Rakesh Malhotra v. Devki Nandan




   
 

 



!"#$% #&

' #$(# % ))*))  !% +% ,  -'!.! *))  / !.!
 


   



% !" $%)%,!.-&.-

&

% $%)+%.-&.-

&

%#/ !%) $%) #0!(0%&.-

&0# $%)1#2$#2!&.-

&

%#% / !.!)   

 #((!3!#/% !/ !  %.%.. 4)5) / . 67 # (%!. .. !  ,.3&

  % '  ,%& ,%3 !& 0#%67 0#( !3  . # !!3 %.%..9)):/ .67#(%!.,. ( $3 %&
 ( & ,%3 !& #

(. 67 !%&0 . 8 .) 

8/(!,!.%1 ! 5;5;
 0  (. 67 /

8/(!!& ' # $(# %& ((3!3#%!##% / !.!6!3# %3!((( 

% .!( /(   ) 99 <0# # 0  (% #!3.   :5=> 8 ,%!3 :)9 ?,% 7%.  -. (( 8! (% .. ))=& !%. ! 3%8!   (( .. )5)=4 0# # /

8/(!!

%   ( (

8 ,!!3  )=&=9; <(%.7 /. 67 % / !.!-'

<> !.!   $;  ! ( ,(.%>) (!

 (

! 0   6 /. 67 # /

8/(!! .% (7   $;  ! ( ,(.%) +% ,  .

,8! & !

(,.!3 # !%(

0%

 %!7& 0% @ ,. 0#  ,%#% ,!.%'!3 8 # % / !.! # # 0 ,(. 3 # /% /%7 %3 %. ! # !8

 # /

8/(!!& 0#! #

8/(  #

! %, !#% !) !#!%/78!#-!36!8.  $;  ! ( ,(.%  67 # / !%& % / !.!-' !.! 0  ((. ,/ !   @ , # ( .. !.&

%.!3(7& # ( .. 0  @ ,. ! - ,%

% / !.!)  / !.!-' !.!&  ,%. # / !% # # 0 ,(. 3 # ( .. @ ,. ! - ,%

/ !% % #  !

8! ! # 6  

 # !%(

0%

 %!7& (%.7 @ ,.) A% !& # / !% 8  '!

0#% / !.!-'!.!&#. (.# ./% /%7 - ,%

B8(21!3#!.'%821!3#)!

&/(.!3  %,.& %8!(/%  , !0  ,3# 6(,!

#.3!  % / !.!-' !.! !. 

% . B8(2 1!3# !. '%821!3#) !#6  

/% ,88 !!3-.!

&#(%!. ,.

( $3 %& ,%3 !& -. %.% .. 9)):& !. # % / !.! !. 

% . B8(2 1!3# !. '%821!3#&  !.#%(,!.%1 !5%.0# 1 !
) 0-%&-. %.%..))/ . !  $95=$ (. 67 

% . B8(2 1!3# !. '%821!3#&

%.!!

#  ,%&  .#

<9> . ,88 !!3 %.%!.?, #.#

8/(!?, !% #%!))B8(21!3#!.'%821!3#) 33%-.

 # ,88 !!3 %.% .. 9)):& % / !.!-' !.!& (.  %- ! / ! 6

% # (%!. 1 !  ,.3& ,%3 !)   . 6 -& -. %.% .. 4)5)& # (%!. .. !  ,.3& ,%3 !&  .# ,88 !!3 %.%!.. 8 .#-%7

8/(! ?, % / !.!-' !.!   0(() # . %.%# 6! #((!3.67#/

8/(!!&67 07

#/% !%- !/ !)
 87 6 !

. #%! # /% 8 # !!3 %.% !. #

(. 67 # /

8/(!! #-!3 6! ?, #. 67  

%.! !

# !  $95=$ C  ()< .)> '%82 1!3# 1!.#, !. !

#% + ) ' # $(# % !. #% & . ..

!))&# -(/%

.!3 !.#6# 

/ !%&(  !. !((7 (.6

%# !D6(1,/%8 ,% ! -( //(  ) 4

 =& % !3 ,

 1A <>  ) 4

  C ' # $(# % + ) B8(2 1!3# 1!.#,E #% &. .. !))=) # / !% #. (.  -( 1, %3%.!3 # 8/% /%7&0# #  ,62 8%

#/% ! /%

.!3    0(()
! # . ,& # (%!. %(  ,% / .  . %

% (%!- %(  ))   %

-% # 8 !7 ( !3 0# !%  F G 8 # .

 # /78! (( %(H !)  0-%& ! //(& # %  //((  ,%&   . # 2,.38! !. . % / . 67 # %(  ,% !.

<5> . %.# , (.67#/ !%)#%3! & B8(2 1!3#1!.#,!.'%821!3# (. 3,(%1

!.//(  )5:

6

%#  ,%)# .//(0 (( 0. 67  

%.! !

 #   ,% ! )) !. # 2,.38!!.. %/ .67#( 0%//(( ,%&0   .!.#. %

#%( ,%0 %  %.) 3!  # 2,.38! .. ))& /

' #$(# %&//% #.# !D6(/@ ,%6707

! -( //(  ) 4

 =& % !3 ,

 1A <>  ) 4

C ' #$(# %+ )B8(21!3#1!.#,E #% ) #  !D6( ,/%8  ,% -. 2,.38! .. ))=&0#(. (!!3 !% %0##2,.38!

#  ,%!.0#(,/# (.!3#. %

%(%!-%( & /, ! !.   # (3 !  60! # /% ) # %(-! @%   8#2,.38!

# !D6(1,/%8 ,%&0 ,(. %. ,!.%" I ! .%!3 #

%8! !.

  !.

,8 !

 

 &#/(!

 !

!(. , #%( &@ /

. %

%

-%7

8 ,!/. %3!(. !.! ))
! # 

% .   !. ,8 !

 

 &0%!

8/(3%8!0##-0'! 67 # (%!. %(  ,%   0((   #

 # 3# ,%&!!

3%!!3# #%%( !.3%!!3# . %

 %

-%7

 # 8 ,! /. 67 # %3!( /(!

 %3!(. !.! ) !(7)
!-0

% !  .6 -&0 !

% ! !% %0# # 2,.38! !. %.% / . 67 # 3#  ,% !.&

! ?,!(7& # /% ! //( . %-  6 . 8 .!. 

%.!3(7. 8 .)  0-%&   3%.& # %3!( . !.!  )  !.9%.% . /7 ,8

)&&;

<:>

%3!(/(!


0# ##7#-3%. /7 /,!!. #(3 !!. 6,7/ & 6 /. %3!(/(!

0#!/% .

 @0' 

8  .7) ! /78!

 # 

% . 8 ,!

)&&;  %3!( /(!

 67 %3!( . !.!  )  !. 9& !7 /%

.!3  /!.!3 60!#/% & !7 #(( !.%8!.)J A%!.

,! (%.8 %3%. #

% .

,(/ !)
876!

.##

(.67 !%3! % / !.!-'!.!&B8(21!3# !.'%821!3#& !% / 

# 8/% /%7&0# 0 # ,62 8%

#

% . -(/%

.!3 !.! # -( /%

.!3 & # 8% #  !. !(7 ,/( #  !D6(1,/%8 ,%) !

.6 -&# !D6(1,/%8 ,%& # 

3 ((7 .% . #

/78!

)&&; 67 B8(2 1!3# !. '%82 1!3# <. !.! )!.9!# -( ,>&(( #%/%

.!3 & !7&60!#/% & #((

8 !!.)  % '!3 !

#

% . ,!. /,. ,(/ !&
8

! .%. /!

!#

!

6707

%.%..))=# !D6(1,/%8 ,% #  .% . # ! /78!

)&&; 67 B8(2 1!3# !. '%82 1!3#& # /%

.!3 &  !7& 60! # /% & #(( !. %8!.& # /% ! /%

.!3 & #(((

8 !!.) !

&#8% !. 

!((7 (. 6

% #  !D6( 1,/%8  ,%& #%   !

(3( 2, 

 !& ! /%

.!3 !7 ,%#% ! # /% ! 8%)

<> -! #%0 & ! 8%& !

    8. ,  !% % 0# # 8/,3!. %.% / . 67 # (%!. .. !  ,.3) # (%!. .. !  ,.3&

,!.# /%#/

8/(!!#8 ( &# 3%8!   (( 0  !%. 67 #8 0# # % / !.! )5)=4& 6,

% !@ : 7% & # ( .. 0  !

 @ ,.) !

& #

8/(!! (!3 

=)) %3%. # %,.,(! % !3 ,.

,8! @ ,. ! # 7% =4& #. (.   /% - !7 . # !  !! ! # /%

 # % / !.!)
! 87 -0 # .

!.!3 /%  (72,  .)#% !#%!78 %.!3 % 8 !%/%

 # -.!

 !

% .


 !. !7 8%( ((3(7 %!

%87!#8/,3!. %.%)
!-0

#6 -&#/% !/ ! .- .

!78%!.# 8 &

%.!3(7. 8 .)         

        !  $% #& . 
K##%1/'!3;  !."  ; K##% / %6("  ;