 
'





> '
5 

 

   







 








 



41


1



@"$
5
5 


'
 




 
 
5


5 


!- &;
*




-.

"/
*





 
B 
5



 





 





 




  

@"$5









  *
5



 



 
 





1 
5
 


 
!
1
'





5
'




 



1





 C1 20.07.2020

(Deepak Sibal) 4





Judge 0
 9
 

D9 
0
+






D9