High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3862/2003dismissed

(O&M) Savitri Devi And ORS v. Subhash Chand And ORS

2015-12-09Mr Justice Jaswant Singh6 pages

! "#$%& '( )* ! "#$%& '( )* ! "#$%& '( )* ! "#$%& '( )* !+,&-& !+,&-& !+,&-& !+,&-& .!/ .!/ .!/ .!/ 0 !

0 !

!1%2+22+3-+& !1%2+22+3-+& !1%2+22+3-+& !1%2+22+3-+& !

.!/ !

.!/ 4" 4" 4" 4" 564 ! 564 ! 564 ! 564 !

&,"

4&72+82+(!&3#+,(9,2 4&!+9+&(3#+,(&,2:,,& 4&3&;,!<2(3#+,(&,2&:3, )=2,2& :&,& #+ 9:+:& $+8 % +93,,2;13<$,>!?

%&&&3,,2 :&,&&,>!? =2,2& ,2 ;13<$, 213 % &:&,3 ,2 3<,>!?

66(. &+/

66(. &+/ #, :,, :&&&3 %8 ,2 +3&3 .:,,&/.9+3$3%8,2 ,,&&(3&3&( 3+,3 ) )++::+:&&&3+<+,,2+3 &3&+3+39+3$33;13<$,3+,3 @ (

,2+3&3%&,21&,(3,2&:,, &8(,2#,,2,+,.&:3,/9+ #+$3+##1,A:+8$,&,(&,2#+,1, %8,2+3&39+,2+,,2,+,.&:3,/9++&&+& 9 B @)'')(CD)( ?A:&$,23(9+,21(+% ,%#,3 3#(,9+:+33(,&++(,2+,,2,+, 2+3,+7,2:&$+,,2&,D ?A:&$,29

) )'' 2 ,,(%<&31:%8,2+3&3(, #+$&,+,D)( ?A:&$,2(9++&<3+3+%&#+,3 3#1$,+#,(,2,+,9+,,3,&#&++$1, D) ( ?A &$ ,2 +3&3 ,2+, 2 2+3 %&&93 +3 E#1,3+:&,+3+&#:,+1&,2,+, +#3&+,,2$+,,&1+3,2 3#&#&3(%,2,2+1,2&,##1&&,8##133 ,2+,,2 ,,(E2%,A)(:&:133%8,2+3&39+ 33+&<3+3+%&#+,33#1$,+3(,21(+3&3 +3,:&,2+,&,3$3:&$9+D)( ?

:&$ +3 +::#+, 9+ +93 , +3 :&$ +3 +::#+, 9+ +93 , +3 :&$ +3 +::#+, 9+ +93 , +3 :&$ +3 +::#+, 9+ +93 , +3 #3+&83#&,,92#2:&3GG #3+&83#&,,92#2:&3GG #3+&83#&,,92#2:&3GG #3+&83#&,,92#2:&3GG ,+3,2&:3,,2+,<+,1& +72 ,+3,2&:3,,2+,<+,1& +72 ,+3,2&:3,,2+,<+,1& +72 ,+3,2&:3,,2+,<+,1& +72 EA)( 9& ,&+:+,3 &$ $&,<+< 33 EA)( 9& ,&+:+,3 &$ $&,<+< 33 EA)( 9& ,&+:+,3 &$ $&,<+< 33 EA)( 9& ,&+:+,3 &$ $&,<+< 33 E

+3<+,1&!1%+22+3&E) E

+3<+,1&!1%+22+3&E) 9&,&+:+,3&$&,,4+&7A 2+& 9&,&+:+,3&$&,,4+&7A 2+& 9&,&+:+,3&$&,,4+&7A 2+& 9&,&+:+,3&$&,,4+&7A 2+& ,2 E+#, &:#+ +3 1:&$:, ,2& ,2 E+#, &:#+ +3 1:&$:, ,2& ,2 E+#, &:#+ +3 1:&$:, ,2& ,2 E+#, &:#+ +3 1:&$:, ,2& 3$ :3,E+$3&,1H!<+ 3$ :3,E+$3&,1H!<+ 3$ :3,E+$3&,1H!<+ 3$ :3,E+$3&,1H!

+::+&3 ,2 :2, #:8 E:+3 %8

2$,2+,+3:&,%#+$<2,&+3<2,& 2$,2+,+3:&,%#+$<2,&+3<2,& 2$,2+,+3:&,%#+$<2,&+3<2,& 2$,2+,+3:&,%#+$<2,&+3<2,& ,2 :&# ,&+:+,< ,2 <+,1&( ,2 :&# ,&+:+,< ,2 <+,1&( ,2 :&# ,&+:+,< ,2 <+,1&( ,2 :&# ,&+:+,< ,2 <+,1&( 9&3I2+3J2+,+::+&3EA) + 9&3I2+3J2+,+::+&3EA) + 9&3I2+3J2+,+::+&3EA) + 9&3I2+3J2+,+::+&3EA) + :&:+&3 ,&+:+&# K1,3 <+,1& :&:+&3 ,&+:+&# K1,3 <+,1& :&:+&3 ,&+:+&# K1,3 <+,1& :&:+&3 ,&+:+&# K1,3 <+,1& +3:#$<+,1&92#2+&:&3+E @ +3:#$<+,1&92#2+&:&3+E @ +3:#$<+,1&92#2+&:&3+E @ +3:#$<+,1&92#2+&:&3+E @ , E AB( 92#2 :& ,2+, <+,1& +72 , E AB( 92#2 :& ,2+, <+,1& +72 , E AB( 92#2 :& ,2+, <+,1& +72 , E AB( 92#2 :& ,2+, <+,1& +72 H1$+&EA),2E+#,&:#+<+,1& H1$+&EA),2E+#,&:#+<+,1& H1$+&EA),2E+#,&:#+<+,1& H1$+&EA),2E+#,&:#+<+,1&

+72 H1$+& $&,<+< 33 E

+3 <+,1&!1%+22+3EA),2E+#, <+,1&!1%+22+3EA),2E+#, <+,1&!1%+22+3EA),2E+#, <+,1&!1%+22+3EA),2E+#, &:#+!1%+22+34+&7 2&3A &:#+!1%+22+34+&7 2&3A &:#+!1%+22+34+&7 2&3A &:#+!1%+22+34+&7 2&3A $+&,8,2&$+,(L(:+#<+3,2& $+&,8,2&$+,(L(:+#<+3,2& $+&,8,2&$+,(L(:+#<+3,2& $+&,8,2&$+,(L(:+#<+3,2& 9&,< #2+&+#,&,# 9+ E+$3 9&,< #2+&+#,&,# 9+ E+$3 9&,< #2+&+#,&,# 9+ E+$3 9&,< #2+&+#,&,# 9+ E+$3

)''

92&+!20+&3&212+2+,+<+&

)''

92&+!20+&3&212+2+,+<+&

)''

92&+!20+&3&212+2+,+<+&

)''

92&+!20+&3&212+2+,+<+& E:&, +::#+, 9+ E+$3 +33,+ E:&, +::#+, 9+ E+$3 +33,+ E:&, +::#+, 9+ E+$3 +33,+ E:&, +::#+, 9+ E+$3 +33,+ 3# ) 2 &:&, 9+ 3# ) 2 &:&, 9+ 3# ) 2 &:&, 9+ 3# ) 2 &:&, 9+ %&!20+&3&212+2+,+<+&E:&,(%1, %&!20+&3&212+2+,+<+&E:&,(%1, %&!20+&3&212+2+,+<+&E:&,(%1, %&!

9,2 ,2 2: G &<&8( # , 9+ GG 9,2 ,2 2: G &<&8( # , 9+ GG 9,2 ,2 2: G &<&8( # , 9+ GG 9,2 ,2 2: G &<&8( # , 9+ GG &:3,,2+,,29&,2&1,,&+:+& &:3,,2+,,29&,2&1,,&+:+& &:3,,2+,,29&,2&1,,&+:+& &:3,,2+,,29&,2&1,,&+:+& &<&8&:&,!2&0+&3&212+2+,+<+& &<&8&:&,!2&0+&3&212+2+,+<+& &<&8&:&,!2&0+&3&212+2+,+<+& &<&8&:&,!

2&0+&3&212+2+,+<+& E:&, =* +% , % <&3 8 ,2 E:&, =* +% , % <&3 8 ,2 E:&, =* +% , % <&3 8 ,2 E:&, =* +% , % <&3 8 ,2 <&13 : ,2+, <+,1& #+, % <&13 : ,2+, <+,1& #+, % <&13 : ,2+, <+,1& #+, % <&13 : ,2+, <+,1& #+, % ,&+:+,3+9,21,+8%+!2&:&, ,&+:+,3+9,21,+8%+!2&:&, ,&+:+,3+9,21,+8%+!2&:&, ,&+:+,3+9,21,+8%+!

2&:&, 3,2:,2#++::#+,+$&:#,1 3,2:,2#++::#+,+$&:#,1 3,2:,2#++::#+,+$&:#,1 3,2:,2#++::#+,+$&:#,1 +<&$,9,2,2+1,2&,8 +<&$,9,2,2+1,2&,8 +<&$,9,2,2+1,2&,8 +<&$,9,2,2+1,2&,86+!<2#,3.1:&+/ 6+!<2#,3.1:&+/ 6+!<2#,3.1:&+/ 6+!<2#,3.

1:&+/ ,2+,E:&,9,+&<&+8,&,3+3, ,2+,E:&,9,+&<&+8,&,3+3, ,2+,E:&,9,+&<&+8,&,3+3, ,2+,E:&,9,+&<&+8,&,3+3, ,2:3#3#E:&,#+% ,2:3#3#E:&,#+% ,2:3#3#E:&,#+% ,2:3#3#E:&,#+% +#,31:92,1%,+,+8#&&%&+,3 +#,31:92,1%,+,+8#&&%&+,3 +#,31:92,1%,+,+8#&&%&+,3 +#,31:92,1%,+,+8#&&%&+,3 ,2+3#+,2&9&E:&,E+$3%8%,2 ,2+3#+,2&9&E:&,E+$3%8%,2 ,2+3#+,2&9&E:&,E+$3%8%,2 ,2+3#+,2&9&E:&,E+$3%8%,2 ,2:+&,,2#+2+3+,21<2,2&+& ,2:+&,,2#+2+3+,21<2,2&+& ,2:+&,,2#+2+3+,21<2,2&+& ,2:+&,,2#+2+3+,21<2,2&+& E:&,E+$3%8%,2,2:+&,%1,,2E:&, E:&,E+$3%8%,2,2:+&,%1,,2E:&, E:&,E+$3%8%,2,2:+&,%1,,2E:&, E:&,E+$3%8%,2,2:+&,%1,,2E:&, +::#+,33,,1#2,2$+,,&3:1,+3 +::#+,33,,1#2,2$+,,&3:1,+3 +::#+,33,,1#2,2$+,,&3:1,+3 +::#+,33,,1#2,2$+,,&3:1,+3 ,2&8&:&, E:&,9,2&<+&3,,2 ,2&8&:&, E:&,9,2&<+&3,,2 ,2&8&:&, E:&,9,2&<+&3,,2 ,2&8&:&, E:&,9,2&<+&3,,2 $+,,& 3:1, +3 2 2+ < ,2 3, $+,,& 3:1, +3 2 2+ < ,2 3, $+,,& 3:1, +3 2 2+ < ,2 3, $+,,& 3:1, +3 2 2+ < ,2 3, :9,2&+2#1&,2+::#+, :9,2&+2#1&,2+::#+, :9,2&+2#1&,2+::#+, :9,2&+2#1&,2+::#+, 2++3,29,2+,2:9&<!

+$ 2++3,29,2+,2:9&<!+$ 2++3,29,2+,2:9&<!+$ 2++3,29,2+,2:9&<!+$ ,29,2+,,2#+: #+, ,29,2+,,2#+: #+, ,29,2+,,2#+: #+, ,29,2+,,2#+: #+, %<&3M %<&3M %<&3M %<&3M EA+#( ,2 &:&,( E2%, A)( 1%$,,3 %8 & ,1H!<+(+39&,<+3 <& &,E:&,.

=A /(18 3$,&+,,2+,,2 ,,(E2%,A)(9++&<3+3 +%&#+,33#1$,,2<#13%:,31,+,29 ,2:&3&3 %8 ,2 E:&, 9+ ,2& &&1 & +%,%3#+&33,2&3#9+3,2&,:& ,2+, ,2 :+&, 2+3 33 ,,3 ,2 &, +, D)( ?A :& $,29 B) )'' 2 +&<1$, ,2+, 2+ % +3+#3 %8 ,2 +&3&#1&,2:,,&,2+,+,2 ,, 4+&7I J(&$+31:&3(,2+$#13,%,+7

, +##1,( +#7 ##,( & %,2 ,2 +1,2&, 2+3 &&&3 , ,2 +3 3#1$,N # ,2 2+39&,< E:&, .

/ 2 &:&, .E2%, )/ 2+3 3,&$3 ,2+, ,2 <+,1&,+,A!1%2+22+3&,,.E2%,)/ 9&,&+:+,3&$,23#1$,4+&7 +3,9+& ,2+,$,3:1&:,23#1$,(4+&7 (9+&&&3, +8 #+( 4&,<+< 3 .E2%,

/ 9+ + 13:1,3 3#1$,+3,23,:&3&3%8,2E:&,9+ ,2+,<+,1&,+,A +72H1$+&9&+,&+:+,3 &,,.E2%,)/&$,2+33#1$,679(,2 ,+,$, =)( ,2+, 9+ &#&33 92 #3&< ,2 +::#+,,2+3&3,+3#3+&83#,:& ,2 ,,.E2%,)/(9+#K1#92+8 3,&$<,2+3,8+3&+#,8,2+33#1$,( ,29+7,2,2&3#&#&32+,%<(,2 8+3,2,+%##1%,2,2+1,2&,#13 +&&+,9+,23,2+,,2+3&32+3+3,:&,2+, ,2&+,&,9+D)( ?A:&$,2 +,2&(,23# &#&3293,2+,,22:K1,,1,+,D ?A:& $,2 #&329,2+,,2&:3,2+3,3&3,2 &, ,2 &, 3+, )* )''( 9

@)'') ,

) )''(9,2,&,+3#,(++3%8,2#1&, 21(,9+&<2,8##133,2+,,2+$1,,3&3%8,2 ,+,9+,2&2&,&+3 2+, %< ( ,&&# 9+&&+,3 E&#&+;1&3#,13&!#,)*.*/,2+,

1;+% &%+ , ,&#,#,()'@' ,,%<33

$&,(+##&3<8(3$3$ 4 '( )* 4 '( )* 4 '( )* 4 '( )* .

66/ .

66/ H+< H+< H+< H+<