← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/718/2002allowed

Amar Singh v. Ajaib Singh

2017-11-02Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages



     







  



    

   

!"#

$!

%&'()*&!+,&!*&-&# .!#,&//0&#1&//00&#

$!

!&%(,&&-&#.! $!

&-!!!&-&#.!!"/#

 

       $"

23412351. 5 ,!"&//0&#"67&#.0&'.07 #,&//0&#.!!"#!&#&&&//0&#.!!"#!&#.#, &//&0&"800

9&!)"0.!#,")!&*/&',&":%# .#,&//0&#"&!&008 $"&!&008&#,&//&0"!"#!##"!7&0 )*:!

$&&""#&6:&!8#,#,"#.:#,/&!#"

  3.

,  /!"#  &//&0  "  &7&"#  #,  &8&!  &#  4

/&"":'#,$#!#"0&*"!:)&0 &#&0&<.!",!#=#, !:)&0=>

,  /!"#  &//&0  ,&"  :  .0  :'  #,  0&*&#"  .!

,&*#.#,&*)#&8&!:'#,!:)&0&"*/"&#.! &#,.,&%&(&)!

,&%&(&)!&724'&!"0"#,!0.&*#!-,)0&! &#4 ;;3 +,8&"#!&-007&%/:&!7!7"#!&# 

$1 ,"&%/8&""#!)6:'&#&6!:&!7!7"#!&# 

4;

&"&!")0#.#,&#",")..!*)0#/0%)!" &0"#,!0.  8&"&0"077

#,0&*/##.0)!+#55.#,$#! ?,0"#;33<.!",!#=#,#=>#,!:)&0&8&!&")*.

43

@1&078#,#!"#&##,!&#.;A/!&)*

,&-,&!0&!)"0.!#,/&!#"&/!)"#, /&/!1:6

,7!-&!&":'0&!)"0.!#,&//00&#" #8.0.!"#0'#,&##,&"8&"&,)"8.&,!*#,0' *,&":#&6&"

@1/!*#,0'8,,"#,08!

"&#,*)0#/0!.,&":8!70'&//0"#&.2

+0',##,&##,&*)#&8&!)!-#&0 ,&"".

@10'  9&!)"0.!#,!"/#",&"&!7)#,&##, &*)#&8&!"%)"#&B)#&:0 *!,&*#"

&00.!

,##.#,0&!)"0.!#,&//00&#8#, !7&!#*)0#/0!#:&//0".)00'")//!#:'#,".#, =:0+)/!*)!# !"#!$"%!"&'&($#)* "!+&,"-", +".

/01*'*#"/!#,"&"&*)0#/0!.2

",)0,&-:&//08,#,&"8&"24'&!"0 +.&!#,#!*&#.*#,0'*.&,)"8. "!#,)#".#,,)"8.&!2C +,8!6"8#,)# &'!*)!&# ,0-&&..#.#,.&*0'6/",!77

/&!#.!*067&.#!#,.&*0'",/!.!*"#,*&#!*&0)#" &"800 ,=:0/D)!#       

  

   . 4<2>+  ,&",0&")!

==-&"")*7&'-&#:#!&!-8&"# "0.1*/0'7*:!!'&#&0!78!6#, .&#!*&"#,&#",8&"&,)"8.&&,**&6!

#",&!#*#E#,*"#8!6:'& ,)"1*#,!

 ,  "!-"  .  #,  *#,!@8.  " &-&0&:02,)!"&,!)#"&!-!.D )!#"

,&-!7"#,#!:)#*&:'#,8.##, ,)"")-&0)&:0&#,&##&#:*/)# #!*"  .  *'

   ,)"18.@,*1*&6!  "  # 8!6:'#,06&",""#&#&##&. #,.&*0'#,!)7,)#&"),"!-"!!:'#, ,**&6!,&"#:""&!0'6/#-88,0 &0)0&#7#,0""./'

== =:0/D)!#,&",0#,&##,)#".#,,)" *&6!&#:)!"#*&#&#"-!'..)0##B)&##,"&* *#&!'#!*"

!*&/!)"&0.#,&8&!#"-##,&##,!:)&0 ,&"B)&##,#!:)#.#,&",)"8.8#,#,"&0&!'. #,*& #").!#)&##,&##,#!:)#.*#,!8.&& ,)"*&6!,&":B)&#8#,"&0&!'.&*&8,,"6/#&.#! ,!&#,

(/7-8#,&7.#,&"&#,.&##,&#",

8&"")!--:',)":&&#8*!,0!,!*#,0'&!7" &""""&# 4

@1/!*#,&#,*)0#/0!.2"&//0&"/! #,".#,/D)!#&"+&!0&?!*&&"<")/!&> ,##!&":'0&!)"0.!#,&//00&# 8#,!7&!#-#&0,&""8.)00'-!:'#,0&#"# ".#,=:0+)/!*)!#

    !"

# $  ?"

% #&   +9 <+/&09&- ##<-0>

44;

. 2>

,/D)!#,0&")!

F5 -8.#,&.!"&&&0'""8/!#!!)! 0)""

<>,#81)7,    ",)0,&-: 800&-"#!.!#,*&##!#&0&!7!,&"#8&" #&67&..!#-8#,&8,&#,&":"#&#  &%)7*#:'&!&#, #":&)"& !&#,.#,"&*"#!7#,&##&6&#!&!' -8#,&8,&#,&":,0:'&#,!!&#,

<>"  ,&"##&6#.#,"     8,,  8&"  0-!  &#  &!0!  /#  .  #*  #, " "#&:7/!#

<>G,0#!*7#,*&&#.4 A.

&#)&0"&0&!'##,*.#,&"#8&!".)#)! /!"/#"8,!#,&",&&/!*&#%:&8&" :08#,&7.2 '&!"",)0:*& ,&#",)0 : A.#,&7.#,&"8&"23:#82 #4

'&!"

&"#,&"8&":#8#,&7.4 #5

'&!"#,&#",)0:4A #)&0"&0&!'",)0:!& &"&#)&0"&0&!'0""#&D <->&"#,&"8&""0.1*/0'!&.D "&0&!'&&#.2 A.#,"#&:0",*",)0: #,8&!!&#8,!#,&"8&":08#,&7.2 '&!"

&#.4A8,!#,&"8&":#8#,&7. #4 '&!"& A8,!#,&"8&":#8#, &7.4 #5 '&!"",)0:!7&!&"#,""&!'

*#, .*/)#&# ,"#&:0", * *&" #, **)"#,#&D*/#

<-> !#!*&#.#,*)0#/0&#,)#.! /!"&0&0-7D/""#,#!:)&0"&#,)!#"",&00 :7):'/&!&7!&/," #.   8,,8 ,&-!/!),!:.! <->,"0#.*)0#/0!",&00:&"&##, &:0 !&8#,/&!&7!&/,2.#,&#%)7*#

<->,&7.#,&"",)0:#,:&"".!&//0'7 #,*)0#/0!

<-> &"&:0.7)!"-#&0,&"&*0'0"" ."#&#0""."!#)*&.)!&0D/""",)0:

4

@1 2 

@1& 4

@1!"/#-0'

, &.!"&&*)#"",)0:,&&##,!&#. A -!'#,!'&!"

H (/7-8.#,0&80&8#,&*)#)! -#&0,&"#,&#&!#:&8&!&")! 1 ,&*)#&8&!:'#,!:)&0)!.)!&0D/"" &#

@1",&#

@1&&#,!")*. 

@1 .!0""."!#)* ,&*)#&8&!:'#,!:)&0",& &"/!#&:07-:08 &

 '  !"  

(  #  )# ! 9""./'

4

CC2 I2 

@1

)!&0  D/""

4

@1 "!#)*



#&0 2.3.

,&8&!&#4

"*.##,D###,&##, &*)#  .  43

@1  &8&!  :'  #,  #!:)&0  "  ,&  :' &2.3.

,0&*&#"",&00:##0#,&&*)#&078#, #!"#&##,!&#.5A.!*#,&#..07.#,0&*/###00#" !&0E&#

##"#&"/&!#0'&0088#,#,&:-*.&#

6'+$$&))*+7!+8 9:7$

 " G,#,!"/&67@!&" "@ G,#,! /!#&:0 "@