High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/411/2004disposed of

Mahinder Pal v. State Ofharyana And Orsd

2015-09-17Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain10 pages

!"" #$% &&"" ' $ () * + & ! "#$%&

'()*+& ,&(-*".% !

,- %). #%") %/'/

$10"/&$+'2 "/* +

,&(-*".%/ ( 0""& 3 /3 4/3

/34 /

/% $ %%5$ 1+ ".&&"/"0 -.%

%& 5$ "/0 6+ ".&&"/) -. $ 1 "+/ ' 3

/ $$ ) 5$/ 4 /7 7/) * +$.5$ "$'"".2$/ ("8 / # "/ $ )0.( %!" 9 -#68 (%0 ""06+ $ ):

(5$"" /7"" 7' 0 3

% -'"$ 5$ " ; /

<=& 00 "" / "0 " 6> ? / " $ 6"0 %% -'"$ 5$ "; /

<=& (0 6%&$.& &&"6+6 &

$" "0 $6%5$ "& "5$"8 +/00 '"&. 5$5$/% "05$

%&$ & )0.( %!"9 -#68 >."05$ @ 02

-8 2 -0" +@.($

/'"$ "5$ ' $ )

)0. ( %!"9 -#68 /; /

<=& /5$0 %&$ &/$. " %/ 6"$ .&6&&"%&%+6 ("5$& %"80 $ 6A*

$ $6%% %&6+$ 7 $& /0$&"6+*76")$& %$ &&" "6+"0 %0. ( )& +&&" ? /" $" )$6% 6 +".'/ %6 %$8/0 & .5$ "/ 0$65$% "'("0 & 60 %&0"&". " $& *0' /$" @&" 0+$ 0 && 6$ $% " 5$% &.$ 0" 06.

-$& * " $" & & $&& 6- (@%&" %"$$ 6 $ & .% %& $ 5$ "% & & +/+& .

5$ $ " 6 $65$ 5$ ""0 9 &&" & . 5$ "% %&$ &0 "6 $ 0 $ ) 0$

/ $"&&&"& . " 5$% 0 &.$ 8 /0" 5$0 " % (- $%"$$/00 $ 0 %+/%& '.$"0 $

/0 @ 6"0= B :( %"". $ 5$/0'0$ @&$ &"/ $ % && & $

""0.

(5$"" ""$ """0 0 "6> $ %&"

""6> '6+"" "5$ "" 6 $ >$ %@%$% 0 % & ". 0 6> 6$ 6>/ ""6@6+""

""6> '$& 5$5$'6 $

3 9' " &$$&6 " $ 6"0/0 $/ ""$ % +< +< "" "" 6> '6+"" $& '6$ >$

6&" 8 " 0 '

0 &$$&

. . / " $ 6"0"""$6"""

.$ %5$ 6 . 6 & $ %

+% "' &

8%6> '"6+ "" + 0' /""6 $+ 6$ % $ %%"+ &% "$660" +&. & ".08 %6$ " +$ """6

$ 6+""

8 + 6> ' &" " 6+" $ /"" 0". %$ >$""@ &+ 0 <>$.% $ ".

0 / & . 5$ 5$

: ( " .$

%5$&=%"

6'""$" '"

(" $ 6"0-&'0 $6+*76")$& %$

.%(0 7 $& & . &" " 5$ 0 @ 6"0 B:9 0 & 6"% 6-". % $ ( $ ) 4$"6 "6+ %"'"& +8

&& & %/6"+ & 6+"$66.%. $&0 .' -. $" & 5$ + " " . & " "+ + ' $ 0 ' 6+ %% $" 6 "$66 . 0 $ + $ '"6" %. 4 @. 6 . %&""" ' 6+%% '

&$ 8 "

$%6 0 '0$"6 +"-"+6 $6 & &6.'(*.

$ $" - &" &+ "5$ 0 &6"$ %+6&

9@&' + $ & "+ 0 +

& $ "% $"6 + ( *.$ @ "".

&0 $"$ % &""&. $6 $ .".%+ 6& 0% % 6'C

4 (& .5$ " "< < <"< 6$ +

%" $ /0 5$ "&

: $.

'"". % &/ '$ $""0+6% $ $ D' % $

/ $. $ " %/" $ 6"0$""%-

""'"+ & $.&" 5$ "8 0$" 6 "" & &"0." 5$ ""$ $. & $6+)$ (" $ 6"0-&'06 ' %6+$ :4:

E -0 $ ' ( ) * + / :4

/& . %$/0 @ 6"0 B*0' / .$%6 %.6 $ /0 +&

$ 6. & $

$" % '"$ 5$ "/0%+ $">$ & + "+/$%6 /&&" "6+"0 & $.

"'/0/ /$"6 & '6"6+" 0 <) ' + 8 %+ / $ /

>$/-) & + & $ &"0. @" 5$ "/" '>$ & + ( $ "+ "+ &"

( 6 ./ 0 $" 6

6 $. 6" $ % '"$ 5$ " $ ) / &+ 0 / &" "/ 0.5$ 6$ +'==' " $ " +/ '""./ .0+/ " 0 "" &' .' %& $&"$"' $ $

$ ) / 6. $" &$ &

% '"$ 5$ " 8 0$" 6 && & " $.6& $6+" 0 ) &$ &"6& $ 6+ & +86 0

$" "% $'"$ ( &"/ 0 $" 6 - /$"66$ && "/ $%6 0 &&" =

+ / &"/0 5$6.%+6 .&& / $%-.

& %" $ C

% ". &&".0 " $ & . 5$/ "" < 5$ ?

"" "

'&&". ""0 " $ & .& $" 5$/'6

( $

F( ) * + ')(- /

/0 &&"0 "6+).0 " $ 6"0 & " 0 $ /0 6 "$& &$ & % %&" +6 $&"6+$ 0% &&"' ". / $ ""0. B('$ +>$ % /8%&& & ""&&" "6+"0 ) ""0. % %$ 6

$ &&""

8" $ "$&+ " 0 & .

% + 5$/

0 +&&". %&. /$"6 % . $ &&" ($%6 $&&"$ 6"%

8 " 0 "$& 6+ $ /$"6 % $ "$&+ " 0 ( $"6% "& . $ &&"

6 & + "$ ( . + $ %&" 5$ % ( %+ 6 6 $. 1 +.

" %%6 1 C

8) " "&&""" 6+ $ $"%"+%$ %& $ 6+. $ /)""6$+=6$ @ &6"+ & "& " ' %$ "$

%.$"+

(" $ $""$

%"" < + " & . 5$ " /0& %/&. >$ 0+5$ " & %/0 &6+ $ . $ $""0+66 $. $

3 8$"6$ 6+$ " & . 5$ "/ 0& %/ 6 -.$& 5$ $ $65$"+C 8/ $ ) 0 $3

/0 $65$5$%

%&$ &/ $ ) 0$

/%&6+$ $& /0 /

<=& ($. "+ ' $ + %%+6 6"& &"6&&" % %&/&""+00"". $ 6+ % 7 $& / ' $ & %0 &&"'"$ "6+$

/ "0 $ )

0$3

@ 2 -D' /0& 0 &.$ & . " 5$)"" . $ "'%"$&&.&&"6. 0/ &&"+.$%6 $"/$% /

<=& 6"%$ %&6&"0 & &&"(+"""6"""$ +6 '"6"%$ 1 & .0>$.%/$ 0$""- )$ ""& & % &" "'" 0.5$ "6+

& %

% & '.""& $" 86 %6+" )$"

"5$ 6+& $" & %*$6% ) * +/"5$ 6+G 6'"&% & %/ & % 8$ H %% / & %

8 ./ & % . $"$ / & % !9 1H/ & % !0 /D' +& %/0&"+5$ "/""6$+6$ % "" 6$ %0 5$ /&+ % &"""6& $ 6 $ & .% %& 5$ "80"""6$ $" )- 5$ " % %80"""6"& $" $ & & % %& " ( &&" " 6+ "0 ""0 &&" "6+) % &+ 6 ) )

!$>6/* +*%) +/G( +/. / %&"

>1" ' I$.