Parshant Sethi And ORS v. State Of Ut Chandigarh And ORS

 
 

   !

 


   

   "#$ %$&'(')     "*(+")#,$#+'")%#+$*( $#'#')$*( -$*(.( ,#"#$ 
+")%'/"*+")%#+$*( $(0)%$)#(
  12 ,
 3



 *$($)# *"5")
+"67"8 %9&"#$

*#+$0$#'#')$*(  *,.5'# "')8 88
+")%'/"*+   * 3,+"*5"8 %9&"#$

**$(0)%$)#( :  3



8 ; 2< =6"= 0*$($)#0$#'#')8#+$0$#'#')$*("*$($$>')/?."(+')/   %"#$%

   8*$/'(#$*$%.)%$*,$&#')( ")%  
;,$&#')( 8 @")% 
"%%$%7"#$*)<")%,$&#')  55'/*"#') &#"#7'&$,#"#'),$&#* 8
+")%'/"*+;

))$A.*$ < ")%  "77  &)($?.$)#  0*&$$%')/(  "*'(')/  #+$*$ *5  )  #+$  B"('(   &50*5'($  ) @  8#+$ 776')/*%$*6"(0"(($% C+$  0*$($)#  0$#'#')  +"(  B$$)  59$%  ')9>')/ D.*'(%'&#')   #+'( 
.*#  .)%$*  ,$&#') @ 
*
  +$ 0$#'#')$*(  "*$  ($$>')/  ?."(+')/         %"#$%

   8*$/'(#$*$% *

$)&$(0.)'(+"B7$.)%$*,$&#')(  ")%  
;,$&#')( 8 @")% 

"%%$%7"#$*)<")%,$&#')  55'/*"#') &#"#7'&$ ,#"#'),$&#* 8
+")%'/"*+")%"77(.B($?.$)#0*&$$%')/( "*'(')/#+$*$#)#+$B"('( &50*5'($2$"*)$%&.)($7

*#+$0$#'#')$*(&)#$)%(#+"##+$5"##$*"7*$"%=(#")%( &50*5'($%9'%$&50*5'($%$$%")%"

'%"9'#(%"#$%   ;

))$A.*$( #<#'&$ 5#') *    *,.5'# "')8 %%7
+")%'/"*+86+ '(0*$($)#')
.*#"&&$0#()#'&$)B$+"7 *$(0)%$)#  ,#"#$* 3,+"*5"8 %9&"#$"00$"*()B$+"7 *$(0)%$)#( ")%")%"%5'#(#+$ "&# #+$*$B$')/ &50*5'($B$#6$$)#+$0"*#'$()9'$6 #+$"B9$8#+$ 0"*#'$(  "*$  %'*$&#$%  #  "00$"*  B$ *$  7$"*)$%  77"?"

"/'(#*"#$E .#="/'(#*"#$)   )#+$'*%')/(8 #+$7$"*)$%77"?""/'(#*"#$E .#="/'(#*"#$(+"77*$&*% #+$'*(#"#$5$)#(")% .*)'(+'#(*$0*###+'(
.*#B=#+$)$A# %"#$ +$"*')/)#+$ 776')/"(0$&#(

.5B$* 0$*()("**"=$%"("&&.($%')#+$  F+$#+$*")="&&.($%'(0*&7"'5$%

$)%$*G F+$#+$*#+$&50*5'($'(/$).')$897.)#"*=")%6'#+.# ")=&$*&')*.)%.$') 7.$)&$G F+$#+$*#+$"&&.($%0$*()("*$')979$%')")=#+$*&"($ *)#G +$#*'"7
.*#'("7(%'*$&#$%#*$&*%#+$(#"#$5$)# #+$  )9$(#'/"#')/  

'&$*  "(  #  +6  5")= 9'&#'5(E&507"')")#("*$#+$*$')#+$ 

&0= #+$*$0*#B$"7(($)###+$$/'(#*"* .%'&'"7 #+'(
.*# $$%7$((#("=#+"#')&"($ *")=*$"()#+$(#"#$5$)#("*$ )#  *$&*%$%  )  #+$  "

*$("'%  %"#$8  #+$  7$"*)$%  77"?"

"/'(#*"#$E .#="/'(#*"#$(+"77B$"#7'B$*#=#&"77#+$0"*#'$() ")=#+$*%"#$B.#)#7"#$*#+")"6$$>#+$*$" #$*H  .*(.")###+$"

*$("'%*%$*8*$0*#%"#$%    *5

.%'&'"7"/'(#*"#$(#
7"((8
+")%'/"*++"(B$$)*$&$'9$%86+'&+'(#">$) )*$&*% (0$*#+$*$0*#8#+$*'"7
.*#+"(*$&*%$%"( 776(



C+$*$"

#$*8  ,  "9$$)  3.5"*  "00$"*$%  ")%  /# *$&*%$%  +'(  (#"#$5$)#  #  #+$  $

$&#  #+"#  +$  6"(  #+$ )9$(#'/"#')/

'&$*')#+$0*$($)#&"($)#+$0*$($)#&"($8 "/")%$$0,')/+")%"*%$$0,')/+"*$#+$&507"')")#(")% *"(+")#,$#+'8"5")%$$0,')/+I"D"#")%-"*.)
+".+") "*$#+$"&&.($%0$*()(")%#+$*$'()#+$*"&&.($%')#+$ "B9$  (#"#$%  8  #+$  "&&.($%  )"5$7=  *"(+")#  ,$#+'8 "5")%$$0,')/+I"D"#")%-"*.)
+".+")6$*$)# .)% ')979$%')")=#+$*&"($0$*#"')')/#7'&$,#"#')8,$&#*  8
+")%'/"*+")%"B9$"&&.($%0$*()(+"9$)$9$*B$$) %$&7"*$%*&7"'5$%

$)%$*')#+'(&"($ J.$*'$(  6$*$  "7(  0.#  #  #+$  0"*#'$(  *$/"*%')/  #+$ /$).')$)$(( #+$&50*5'($%.*')/#+$0*&$$%')/( .*')/ ?.$*=8  0"*#'$(  +"9$  *$07'$%  #+"#  #+$  &50*5'($  +"(  B$$) $)#$*$%')#6'#+#+$'* *$$6'776'#+.#")=#+*$"#8&$*&')* .)%.$') 7.$)&$ *5")=&*)$*?.""&&.($%*"(+")#,$#+'8 "5")%$$0  ,')/+  I  "D"#  ")%  -"*.) 
+".+")  (  0$* )9$(#'/"#')/

'&$* #+'(&"($8"&&.($%0$*()(+"9$)# B$$)%$&7"*$%*&7"'5$%

$)%$*")%"&&.($%0$*()("*$ )#')979$%')")=#+$* +$9'&#'5("/")%$$0,')/+ ")%"*%$$0,')/+"*$#+$&507"')")#(')#+'(&"($H 2$"*)$%&.)($7 **$(0)%$)#( ")%"%5'#(#+$ "&# 0"*#'$(+"9')/&50*5'($%")%(#"#$(#+"#+$+"()BD$&#')')&"($#+$

  ")%  "77  0*&$$%')/( (.B($?.$)#  #+$*$#  "/"')(#  #+$  0$#'#')$*(  "*$ ?."(+$%  ,'5'7"*7=87$"*)$%,#"#$&.)($7+"((#"#$%)BD$&#')')&"($ #+$ '(?."(+$%B"($%.0)#+$&50*5'($;

))$A.*$ < +"9$+$"*%7$"*)$%
.)($7 *#+$0"*#'$(")%+"9$&"*$ .77= /)$#+*./+#+$*$&*%( #+$&"($  +'(
.*#")% 0$A
.*#+"(*$0$"#$%7=%$"7#6'#+#+$'((.$

 $A$*&'($    D.*'(%'&#')  .)%$*  ,$&#')  @    #+$ 
%$  #  ?."(+ 0*&$$%')/*$&/)'K')/&50*5'($B$#6$$)0"*#'$(')))&50.)%"B7$

$)&$(')#+$&"($(  '"),')/+9(,#"#$ .)D"B ")%")#+$*8  ;

<,

8 ,#"#$ "%+="*"%$(+9(2"A5'"*"=")")% #+$*(; 

<,

 @@83.76')%$*,')/+:#+$*(9(,#"#$ .)D"B:

")#+$*8 ;<
;
*'5')"7<  ")% "50"7")%")#+$*9( ,#"#$ "%+="*"%$(+8  ;<
;
*'5')"7< ;
*'5')"7 00$"7  @   %$&'%$%) #+ ,$0#$5B$*8  <+$0*0('#') 7"6#+"#$5$*/$( *5#+$"

*$("'%%$&'(')(*$)%$*$%B= 0$A
.*#")% #+'(
.*#'( ;"< 6$*.E(@ 
*
9$(#$%6'#+#+'(
.*#'(5.&+6'($* ")%'(.)"

$&#$%B=,$&#')  #+$
%$ ;B< 6$9$*86'%$*#+$06$*/*$"#$*#+$&".#') ;&< +$.)%$*7')')/0*')&'07$6+'7$$A$*&'(')/(.&+06$*'( #+"#  '#  &")  B$  ')9>$%  #  ?."(+  #+$  0*&$$%')/(  *$&/)'K')/ &50*5'($  B$#6$$)  #+$  0"*#'$(  ')  #+$  5"##$*(  6+'&+  "*$ 9$*6+$75')/7=  ")%  0*$%5')")#7=    &'9'7  &+"*"&#$*  7'>$ &55$*&'"7#*")("&#')(*"*'(')/.# 5"#*'5)'"7*$7"#')(+'0 * "5'7=%'(0.#$( ;%< +$("'%06$*'()##B$$A$*&'($%')#+$ 0*($&.#')(')979')/+$').(")%($*'.(

$)&$( 5$)#"7 %$0*"9'#=  *  

$)&$(  7'>$  5.*%$*8  *"0$8  %"&'#=  $#&  "(  (.&+

$)&$("*$)#0*'9"#$'))"#.*$")%+"9$"($*'.('50"&#) (&'$#= ;$< ,$&#')@ 
*
&"(#(%.#=.0)#+$'/+
.*## "%9")&$')#$*$(# D.(#'&$"(6$77#'(')*$&/)'#') #+'(%.#= &"(#$%.0)#+$'/+
.*#8#+"# 0$A
.*#+$7%#+"##+$'/+
.*#6.7%)#*$ .($#?."(+ .)%$*,$&#')5$*$7= B$&".($  ')%(5$)#')#+$*$ '/+
.*#&")"(($(()"#.*$  ')D.*'$(  (.(#"')$%8  6+$#+$*  (.&+  ')D.*'$(  ') 7'&#$%  ) 9'#"7E%$7'&"#$0"*#( #+$B%=E)"#.*$ 6$"0)(.($%$#& ;

< ,.&+  $A$*&'($  "#  #+$  +")%(    '/+ 
.*#  6.7%  B$ 0$*5'(('B7$)7="

#$*#+$$9'%$)&$'(&77$&#$%"

#$*')9$(#'/"#')



")%&+"*/$(+$$#'( '7$%E&+"*/$( *"5$%%.*')/#+$#*'"7 ,.&+ $A$*&'($ &"))# B$ &"**'$% .#  6+'7$ #+$  5"##$*  '(  (#'77 .)%$* ')9$(#'/"#') ;/< F+'7$?."(+')/ ')))&50.)%"B7$

$)&$($9$) 6+'&+"*$ 0*'9"#$'))"#.*$8'/+
.*#'(*$?.'*$%#&)('%$* ")#$&$%$)#( #+$"&&.($%8&)%.&# #+$"&&.($%")%6+$#+$*+$ 6"("B(&)%')/*6+$#+$*+$+"(5")"/$%#+$&507"')")## $)#$*')#"&50*5'($ @ +.(8>$$0')/')9'$6#+$"

*$("'% "&#(")%&'*&.5(#")&$(8 #+'(
.*#'( #+$&)('%$*$%0')')#+"#'#'(" '#&"($#$A$*&'($ D.*'(%'&#')9$(#$%.E(@ 
*
#?."(+#+$ "( ;'< +$0*$($)#5"##$*%$()# "776'#+')#+$$A&$0#')("( &"*9$%.#') 2"A5'"*"=")1( &"($;(.0*"<'$+$').(

$)&$ ;''< +$

$)&$("77$/$%"*$ 0*'9"#$)"#.*$ ;'''< +$0"*#'$(+"9$&50*5'($% ;'9<

(0$*#+$*$0*#*$&$'9$%#+$&50*5'($'(("'%#B$ 97.)#"*=')'#()"#.*$ ;9<
507"')")#E9'&#'5  '(  *$0*#$%  #  +"9$  $)#$*$%  ')# &50*5'($)+'(6)97'#')
)($?.$)#7=8  #+$  0$#'#')  '(  "776$%        %"#$%

   8*$/'(#$*$%.)%$*,$&#')( ")%  
;,$&#')( 8 @")% 
"%%$%7"#$*)<")%,$&#')  55'/*"#') &#"# 7'&$,#"#'),$&#* 8
+")%'/"*+;

))$A.*$ < ")%"770*&$$%')/( "*'(')/#+$*$ *58"*$8+$*$B=8?."(+$%?."#+$0$#'#')$*(       ; 3



< 0*=  

  F+$#+$*(0$">')/E*$"()$%  !$(E F+$#+$**$0*#"B7$  !$(E