Satnam Singh v. Punjab Water Supply And Sewerage Board And Another





  
 

       

"# "$%

!!!!!& &

'&

()* & "(++,-  ".&$ %&

!!!!!!
 +0

    
 

&$(0 04 

 & +0 %&) %.,3 04 

+0.&   

()* & "(++,-  ".&$ %0$&%

%&3 6% /&063

& & +0

  

!

%&3 ,,.$

+!

+0 %&3 #+,- $$&40 #+  #)& +,-

++$ %& &#

((& 

!



% 89 (4



&# %& ++,

& & 

 !

!

  &( !

,-

($%3 &,

(0 %0 ,&0- 0# &0 !

 &,

# &&$(,&

&#0 *

,&

(,#0 #+($0 +( %#

++$ %& &#

(#(,4 !



&#0 +&4

4& .%0&.3

%,0

+,:0 .

# &&$(,&

 04 *%,

(%&- .% %0

#+

!

(0

(++&

!

%,0 %3

3 

&,- %0 ,,

,- %&&3 

& %!

=

$& ,,- %,0 %3 7$ (&

0(&3

)( - . +,

*$ 4 0 #+,-

#

!

,

+, 0,

(++&

,$, +&+ 

>( %&3

,,.0!

%,

3

#,-



%0

% 89 (4



-&

!

.

(& *

, (,,- 7$

( &4 #0 %3

.&$3 &

0 $

 ,&0

( ,

,$% ,0 0. "(+&#

    



 !"#
! $  ?%&' (

' @3 +

7 

(* >( 4

+(&+ !

+&(

0# &

%3 %&3  ( /

0,$

(* 4 +.& "(+&# (0& & ,   (

93

&40 9+&

6& &063

#

.+3 # - *&($% &0 ,& ,4 #*&

(* >( 4 .

,$%

(0

!

&4

# /&0!



#,& ,

 ,0 0. "(+&#

#


 

) 

*)

  ?% ( 

+@!

5%

(&$ %& +.& "(+&#

&& 7

)(0$#

&40 ++&+&

"(+&# #-

  



&& 7

)(0$#

%& +.&

,- .% %& 00 9 - +&4 *%,!

5%

)(0$# 00 (

+ (0&

!

&(

,$, +&4 0# &

#0

&$%

4&- .

#+& #& 40 %3 & 0( 0,$ 3

.% 7.,0$ +&-

)(0$#

0A

(

# 7 &&& ++& &0A -

!

%03

%&& &#40 *

&0&!

/ 0

#+,,- (&0 %0 ,&0-

(*) 0 6.&$6 &,

#

#3 %0 &0 &

5%&&3

*$ .%,,- .

04,+# &$$  ($ 0)(0 ,3

>(0 6.

#+& #& 40 6 &#

!

"$ ,-3 +&4 + (,

6.

#+& #& 40 63 + 0( 0,$ +&-3

&0&!

6.

#+& #& 40 6 #( 9  +

  5%&&3

9+&

7 .%

#*

& +

,  4,0$ *

+ ,!

#& .%0&.,

,

$ +& && + 4,-3 %&*- 4,0$

(*)

%&& 4, /&0!

,&0

( ,3

6.&$6 0

$(& #$

&*0 +,

&4

 &$(,

03 %&&3 &&

-

6+,:06 . !

0

#&

!

=

. 0#3 00 0#

&(

($% .&& , #& +,- , %#  #& -&

3

%&&

0 %($%

 #)& +,-

$ %# & ,,$

%#!

"$ ,-3

 ,!# # 

 $ -.   ?% ( 

/' @3

&&&0 &0&3 "(+&# %,0

0 >(&-

%&$

.& 60&++0 &,&6 #( %&

#!

"#,&

4.

7 0  $    

12

 !

?% ( /

/&@

5%&&3 &$(# #& +,-

,40 ,,- + 

& %3 $&$ .&$3

( 0!

& 3

(0& 0$ %&



- .%0&.

++&* &+&*

(

.

4 !

7

,( $ (,&,,-

& %3

,&

-&

3 0

( 6 47$ 

(&!

*

3# 4 ,!# 

0  $   +

56  - '/3 B%&7%0 ;$% &40 .&0

6

 .0 ($% ,(0

+ ,.!

! %&

+ &

+,00 +&40 ,-3

( 6!

&

8$&%

#+

( 5%

(.&%-

0&

&$(#

&

$ %&$

(++& %&!

+&#0

4,*, %&&3

%(,0 ,,.0 .

#7 $0 ,+

+&!

,4,

#+ /&06

+&

&(, 4,*, %!



#

+&- #+&4

*,0,-

4,*, ,, ,$!

+03



4,

.%0&. *&

5%( *%

& 040 #& .&& !

&0$,-

0!

7 +& 
 

%,,

0

0!

  

    ! "#$%$&$&  "

'())* %%&

+7$C& 0 D

E %%&
+&*, D

E!