Ravi Kapoor v. Ut Of Chandigarh
!"
#$!
%&' &"(& && & ) &"
)*+,+ -.*/%0123
"& -
4'5 "
%!6
"&%6 &"&
"
!
"&%6 &"&
"
2%
" #
$ "
%
& '
( ) * +
"
,-./0 1
12'
( ) *
+ "
,-./0 1 12
34-
" 56( 784
78 78,:
77
43
78 78,:
' ,8"
,8 78 & 7 "
'
;
& ' " + ' + "
'
( ,8//0<2
,- ,8 788, "+
=
( ,9-"
!
" 78 '
# "
3 " #$# % & !##''% #
'
/ 9 "
' 7 + & + +
+
'
&
"
"
>
6 '
'
78
7
38
38 '
# + + "
+'
"
'
!
"
" " 7 99
#
+
"+
"
6
>
$1"
0 +9/: /; / 6**+ 7+ 7889 072 0 2 ,7:< ! "
# 788.0,2
79?'
>
$% &
( @9,4 78,.
,7 78,.?#
'
&
( @7/8 78,.
,7 8, 78,.? ( # &
( @7/:.: 78,:
7/ 8, 78,.? " &
( @,8,8 78,.
8, 78,.? ) &
( @399- 78,.
878,.? (
'
&
( @34/3, 78,:
,- 8, 78,. !
") !
& 78,90,2 0 29.:?*
'+ 7889 !A9:3?*
& 78,904332<!40 *$2?,
'
&
( 9,77 78,3 ( @33-4@B 78,4
,:
,7 78,3?
& 78,/ 0/2 !' $ 4-4-?
&
( 78--: 78,:
8.
78,:
C
"
'
;
,88 "
990"2' '
# + '
+
"
>
'
"
"
# '
# + +
0" 78 " 2
" 99 D 6
' " 7 99
'
" 7 0"2
"
'
@
C">
"
B ;
"
"
"
" ">
'
"+
' ">
*=, +=0*=*/+9+* +*=* * )0= $ /*9
60> * +
6 '
6
">
"
+
+ "
&
6 "
" '
; "
+
.
@ & '
!
' ;
? @
&
"
"
+ '
"
;' + "
"
=
6 ' "
+
'
& '
& "
" +
+ ;
,-.7 !
"
+ 6"
"
"
"
"
' "
++
99 '
&
1+
1
9/@
"
EE666
7
F+
G @ ( ") * ") "
" + "
") " + ") + ",
' ,,,
?
+
"
' ' ( -7
9/ () ;
"
+
@ @?.& 6+290 / +2 09*0 +9 /*9
0> * + (
+ + "
&
'
)
,-3/H
+
6 "
+
66 5 99 + +
"
"
) *
,-3/
"
++
+
3/ ' + "
+
7
;
+'
@ @--& ' ' - ") + + " "% ." " /+"
" 0 "
") + + "" "1 2 + ") + " 3 ) + "
4335#
-/ ")" " ")6 ))
" ") / " ") " % .7" 2 / " " % .7" 2
)8"
+"
") ) + " + 8" " 8" ) +"
) " ) ,G 5 7"
# ' ' ? ,88
@ '
+ "
# +
&
$'
"
"+
7 @
+ # +
&
I"
&
H
+ "
"+
042 +
"@ 072
+
"
!
# +
,88
+
$ '
&
+ "
'
" "
"
'
6
"
;
+ ' "
+ ;
' ,88 ,,,+
"
'
'
+
J
@ ;
" @
' + + <
$ " '
,,8 "
"
+
6
" + + +
" "
7 99
'
+
+,88
+
"
&
' ">
">
+ " "
+
"
6
+ +
"
' "
# +
"
&
+
" ;
" +
4: ()
@ FC
"
K"
@" "
L 0,2 ( ' +
,-:407 ,-:32@ 02 +
"
"
K"
?
0"2
"
I
,-
73
7:
# +H "
" '" @ 02 "
"
+
02 '
"
"
"
+
;
+
+
' " 072 "
0"2 "@
0,2
,-:407 ,-:32 +
'
"
6 '
+"
'
"
# "">
"
"+ 0"2 "@
0,2
5 + "
"
' 02
"
"
?02 ;
+
+
' "
"
# "
"
,-
73
7:@
# +
C"
,-:4' "
$1"
! ,A
6/A6/;+7+ 263 ( "
" ' + ?
"
"
+ ;
+
+
' " B
"
6 '
"
"
&
4:0,20"202 M "
M &
6
" ""
"
"
"
&
> +
' M "
M '
"
'
" +;' ;'
6 &
' M "
M F6 1A )
+3 < @77/.
' "
"
&
&
' 1 "
+ +
' ;
' "
' ;
>
1 + M 0
0 9 9 )+/ A %= */ & /;
700 /83 :2 0B*C*+60991, 6+D+=+',A !E0+ + * 0B*$5*,
EEEEE ,, ' " '
+ 6
+ #
"
"
"
+
" &
B
>
#
+
,7
+
' "
;
+
+
&
M 6
>
$1"
6*96=/ 6**+$0B> 78,. 60%278,,
( 3' "
#
"' @
()
'
"
,- 73 7:
# +
" "
"
+
"
"
"
"
+
;
+
+
' "
"
"
&
"
+ '
" 6 '
'
;
+
"
'
" *
4:
&
+
&
+
+
"
'
'
4:0"2 ;
'' " "
'
99 < " 7 990"2
+
"
"
5 ' ;
# + + "
"
4:
99 6 6B&>/ 6**+7+< 078832333, $1"
' + '
0 +9/: /; / 6**+7+
6**+ 7+ 09 "
+ ,,8 " ' # + "
+ 788- @ '
"J+ "
"
# +
@'
'
+ '
# +
" #
' #
"
,.
,, 788-
$1"
6B&>/4 0 2 '
0 +9/: /; / 6**+ 7+0 ( ,7/9 788, 9 )
"
788,2 '
+ ,,8
+ "
"
' ' + '
0 +9/: /; /4 0 2
''
7:0"2
"+ ,,8 B '
0 ' # +
788- $'
'+ '
' B
$1"
,8
,7 '" @ ('#3 + / + +
"
/ 8"
+ ") / / + ) #9 + / ")" 9 + "
+ "#9 )"
" )
" ) ) ")#3"
+ :" )
+) )# #$
"+ + +
"
/ ) 8"
+)" 9 / + +
" + ++ ) /"+ " +
# #; + + + 5 # ;
" " ) + -<2 5 / + #= :
+ )/#3 +" ) :
+ ) ) "#;
+ :
" +:
+ / "8" #9 + ) #* 0 +9/: /; /4 +0 2
.
'
7:0"2 ()
"+
+
' # " 6 ' 0 +9/: /; /4 +0 2
' #
"
,,8 '
7:0"2
B
"+$1"
6B &>/4 0 2
788-
;
'6B&>/4 0 2'
#
"
"
;
# + &
B %=,+6=/ 6**+ !
2 /,=/< @7.::4@78,:
79 - 78,: '6B&>/4 0 2'
"
" @ F6
'
+
(
"
'
"
"
+ ' '
'
>
#
>
" "+
"
6'+
"
:4>
B
;
,88
' ' + "
6
;
J ,88
?
+
' ()
' +
' '
;
G 6
"+
4:
"
"
"
"
" ' &
+ >"
6
+ +
)
+
+ >"
" "
+ + "
+ + ' " ;"
+
6
+
+ 6 '
'
;
,88 "
,,8+
'
+'
'
0"2 +
'
"
6 '
&
>
" >" $ + '
@
!
"+ '
< +
"
'
& '
6
"
" "
;
'
+ &
&'
6
0,7
78-2" @ (5+ ):" + "
"
>" /"+
"
)" + + / ) # ; "
+ " + /
"
+ "/ /" ) ":" "
" / "
" "
) " ) )" ) + /#* 5 7,8 "
" @ (9 " / "++/ /") )"#* 99 + "+ '
'
' ">
"@ 7 99
" 6 + ">
C +
'
">
"
"+
'
">
0
3 !
78,4 !A,,,702
' "
'
+
'
# "
+
;
" 70"2 N
;
+ "
" 6 ';
"
+
+
'
"
#
"
'
# +
"
"&%6 &"&
"
.
3 %!)
%
;J N J( %
"
N J(