High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/356/2021dismissed

Uco Bank And ANR v. Santosh Gupta

2021-09-30Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill6 pages

!" #$%&$'(% ) $*#$+,$-.

%#0$- 11111**$22

3$-(4(

#%(04*# $(*% ) 56 1 6 66

-$($ #) -1% (074+ -.8%'

#$&%-#0$ **2'

#(1 999 6 66.1 0(+ ##$-(,$ :# /$ 4*&%-0$ - :#0-%4:08$%'% &$-$ ' 4$#%%4#,-$ /%&#0$*

$+'. 3;1

<$- **2'

(&%-*-$*% $+$ #%&0$ - :%&#0$+ ##$-. =0'0(2(#$&%-111 $ -1

%- #0$ -$ (% ( +$ $ **2'

( =$22 -:4+$

-$(($.0$ - :%&#0$ 2(*-$*% $&-%+11&%-#% <#($2&1 **2'

((*%($%&1

**$22

#($&$

#( 0 8$ &2$ #0( -$:42 - ($'% '0 22$ : : >4:+$

$'-$$ #$ "1!1? * (($ ,< #0$ 2$ $ 82 4:$ @4 %- 8(% A. ( =$22 ( >4:+$

$'-$$ #$ ;11* (($,<2$ $#%

2(#-'#4:$.+, 1

-$&& '#( $'$(( -<&%- >4'

%&#0$'

($ -$#0 #*2 #&&B -$(*% #&2$ '82(4#&%-+

#%-< >4 &%--$'# :#0$$&$

#%-$#4- #%& (=$22 ('%(#%&'%

%#0$-$C*$ ($( '4--$,<0$-&%-*-%'4- :( 2$'$-#&'

#$ -$(*$'##%#0$*-%*$-#<$# 2$ #0$*2 #1 2(%(%4:0# + :$(

'%+*$ &%-+$ # 2* . :% <

((+$ #1 #&&*2$ $#0 #(0$* -#'* #$ '% 4'#$,<#0$ $&$

/% 1?1 -$(*$'##% *2%# ($('-,$ #10( *2%#= (*4-'0 ($,<0$-&%-

#%& (1".!. 1 2$'$-#&'

#$= ((4$ #% 0$- % 1;1

*%(($((% 0

$ %8$- #% 0$-1 4# = $2 <$ ,< #0$ -$8$ 4$ 4#0%-#$( &%- ,%4# &8$ +% #0(1 %=$8$-. +$

#+$.(0$- ($'% %8$-#0$*2%#,<(*$ ,%4# (12 /0(1# ( #0$-$ &#$- '2 +$ #0 # % !11. *$-(%

+$2< 08

#-$(* (($ #%*2 #&&D(*-%*$-#<

$+%2(0$#0$,%4

-<= 22.=0'0'

4($+% $# -< 2%(( #% 0$-1 ##$- = ( -$*%-#$ #% #0$ *%2'$

% &4-#0$- E4-< &-%+ #0$ -$8$ 4$$* -#+$ #.#'

+$#%2:0##0 ##0$*2%#=0'0= $#%0$-

%# $8$ ,$2% : #% #0$ $& 42#$- %& #0$

/ 1$1 4-$ $- :0 (% %& -$+ :01 #&&.#04(.'2 +$#0 ##0$,

/(%2 &&$-$ #*2%##%0$-

8$ *%(($((% %& ($* #$% $1$ '$.#0$(4#= (&2$1 4# = ( '% #$(#$ ,< #0$ $&$

#( # / : 8 -%4( *-$2+

-< %,>$'#%

$ < :#0$'2 +% +$-#(1#((# #$#0 # 4-$ $- :0(% %&

-$+ :0 0 # /$ 2%

&-%+ $&$

# B

/1 $ +%-#:

:$ #0$ *2%# E4$(#% & 8%4-%&#0$,

/,<= <%&

$E4# ,2$+%-#:

:$1$$& 42#$ * <+$ #%&2%

1 -%'$$ :(4 $- $'4-#(

$'% %&

' (($#(

&%-'$+$ # %& $'4-#< #$-$(# '#. @

'#A =$-$ $-# /$ 1 %(($((% %& #0$ *2%# = ( # /$ ,< #0$ ,

#0$ ( +$ =

$1 #&&*4-'0 ($#0(*2%#1 2$2$##$- #$1;1= (((4$#% 0$-

*%(($((% %&#0$*-%*$-#<0

$%8$-1#(&4-#0$-(# #$#0 #&

<%#0$-

84 2 #$-&$-$( #0$*%(($((% %&#0$*2 #&&%-'

4($(

< + :$#%#0$ *-%*$-#<.#0$-$ &#$-#0$,

/0 %-%2$#%*2 <#0$-$ 1(+(( 2%&#0$(4#= (%4:0#1

%22%= :((4$(=$-$&- +$% #0$, ((%&#0$*2$ :() 1 F0$#0$- #0$ *2 #&& ( $ ##2$ #% #0$ -$2$& %& +

#%-< >4 -$'# :#0$$&$

#(#%-$#4- #%& . '%(#(%&'% 2% :=#0$C*$ ($( '4--$,<#0$*2 &%- :$## : #0$ ( 2$ '$-#&'

#$ ((4$ 0$- & 8%4- 2% : =#0 '%+*$ &%- '

4( : +$ # 2 * . 0 ((+$

:% < %- -$'# :#0$$&$

#(#%0

%8$-#0$8 '

#*%(($((% %&*2%# (*- <$&%-G

1 F0$#0$- (4# %& #0$ *2 #&& ( %# + #

,2$ #0$ *-$($ &%-+G 1 F0$#0$-*2 #&&($(#%**$,<0(%= '#

'% 4'##%&2$#0$ *-$($ #(4#G 1 F0$#0$- *2 #&& 0 ( '% '$ 2$ #0$ #-4$

+ #$- 2 & '#( &-%+ #0$%4-#G !1 F0$#0$-*2 #&&0 %'

4($%& G "1 $2$&1 8$ '$= (2$,<,%#0#0$* -#$(1 $#- 2'%4-#0$2#0 ##= (#0$4#<%&#0$$&$

/#% (4-$#0 ##0$*-%*$-#<,$ $(&-$$&-%+

<$&$'# #0$##2$

# (0$2% #0$, ((%&$8$ '$% -$'%-#0 ###2$%&#0$*2%#= %#'2$ - ##0$ #+$%& %&*-%*$-#<#%#0$*2 #&&1''%- :2<.*2 #&&= (0$2$ ##2$ #% -$'%8$- '% ($- # * ,< 0$- #% #0$

/ 1$1 (1".!. 1 %=$8$-. (#0$*2 #&&= (&%4 #%0 8$,$$ *%(($((% %&#0$*-%*$-#<

%(4,(#

#8$$8$ '$= (&%4 -$(*$'##%

<%#0$-$C*$ ($( '4--$,<#0$ #&&. #0$-$&%-$. (0$ = %# 0$2 $ ##2$ #%

< (4'0 #1 **$ 2 = *-$&$--$ ,< $&$

# B

'-%(( %,>$'#% ( &2$ ,< #0$ *2 #&&1 $ #%

2 (#-'# 4:$. +, (+(($ #0$ 2 &2$ ,< #0$ $&$

# B

#. 0%=$8$-. =02$ * -#2< 22%= : #0$ '-%(( %,>$'#% (.

+%&$ >4:+$

$'-$$ %& #0$ 2$ $ #- 2 %4-# #% #0$ $C#$ # #0 # #0$ #&& = ( 0$2 $ ##2$ #% #$-$(# # #0$ - #$ %& "H % # %&

(1".!. .8$>4:+$

$'-$$ #$;111::-$8$#0$-$&-%+. *-$($ 20 (,$$ &2$1 $ '%4 ($2 &%- #0$

#( 8$0$+$ #2< -:4$( #0 # *2 0$-($2& %#(#$* #%#0$=# $((,%C,4##(0$-04(,

=0%$*%($ (0$- *%=$-%& ##%- $<0%2$-.#0$-$&%-$.#0(:-%4 #($2&((4&&'$ ##% % (4##0$ #&&1 %-$%8$-. *%(($((% %& #0$ *-%*$-#< = ( 42< 0

$ %8$- #% #0$

(0$ 0 ( - ($ '% #0$-$% 1 # ( 4$ #% #0( 8$-< & '# #0 $ #- 2 %4-# 0 ( -$#4- & : #0 # *2 #&& 0$-($2& 0 -$+

$:2:$

= %#$ ##2$#%

<'%+*$ ((0$0$-($2& %#+ /$

$'$(( -< E4-$(,$&%-$( 2$%&*-%*$-#< =0'0= ((%2,<= <%&

1 #&&(.#04(.(# #$#%,$:42#<%& %#0 8 :$C$-'($4$2:$ '$1 $'%4-#(,$2%=.#((4,+##$.0 8$$--$ %,($-8 :#0

#-< -$:

$E4# ,2$ +%-#:

:$ (0%42 0 8$ ,$$ + $ #0$ -$8$ 4$ -$'%-(

#0 ##0$

#= (.#04(. $:2:$ # #0(-$:

-2$ :#%8$(# %&

<-:0# #&&1#(.#04(.*- <$#0 #>4:+$

$'-$$"1!1? * (($ ,< #0$ 2$ $ 82 4:$ @4 %- 8(% A. ( =$22 >4:+$

$'-$$ #$ ;11 * (($ ,< 2$ $ #%

2 (#-'# 4:$.+, ,$($# ($1 $ -2$

8$:% $#0-%4:0#0$ &2$=#00( ,2$ (((#

'$1 #( + ##$-%&-$'%-#0 #*-%*$-#< ,$$ +%-#:

:$ =#0 #0$

# B ,

/ ,< % $ 4-$ $- :0 (% %& -$+ :0 =0$ 0$

2$#0$& '2#<%&2%

&-%+#0$

#0$( +$= +##$2<,< < %&

$E4# ,2$+%-#:

:$1 6$ $ '%4 ($2 (4

,2$ #%$ < #0 # 4-$ $- :0.=0%0 +%-#:

:$*-%*$-#<=#0#0$,

/0 #-

(&$--$#0$( +$4-

#0$*$-%#(#%%+%-#:

:$=#0#0$,

((-$&2$'#$ +4# %1?;

#0 #*%(($((% %&#0$*2 #&&= ((#4-,$,<% $ 0874+ -.#0%4:0#( (4,+##$#0 #*2 #&&$ #$-$ #% '%+*-%+($=#00+ (4,($E4$ #(# :$1 ($2(4

,2$#%*% #%4#

<#0 :% -$'%-#% '

#$#0 ##0(& '# ( ,-%4:0# #% #0$ &%-$ ,< #0$

# #0$ #+$ %& %& #0$ *2%#

*4-'0 ($- = ( *4# #% %#'$ %& #0$ & '#1 (4'0 (#4 #% ( < #0

# B ,

/ ( $ ##2$ #% -$# #0$ '% ($- # $*%(#$ ,< #0$ #&&E4 #0$*-%*$-#< .('2$ -2<4 >4(#&$1-:4+$ #- ($,<

#(#0 ##0$*2 #&&0 ((4,($E4$ #2<$ #$-$ #% '%+*-%+($=#0(4,($E4$ #*4-'0 ($-(%& % 2#%#0$

(#( %# -$2$8

8$ %,$ - :% #0$#-

,$#=$$

/1#(-$2$8

##% %#$ ##0((# :$#0 ##0$-$( %(4'0$8$ '$% -$'%- -$:

- : '%+*-%+($ %- ($##2$+$ #. &

<. ,$#=$$ #0$ *2

(4,($E4$ #*4-'0 ($-%- 4-$ $- :0

#&&1 +2 -2<.% %#&

<+$-# -:4+$ #- ($,<2$ '%4

#(#0 #*2 #&&(0%42,$ % (4#$% #0$:-%4 #0 ##( 0$-04(,

=0%(#$**$ #%#0$=# $((,%C

%##0$*2 #&&0$-($2&10$-$(

%#0 :% -$'%-#% '

#$#0 ##0$*2 #&&D(04(,

= %# -$%& 22#0$ & '#4 (*$'#( %& #0$ + ##$-

%# 0 8$ *$-(%

2 / %=2$:$ %&#0$ ( +$1

$&$-$ '$ #0(-$:

,$+ $#%>4:+$ #%&#0$% D,2$ 4*-$+$%4-#

!"#

%1 6$ $ '%4-#( ,$2%= 0 8$ '%--$'#2< -$#4- $ '% '4--$ # & :( %& & '#. , ($4*% *-%*$- **-$' %&#0$$8$ '$% -$'%-1 7$$* : 8$=#0$& '#(

'-'4+(#

'$(.#0$-$( %E4$(#% %& =.+4'02$(( (4,(#

# 2E4$(#% %&2 =.=0'0( 8%28$&%-'% ($- #0(-$:42 -($'% 21

#(4

,2$#%*% #%4#

<22$:

2#<. &-+#<%-*$-8$-(#< +*4:

$>4:+$

$'-$$"1!1?* (($,<#0$ $824:$@4 %-8(% A. (=$22 (>4:+$

$'-$$

#$;11* (($,<2$ $#%

2(#-'#4:$.+, .=0'0'

22( &%-

< #$-&$-$ '$,<#0(%4-# ($'% 21 ''%- :2<.#0( 2((+(($=#0 %%-$- (#%'%(#(1 @6( 22A $*#$+,$-. 4:$

F0$#0$-(*$ / -$ (% )$( % F0$#0$--$*%-# ,2$ )$( %