← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20686/2024allowed

Mahesh Kumar @ Mahesh Bansal v. State Of Haryana

2024-05-02Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain16 pages



       

   



!

"#$# %     &$& '() * +  &$& %$ ,

-------- # # %*

.*$($

/

!

*0 %

--------$1 %2%

  34 - /   ' 



  



           ! " # $%   ' 

- 6* ,7

&  %        '   '   ()* + ,--   .

&/ // 01  &2 '     ! 3/3/3&43-353.35&&/ 6 )70! 3/4)7 2! &,7 !8  /&5 !  79!#  !  7      /, /3   7*

&3/3 /3 "

 %    6  % ' '  % 7  '

:&  8           %    ! 3,47   '' '  '  "'()*





- !!%"$ 1(%#$& 8,

(%2* /"

# %$ 9#$ *2

-5  5 /5 /& 3/3/43&43-35 3.35&&/ 6 )7 !  ! 7 %#  ! 35  3 &/ // 3/3&43/3-35 3.35&3/4&/

6)7 !  ! 7 %#  ! ,3.  3 &/ // 3/3&43/3-35 3.35&3/4;&/ 6 )7! &, 7   !81  !82 !  7 9!#   ! -.  5 /5 /& 3/3/43&43/3- 353.35&&/

6)7 !  ! 7 %#  ! 33  3 &/ // 3/3&43/3-35 3.35&3/4;&/ 6 )7  !  ! 7 %#  ! -/  3 &/ // 3/3/43&43/3- 353.35&;&/ 6 )7  !  ! 7 %#  ! 3  3 &/ // 3/3/43&43/3- 353.35&&/

6)7  !  ! 7 %#  !      '     ' %  ,  7                6           /.

/ /3 '

:1111111  ,  7     02              1 $% <8   '  ! ,5" ! ,.  '

   

  )7

 

 

 

 

       

          

  

     ! "

    

   

  

 

       #$$ "    

%    &

 

       !       

    '       

    

     !"

 (            &

  &$   





  



 )" 

* + 





    



 , -   &        

   

   

 . , - 

   &    . , -

 &             . , -   

   



.,- "    " "

   . , - likelihood of the offence being repeated; (vii) reasonable apprehension of the witnesses being tampered with; and (viii) danger, of course, of justice being thwarted by grant of bail (see Prahlad Singh Bhati vs. NCT, Delhi 2001 (4) SCC 280 and Gurcharan Singh vs. State (Delhi Administration) AIR 1978 SC 179). While a vague allegation that accused may tamper with the evidence or witnesses may not be a ground to refuse bail, if the accused is of such character that his mere presence at large would intimidate the witnesses or if there is material to show that he will use his liberty to subvert justice or tamper with the evidence, then bail will be refused."



/  

 0  !  "

     

       *1 +   2 "       

"

 3  

    



 



 



*1, -4

   5., -4  

   " 

6, -       

"  

 7 "

 &  5  ,

 &

& 

 

 8 $

-"     

 8 $



&9



 

 "   3  

 

     

 

  

   :"        

      

 

  ;

      

    





 "



    5           

   " $ 



   

  

      



        &   4      &    

     " $    

   #  $  $   %           &  

 ''

( 

* + //4

   

   <

 

  



  



 &  

 

   

  ) *  +"  % ,% "  '

-. " 

5            & "    8 $

  

  

5 "    $ 

"        

 

"

       & 

  "  

   



      &



8  

  "

         

"     *1 )" ) *+"  %,% "  '

-. / =! "



  

 

    

0

     

   



 





 





 

 

&        :"     

    &   

   <  5       &

    



 

   

>   

 < 

      & 

      

 

         

&+ ;

 

     



 

       

"

 

 

  

  

%  

     &

  

  

      

 8  

     &         

   

   &  

 

5   

  





 "  

    & 

  



 

     

 

  

  

 "

   

      

   &   "     

   

  



  &

      0

&   

   

1 1



   

    

 01 

   

2/ +!  

5

 

" 

 <



   *   &

 

  &      1       "    



8

< .

 & 

 

&  

   

  

"  



 

&    &   &       

             &  & 

"



   

 "      &



"   " 

"      

"   

   &   

5  

 ? 



           

"  

  

       

 0

 " 

  & 





 

    & 

     

 

     8



 5  "  "

 " 5



&  

&  "

:

   "

 

     

     <   /4   

      

4    

 " " & 

&  &$

 "  

  

 

& 

 &   

 1   & 

  8  @ " 0" A B  "       

&  &   

&   

 4     



  

    

      &   

0;

&34,356, 37& / 

      

 

& &  

     

   

 

  



  5



&         &"

 

      

  &"  &        4       

 

 

"        





  

& & %

  &"

<

     

&   

  

 /7    

      

 

     & C &"

   

" 

  "   "  

  

 $&        

 

  &    

&      D  & 

  5

  



  

 $    

 



  

& 

  5   

 

 

  *! 08 9 %!  

2-"





* +/  :

      

  "  



&

  

&   &  

 $

"   D

   

         8  7=    :   5





&     +

 

&       

; B  <  : 

"     

  8 7="     

 :   

       

  

   

       



5   

    

   

  

    

       & 

 

  :    

 

  E    E           <

& 

 *  &8 7=     : 





  

 



   &        " 77 

   

 



 

 

 

. &     8 (/ 1$

1 "   &     F 8  7=

  !G    :  

     

    &      &     

  

    

   

    

& 

 

" 

 

  

   "

  

"  

  

  

 

   

            %  " 

      

 

:  

   &

   

" :   



;

 D     









  





          

5     $ =?=?   

 





 

       



 & 4   

 

<

  2'    

:   

5      





  &  

   

 5     

 2'" : 

 

 

 

  

     &

 

   



  

   

  

 

              

    

   H<

& 

& 



 E  

      &"  : 

 8   

          

 D 

    

 E    

         "  "

 

          



  C 

   

   C

         D "    &       

  

   ,  &- I    "   

&     

  ;,

 - 78   &"  

 #$

     

 & &



(  $ *1 + :"     

    &  

& 

 

 

$  8   ,

-    



    &

<

 

 

' 



 

 $#   %) 0* '

' & &

$

2 

*1 +   

           

  :)  8    B  5 8

   9

 ,

-        



:) 8    A 7  B  5 8

   9

)  

 ,

- 

 

*1 + 7 



         



  



" 

  

   



 

 

 

   

5"     

 

   

           &

 

   "  &"         

   



 "

    

   



-



 &   

  



  . - 

 

   

    

  . -      

     

    

"      



  1

      

 "  5       



     

  

"            

&    



  

& !

?!=?

?"     

" 

(?=?

 !?

=?

"  

   

<<

  &

 

5   

  

 



& 

    

   

&      " $  =

  

 $      8 

 )  

 ,

- 

5 

 <

  & 

   

 

 

J   " :) 8    

8   ,

-



*1J

(   

 

"

    &  

J   

J



  

 )        

 

  

 <   " &  

 

&  

   

&      & 

 





  "   

  " 

"       

    

 

 &

 *  

< 

5   

   

    "     

        $  %  " 

 &

" 

 

' 



J



   

J        &        

 

      

        &" 

  

 

  

   &    

  

   &        "  

 

  B

  @ "   

:  "    "   

    &

         

&

     < 

        

<

&

  D"   &   

     D   &    

 " > &  5 # '

 '

 1,=??(-=8

="



J        &" 

   1

" 

 

  

&     & 



     

           <



  

 $  =

" 



 D &   0

     

   



   

 

    

       

  

3 

  &



    

    

"    

  

"  

<  J

?  8   )  

 ,

-  :)   

        

 

        

  

    

     

 8

<    

 

   

   

&" &" 

     8        $     :"   

   5     

&     $ =

 

  

  &     

& & 

 

   

"   5  

  

& 

   &           

   

 & 

  

          



< 

= 8      

               

    

&            &                K         

  

&   

A





       



 8

< "



     

 & &  &  



         &  

    

& 



     

    



&  1



  

 8

 <    

 

  



 

&"&"

 

     8       

   $     :"  

  5     

&     $ =

 

  

  &      

&  &    

  

"    5  

  

& 

   &           

    

& 

 

       



!     "      

 



  

    

          

&  

&  

  

   

 

    

  

&   

  

         

&      

;

<

? 

, -

      

      

  

&  

 0    <

  

    2' A( 

 =? =?

/" 

   

 8  ?/"  " =?" /(" / " /7   ,8 ? =?10



-

 8

 8

8 

&"B

  8 



  8

   

 



 

= >     

 

" 

    

 

"  

 



 

 &

        

   8

>  $ ) 

,

-"  

 

  





     



 

    3B

& 9



!A

 



  &        

 

  1    

 $  

< 



     

5     

     3 3 & & 

3



3





   3      

   

   

 

        &  

&

 

A

&    

 

       





($ &       

;







   2'

& 

 #$ $       

" 2'

      

   

  2

 

 

 $ 0

 (

 8



 

     

 

 

"



   & / $'    '"

   /.

/ /3  

<

  % !          "  6    "     '   ' = %  

   9 87 =# % '    + % '      1    > ,  '  "   %     %  %            "        '   ' = %      9 87 =# % '    + % '        1          

/ /- /3  6 ' 

 ?

 '=@ ?

*  +