High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4031/2019dismissed

Sukhram Yadav v. Suchita Vij

2019-09-02Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal12 pages

!"#$%&'

##('&&"

!"" #"$%

!" %"&&"

" ))))) #('&&"*$ "' % "&& !" ! "' ) "' *

(%"&&" +" ,

- "

. ."

% "&& !" % ". "- /"' ) "' *

(%"&&"" ! / & "!!

0%"( % & "&&" %" $

! "("

!!#

( ! $' % 0# -%$' # &!

! & ."! "(. "

1 1 &! &

21! 1 3"

"$"

."# 4#"'"

$'%

5&"

-" ! $' % " 0#

6# (. "

! " 7 7

1%"!".$"

. "&&"$'%/ ! 8# ( 3"

"$"

9% 5&"

%" !"

. %" % "&&"5 "-" - % # &&'

" "

7 + "( % # &&' % &"

"(. "

1 1 " !

" 7 ":% 9% "&&" !

":% -" " .' 2 5* &"

!%4# " 7 2 5* !"% , -" "( %" % "&&" - ( !#! 2; "" & " $"

!.& !

!" .!! "#% '" " " .":

&"'. $""!"!

" -":&& ." % "&&" %& " .":

(&"&"'.% . $ %!# $"

!.& !

!" "&"(.9% " !

" -"&"

9%& "&"

! !#! & $' % " "&" . &"'

( 7 ":% < "

" %"&&":& "'

(%." %&= ) 7

%"&&""

% " !

" " - " =& !#! &! % " - 8( (%" ."

" .

% (" % $"!: "(. 4# 9% "&&" # :=!#%" - % -.%$'"

"' % &"9%"&&"

!. -" =!#%" 9%& (" ! )

(%"&&" $& %

! #$( " 2

9%& !".& %

! #$( " 2

$#%"&&"

# #& 9% & "-"' ."

' " -

( & .%&" %"(.%-"& %

! #$ ( " "( - % ".& " ( " !%"( $# % "&&" $"!% & .% &" %"(./#!"" & ! %" %"&&"%"$"!: # %"(.+!%# 9% "&&"5 "

% - ". "

& "' $6! - % (" ."

' " % "(. $ ( " "$ !" , &"

%"% " =!# "' "(. - % % & /# "!4#"

"! - % % "&&"%"

":" '" 2 2 5* .% # -% !% 2 5*-"":

1 1" 5* 2 7 1 "& '", # %"".# & %"

": % ("# $": ".& &"& " " # &"! - % # "

(%"# &&'-".("( %"-"!" , % '" 7 % "&&" &"

% # ".# " ": % #%".&&"&- %% ("#$#%

#%".> (""

! %! %".&&"& "(. 4# -% !% "" ( 9%# " $ .*$" 9% &"

%" !!" ." " "! " &&

(%# $'%-"!" ! #!+ =!# "(." !

"!"

% 9% " 0# ". # & #! &"" % 6# (.9%

! $'%&" %"$ &""2 1 %6# (. "

%" $ ! % $ #

$' % 5&"

-" ! $'% "0#" &# ."&"" %6# (."

" -* ?@%$" "(. "

1 1 % %"%&"

( ! & $' -"' &!

!& ."! !"! % #9%

! =!#%" # &&'

% # &"

- % % .% %- % &"

!.&"' %" %"

(% ( % " =!# %#(% 0# 3#%. % " "

. " ( ( "

" ( % # &&' "'&"% .!" ("'!%"( !#.$"! % # &&' " . !%"( "#@A 9%##!! #"&&"5 " ("'

&&"0#"%0# "&&"6! ! % "&&" " "

( % " 0# - %# "'

" "!

% & "&&" %" $ & $'%"&&"5 " 0# %"&&"%"""

!!#

( %0#& ." '$'.":

(%* #$.

, "(# "(. " $""" $'%$#'""#% B &"

%$%"

% %*!" "(. " "(. % ' "- %# !" . % $" ("

! "' &!

!& ."!%

0# % "&&" %" " ""

( % 0#"!!& (&" %& 5&"

%"%"-"'."

'" -

(& .%&" %"(., "(# &" "

" -

( 4# $ !

- % &!# " "! " !

!#."! " !" !#& - % "

!#."! %" %"

$" ( % 4# "

5" -

( , "(# %" " & !" #& $' % & "(. -" =!#

1 1 " % ."

% &"'.#&!$ 1$## :

(&!

!& ."! % "(.%"$ # %'"

, #%"(# * $-!$ 1 !$

":"' & "' !#&%"&&"!"

(#&% .=!# %" % ( !%&" & ("( -"'("%&" &! %-

((%" =!# " ( % #$.

$' !# %" % &!

! & ."! "

! "' " % ". !" $ "-

" ("%"& %"(. "!#& - % "

" -

(& .% &" %"(., #% "(# %"% &- $=!

""$' "$ " '"

"!! "! - % # 6#

" & !

& " . !## !

" "!" !

!#."!%"(" !."'$ # " #. && %"

# "

""( &" 0#-# "(#%" % "!"%"."'"-% !% -# " %-"' & 5&"

: #(! % 0# ("

! "' &!

!& ."! "(.

) &&# $'%9$ (%.% ! !#%"&

!% "

! "'

(%# :

(&!

! & ."! "(.,"

"(# %"#!% "C 6%" =& % ("! - % (" " # . ."

$"!:

%"(. #&$'% %- %(" &"* &"'.# ":

($'%"&&"=!#%" - % -.% ) 7

, #%"(# %"#!% "C 6%" =&"

% #! " # &"'. &#& ' ."

% "&&" %"&%"(.

- .% $"!: "(. % !#. .": " <= % "

!!"$ "-%"% .' #"!!# .', #% "(# %""&&

,!.9"=! ) &"'.$' 5*!"$."

!"% % %"( &"'. !"% ."

$' % & "

" " "#' &

(!# "

($"!:.'"

" " #"#' &

% %0#%"

-('=!

! "' &-$'"- (&!

!& ."! "(. 4# 0# & ( % & 5&"

%" #&& !!#

( ! $' % 0# - %% #$.

%" % ". #

.(" "-.#!%& '%"-# !"

! "&&", #%"(# %""&&"-%%" $ # $ ($"" $' '

(%"(. ""

"&" ":

("" #% '

" #&"'.."

. . . !

!#."! !" : #(! % 0#

' &!

!& ."!, #%"(# %4# . "-%"$ (""&"

=&"

%.'

$'% .-" ".'"!

" "!!# %- &" !#"' %!

!#."!%"#!%&"-""

$' % "&&" % - ". , #% "(# %" 5&"

%"!"( !"'" %"%$"

.' . %(" *&"

!%"( (% "$

'# %"(. " -%$'%&"

".' ":%"% . "(. " ."

(".#

"-% !%- #'"!:- ( $'%"&&" % !=".

" +-# #%"(#%"% '&"

%"!

" "( $-%&" $#"&"

! !#! -% !%-"$ !# $'%"&&" " % "

"! %" $ #' ! % . "

) 7

$ %- ( "&&"" " $' % ".' "6 " .": " " =% $ 9% " #$.

$'!# %"

. " ) 7

% "

"' ""! %"

( #!

" $#"$% ." # :=!#" - % - .%$# !.& (%& #( ("

(-""( . (' .' "('" %" % & ,%"

%" !# %&" &# %&"&*$: &" !#"' % 6# (. .&#( " !& !#. #&&

# ( !# %" ( !! -% %" $ #!% $' !# %&" 9%

! "

$' !# % "&&"

" $'%0# "&&"%"$(" $''

#& 6# (. +D$ % #&. 0# ! "# $"

!%&!'&!#()!*+',#%"-./)()0%'!"#" ,%"

(

%#(% "!#"

(! $'%

&&"0#" " "-"

- !"#1"2!"##&"$#

.' #"$

- %

( %

&&" 0# "!!& ! % "&&" %" "(. " !" . $" :

( &!

! & ."! .' $!"# % ". %" $ ( $' % &#!%" " "#% B &"

% $%"

%" $ (%' % $' % 0# "&&" %" % "(. ( $' % " %".-""!!& $'%&#!%"-%."

&"'. % . . . -% !% - #' "!:- ( $' % "&&"$'.":

( . % -%" - (%$"!: "(." "&""& ! &"&,%

- %."

! "

$'%"&&" &"'.

" "$$ 6! 9% $ ( % 0# &" % "&&" %" % %" & (

! )! %&!

! ! ) - %(" "

" -

(& .% &" %"(.&%"(. %&&'-""( $ " #. 7 ":% # -% !% ":% - &"

" " .' " &" &"'. - ."

- . <= " ! & <= 9% "&&" % - %" ."

" . " ) 7

( ! & " !

" " -"! !#! " %"

.%"$" $' % "&&"5 " ' % $' -"' % . %"&&" "

"' *=!# " " $#"$% ." %# :=!#%" - % - .% . ) 7

! % & %" ""

!%"( %$ (" &"'% "!

" " %"

(%= &"'

(! !#! -% !%-"$' % !& "(.!#& - %%"&&"%"

%"%-" & $ "' %""! #!

' #$.

$' !# % "&&" !%"(

( % 0# %" % "-"'."

'" -

(& .%&" % "(. " !"' ! " % # .

(

! "

#! $' % & " "

$' % "&&"5 " ! =".

" 9% "&&" % &!

!"' "

. % &"

%" " !

" ""

' &"

& (" ! # $'%& " & ! !"

(% "!"

"'#!% #$ %0#-% .":

( . " ) 7

% % !"$"- "

" "!#"! ' ! "&&"%"

- "(((" &"'.."

"".'

. %$"!: "(." !#.<= %& %"

&"'.%"":%-" $""!"!

" ,%

- %." ,

- %

( %0#%"% 5&"

"-"'."

'" -

(& .%&" %"(. % "(#. "

$' !# % "&&" "("

!& ."! "(. % # "'

(% # -% !%-""."

"(# ""!:

( "

" -

!# ."

% $ % ! . #" "!!

('6!

%" $ (%' "(# $' !# % & % #!%4# . "-%" !

( &"

.# =&"

%".'-% !%-"&"

# %"(.$""!" !

"' $&"

$'% %"""!!# #! #!%&"-""

$'%"&&"%"

"!!& ."

"%&"'.! % !#.<= % ". %"

" (" #! %# !" $ ": !

" =!

! # %& % % %"

.' & $' " $#' &#!%" ( &&' #"!!# %!.&"#% ' ""&&& ""! "("

% .5%0# %"&&"%" !

"'6# (. %""'"" %" "# &!

!& ."! "(. % &"

%""$ (" '=&"

% !"&"!

'&"'$""! " !

" $# " =&"

%" .' &"

5 $ &"

"!!# ,%

- %." ! "

$'!# %"&&" % (" !"'- (% "' &"'. !"% $' 5* !" $ ( .' $!"# % " &

,!. 9"= ! %" $ (" &"' .' . %" 5*$'-"' !%4#9% "&" !%"&&"%"

"!!& &"'. $' 5* !"% % !" $ "- ":

""( % --(!"- ((# % "$

'=!# %" $'!

(%"% !# &"'.'$' 5* !"%, #%"&&"%0#%"%! %"

$'%"&&"- %"!" - ((# % $ (" # %"(. ."'$ $!"# & ! %&&' %"

3 =!

! -%% "- &!

! & ."!""

! '-# 6# ! ! #! $% % &" "#. (

!"! , % !" " %" ! #! % "&&" " " " $"

, % - ". % %" =!# "(. " "

" &" %"

(":" 2 2 5*"&"'. 2 2 5*-"."

$'-"' !%4# %# !# $ + &" "-" && "&" # (% !=".

" +""

"&"%"%# 2 2 5* $# % &

# % ".& &"& %"

$": ("# , #"!!&"$ %" " &# ." -# # .' - %# # !#. - % "( $": ("#"""! &"!:- ( (&"'.9% ! #&$'%"&&" '=!# "(. &"'."" .' " #$4# &"'. ( "

" $

- % "&&"%"

% .$"!: "(."

!#.<= $ % %" " # % (5 " (" -% !"#(% ($"" %!": #(! ("

! !"("

% "- %! &"' =!

! "'6#

! ,-# %""

% " !" % "&&" %" "

"' #!% ! &" "$ # ! % &!

! ! ) "'B

."'"( !%"(% .&#( 6# (. -* # % "!#"' ("' % "$ $ 6! " "!!

(' 9$ %"&&" !#%" #&6# (. +D$ % #&. 0# 3 !*4!55! .+#!+/ 67 8 " $"

!&##+9&##%"!6.+#!+/678 "!*+!*',#%-.:/ ;:- !*40*!', *!*+!55! % ,)(!55! !*!") $" !&&!*!"! !*+ ',#%"- ./ .)()/; " 6+0! 7!!4)!*+',#%"$"

06)",!%!7)!*+!*',#%-8!'#"'!"#8!<; = %6# (.!

"$"%"$" (% "! %!""%" "' #!% " %" $ "

- -% !% !" $ # # % "&&" % !

( ! $' % 0# 9%"$ ( %"&&"!"

"'"

""( .% "#% ,

- -%"%"$

!# % $

( . %"&&" " "!!

- 38/ E/#" D F%%&":

(5" '5 F%%&"$ '5