Hewlett Packard India Sales Pvt. Ltd. Etc. v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"# "$ "%"" " "$ "
$&'
$'()*) + , ,
'-.'&& (/0 ) 1.'* 2&, 3&, &(, ,,,,,, '&)&) '0* 4* 1&&'
05 0, ,,,,,'*6 '&*
'-.'&& (/0 ) 1.'* 2&, 3&, &(, ,,,,,, '&)&) '0* 4* 1&&'
05 0, ,,,,,'*6 '&*
!
"
# $ %%%%%
!"#$ %&'%($)!
&' ( # & " )
" &*+, -
""
"" . /
- # $0 1-# &
$'
# $ - - () # 23& 4* 4, $4&5 5$45,05,050&&$467+4,) 8 9 1 - ""
- " / / " -" $* &4 $4&5 " 2+
- / # $
" "
" / "
- : ";
-"
< " 24
/ "
/ - # 30020, $3 &4 $4&5 9( 7 1 " // = 8 " / # $ ( # 2 5 + , 0 -" 6
!
! "#
$% $% & !
'
'
(())*(+
(,-)*(+./ 0 1( )*(+ (2-)*(+ % 34 5
$ +/
! $% $%&
'
.
6
$%
! $% $% &
7 .!
$% $% &
!
(())*(+
(,-)*(+./ 0 2( )*(+ (2*-)*(+ % 34
5
$
'
4
8
9 !
! !
8
- 4
!
8
!
8
5
% !
:
5
%
!
$% $%&
(())*(+
(,-)*(+ ./ 0 1( )*(+ (2-)*(+ % 34
5
$ 4
!
5
%
./ 0 1(
)*(+
6 ; 5
4
!
6 ;
./
5
% :
6 ;
!
! !
, 4
!
.
:
%< $ $
$% $% &
:
$
% $
:
./ 0 1(
)*(+ 4
: % $%$%&
:
8
9 !
! !
8
$% $% &
!
= 2' 8 " - 1 -/ / /
# $ : $* &4 $4&5
"- " "" "
"
"
" "
- # 25 +, 0 $* &4 $4&5
6
/
/
% '
$ !
%
/ % 6 "$%=#
> !
! $%/
$%" $% $% & #
!
!
8 )2
?
)*(+ "8 =#
!
$%
** *****@ . 6
A 4 6
!
/ $%$%& + /
8 ! $% $%& . ;' $ &
$%$%&
!
(())*(+
(,-)*(+ ./ 0 1( )*(+ (2-)*(+ % 34
5
$
'
/
/
8 9
!
! !
8
-/
/
5
%
./ 0 1( )*(+
6 ; 5
/
/
6 ; !
:
./
5
%
6 ;
8
!
! !
,/
/
:
%<$ $
$%$%&
:
$
%$
:
./ 0 1( )*(+
:
!
: $%$%& =
5' - < - () / "" 8 $& && $4&5
-6 6
' )2(*)*(+"8 9 %3)#
./ "8 9 %3(#
: $
(-())*(+ ; !
;
"#
!
"#
!
!
' )2(*)*(+ "8 9 %3)#"#
9 = +' 8 &4 &$ $4&5>
- 1 " # $ ! / ";
-" $* &4 $4&5 /: -- 1
8 -"
: - - - "
"
-
#
""
1 "
"
-" ? &4 &$ $4&5 &, &$ $4&5 / "
" 2+
8 &, &$ $4&5 /
6 8
),*()*(
!
9 = ,' ) / # $ / "
/ < / -
-" <// ?$* &4 $4&5
- # $
"
1- " " 1 "" @# $ "
: /- 1- # &
.- "
""- ) /- 1
1 # $ 1# "
-""/
# / "- - " -" / - - # $ - - " - )- " ) A / "
- -" 8# $ :
/ # $ /- / 1- 0'
# $
- "
&* && $4&5
- "" $* &4 $4&5
- - -/ # $ # @ 1 / # $ "
"
/ >
-
1 () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ 5$425$235+4,&$47) /-
8 ) # $ < - () / ""
)1< - &3 4$ $4&+ / >
- &+, B2' < () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ 5$4;25$;235;+4,;&$467 ) -
8 9 1
- /<- 8/ 1- () "/-
/-- 6 62*+23 $4&5 8 -- () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ / : "- / "
6 62*+23$4&5 8 () " : - $& && $4&5 &, &$ $4&5 / 6 62*+23$4&5 **7'
( 8)*'
*'
";
-"
: $ - - " "
2+
/ / "
"
// =
/ "
/ # & ""
- -- : -" ?
/ - " " -" "
# $ --
: -" " " / / # $ @ " / "
/ " / 1 / " : " 8 # $ - <. " " " - / - "" &4' @ "
/ &, &$ $4&5 1 # $
" 2+
/: - &&' 8 " # $ - " - "
1 8
" /
# $ - "< / - - # $ / # )
" # $ " "" - " 1/ 1 :/: " / ) # $
"
()
&$' @ /
" &, &$ $4&5 () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ 5$425$235+4,&$47)
8 " / - $& 4$ $4&+ --()
- # $
" 2+
-" "" ( - # $ / 1 " "" - / 1 " 2+
/ 1-
/ - / 1 " # $
-- () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ - - # $ / / # $ /
/
"/ &2' 8 1 / # $ - / - " -)- " ) A B
/# &' / "
8 / "
" / -"; " " : )
# $ -"; "/ -"
" " ? " -" # $
-"; " / # $ " - -" - " " &5' ) 91:.
/ #:0-; 4'0*7* 7)/ &:'0*<
0)8).= C/ : "
"
"
/ "
- " / "
/ - : # / -"
" - " ) "
- - - - - "" -- "" &+' ) () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ 5$4 25$235+4,&$47) 8 " /23
"
/ - "
- " " 23
8 "- ()
5() 6
+4 )2(*)*(+
;
0
!
:
;
0
!
5
!
!
! !
0 4
!
B
B 4
0 B ?
0 !
!
!
= &,' 8 -- " / "
/ " - /
" D)- " ) A"E / " () # 23& &* 4, $4&5 5$4 5,05,350&+4,&$47) 8
&0' = "" / "
- () # 3&* $& && $4&5 "
- @# $52,*$4&5
/ / - /
&+,B2' () # 23&() # 3&* () # &2, / " " / / " -? (.7*) &3' - "
) " " 2+
/ - " - / " " " "" "" / / "
" / - " / - "# $ <." "" /
-- "/
-- " - 6 " )- " ) A # $ /
/ 1 1
" 2+
&*' 53$ / - : 8 /:/ -B' B' /
B' )
# $ /
"- / " "" # $ / / /
/ "/ 8 :
53$ "
/ -
" 2+
"
# $ - " # $ " - " /< () # &20
/
$4' < /
() # 23& 4* 4, $4&5 5$4 5,0 5,0 50& &$467 +4, ) 8 9
1 () # &20 $& 4$ $4&+ 5$4 25$ 235 +4, &$47 ) - 8
- /< - - " < "! " 1 !
$
> 42$4&+