High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/39227/2014allowed

Saurabh Nayyar v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2015-09-04Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

"#$%"%&'(")*"+,"- . /!

(01-0,20330- !!!!!!!!!

"*$*$&"-! 4"-515 (*0*"0-30&00&%0&*2"- !!!!!!!!!

"5)&%"&*5!

!62"*2"--")-*"-57#07&"85)0)"-5+03,"0778"%*5""91%:+"&*; !,"-""--"%*-")-*"-5-&*;

!62"*2"-*2"91%:+"&*5217%,"-")-*"%$&*2"$:"5*; -:1"%,3'-!&+7 0**0&($%21.("&$-%<#0*"8$*2 -! 09$<072*-0.%<#0*"0&% -! -0*20+("*2$.%<#0*"

-*2")"*$*$&"-!

-!=0)$7::0-807.%%7!!!.0-30&0! -!!(!21770-.%<#0*"

--"5)&%"&*!!

-03"-$&*2$5)"*$*$&$7"%1&%"-("#*$& >-!

$5-:-0&* 0&*$#$)0*-3,0$7**2")"*$*$&"-$&#05" !>%0*"%!?!

1&%"-("#*$&5 ?@ >@ .-":$5*"-"%0* 7$#"(*0*$&("#*-/.

$5*-$#* 0&#2A170! 2$51-*<$%"-%"-%0*"%<"+,"- >.

20%5*03"%*2"

0--"5**2")"*$*$&"-!

B"0-&"%5"&$-#1&5"7-*2")"*$*$&"-20551,+$**"%*20*& -"#<"-3$5-"C1$-"%*,"""#*"%-+*2")"*$*$&"-0&%*2"%8-30-*$#7"5 20<"07-"0%3,""&-"#<"-"%05%"*0$7"%$&&&"D1-" !"2051-*2"- 51,+$**"%*20**2")"*$*$&"-$5-"0%3*#)"-0*"8$*2*2"$&<"5*$:0*$&: 0:"&#30&%*A"")2$58$"0&%5&8$*22$+!"205-"7$"%1)&*2" 91%:+"&*5&E,7"(1)-"+"1-*$&

#*$*7"% 05 $$% &'(%!! )! *%+$ $ ,',%!%$*-+!

.+! )! )! *%+$ 0&% /

#0*$*7"%05 $,+1'!

$ ,',%!%$*-

! )! *%+$ !

&*2"*2"-20&%.7"0-&"%#1&5"7-*2"#+)70$&0&*205 ))5"%*2"0&*$#$)0*-3,0$7&*2":-1&%*20**2"#+)70$&0&*205+"* 8$*2"D*-"+"#-1"7*30&%20-055+"&*0**2"20&%5*2")"*$*$&"-0&%2$5 0+$73+"+,"-5!5-":0-%5-"#<"-3%8-30-*$#7"5.2"20551,+$**"% *20*&73)0-*$07-"#<"-3205,""&""#*"%!"2051-*2"-51,+$**"%*20*$& #05"*2")"*$*$&"-$50778"%*2"#&#"55$&0&*$#$)0*-3,0$7.*2"-"$5 )55$,$7$*3*20*2"+037"0<"*2"#1&*-39")0-%$5$&:*2"*-$07!&51))-* 2$5#&*"&*$&5.2"205-"7$"%1)&*2"91%:+"&*&E,7"(1)-"+"1-* $& /

2#/ *$*7"%05 !3! .!%+!.$ ,',%!%$ &*4%*- *-5$"+

! )! *%+$ 0&%20551,+$**"%*20**2")-"5"&* )"*$*$&%"5"-<"5*,"-"9"#*"%! B"0-&"% #1&5"7 - *2" (*0*" 9$&5 8$*2 *2" 0-:1+"&*5 7"0-&"%#1&5"7-*2"#+)70$&0&*!

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

0-"&**2"-"#<"-3 )-#""%$&:5.058"7705$&<$"8*2"**07$*3*2"0,<"0#*50&% #$-#1+5*0&#"5*2"#05".$*0))"0-5*20*#15*%$07$&*"--:0*$&*2" )"*$*$&"-$5&*-"C1$-"%!551#2.*2")-"5"&*)"*$*$&$50778"%0&%*2" $&*"-$+-"7$":-0&*"%**2")"*$*$&"-<$%"-%"-%0*"% >!

*2$5 1-*.$5+0%"0,571*"!8"<"-.*2")"*$*$&"-520779$&*2"$&<"5*$:0*$& 050&%82"&%$-"#*"%,3*2"$&<"5*$:0*$&:0:"&#30&%520770,$%",3*2" 778$&:*"-+50&%#&%$*$&50570$%%8&1&%"-("#*$& > *2"

%"-$+$&07 -#"%1-"'

" # $

$ % & '(%) * %$"

%$"* "

%($ * # " #

$'( % & $

%(%

%$ ! ($ $ (

" # $

$) %* + % & ( # ( #

(, *$5+0%"#7"0-*20**2",5"-<0*$&5+0%"2"-"$&0,<"52077 &*,"#&5*-1"%05-"7"#*$&0&3)$&$&&*2"+"-$*5*2"+0$&#05" 0&%*2"*-$071-*52077%"#$%"*2"#05"&*2",05$50<0$70,$7$*3 "<$%"&#"!

E0:1**E