High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/594/2004allowed

Khacheru And ORS v. Land Acquisition Collector And ORS

2019-02-27Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari14 pages

!"#

!" #

$! %&'$ ( '(( )& $ % & '! ( & ! ) &

*+(!",- & *+ , -#.#/. #-"0#-1 * 2,3, &* """"11 (( )&. 4,25 ./0

!/123

!" #45 /6 6447(*- 8 *

95!74!444:*-# #- .60 + 3 (

/2 4;

/22; ;46 /22< 75 /8/ ( # = ! + !

" # * # $ " $ = ( > / 4;

/221! !" #( ( 9

5!74!444: 68 = #( -*

.70 + ? - /4 ( /7 # @A $/!$7 $3(A (

* ( - ( - ! * 3 ( @A $5 $/4(# *# ( 8 @A $6(( A ( *# ( # * 8

# 8 + @A

// /7( *#*( (*- ( 65 ( @A

/6 /; 8 .6 0(( ;!<4!444:( # ( # ( > 637 *# > 7< * * * .30 & '! - * A (*

A * ! ( ?

?# -(* + 8 ** @A $/( ( # 8 /;8 // * 9<6 8 ( *73!;2!114: ,#- *

( ** , - * ( -*-(- (

.50 & @A $/$6( *-&:

$ ( @A $7 $3( *- - ( * ! -!' ' " * * + -( # #-! * ( ( ?

* - + (* *-* % '6 2 , (2*! (2 * , ! 3 , , !

7 $ $/ /4 /22; /; // <6!44!444 44 73!;2!114 44 $6 6/ /225 /3 /3 71!54!444 44 64!25!671 44 $7 /5 /22; / /2 3!;2!4;6 44 /2!63!75< 44 $3 /5 /22; / /5 3!42!;1< 44 /1!<6!153 44 $5 /1 /4 /22; / 4 3!25!444 44 72!;4!444 44 $; /4 /22; 4 7 27!<54 44 54!44!444 44 $< /1 /4 /22; 4 /1 3!<1!/65 44 36!54!444 44 $1 4< /22; 6 /3 3!<5!444 44 /3!4<!34< 44 $2 4< /22; 6 /7 3!<5!444 44 /3!77!2;6 44 $/4 4< /22; 6 /7 3!<5!444 44 /3!77!2;6 44

/ 4;

/22; 1 / 3!65!444 44 3!66!7;4 44

6 /7 4;

/22; 5 3 /!76!444 44 6!47!4<< 44

7 /2 4;

/22; 3 4 /!46!444 44 6!43!444 44

3 /7 4;

/22; / /< 3<!444 44 6!47!637 44

5 /7 4;

/22; 4 /5 /2!544 44 6!41!444 44

; 4;

/22; < 6 /!15!621 44 6!41!<1;

< 4;

/22; 6 /5 <1!24/ 44 6!62!574 44

1 4;

/22; < /6 6!7<!544 44 6!54!444 44

2 4;

/22; 1 4 6!54!444 44 6!54!444 44

/4 4;

/22; 2 /4 6!2;!1<5 44 6!54!444 44

// 6/ 4;

/22; 1 4 6!47!444 44 6!47!444 44

/6 /< /22; /; 4 /7!34!444 44 ;!<4!444 44

/7 /22; 2 /2 6!56!144 44 6!47!4/5 44 .;0 # ( #

( ( ( 8 (

658 ( 768 * + - *# - @A$ & 8

(

- & @ - - ( * & &- B $ ! @A

$ 8 8 C B

- A 3 &-) D ! $# ) -! = &! # $ A 3 .<0 )( *- !( 8 ( ( $ ?* D#

! /2;7 * E A # ( *#

# *-( (

+ ( *- ((

# ( * ;48

= + 8! & @ - - (A 3 ( (- - (

# 8 +*#-

(# ! -! *( ( * -

8 ( .10 =#$C/! ( #

+ (

$ ?

5 (- = >?- F 8 B

- 8( # ( ?

# - * ( ?

/ 8 (- @ @ ( ?

?# 8

( 3:5 (- - ( A**- (

( *<18

" #

A ! *-' '@A $7 $3(

/2 548 , 8

B @ @ ( " # *

& ? - .20 @A $// & ( *- $ >#! + ( $C6 ! ( ( (#-( ( (*

, (

, $& ?(

( = -( F , (

8B @ B ./40

A $C7, ! ( B# #= ((

" #( = !( 8( >"= ( * # #=

A ! 8!@A $ & ( # ! " # = (

# .//0 B C/ # !

&#!$"@##! = = #( 58 = = ( (

? 68 = + # = ( 6F 8 #

( * 68

# ?

( * 4 58

+ 8G #= ( / 18

+ ( # ! ( ! ( # ./60 + # @A $//!( * " #( * 8 + - A ?

#( &-! * ( ?#- ( # (( 8 + @A $/!$7 $3((A /22;!(! *!* @A $// !( @A $66/ /225 ./70 + - ( # ( 6/ /225 /5 /22;! 8 ( -# !"#" $%& '%"( "%& +@A $/ ( /4 /22; 8#- * /; 8 // .6 A -0 ( # 73!;2!114: )

# *-& (*- &:

$ * )

- # # * * *- - ( #*- #(## + ( * @A $7 $3 ( 9 '#" "$(& ' ! '##)

* $")#"%%!& +

,- ./ 0' -

')1''- @A

/6( ** # /< /22; ( ( 3 /2 4;

/22; 6 ./;8 0 8 ( (8

;!<4!444:( @A $6$3 ( ##*(/1!<6!153:64!25!671: ./30 + A 7, 8 ,9 ) , (:332; * , < ,*=7 <*>,330 ,45##(#-! ( ## A 8 ( * * * 3./0 * ?

# #

./50 )$? 73 2$ >,0,=0 ,4#5 ( - ( * - ( *(( #

./;0 ) >:2 @ = 0 , 4#5 ## ( /"! (

-# (8 (*A #

* # ( # * *

+ %

! "

# $

% ./<0 @A

/6( # (- ( *- - /7!34!444: (78 -* * /4!34!444:( *-- /;

/22; ( A - )

! @A

/6( (#-# # (*- *-# 8 /;8 ( &-!* ( *#

?# A 8 + * 61 6447*- #( *? * * ( ( ( ./10 )&2> *A * 4#5("-.( * *8 /68

- 8 8 ( *! 54

- 8 # 8 *

+ ? # % &'

( )

# $ $ * +, -! ! "

# # "

. $ # /

# #

# +1 #

# % ./20 +# & # 6< /4 /211 ( 8 (

96!56!144: ?

1 - ( # ( ? # A ! " # $ %& ' ($ )* *+

((

# *- # ( 1 - ( # 8 +A #- * *-5- $ ?7:@,=,; ( . #1454 = 251# # ** .640

-!8#(*

! 8 *

9<8 8#(@A

/6 * #

@A $// + ( * 75 *# **

8# ( @A

/6#6 ( # 8 ( * (# 8 ( *

+ ** - 8# ( ( *# * $ " .6/0 -! ) "/ 01 ,-

2! ( 12 #& -!( -( - # - - *-

( - - 8 ( * 8 A**- A /4H( A #

.660 + (( (*-A 3/ +& 4* ,- 2!*--#/4H -

? # % I, 2

+13

* 4

$ &5+111 "

# 2 78&+&5 6 ( 9

&1 ! #

+&+ ) 7 #

)

&, )

) 7 # ) 7 6

&& ,13 $ 2 81'111 ( % .670 #-8#( A ( *- # 8 ! ** -8#( * #

! 8

9<8 -*

.630 + # *- & ' (

(

( - *

8 * A* A *- ( (-

) -

A 8 * 8 *#A A -

# 8

! ( A( .650 + # ( *# ( **# ** + *8# # # # (?

.6;0 )=,( <>0 ,=( : ?90 ,#145 , ,4 = 251. ( ;< (# # -!( #*8 - ! * # *#

.6<0 ) #(- * 8#(? # 05 + &3 ,-

# # *- (# ( A# 8 9 < 8 # (

- * ( #-

"# 4(( *>+2 5

:*<