High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11815/2021disposed of

Union Territory And Others v. Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh And ORS

2025-02-10Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma15 pages

!"#$%&' !$%$(%)#$%&

& *+

, -

, ,, ,

! "#$ %&'() *+( , ( !-.

'( !('/' ( ' (#(- *+( 0'12(-+( )(( %((% *+( 0'(-+(2 3 ,

, -

. 5 '!''(/ ''2 # '( !('

(#0'!( 0' ( 67556868 , 9 25.

/'"# ' -( (-

%(* "(- ,'(0 0 ' +(-- ( ' .

'( !(' +'

'( :(' - ( 5;8<685= ( '( + '+ '+(0'(-+(2 3 '0%0%'0

'(0 (!(' 9! *(+(+# 0 # %%( ( ( 0 0 0 * (--+:(-"00((0(#( (--/(+(

#/'( 0/%'0%' (0+0( +0 +#0'(

/)0(/1/)23!$(%# 6 3 (--# ) # '( !(' -+ (

5;835<<5 /( % ( 00+(! " + 558;5<<; ( * ( 6<585<<> '"+(%0'% (+ '+"( ?' (+ ' + ( "# ' 5856685@ A268=8;26855- (B'( !'

%(( ' 3/(% ( #

0-+!-("(* ( 8785685; ' ( % /( !( (--# /0 66866855 " ")+'+ % ' ( 8785685;

+- !'+%0'# !0 %( A6>8606853( A67<=;06856 3 3/(0'"!'C C( /( % '(D0

/0858;688<* E8;2

,5.2685<E6@65 ( 5<866868 ( "+(% "# ' '( !(' %( 7 (%''('(*'

(0)("

0%0%'0

'( 0'

0-+, .

"'( !('-+ '(-# 0(+ 0 %(-#0' 00+' (+ 0 0 00+'( !('-+'

'( !(' %(%0 +-38<0' 0 ('(0(% (0%-+# ( 358=685@/'!( !*! ,/ (D %. *2(2* ' (D 0

0-+ ''

0'( !('-+ /' ( '( -+# '-!"-#0(D0

0 -+ '( '

/' ( '/00%( '(*+%- 56#(0*+(

/--"!( /(D%( /--"2 !( (

' / /(# ? ' %(! '( !('

%('(0(% (#((- '!*!' '( !('-+ ( ('0+( ( 53855<<6

''( !(' %(0--/!'*0)(" -+ *+- 5<@<,'(00'+(-- ('

5<@<. @ ' *%0)("(% ' 5<@< 6;56688;

( '- '(%'(D0 '(--"%( 0%'(D0

,"'% 0%'(D0+( (- +-#+ .

#/''('(*!9#(+ *+'(D0

,"(*.

' '"(0%2 +%2#")+'(*(-("-#0'(+ 0 ('"#'?(+ (%0%%% ; '( (% %%( "#' *%0)("

/(*( "#''( !(' %( */0' 0(+ '(/'+'%0%'0

('''( !(' %( '(0(% /-+# ( 358=685@'0 ' (% % %( 5<@< "# ' )(" *%/((-+("-''( !('-+ = ' '( !(' %( '( ( ' ( * ((-, .

'/''(*(-0' *%0 ( ' +--(/( ('#0 %

00( *0 ('( (+ 0%%( (( ' 0 # %%( ( ' ' 0 %%( (:*(- 0-+( '0

# %%( ( :*(- ' 0 (-

0-+ +''( !('-+ '(* 00+ 0 ' ( (D +( '0 ' 0 %%( (

0-- "#( 00+0

+( (

'0 #%%( (/"!0-- "#(D!("- 00+ 0 (- (D 0% )("

(#(( ( -'

%( " ( > 3 "% ( ( 6=86685= ' * ' %( # '( !('

0+ (( %'0 # %%( (

'! '('(%0--'(D0

0-+, .( + 3/( % (

/066866855 ( 0'/0858;688<

'0 '-!"-0'(%

< ':0 30%'(D 0 0-+ /()+ "#' %(* ( 5=56685> '! '('*(+(+#' (D0 , .'( !('-+ '%(0% 0% ' (D 0

( '( ' )(" - !*! ' %0%'(D0

(-- !( 58 '(0 30- "0'(-

%(*"(- '( !(' +'

/'"# '%( ( (- '( ' , '. " + + '+-(%0%( 0-+ (!( '9!*(+(+#0 #%%( (

' '(D0

0 -+ ' "! ' % ( -!"- (( %0' 5<@<((% 6;56688; 55 ' ( "+(% (--/ * ( 67556868'-*(((!('(++'( * +( 9(+ '(0 58 A'(*+ '"%%( "'(-00"' %-#?%'-( !0'( '%0 + ('+((( $2

!! " !

! #$!

%& !$'

(

)

$ *+* $!!'

! $

! ,

!& !$'

(

(" "

$!"' ' !

- !

(

$$ !

!$ !

"' !

! 55 ?0(-- /+ + '5F6 %-(-#((0%'-( !'(' '%-*( %- ( 6;586858, 9 266./ "# *%0 ('( !(' %(+*#!( +0%!0+( 0 (* ((-/'' 9!+( 0'( !('-+'

'( !('-+ !* "#'-05<@<(++ !/'+'%' (D0 0-+"%( 0%'(D0

'(*!9#(+*+'(-+(/(% (

/0858;688<( (+'"+(%-!"-0% /0858;685@(- '(''%

'0 +( ++!G '('/(-!"-0 %"/(!*%0''( ( -%(-#% +*-# '+' '(" + (9+0#( -!"-#(-0% '!'' +("(--/ ( ( +-(%'('(2 ( 0%/- "+ ( 9+ */ 0 ' 0(+ '- '( +( 0 '( !('-+( (* ((-'( !('

+%%( (-+(-!"-0%'0

0 -+E # %%( (

# '( !('% $4/!/ /5 %)$4 )!(607%0 (1 .

/ 81/##59! 8$%#%0 6 )$%)!%#.59"6!0($4$0646)/06$% #/0#:;;.0< (1 $4;;=$(1#/88190$0<8$ 0$4 8(09$77/%#/%0.=<6)<6 8/!0$40<</%#63/!< $16) /#! '((%(# '0(+'(/--- -(/'(' +%-/'+'((-+("-('%0*(+(+#/- (-# ( ' ":-# 0(% +% - 0 %(- <( .=</"%$< 60/06$%6%(8<$1#6%3 0<81/$40</8816)/%00</0 6%)0</8816)/%05)/7163651 4$!8!$7$06$%6%. $0< )!(607%0 (1 $4 (%>/5=$(1# 5/8816)/510$<67 <?( 06$%/ 0$=<0<!0< (1 $4;;=$(1#/8819 0$0<)/03$!9$40</8816)/%0$!%$06 %$1$%3!! 6%03!//%#

0/%# 001# 59 /8@ #6 8% /06$% 6% 0< )/ $4 , -

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

H%"(("-+'( 9!('%'-(- '(/- "(D (++-0++9%(# +('/A0 +'+9"#(0/'+'/%(#(!%(!''( ''('%(! !(-'(+'( 9 0%( 0(00(+/'+'%(# (( 9('%-(- /'+'%(#*(#( 00 %H-#'( %0((=0 ( ! >3E685@-(!!

((- '( !(' H -- (+ - + ( ! -(-+("-''( !('-+/--"(-+("- ' %-# 0 ( ( (( > H( H

'( !('(!(-(( (+-0'( !('-+( /- 0%+( 53 //+ + ':,7.(/''' 0 #%%( (E % '(*"("-' */0'(*!%( 0-- 0+'(-!% %0<6 6 (.0< 0/%#0/2%59/8816)/%0/%#6%$(!"6=!63<019.6 0</0 #76%3/5$1606$%$40<8$ 0$48(09$77/%#/%0 6 %$05$!%$(04!$70<!)$!#/ /#7600#19 /1/!9/3/6% 0$%$4 0<0<!8$ 0 6%0<!/%2$4,(8!6%0%#%0$4 $16)</#5% #!/=%/%#8/6#0$ ! /!#8-(7/!. 4!$7(3( 0'

0$;B/%#/40!=/!# 4!$7B0$;'B0$

!-</3 <</%#/!6 <( .0<8$ 0)/%%$050!/0#

/ /5$16 <#7$! $=<%0</8816)/%0)1/67 0$51636514$! 8!$7$06$%$%C60 14</"6%35%36"% %6$!609/ , =4C; ''(-0'( -((D"#' '('(-+( (/!!( (#0;;88E2( (+' -!"-0%'0 - E '+ '/'((-+(/( (/!(# 05@;8823<588I

( (#;;88E2, 9 26;.(#+( ' (0 %0'(-+(( ( ( 858;688< '"#' '("!( ( (#0;;88E2/0858;6853( 0 =;88E2 /0 858;685> ' * ' -( -! (*(-("-' '((-+(' % # 0-+ '( !(' -+ '(*!#'( +( /0858;688<(#+( ' ++0("-0(- ++%( %(-/'+'0(+!" ( (+''( "'- '(''("("-' %!0+ %/'(-+(/((*(-("-0+'%(# +( '/(+ ( + 7;<E6858 - B

? F

+ ;566858"#(D-% +'0'"(-'- !

'(':0("-0"0-- 0 %(- :( ' % ("- 0 ++ (-+("-' ++%:(-# %-(*//( (D <86E6853 -

+ 635685= "# (D-% +'0'"(- ' @@@@ 5; */ 0 ' (0( + ' % (++(+( (+'(--/ '%! 9 5:(' ( ( ' ( + + '+(0'(-+(0%''!'%0 ("*"*(( 00 0%'%0% (/' (--'+:(-"00((0(#( (--/(+( # /'( 0/%'0%' (0+0( +0 +#0' '(( '/* -0"(' /+J

56 ?-!(!!* 0%'(0( '2 #( ''(*0- '(!('(/ %4!%) $40<6 $(!0 53 '+0+( (D"#' '(

0 ( "# ' '( !(' %( ' :( ' (% %%( "#')(" *%' 5<@< 6;56688;

/'"# '(!'+0 -#' 00+ *!-#')("-+ "+%% ' 0 0 -+ (' %(D ' +-(% 0 ' 3 /'(%%"0''( !('-+ " 9%-#/(D 57

/* ' ( 0(+ "+(% +*(- "# ' -( "(-'!' (/!++0%() !%%( "# ' 9+(6"6188/1$B:$4;;B- ( %6$% !!60$!9$4</%#63/!</%# 0<! D /> <-(7/!/ /%#<6 /%#%$0<!

' ,C'-(+(%( '( ) !%((-(+ (' ' C"-

%/(0(+ /''0(+0%(D!((0 ''9!- -(! %!'(!+( *2(2 * ' +% ' 0 ( + #E(/ 00+ ' ( - ( "+(% 0-- 0 ( "+% 9(+ '(0 .

#"" $

#% % & !

# "

#( #

)( #

!0 $!((& $

($"1

( "

! !$1"#

!! "

(

$1"( "

!' '"

$1"

5@ ' C"- %') !%,(.

/'- %(D!((0'("*9(+ - ((! ' !% !*! ' + 0 *+ 0 '

( '(-*- *+(

(

'( %(* +-0 ' %(0 #0'( !('

'++- '('+ 0*+ 0( /''"+%-( "!-( "#' + 0 *+ ((! ' /' "+% ( + !)("*- *+ (.

-(-#'"# "")+'+ ( %( '(9(+ - (%+'( '#"!- '+(#0%-( "#' 0 ( ' ')("

*- *+- /'( % (9 "#'+(! *#

(

+ , #""%!#+%

!# ,-

"+% (-+("- ' /'(( ')("*- *+ /' '#((-" $

$'+(-+("-'( '( (' '+-0' %(0#0 '( !(' ".

' 9 *#

(

+ , #""%!#+%

!# ,-

.((--#/'"# ' -,(.

-(- ("%( (-+("- ' ( ' ( ' )(" *- *+

/' '#((-""( ("-'9 '( '((-( '#((-+("--#' +* /''-"(-'( +*- '( %(*+-0'#0'( !(' '/ '(9 *#

(

+ , #""%!#+%

!# ,-

./ " ' ( (- /D("-0(:('(*++ 0' /' ( ( (!( + ! ' +-0' %(0# '( !(' /*

(!(0'9 *#

(

+ , #""%!#+%

!# ,-

.. ( ((! ' ( + ! )(" *- *+ 0 - ' 0+ '!'' !!(+'(!'!'((% %'

"+%!%( " 0'( %( (% %'%( ( "#'(- *% +'

''(-

*% 0%-( - !% 0%-(%-+#+*!'-*(")+'/

'0 '(:%0'( '"!%( %'-!%"!"!''- D('0 +--!'*++ 0'++ /'( ( ''( !(' %( 5; -(-# ' (-+( 0 ' ( ( (00 '(9(+ -"#' C"- 9 '

'(+( ('/- %!-#/' *'( +( ( /( ' ( - ' /( ' 9! ( (-D '/'* /* '(+'(-D*,. '9(- ( ((!'( /' '- -(! ' *+ + !*! ' ( ' )(" *- *+ " / %( %( (-+("- ' + ! ' '( !(' %( - '# "+(%(- -('-*(% (+('- "+(%%-!( "#' 0 '+(#+--(# '0% '( '( 0'(% %,(."#' 0 ( '+%--#0"-'+-(%0' 3 '('-( '+0%0(!' 00+')("-+ "+%% '(D

0 ')("-+ "(-: " / E(- :('% ( E:('%%"0''( !('-+ 5=

'((%(# #%0'(-+#,.

(/"#''( !(' %( /'+'% 0 3 0%'0

''( !('

-+ '/: +0'"00'( -+#(('('"00'( -+# '("(D "+0 ' ' '! '( '0 #%%( ( % '(*"("-' '! '(%( 0-- 0(-! (0%' ( (!%'((-""(-# (-/'"#'-( "(-/'-%(D!((-(+') !% "# '(D-% +'0'"(-+( $'C;E- ( - $</%/%D %6$%$4%#6//%# 0<!

( $;E: - ( /)-D ,(8!6%0%#%0/%# 0<!

/' '("+-(-#9-( '('++0("- 0(-+("--#/' ++%("%( ( (-+("- /' +% '!' % ' -#("-' ("%( 5>

+'( */'("("-' "* '"#' !'++ "#' 9 '"#

*2(2*'(+( *0'0 #%%( ( %( 0-- 0(-! (0% '"# % "("-' '"#' +("

+-( "-!"-"+ 0%'0

#%%( ( ':*(-'(D0 (- ( ''(%0'-*(-+# ('+%- ':(-0#!

0 *+ /'"# ' "+% -!"- " + 0%'+* /''-*(-+# +:+ '((0'%! ) !% /'"# ' '(*" + +( '+ ' -!"-#0' 3"+%% ' 0 #%%( ( 000%(#0%# 5<

'((%(# '-0(+-(% "#' '9 '('" / ( ( % "+(%(-!( ' "/'(-%(

'('( +0 "00( ( % -#+0' !'0-!"-#0"!+ 0%'( */ /--(+' () !% "#' 9+( - ( %6$%$4%#6//%# 0<! - />$!6/

,;./' '("9-( '((#-0:( ( ( %/- +- !(0#( -!"-#0 %'0 ' 0("-!'+0 ' 3 */'0(+!'+ +-(% (!'0% " 0-#' 3'( (+: ' : -!"-# 0 ' "! + " % '( (D '%0'-+#,.

(

(/"#''( !(' %(

' ("* 9 ' %! (00% ( '- ( ' + 0'/' + +( 0+ !' 30"! % '-*(-+#'%(-++ '( "+* /'//D0% (#( ' + '"*-#"%( /'(/D'(0"%0 '-+#,(. 65 ?' %0'( + 0'/'(+" (/"#' 0(++ !-# 66

+'%(+(-0'(" + ' (--' !(-+(,.

0(# ( 0(+' ,

, -

, ,

D(*!'

<0<! 8/26%3E!/ $%# & E$ <0<!!8$!0/51 & E$