M/S Sgm Packaging Industries v. M/S Goyal Plywood Llp
! !"#$#%&
'$( ") *#%*%+,$ -#!$ ../#" % '$0 //01+22 !$.%+!% $ &342( (2(22
Present:
Mr. D.S.Sobti, Advocate for the applicant.
Mr. Vikram Amarnath, Advocate for the respondent.
2(225
- /
!
#
$ % #
# "" # " &' !"
"#
#
"
(
"
$ )
(
# # " &
!"
"# (
$ )
# " # *
"
(
( +,-$ (
.( /
# 0 1
./01
" # )$',' , 23$ % #
(4
" / ' # / # 0 54
# ' +,,- //05
4 4
,6$,-$+,+, $
'!
+,$,-$+,+,
( ./01$%
+
!
"4
'
& 3+
7
&
' ./01
4 #
$/ 4'
#
+
' #(
$
# (
+,$,-$+,+,'& 38$
"
( "
4
+
$% #
# (
#
# 4 (+,-$9
"
6 8 //05
(
'
"$ 1 '
#
" 4(
' #
$
4 # (
(
6
#
" # # $%
3 # " ( "
//05
./01
" 4$ %
#
# ( 4( 4 + $,:$+,:
4
( # *
$% ./01 +-$,+$+,+,
#
#
$$' $
'
;"$ '
# "(
$ 9
#
#
+ 8
+,$,-$+,+,'
8$,<$+,+,$
! (
6$,<$+,+,$
)=> $8 +,+,
8<
5 ;"' ?"#' "
6$,<$+,+, !
$>
)=> $8 +,+, 8$,<$+,+,'
4 $
'
)=> $ +,+, $$'
8<
5 ;"' ?"#' "
" !
(
"'
! +$,<$+,+,$ % #
# 4#
' +$,<$+,+, (
5 ;"'?"# )=> $ +,+,
# (
' # ($ %
(4
#'
4
7
$$')=> $8 +,+, 8$,<$+,+,$ % #
(
$$')=> $6- +,+,'
'
! +<$,<$+,+,
4(
( )=> $ +,+, (
;"' ?"# +$,<$+,+,
'
+<$,<$+,+,
$ "
4
& ( +$,<$+,+, 8$,<$+,+,
5 ;"'?"#$)=> $ +,+,
# ( # ,$,6$+,+,$ 9
#
4 " #
' " 4( # //05 $ 0&
*
3 #
./01
//05 #
6 $
+
' "
( # (
$/ 4'
'
"
# '
4 #(4
$
'
#
#( (
4
(
" (
4(
//05 $% (
# $ .
4"
"
$
8 >
#
(
=
"
"#
' '
4
( 4 !
"
6 //05 4
6 //05
4 !'
$'
$
4
"
#
( ./01'4 +-$,+$+,+,
(
4 $ .4
'-'< 6 //05
@3 A $ 2# 9#/# 0 9,0!- : )! . 0:!% BC (
("
(4
( (' ( #! (# "
#
' "#
'
(@
"
(
" & (3 4 ( (
( #
$ -$ ! -: 1;#"; %+ - ! 1;#"; #% !-!$ #$ . 0 9/!<C ((
#! (# #
'*
' ( '
" (
" ( "#
(
(
# '
(
# (
#
( ' #(' ## (
"
'
# !
( )4=!$ <$ !"=!-0 :,% +,!<1 ( "
4 (
' (
( #
-$ 6$ !
!-!%"! #"- %+(: //% !-.-#$!$ "#/# #% ,%"#/< >
"(
" (
# ' (
#('
"
(#
<'#!
/ #0 1
$ + D
3
#
! (
"
4 (#!
'
-
6
'::-+- ::-
(
%%% $ 8 C
3
+
(
#
'
!
(
"
4
'::-+- ::-
(
"#
3
< $ >
"(
" (
# ' / #0 1
"
4 47
7
( ( % $ 04(#
( ( #!
> $E
(
"
//05 ' 4
#
./01 //05
" 4$.
# '$(#/.##%+,$ -#!$! "5?$ @!-!/ ( ! + - %$.- -.- #% %+ % ;!- ! "5 #=#/ ..! /$8> 38>
5+'+ A
5 @3 A+8$ "
(
#! (# '
# !
()4 =! 4 (( ( # # 4(
/ # 0 1
# +,,- ("" 4( ' 4(
+,,- $
+8 "
4 4 "
" (
(
# $1 # D7 )
"
#'# # #
$
'::- " / ' # / # 0 54
# ' +,,- "
# ' # # # 4( $E % (
//05 4 4 4 "
$ 04 & "#
(
' 4
//05
#!
#"# ('
"
4
( "
# # //05 $
(
($
6 //05
'
'"# "
#
4 (#
' 7 $ %
"#
$'
+-$,+$+,+, (
4 7
" (
$ % 4
"
4 # $ % #
8$,<$+,+,$)=> $8 +,+, (
6$,<$+,+, "
6$,<$+,+, (
(
! $ #
('
(
5 ;"' ?"# +8$,<$+,+,
( $)=> $ +,+,
8<
" (
! +$,<$+,+,(
5 ;"' ?"# #
$ D +$,<$+,+,
(
5 ;"'?"#'@3 A
2 8<
::- 4( ( "# $% !"
$ 9$
#
& + $,<$+,+, #
!
(#
$9$
# #
(
4(
&
#
$ %=#!1 ;!-!B,!$ : +!90/+",%$!/.-%,%"!:!% ;! 1 -+#$$ 0!+$ !:.; $#$ ++!+
A >
"
4
1F
$ 8$,<$+,+,$5
("
4$E )=> $8 +,+, (
#
5 ;"' ?"# (
8$,<$+,+,$1 '
+$,<$+,+,'
#
"
= +<$,<$+,+,'
#
#
$ 9
"
& 4 (
! # D%53:'
# ##
*
( #
$.
4'
&
# "
4 # &$ 9
5 ;"'?"#'
# )=> $ +,+, ,$,6$+,+, ( 4 # #
# (
( $ " '
# (
'
44
#
#
' 7
" (
$%
+
@3 A12. Grounds for challenge.-
(1) When a person is approached in connection with his possible appointment as an arbitrator, he shall disclose in writing any circumstances likely to give rise to justifiable doubts as to his independence or impartiality.
(2) An arbitrator, from the time of his appointment and throughout the arbitral proceedings, shall, without delay,
disclose to the parties in writing any circumstances referred to in sub-section (1) unless they have already been informed of them by him.
(3) An arbitrator may be challenged only if- (a) circumstances exist that give rise to justifiable doubts as to his independence or impartiality, or (b) he does not possess the qualifications agreed to by the parties.
(4) A party may challenge an arbitrator appointed by him, or in whose appointment he has participated, only for reasons of which he becomes aware after the appointment has been made.
&&&
14. Failure or impossibility to act.- (1) The mandate of an arbitrator shall terminate if- (a) he becomes de jure or de facto unable to perform his functions or for other reasons fails to act without undue delay; and (b) he withdraws from his office or the parties agree to the termination of his mandate.
(2) If a controversy remains concerning any of the grounds referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1), a party may, unless otherwise agreed by the parties, apply to the Court to decide on the termination of the mandate.
(3) If, under this section or sub-section (3) of section 13, an arbitrator withdraws from his office or a party agrees to the termination of the mandate of an arbitrator, it shall not imply acceptance of the validity of any ground referred to in this section or sub-section (3) of section 12."
.
# -.- #%?$2
%+# 2 +5
(7>' 4@3 A +,-## '
#( #(
#A "
E
'
#7
&
($ "
("
# '
+
4 #!
(
"
4 ' # A "
E
$ D #
"
'
'
' #7
#
# ' ' " A "
E$ %
7
#
'
(
"
8$
! 7
( '
#(
+
2 #
" $
' "
" 1 '
"
4
7
('
4
#
"(
8$ % "
'
7
2
' #
"
8 #! $ % ( #' ( "
# " 1 #( #!
"
8 " $% '
' ( " 1 "
# ;
5 ;
9
"
"'
"
(
"
4 $ ' &
# 1
#( "
#
$ (
( ( $E
.
# ; - - +9 %+ ! 1-) 2#:# !+?$%# !+!/!":$2#:# !+5
A ( 767' 4 @3 A<$ #
+'8' ' '
#!
!(
"
47
('
#
#( "
+
+
8$ .
4'
#A "
E
' *
"
'
$ % ' $$'
+ '
"
#
#'#
$$' 7 '
#
+ "
$ "
#
#
( '
(
$%
( 4( # 7
#
' (
(
# '
" (
$ '
+ ' "
4 $ %
' " 7
#
'
(
"
#
+ '
4 ' (#(
(
# $G
#( (
(
#(
( "
#
4 ' 4
+ $ #
+ #
$
# 4( H
+
4 ( &
6 "#
"
( # *
4 "
#$E ' ' #(
(
4
# '
$)
" (#
!/;# #*; ,- #% ( !=!/.!-$ %+ % - " -$ -#= ! 2#:# !+=$/.; -. !=!/.:!% -#= !2#:# !+ %+ ;!-$5
A
2866$9
( "
$ >
"# $
"4 ( #
#
$ C2(22D
,+*! $); % C !
"2 @ I2> $ C
@ I2> $