Indian Oil Corporation Limited v. Union Of India

    




 

  



 !

"# $!%&'&"( )

*+ +

($&( &, "-."- &"( /&0& !$ ++++++ ..!,,( 1!-'2'

(&"( "# ($&

++++++ !'."($!(  )

3 / + 45  

   



     

       !"#

$$$$ 5 6 +

-,  *

%   
& ' 

( )    ) *   
& '  

 *

%   

&+   ' 

( )    ) *   

&+  '  

&( %'!


   ) , -

-    
  

  

       

          +
+ &+&
*   

.% /') 0 -'( "1 ( " 223 &+
4( " 20+5 &+
4( "

0&0 &+
4 ( " 0&5+ &+
4( " 0&
6 &+
4( " 0&
4 &+
4( " 0&2& &+
4( " 055 &+
4 ( " 056+ &+
4 ( " 0033 &+
4 ( " 05+
&+
4( " 05+0 &+
4( "

05+5 &+
4( "
632 &+
 ( "
633 &+
( "
22 &+
  ( " 026 &+
  ( " 0& &+
  ( " 2044 &+
 ( " 03&6 &+
  ( " 0303 &+
  ( " 03+& &+
  ( "

0&3 &+
  ( " 4254 &+
  ( " 40+
&+
  ( " 40+& &+
( " 545 &+
4( " 544 &+
4 ( " 543 &+
4 ( " 64+ &+
4( " 642 &+
4 ( " 646 &+
4( "

6642 &+
 ( " 6644 &+
')),  *  7*    - 8)( " 223 &+
4   
 

   


'       &3 + &+
6-  * )%-

'*-  ) 
6  )%-  
348'9 ' '-/  )  1
 '   )*-- )  

: )' %-)  '     )-*  6)  
+6*  
+4 *    
33;  <  <=  '*- * /')   9  -2( 520- 88-9, :'+ 8-&;

<."- '

 / $+ (" =!-

 4

   ) -

    /')   9   

&
6& &+
4   > 7  )  ?  : !# 
0
& &+
4* -     @2
+2 &+
6*      *  8'* /') (&"( "# ($& " =!-'

:'+ >!'

"'

.!- &,,'

/ $+ (" =!-

 

4  *    '  '  *

 '-)  '*    4 @ #*  
3+*  )   
+6   *-

%-     )   * * ) -)  

  

.
+ "  A    ? 

;=   '&+  8 *   ' *     * -'   #   * 8-                )         *    *  
3+;   4 @=* *     *'  *- 8'

  * ) 

,   '  -* *  B    7'  *   * ) %-  '    *    )      **- *   

 -8*' *   )      *

   )@; = 

2+ 8)*  * 8
&4+8)-       )- ' ' )-)  6 )  # A    ?   ;=  9

 *'*  -    ) *-    %   * *   *-- )         -          -      ) 4@ #  
3+    *'   ''' *'  **

.
 % )'   #    )'D'D)D' )) ) - *DE %

?*?9 )   
334F  '
23G % ))    7'  H/  > )8 ;

=-  !#" ;
34
=
& H?32 I  @'* ;7?   *=        )  -  '   D"'D  ) # 

* F'''*'    ) '9  -) - * %-' )) )  8 )  ' ) - )' '  -  8)  ) * ' "' ) '9  * ' *
3 #    '   -   )  9       

* '  *  '--  %-  0
   *'  '  '  -    *  -        '   *    %' -    *    %    '  #  ' '  -'

-  &    ,  ) -  %-   %-'--

  ''< '- ) <'<     -  4@ *

( ''*   ) - -)% )  '            %

 -  7'  )

) %* *-* 




 ;=   @   *  6&6 &+
0

 




 


&+ +& &+
;

9 0=*  %-) )  * '   
+6;2= * *  * *    -   )

A '    ) *- 




  ;= *   *' ' *  %-*8    '* -       )' &3 + &+
6   * **-   9  '  )  ) )   %-  )    -  %-+&

&+&
 
+ ++ ) &

'*   ) )-              -         +
+ &+&
   - )' &3 +3 &+
5  -  %) )-8  %-   )     - %-

7+ + +

'

5   

*+ +   

 A 8'>

J A  - 1