High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2414/2009disposed of

Rachhpal Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-04-03Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill7 pages

!"#$# %&'(#)*+ %$

"--'

).#%/- 00100

# %( 2($3$

, $' %5% & 67 0 . ..77

($% & (0

%4 %7 8- %'

)+59 "

+! ( # %(0 (0.

,4# .#%/--:

+$$#$

00+ ,0

- '

# %( ;

(#5 ! ( " ::#

#%/ - !!%"$ '3%#$- ,) 3%5( ."

# %$ <=+ <> %5 ? 0 2#5 435/:% %5 (5(5

500=+) (%555# # % )-#! 35#"# ) /#$

+ 735-# + -)5 # %( /3#) @ 3%5(

! ($ #5."

# %$ %5$% %"5-#: 3%5(/ ! ( % @ (3%5(."

# %<= A ! ( ; @ ($ '

@ !#% !

$0+B3%5(."

# %<> %5+#%5!

3) !'

@:% !!#%+

3%5(/ !3( ! ( = 5 @$ %5 3%5(/ ! ( % @ (3%5(."

# %? 0)) -$% %"$;( (5(5 (3%" %"3((% )@0 //(#95 -( / #%$ + # %( '(!((5

) ,! ( - ) (%5 .$$# %$ 35/+ 735-# 0 ;9(+ 9#5 435/:% 5

5 0?0+ ) !#)5 ,@ '

5 ,% 5#$:#$$5 ,@ - ) (%5 55# # % ) .$$# %$ 35/+ 735-# 0 .

#)) //(#95+ '(!((5 -'($% (9#$# %'

# %0

CD $ '( - '( $"3 # % "

'')#5 ! ( - ' $ ! .'"# ) )#" !!#"( .

#% #$ (#"

735-# ,@!#))#%/3' (: 0?+:% # %#%/-#$5

,#( $ 00<0 (#/#% ) :

# % "(

;

"-5+;-#"- )$ " %

#%5 # %(6$5

00<<07

( %+ # %(+ %- 9#%/,% ))

,)3:,(+;

%$!((5 ( E'3(0-( !

(+ '3 @ %$'"

( %( ) ! )#" + ( E'3(+ - 5 $%

# %(6$:

# %"(

) %/;# -"(

$ ! $ : -( "

%5#5

, ."- ) 53"

# % (5+ - )#+ ! ( %F3#(@ (/ (5#%/ -#( 5

! ,#( -$0 3($3

-( + #%F3#(@ (' ( $ ("#95 !( : , ."- ) 53"

# % (5+ - )#+ - )5#%/

"- %/5-#$5

-!( :00< 00<<+ !

$#%/ - $ :0 -3$+ # ))/5

#%5 -4 ,!( 353)% )@0 ;

$!3( ))/5

#% -#$ (/ (5+ )

( ;

)$ ;(#

.%# ( .3'(#% %5% !

)#"+ ;- !

( ,

#%#%/ )/ ) '#%# % ! - '3 @ #$ (#"

(%@ 7/ )+ (5(5 (/#$

# % ! "(#:#% ) "

$ / #%$

# %(0"" (5#%/)@+ #% -#$"

$(/#$ (50 !

( " :') # % ! - #%9$ #/

# %+ "- )) % ;

'($% 5 #% - 3( 0 9#%/ ! 3%5 '(#:

"# "

$+ "- (/$ 3%5( ."

# %$ <=+ <> %5 ? ;( !( :5

/ #%$ ""3$50 -'( $"3 # %- 5+#% (5( ,(#%/- : -/3#) ! ""3$5+G :#%5 $:

$$9%;# %$$$0

C*D

:% ""3$53%5(."

# %**(0 00 ;

$ (" (55 ;-(#% - $

- - 5 !

)$)@ ,% #:')#"

%5") #:5 (# )0 - ) (%5 (# ) 3( - 5+ $ % #"5 , 9+ " %9#"

%5 $% %"5 # %( ""3$5 3%5(."

# %$ <=+<> %5? 0- )!#)5,@-#:;

$5#$:#$$5,@

-) (%555# # % ).$$# %$35/+735-# +9#5435/:%

50?00 (%5 " 3%$) ! ( $ 9-:% )@ " % %55

;-#) '

$$#%/ - #:'3/%5 435/:% (5(+ -) (%5 3( $,) ;5#5%

8#% " %$#5(

-( ;

$ % 5#("

9#5%" % (" (5 " %%"

# %(;# - !!%" !! (/(@0()@,"

3$ -5

,#( - ! # %(5#5%

))@;# --#$5

-#% !!#"# )

+ #$ % /( 3%5 (" (5 - " %9#"

# % ! '

# %(0 H-#) (!((#%/ $ #: %@ ! H?2 (#%5(

%+ !!#"# ) ! , ."- ) 53"

# % (5+ # - ,% " % %55

- $ #5 ;# %$$ - 5 %)@ '( 95 $#/%

3($ ! -."(

(@#% - !!#"# )

$ #5;# %$$- )$ 5:#

5#%-#$"( $$G :#%

$ #5 !!#"# )

)$ $3,4"

-3:

% (( ( :#$$# %0 .

#)) !3( -(+ # #$ (/35

# $ % '( 95 % (" (5 ;- -

:'(5;# # %(6$5

#% -:

# %"(

0 -( - %5+ - ) (%5 .

3%$) -

(/35

- !#%5#%/$ (" (55 ,@ - ) (%5 3( $ ,) ;

( , $5 % - 9#5%" % (" (5

# %( " 3)5% '( 9

-(" 3)5, -('($ %)# ,)! (

:'(#%/ ;# - 5

! ,#( -0 H-#) 5!%5#%/ - !#%5#%/$ (" (55 ,@ - 3( $ ,) ;+ # - $ ,% (/35

H? (#%5(

%+ - 5 ,( 3/- - (#/#% )

%5 -

$ #!#5 , 3 ""3$5'

9#%/ (5 #%

# % G :0 -3$+ % - , $#$ ! - $ #5 (" (5+ # $ 5'( 95 %(" (5

-(;

:'(#%/#% -5

,#( - ! # %(0 - 9 - (5 ) (%5 " 3%$) ! ( #$0 ;9(+5 % !#%5 %@:(# #% -'($% (9#$# %'

# %0 %5#$'3

,)@+

(@ #%

'( 53"5 ,@ # %( ! ( ,

#%#%/ - 4 , ! +" %

#%5 5#!!(% 5

- %(" (55#%

- (#/#% )(" (5 ! ,."- )53"

# % (50

- 3( $- 9! 3%5

-5

- ! # %(#%

- !!#"# )

$ 00<+ ;-( - 5

! ,#( (5#% -"(

'( 53"5,@ # %(! ( ,

#%#%/

-4 ,;

$:% # %5 $00<<0 ;

$!3( -(! 3%5

- :#%3 ,$(9

# % ! - (

G0 9% ;# 85@+$- ;5

-(;(# #%/;# -,) "8'% %

;

$;# -)#/- #%8;-( -;(# #%/'(

#%#%/

- 5

! ,#( - ;

$ ;# - 5 (8 #%8

, %5;(# #%/$;(5#!!(% 0 ;

$!3( -(! 3%5

# ;

$ %)@

""3$5'

# %(+ ;- ;

$ #% ($ %5 ,%!#"# (@ #% :

8#%/ -$ #5"- %/#% (5( ,

#% -4 , !.

%5% %)$"

%,$ #5 - 9:

5 -$ #5 )

# %0 %:@" %$#5(5 '#%# %+# " 3)5% ,' #% 5 3 ,@ - ) (%5 " 3%$) ! ( ""3$5'

# %(

'($ % # %(" 3)5- 95 % )

C=D #% -5

-0-'

# %(" 3)5% $- ;

-$ #5

:'(#%/- 5,%5 %;# 9#; ! "

3$ %@#))/ )) $$

# %( %5B (#))/ )/ #% $ : %)$0 " 3)5 )$ , $- ;% %@ % - / #% #% %@ :

%%( ,@ :

8#%/ )

# % #% - :

# % "(

! '

# %(0.

#))!3( -(+# " 3)5 )$ % ,$

,)#$-5

$ #5 "(

- 5,%#%' $$$$# % ! -('($ %$

(#,3 $3"- )

'($ %0 - $#

# %+ -3$+

($ $

# ""3$5'

# %( ) %+ ;- - 5 % )

# % #00 "- %/ ! 5

! ,#( - #% :

# %"(

#))!3( -(+ ) (55

-#$ ()@ ; @ ($ : ( - (#/#% ) 5

! ,#( -0 -#$ "#("3:$

%" )$ ) 5$ " %")3$# %

,@$- ;#%/-#:$)! @ 3%/(+ - #% # % % # %( ""3$5 ;

8 -#:)#/#,)! ( -4 , %5B ( $

@! ( ) %/('(# 5#% $(9#",! (( "-#%/ / !$3'( %%3

# %0 )) -$ $ %$+ !#%5

- !#%5#%/$ (" (55 ,@ - 3( $ ,) ;

('(!"

)@43$ #!#5(F3#(#%/% #% (!(%",@ -#$ 3( 0 ;9(+

-#$ $

/+ ) (%5 " 3%$) ! ( '

# %($3,:#

# %(#$ ' ('($ %,) %/#%/

-."-53)5 $ $" ::3%# @0#$- 9#%/ -($"- ) / #%/"-#)5(% %5#$ (%#%/-#$)#9)#- 5,@5 #%/ -) , 3( ; (80 - '

)( 5@ 3%5(/ % : % %5 = @$ 3

)$% %" ! ; @ ($#:' $53' %-#:0 -3$+ -) (%5" 3%$)'( @$

-$% %"#:' $53' %

# %( ""3$5 :

@ , (53"5 - '(# 5 )( 5@ 3%5(/ %,@-#:0

C<D - %6,) .3'(: 3( #% 3%#) ) "-# 2$0

! #- -(+ * (#:#% ) ?+ ;-#) " %$#5(#%/ -" %9#"

# %(" (55 %5$% %"#:' $53' %

""3$5 -(#% ! ( - !!%"$ 3%5( ."

# %$ + <?+ <>+<> %5? +- 5(53"5 -$% %" !B@ ($

-'(# 5 )( 5@3%5(/ %0 ;

$-)5 $3%5(& I0 #$ % #% 5#$'3

- ""3((%" ()

'(# 5>>*09% %00*+-( #(5!( : ' $ !'3 @ ))"

(+ ) %5 %5$ 5" %9#"

5,@

(# ) 3( ! ($ #5 %)@#%+#00+ !

) %/ '(# 5 !@ ($0$(#/- )@' #% 5 3 ,@(0 /%5(

#+ - - 5 3%5(/ % - (5 ) ! !

"#%/ (# )

#"#'

#%/ 3%"(

#% @ , 3 - %

3( ! " %9#"

! ($3"- ) %/'(# 50 #$ (3

'')) ;

% :5#% 0 ;9(+ !

'(# 5 !=@ ($+ ;-% -'( $"3 # %!#)5 "- (/$- +-;

$$- ;%

$ *(5 ""3$50 $ (#/- )@ ' #% 5 3 ,@ (0

'')) - 5()53%5( -(

!,#%/" %9#"

%5$% %"5! ( )) -$@ ($09% -#/- 3(

8%: ( %<@ ($ 5#$' $ ! )0$ %5

+ '')) #$?@ ($ ! / %5- )( 5@ 3%5(/ % < : % -$ #:'(#$ %:% 0 ! ; " %$#5(

! ""3((%"+@ ($- 9,%'

$$5% ;0-( #$ % (" (5 $- ;

'')) $ #%9 )95 #%

-( "(#:#% ) "

$0 %$#5(#%/ - "

$ ! '( $"3 # %+% :)@+$9( )#))/ )# #$ %5#((/3) (# #$ #% G"3 # % ! ;-#"- #$ ."-: ! (:3)

5 ,@

- 9(%:% ! %5# + - !

- ""3((%" ()

- @ ( >>*+ (# ) ;% ! ( @ ($

%5 %55 #% " %9#"

# % #% + '')) ( #(5

C?D !( : $(9#" 9% ,! ( " %9#"

%5 -#$ ) ;

'%5#%/#% -#/- 3( ! (% ()@<@ ($+

8#%/ !-#$'($% /+% :)@+?@ ($ %53%5(/ % < : % -$ #:'(#$ %:% + ; !)

%5$ ! 43$ #" ; 3)5 , :

,@ : 5#!@#%/ - $% %" - '(# 5

)( 5@3%5(/ %0J - #% -#$"

$(/#$ (5 %00>0% -#$ ;

@+ $ ,% !

"#%/ / %@ ! (# ) ! ( : (

% @ ($0 - /3#) $"(

#%5 % !

""3$5'

# %(+ - - )( 5@ $3!!(5 ) #%")35#%/ -#$ (: 9 )!( : - 9(%:% $(9#"0%"+#%:@ '#%# %+% 3$!3)'3(' $; 3)5,$(95,@$%5#%/ # %(,-#%5

- , ($ %" / #%0 %5$ ! 43$ #" ; 3)5 , !3))@ :

+ #! $% %"#:' $53' % # %( ""3$5#$(53"5 % )( 5@3%5(/ %,@-#:0 %9#; ! , 9+;-#)3'- )5#%/ -" %9#"

! # %( 3%5( ."

# %$ <=+ <> %5 ? + $3,$

#9$% %"#:' $53' % # %(#$(53"5

- % )( 5@ 3%5(/ % ,@ -#:0 ;9(+ - !#% #:' $5 $- ))(:

#%#%

0 #$' $5 !#% , 9 (:$0 '(#)*+ 5$ H- -(.'

8#%/B

$ %5& $B H- ' (

,)& $B