High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9749/2025dismissed

Shubhamdeep Singh Kang v. Union Territory Chandigarh

2025-05-27The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel16 pages

"

#$% &'()*+(,-.-)/

!"

6

!

#$ %

$ &

'()*+) ,-,./

&/ #!

%$ # 0

$ &

'(-11.2,+,, &/ , ,-,./ #!

%$ # $ # $ $

&

'(-, ,-,./ 2

&/ #$ 0

$

# 0

$

#4 $ #%

$

5#4

#6

#63 %$

&'(- # $

&

'(-, ,-,./

9

9:,8

( #

-11. -, ,-,./

(+ 77777

!

8 3

&'

'9)*+)9,-,./

2 , &'

(

'9-11.9,-,./ : ; 3

-,9,-,./

&'

'9 +

,+

<

+,,9,-,./

&'

'9 @

'9)*+ +)9,-,.

&

/ ,

$

,,A",,* *

=

% % 3

"

(>> 5 5 9 $ #

&#;"# #/ ",- -,+&

?

C : 9

& /

$

,-) 5 #

&#;"#/ / B

"

'91, ,:+9 ,-) 5

? C

0

!

" # #

!

$" % &

> > %

$

$

'( % $

) * + !

+

!

(

#

, !

!

"

" - +

# "

"

"

"

. !

"

"

#

" " # # !

#

! "

/ * + !

+ . "

! 01+

(

"

#

"

"

# "

"

# " !

" "

2331 4

5 &

/

4 C

-),,-)

D &

/( ,)19,-) &/

8

9

/ 6

"

# + # +

# !

, ?"

#

+

( 7 + +

" +

!

! " +

,01

#

7 +

" " 8 -

! !

#

9 !

" " 8 - !

: ; # !

, ?"

#

( 7 5 <

#

" =

>!

!

!

#

!

( , ?"

#

7 5 " +

" 4

! # , ?"

#

!

(7

5 <

= " +! , ?"

#

( 7 5 " +

" "

. " 2331+

"

" ! # , ?"

#

,01

#

7 =

>!

!

!! #

! , ?"

#

( 7 5 " +

< +

"

! +

" ! =5 &

/ $ 0 8

4 C

3 ,)-,-,.E ! " !#

&

?

C/ D &

/ (,)1 19,-)

1 %

( %

"

!

" "

!

-

* !

7

7

@ # 0

! > 0@>

@ AA ;; ;B9+ 2.

# ! 0 .

@ A;

;A

C+D

@ # !&

.

@ A;) ;; )/9

2 2 @ @- E #

@ #0

!>

@

) ;+

# !

( % 1 + ?"

#

" (

# # #

?"

#

" ( 7 +

+

!

" "

!

?"

#

+

# # " !

"

! ?> 4

1 +

!9) "

! "

# "

!

"

!

!

! +

# -

. 01

!

"

! +

! !

!

) * .

! " ! ?"

#

( ( 7

!! #

+

(

# + ! # 7 +

* "

!

# !

# + !

+

+F

" # ! !

AGA/ A;G+

"

!! " 5 &

/ =

$

" ! !

) ;// ;/; ) !

3* < < # >

< ><

<

" : ; > < ><:C/ >

!

$"

+ /AH !

+ 4 ) !

3* < + >

<

< :C9 IA)3* *

;/H ! C9 # !

" /H ! C9 # !

(

- . ' " (-'

J

"

>

!

!

$" ( "F

+"

! < " : ! % !

! () ) $

& '

B (-' ; >

/

( !

( I 3* (

>( 3

01

(

B (-' 9

(

1 I C9 * 9I) * ;; 9/ A)

%!% ! $ % $ $ $ $ *+ + % , $

$$!+ +!

$ % !!

+!

$ % ! 444 444 444 444 444 444 !* $ % *!& & *' ;

# 7-- 4

! # 7 F +

1 " " !

" ' .

! 6

( !

,' , !

! ' ( + 7 ?

+

-*!

"

. !

1 " " !

+

!!

! !

: ; !

!/ 0

1 !

! "

!

,

# 0

1

!

!

! /

! "

!

! !

! "

!

#

,

# " 0

1 !

!

!!#

! "

!

1

"

"

!

!, ! -.

! !% $ 9:

% %

$ % % /0

$ 12

!

$ .!! +!!

% % %

$% % /0

$1 2 !

$ 3

4 .!! ! $ * *!, %!

*% ++

% $ *!+ !!,

5 $$

$! $ 5 $ $$

$ $ % ! " 6 %! !!

7 1!, 8

. ;9 <= / > %!

>

$ $ % / $ %!$ (( !5 & / $

&

L0 01

!

K

9

$

,+-,,-,. % %

& &/"

&

/ !

,+-:, ,-,. &

?

)A

/ C/ 4 C

& / 01

!

+

# ! ( ) ! # 2 G BG, A;G

"

?"

#

" !

#

4 " +!

!

+

+

"

!

+

!

" "

! !

!

+

! 1

%

!

#

" # #

# + ! E;A+A AA,? E 1 1

+

" "

5 8 #

!

.! &

/

$

-) -+,-,. &

CAGA) / (" 2 C/

F

=

7

F ,-,+9,.

. %

(>>&5/, ,-,+ =

%

&/

-2&345 56-..-)/. + D

,*,-,+ ,:,,-, ,+

2

G

" G

&/ G G

"

D

+

4 4 C D

A AGA) /("2

$

F =

F

H D

3

+ D

'9-,9,-,. ; 3

$

F

=

=

.-I

D

G

"

G

G

AGA) /("2 +, D

'9-11.9,-,. ( (

2 '9,+ +,,9,-,. <

AGA)

/("2

)A

/

D

$

G =

D

"

G" 4 C

%

"

G

L

K2L

K

$= F J

&/ /

&/

.

$

,)-+,-,.

$3 &=$/ #

> 6

D

$

E $ $ 0

$ E

&/

$ $

C

AG A) /("2

.-I =

D

AGA)

/("2

D

$= = F

$=

F H .-I

D

F

=

F ,-,+9, ,. %

(>>&5 5/9,-,+ AGA) /( ("2

D

=

F

&

"

/

G 4 C

""

J

$

AGA) /("2 A '

8-6( ..

.4( *

$

F=

F , -,+9,. /&39.-.

1

5 #

4 C

=

E

&/ /

0 8

4 C

%

2 H

,-)9,-,-'

H

,- )9,-,-

&/

"

,-)9,-,- 3H

,-,+9,-,.

2

"

, -,+9,-,.

,-,+9,-,.

3 3

4 C )

)

$

,)- -+,-,.

3H 0 01

!

$ 3

01

!

1

+

# #

01

(

< " !

2331 + >

( ! >( <

!

7--! 7?

" !

2331 )1

# +

! ;B 01+

(

! ! ! ! ;F

! / 1

#

!

! !

! 01

(

+

# #

"0

> < >< "

" /AH 91

! !

7',7 7?

+

! 01 <

+ # # " ?"

01

(

C 1

! #

#

+

!

#

+

#

:

'

!

+ !

" ( ! !

?"

+ !!

.

"

! . 8

!

+

!!

! 01

(

< B1

. !

!

:? 3 "

!

@

( : 1

$" + GA;

/+ !

?"

+

#

>

!

"

7',7 ) "

.

4 ! .+

"

" " "

# 6 " F F

: 1

! 01

(

<

#

#

!

+ !!

7?

"

> ?

# "

E. !@# > <

:?>!

01

(

><+ ><

4 /AH+

? "

!

# #

#8 34

!

:?1

!

"

A;G

1

4

"

#

! .

"

!

!

!

#

5 =

01

!

4 C

$

&1

/

F

% = 01

!

$= F

.-I $= F = 9 3

H

3

H 3

'

! ! ! + G

>H !

)- -1 >H

H

=

<

3

3

H

3

C

H

3

9

3

3

3

&/

3

1

!

- 4 C

"

4 C < &/

, -) 3

,-,.

%

%

! +

"

95 #

E

+

-

=

G

"1

G &/ =

+

% % (,-.-)/ =

'

& / $

)A

/

& ,./ ;

8

,:-+,- )

* *(?

)?

A;

G *(?G/9/?

A;G+ &

H $

H $9+

,)-+,-,.

$

/ &

/ '9)*+)9,-,.

&

/ ( #

#,*,

% ,-,. #

%

' %

" K "( ' K "(