Shaminder Singh v. The Financial Commissioner ( Appeals) And Orss



    
   




 !"#$%$ &  ' ('  )* +$&",)$&-* ''''' $ $ &, .,%/% *$& &#$ 0
++$%%$ &,122 0%3 &" *,% '''''%2 &"& %
4  564')
)   











)  8'




 





 
  
 


 

 
! 


 
"# $% "$&#
 


' (



' ) 



* 
, 

-  .
/ 01


 "$&%
 

 ' "







2


 
&& "$""
 


' &


 




 




 

 



 


 


* 
,



 
 
 




 


  ' (%4)
 
"% $% "$&3 







  








 .
5

 
 



) 


 

 




  





 
 



)




 
 









*

+ 


 
"# $% "$&#









 





* 

+ 
,
 
5 


' )
  





  

*

 











 





  




' )






 

 
5
/ 0



 

 "$&%








  
/  
5
6 7
2 


 

 
&& "$""



 


 
5







 

 







 





 

 

5



 

 
 * 




 

  
 



 
 
8 
 
 







 
9

 




 
,



 


 
 






 
* 




 

:
 
 



*
9
 

 
  



 

2



 

  



 
 


' 













*
9
 
  

' )
 
 
 


  
* 


 

 



 


 
* 




9

 
 
 





 


'

 



9
 

 


   

' )

#
 
9

  



"3
 
 
 

' )

("
   





9
 

 










 


 



 



' )




* 
 
 
 




 



 






5
9
 

 



 




  


 



 

  





 



 *

 
, 


5
 
 





 

;

 





 


 
  







* 
,





 

 
 

  
 






) 


 


 









<
 
 








 

 
!   

 
 
$)
 
 



 


 




*


 

)










5



'






("
 





 
 
4$
0  
9



 

 


+ 



 
 


 

8  



 


 




 
  
5
/ 0
 
 




  
5











 "$&%
 

 
5




 

 

 



 
 

/ 
5
2

9 
  / 
5









 









 
5


 
5








  && "$""

;







 



 5
 

 


  
 


 
 

 
 







 
 

 


 
5
;



 
  

 

   

  ! "#

5


 


 
!
 




 
 




     
  

    
    


        

     
 

  

  


   
 
 

  





9

! "#$

 
%
$
& '
  (      )**!+ ,((+

,-.-    
 
 


     


       
        


    
 
  
 ;

 

 


 
 

5






 
 








' 

' )


  



* 


+
'

 5

 


8 









 

  



5 





 


  
5








 

 5







 

8 
;






9=


5



$ %  &









  





 


  ' ('   1)  
3   >
 0? 
 @?' >
 
 @?'