Devi Dayal Singla v. Mahabir Singh Bedi And Another

 
    
   

 ! !"#$#%&' (

!)# *+,#%-+ ! # #%!.

/!.$0$ 12#.,#%-1 !3#%3% 1!.

!$4%3!% $
&5 6,
/786 



 




 





/7869 



 





!


 "# #"

"#"$


&'(

)

 


*
  

+





)



 ,-
* 
"

"





 
'.#/


01
 2!

!

+
!

2)

 



)
2

"




2!
2





  3




4
'5


6 7)


*

8

'.95




 0*
1




&
:
:
4!
2
 


6 
; "9<
4
'/
 




 02
21


! 

& 2



 




+



)
+

+
2


&5

:

!







 



--
* 
''




&<
+



=









+



)
+

 


&9

72




+
=


 #( #'

"#"$
!


!

*
; "9'

"#"$




 2


!
)

&
>


 


2 +
+
++
+
)







!
  

= 




-








,-
* 
"
"
 


&'5
+


-
+








! 

2
2
+


'#




 
 
*





= 


+







2





+


 

=  )





)

)
!
+
 






)
=
)
+


2

!

!


!






(

-



 





  
 
)

$

?
 

 )2


2

!


 )

6
 )2


2
2
+

 


 

"#'5




+


@ 
"#""

+








2
 
+

!!


?  
 )2


!


2
2



'#

 

 


*

+ 



=  





?
 


 )2

 

+
)
)
!
 
+

+
 


)
!



!


) !

-








 




= !2


4

2  



#)#+44!+:;:

   $<6 !!

%./$ ,122#.1<3%3 1!.$


'"

#'

"#"(

<

-



 )2
2
)

 







2

)


2


!

 

 
 *
; "9'

"#"$
)


)
!











!

 

= 





6+


2
2



)

) 
&
>


 

)
!

 2)

+


 






2
+  )

 


+
+








,-
* 
"

"






&'5













!


2
2



'# 




*

+ 



=  

+

2

-
+




 2

  +
!

2)






! 
 = 
)


2!



-

  


 

 


*

!
) 


 
 
)




+
2

 

-


 


*

% 


 
 

 !

+







 +!
)







'#



 

 



2


)

+

+





> 


2

 



 


 


 +



 
 
)






(  
)

)
!
+

 


= !2

 
$<6 !!

$04.
+ 

2







  



= !2
+



-

+
!
+ 
 




)
+
2
)

4

2
 
+ 10-1% 3#.!" +*.#$#%-#% 1!4.!$!% "$!9=!+$ =#$1    2$!.)!  1  1!  >0!$ #%    ?0.#$3#" #%  =0+3  $$0<!

#<4. %"!!)!%  1!$ -!"0. "%$#3!.$ 1!>0!$ #% -.% 

#% !.#<.!+#!

81!.!#% !.#<.!+#!

#$"+#<!3#%$0# 2!

.!"#)#+ "0. %3 1!4. * 2!

!" !32*-.%  $0"1.!+#!

9.%* 1!.

4. *  1!$0# 9.#$!$4#%  <#% #%2#+# * 1!.! . 1 # #$ 2..!32*+=%3+$"% !%3$% 1 2$#$ 1 #% !.#<.!+#!

$10+3%  2!-.% !39-.%  .!+#!

#%=1 !)!. .<9#  ++9 0-1  2!4.!"!3!32* .< #%%3.!".3#%-  +!$ 4.#<

"#!$ #$ " #% 1  1!$0# #$<#% #%2+!. 1 # #$% 2..!3 2*+=,0"1$ #$ " #%.!$ #%-%44.!"# #%  1!)!.<!% $#% 1!4+#% 9 1!44+#" #% .#% !.#<.!+#!

%3 1!=.# !%2?!" #% 1!.! 9$=!++$ 1!.!+!)% += 1 #$"# !3#%$044.   1!

2?!" #%9=0+32!4.   1!"0. @$.!$%#%- 4.#< "#!

"$!  1)#%-  2!!%  $!  04  .  #% !.#<  .!+#!

9  1  1!  2+%"!  

"%)!%#!%"!#$#% )0.  1!-.% %3%%A-.% =0+3"0$!

#..!4.2+!1.<%34.!?03#"! =0+32!#%44.4.# ! ."0.

2$ #% .<.!".3#%-# $4.#< "#!$ #$ " #%% 1!>0!$ #% <#% #%2#+# *9*! 94."!!3 -.% 4. !" #%4. !<% 1! $$0<4 #% 1  1!>0!$ #% <#% #%2#+# *1$ 2!3!"#3!3$ 4.!+#<#%.*  #$$0!  0%3!. 0+!      .3!. B/9 

 1  "0+3 <0%  %#<4.4!.!C!."#$! 4=!.  1!"0. #$  1!4#%#%   1!$ -! 1!.#%- 1!44+#" #% .#% !.#<.!+#!

 1  1!$0# #$ 2..!32*+=.#$ 1!.=#$!% <#% #%2+!9# "%% 3#$<#$$# =# 10  .<#%-4.!+#<#%.*#$$0! !. 1!=.# !%$  !<!% #$

#+!320 "%<$ "!. #%+*$$#-%$0"14#%#% ..!

0$#%-#% !.#< .!+#!

=!)!.9# %!C ..3#%.*$# 0 #%.#$!$=1!.!# "0+3 D! #<! 3!"#3! 1!4#%  <#% #%2#+# *  1!$0# %3%%A -.%   4. !" #% 4.  !<4!%3#%- $0"1 3!"#$#%  "0+3  +!3   #..!)!.$#2+!  "%$!>0!%"!$9  1!  "0.  <*  4."!!3    <D!  % 44.4.# !.3!.#% 1!<%%!.#%3#" !32)!?0$ # *#%- 1!"0.$!

" #%# 34 $% 1!.=.3$9$0"1%.3!.<*2!4$$!39# ++.!>0#.!39 )#3#..!4.2+!1.<.#%?0.*.0%30!1.3$1#4 

1!4. *"+#<#%- 1!.!+#!

%3E. !%$0.! 1  1!4."!!3#%-$.!

% .!%3!.!3#% .0" 00$2*.!$% %%A#% !.

!.!%"!2* 1!"0. 

2)
!


)
2
)

4

2  


2

!

+ 
+




* 
% 


 
 
) 

2)

 

+

 
+ 
)
 )=


!

  

/

-
+


2


 2
-

 

2







2

! 2

!


 





 


 /786   ' (

 A
 !3 B3; A
 ) B3;