Subhash And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

 


   
  


 !"#$"#%&'"()$ ('*'*%()$ +()$ $ '#'(,#)-#%# ($.%&(%'


/ ,

#'(, (0*$*%1 /

 !"#$"#%&'"()$ ('*'*%()$ +()$ $ '#'(,#)-#%# ($.%&(%'

 





    )($(%'

)#" 2&+0#'(,)'"(.('*'*%()$ ) #$"3*%&()*%4"2 2#)-#%#        $'"(.).()'-*%&*$. '(#$3(66#$'"(.#)'*($#)($#7(2 '"()(,)(2#,)(7(%'*%(&


, #%&
/

, #)(!(*%4&*$.$(&,,!-'"(077%)&()


 "#$!((%,*6(& %&()(0'*%/8,'"(
&(,
)*7*%#6)0(& )(9,)$")':
)
:;,)< #$"*%4,'"(  &#'(& / %&()(0'*%$882// 2/ ,'"(%&*#% (%#6
&(28 9,)$")':
:;)(4*$'()(&#'6*0('#'*% "#'' =#6#%2

*$')*0'#'("#!#&#%&#660%$(< (%'.)0((&*%4$#)*$*%4'"()(,)7
/  "#$!((%,*6(& %&()(0'*%/8
)
,)< #$"*%4,'"( &#'(&8 / %&()(0'*%$882//

#%& /
)(4*$'()(&#'6*0('#'*% "#'' =#6#%2 *$')*0'#'("#!#&#%&

 #660%$(< (%'.)0((&*%4$#)*$*%4'"()(,)7 (.#)#'()(.6*($!-3#-,#,,*&#+*', )&*#6*%4"2 (. '-  .()*%'(%&(%',6*0(29
*'-;2#'("#!#&%!("#6,,)($.%&(%'2#6)(#&- ,*6(&*%'"()(4*$')-#)('#>(%%)(0)& "(,#0'$#)(!(*%4'#>(%,)7


  '*$0%'(%&(&!-6(#)%(&0 %$(6,)'"(.('*'*%()$'"#'*% < ($'*%*$#!$6 '(7*$ $(,'"(.)0($$,'"(
 )'#$*%+*(3,'"(!#) %&()(0'*%


)
2%0#%!()(4*$'()(&*%'"(7#''()%$ ..)' ,"*$0%'(%'*%2"("#$.6#0(&)(6*#%0( .%'"(? &47(%','"*$
 )'*% 

!!"

#$ % &'

( #!)"* +,,-. 
 
 / 0.1 %'"('"()"#%&26(#)%(&'#'(0 %$(62%*%$') 0'*%$,)7 #*@#62"#$0%'(%&(&'"#'*%'"*$0#$('"((%'*)(.)$(0 '*%(+*&(%0(*$ +()#%&%#00 %','"($'#-4)#%'(&!-'"*$
 )'2')*#6*$"(6& . (#)&6(#)%(&0 %$(6,)!'"$*&($#%&.() $(&'"(.#.() !> "(!)*(,#66(4#'*%$*%'"(3"*0"3#$)(4*$'()(&%'"( !#$*$,#3)*''(%07.6#*%'7#&(!-("$*6&#)2#'("#!#&#)('"#'#%)&() &#'(&8 3#$.#$$(&!- ! *+*$*%#6#4*$')#'(2#'("#!#&9,) $")'  :

:;  %&()  (0'*%  / 
)
 #%&  ("$*6&#)2  #'("#!#&  3#$ #..*%'(&#$(0(*+()
%$(< (%'6-2.$$($$*%,'"(.).()'-*%&*$. '( 3#$"#%&(&+()'"*7'#+*&#%- %'3#)&*%0*&(%'#$3(66#$,) 7#*%'(%#%0(,6#3#%&)&()"()(#,'()2#)(.)'&#'(&  3#$ )(0(*+(&,)7#6>##'3#)*''"((,,(0''"#' ',6#%&07.)*$*%4*% >"#$)#% AA 98;298;2+()#..)B*7#'(6- :B 8:3#$(%0*)06(& #%&  0%$') 0'(&  !-  # $"#6# 
%$') 0'*% 
77*''((  &($.*'(  '"(

.)0((&*%4$  %&()  (0'*%$  /  #%&  / 
)
 #%&  '"(  ("$*6&#)2 #'("#!#&#6$$ !7*''(&#)(.)'' *%'"*$)(4#)& )'"()#66(4(& '"#'%#%(#)6*().*%','*7(
C, '*'6(&#$ )*? " $"#% ('0+'#'(,#)-#%#3#$,*6(&3"*0"3#$&(0*&(&!-'"*$
 )'+*&()&() &#'(&/  #%& .()*%'(%&(%',6*0(2#'("#!#&3#$&*)(0'(&' '#>(#0'*%#4#*%$''"(.()$%3"$(+()*$, %&+*6#'*%4'"(.)0((&*%4$ %&()(0'*%/ 
)
 ($.*'('"(#!+(,#0' #6.$*'*%2'"( .)($(%'.('*'*%()$"#+(0%$') 0'(&$"(&,)# $"#6#+()'"(6#%&*% < ($'*%#%&'" $'"(-"#+(+*6#'(&'"()&()&#'(&8 #%&3*'"

'"($(#66(4#'*%$'"(*%< ($'*%3#$)(4*$'()(& () $#6,'"(#$3(66#$.#.()!>)(+(#6$'"#'%#% (#)6*()00#$*%
C, '*'6(&

 



   3#$,*6(&#%&&(0*&(&'"($#7(!- *+*$*% (%0",'"*$
 )'% /  #%&.()#'*+(.#)','"#')&()*$(B')#0'(&"()( %&()1       

  

  

    

 

      

                



  

    !

        

          

          

   



  

   



 

  "#$ "#%&'&(

      

'

         

  

   

     &  

 

 

 )

      



       !  

 

      *  '

     

  

   

  



 

  

 

    +

/ () $#6  ,  '"(  #!+(  )&()  06(#)6-  )(+(#6$  '"#'  $.(0*,*0 &*)(0'*%$3()(4*+(%''"(2#'("#!#&'"#'*,#%-,'"(.#)'*($+*6#'( '"()&(),'"*$
 )'2%(0($$#)-#0'*%!('#>(%*%'"*$)(4#)&"()(,)(2 *%07.6*#%0(,'"()&()&#'(&/  2.#$$(&!-'"*$
 )'2*% < ($'*%3#$)(4*$'()(&#%&'"#'*$'"($ !?(0'7#''(),0"#66(%4(*%'"( .)($(%'.('*'*% "(#)4 7(%')#*$(&%!("#6,,'"(.('*'*%()$'"#'% 0#%!()(4*$'()(&*%+*(3,'"(!#)0)(#'(&!-(0'*%


)
*$%'

#00(.'#!6(,)'"()(#$%'"#'.)($(%'"#$!((%)(4*$'()(&%'%6- %&() (0'*%882! ' %&()(0'*%$// 2/ 
2#$3(66"()(*$% < #))(6'"#',,(%0( %&()(0'*%$/ A/ #%&// 
#)(04%*D#!6( #%&*%+*(3,'"(.)+*$*%$ %&()(0'*% /
)
2#%0#%!( )(4*$'()(&*%#04%*D#!6(,,(%0(#%&'"(!#) %&()(0'*%


)
0#%%'!(.)($$(&*%'$()+*0(''"#'(,,(0' '*$%(0($$#)-'7(%'*%"()('"#'*%+*(3,'"(.)+*$*%$, (0'*%

9/;
)
23"()(#0#$()(6#'($''3)7)(,,(%0($2, 3"*0"  #'  6(#$'  %(  *$  04%*D#!6(2  '"(%  0#$(  $"#66  !(  &((7(&  '  !(  # 04%*D#!6(0#$(%'3*'"$'#%&*%4'"#''"(),,(%0($#)(%%04%*D#!6(#%& (0'*%

9/;
)
)(#&$#$ %&()1 2
 

 

       





    
 
 
 
 

 

     



     

 

 

    

 

 





 

         



  

  

" $2  *%  +*(3  ,  '"(  .)+*$*%$ ,  (0'*%  

9/;
)
2 )(.)& 0(&"()(*%#!+(2*'*$#..#)(%'6-06(#)'"#'*,'"()(#)('3)7)( ,,(%0($#%&#'6(#$'%(*$04%*D#!6('"(%'"(0#$($"#66!(&((7(&'!(# 04%*D#!6(0#$(#%&*%'"#'(+(%' #6*'- %&()(0'*% /
)
0#%!( )(4*$'()(&*%#%%04%*D#!6(,,(%0(2#$3(66" $2'"(#)4 7(%','"( .('*'*%()$*%'"*$)(4#)&*$)(?(0'(&  &47(%'0*'(&*% 3(*) ( #!)"* 4*"

* 5 *$%'

#..6*0#!6(  ,)  '"(  $*7.6(  )(#$%  '"#'  *%  '"#'  0#$(    

 &#'(& /3#$)(4*$'()(& %&()(0'*%88A /
%6-#%&*%+*(3,'"( !#)  0)(#'(&  %&()  (0'*%  

9; 
)
2  '"(    3#$  "(6&  '  !( *7.()7*$$*!6( '*%'"(.)($(%'0#$(2#$&*$0 $$(&"()(*%#!+(2'"( "#$!((%)(4*$'()(& %&()(0'*%$88A// A /
2'"()(,)(2.('*'*%()$ 0#%%'!(#663(&''#>(#%-!(%(,*','"(? &47(%')(,())(&%'"(*) !("#6, %&*$. '(&6-2*%'"(.)($(%'0#$(0"#)4($3()(,)#7(&3#- !#0>%8/ %&()(0'*%$/ 288#%&// 
#%&(+(%'"( (%'*)(.)$(0 '*%(+*&(%0(*$+()2'"()(,)(2%'"#'0 %'#6$2< #$"*%4 ,'"(2#''"*$$'#4(23 6&%'!(#..).)*#'(,)'"*$
 )'3"*6( (B()0*$*%4.3()$ %&()(0'*%/8
)
 =((.*%4  *%  +*(3 '"( #!+(2  '"()(  *$  %  7()*'  *% !'"  '"( .('*'*%$#%&'"($#7(#)(&*$7*$$(& @(#)%(&')*#6
 )'3*66.)0((&3*'"'"(7#''()(B.(&*'* $6- "(  #,)($#*&  !$()+#'*%$  7#-  %'  !(  0%$') (&  #$  #% (B.)($$*%,.*%*%%'"(7()*'$,'"(0#$(.(%&*%4!(,)('"(6(#)%(& ')*#6
 )'

0.-,'"*$)&()!(.6#0(&%'"(,*6(,0%%(0'(&0#$( % 7!()(&#!+(  /

   

!



6)"!)"

*5"738"*#"( 9"*8# 6)"!)"

"5#!'/"

9"*8#