High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13229/2023dismissed

Indian Red Cross Society, Faridkot v. Rekha Rani And ORS.

2023-07-06Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

$!%&'&"(

) ) ($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! , )))))) ! & &"(!* -!*'.'

!/0 (& " 0!*'

)))))) !'1"($!( '

*!'!(

2*) 30&'0!/ &($45 $6"% !

#"* 1! & &"(!*)

) ) ) ! & &"(!* 7($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! ,8 0'

#&4!$ &(' ( 9*& 1! & &"( .($!* * &%4!'

: "(' & . &"( ($& '!!/&(;

9*& ( .*!

%!* &"**& #"* <.'0&(;

9*$ $ !$ ) ) 7((!=.*!

85 1''!$ ($.' *&4 *&3.(45

0&($ 7*!'1"($!( ") 0!*!&(8 90!*!3, %4&> ' !>!( *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0!*!&( 7!/0 (&8 44"9!$ "*$!*!$ 3!

*!&(' !$ ?

3%/ 9;!'

#*"> $ !

!*>&( &"( 0!* '!*6&%!'

&44 @"&(!$ 0!* $. ,)

)

*&!#4,5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* *&'!$ ( &($.' *&4 $&'1. !

'!*6&(;

$!>($ (" &%!

$ !$ ) ) .1"( 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , ;&('

0!* .(49#.4 !*>&( &"( '!*6&%!'

!##!% #*"> ) A) 5 0"9!6!*5 > !* 1!($&(;

!6!( # !* !=1&*, A $,'

#*"> $ !

&''.(%!

$!>($ (" &%!5 %%"*$&(;4,5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0!*!&( #&4!$ 0!* %4&> ' !>!( #"* $@.$&% &"( 0!* $&'1. !

1!* &(&(;

!*>&( &"( 0!* '!*6&%!'

.($!* +!% &"( 78 ($.' *&4

&'1. !'

% 5 A 70!*!&(# !* *!#!**!$ '

BA % B8 90!*!&( 14!$!$ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 9"*/!$ '

!41!* .($!* ($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! ,1! & &"(!* #*"> A))

) ) 0!*!# !*5 11"&( !$ '

"' !4 *$!( "( ) )5 #"* 90&%0 1"'

$6!* &'!$ *!''

&( !*6&!9 0!4$)

!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* %4&>'

'!*6!$ '

"' !4 *$!( #*"> ,!* ) ) ) A) 0.'5 0$ '!*6!$ 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , #"* >"*!

,!*')

%%"*$&(;

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!*5 1!*#"*>!$ 0!* $. &!'

'&(%!*!4, 0"(!' 4, 90&4!

0"4$&(;

1"'

"' !4 *$!(5 .'!$ %"44!% #!!

#*"> ' .$!( '

' ,&(;

0"' !45 >&( &(!$ %%".( '>!5 1!*#"*>!$ $. &!'

!4!10"(!

"1!* "* " 0!* %4!*&%4 $. &!')

!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* #.* 0!* ' !$

B"*/>(B '

$!#&(!$

.($!* A % ($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! , 71! & &"(!* 0!*!&(8 &'

( B($.' *,B .($!* '&$ % )

14!$!$ %'!

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! ,5 6&$!

& '

4! !* $ !$ ) ) 5 0$ !*>&( !$ 0!* '!*6&%!'

9)!)#) ) A) )

%4&>!$ 3!#"*!

!*>&( &"( '!*6&%!'5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* ;&6!( "(!

>"( 0 (" &%!

(!& 0!* 1, 4&!.

(" &%!

("* (, %">1!(' &"( 1&$ 0!*) 4'"

%4&>!$ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 9"*/!$ #"* >"*!

0( A $,'

>"( 0'

1*!%!$&(;

$ !

0!* !*>&( &"()

#.* 0!* %4&>!$ @.(&"*'

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0$ 3!!( *! &(!$ (!9 1!*'"('

06!

3!!( 11"&( !$ # !* !*>&( &"( 0!* '!*6&%!')

%%"*$&(;4,5 44!;!$ '!*6&%!'

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 9!*!

!*>&( !$ 6&"4 &"( +!% &"('

A % )

4'"

' !$

&>!

!*>&( &"( 0!* '!*6&%!'5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* ;! &(;

9;!'

') 5 : 1!* >"( 0)

& 0 #"*!'&$ 14!'5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0!*!&( '".;0 *!&(' !>!( #.44 3%/ 9;!'

!##!% #*"> ) ) &44 $ !

0!* *!&(' !>!( )

) 0!

#"*!'&$ %4&> ' !>!( *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* %"( !' !$ 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , '.3>& &(;

& '

*!14, 90!*!&( %"( !($!$ ($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! , 71! & &"(!*8 &'

%0*& 34!

("( 1*"#& 34!

*;(&C &"( $"!'

#44 9& 0&( $!#&(& &"( ($.' *, .($!* A % )

#.* 0!* '.3>& !$ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 11"&( !$ ;&('

1*"@!% "( %"( *% 3'&'

'&$ %"( *% 3!&(;

*!(!9!$ #*"> &>!

&>!)

44!;!$ 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 9"*/ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* .1 "

>*/ 9*(!$ &>1*"6!

0!* 9"*/5 3.

$&$ %**, ".

"*$!*'

1*"1!*4,)

6!*>!( *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0$ 9"*/!$ '

!41!* #*"> A)) ) ) 0!( '

"' !4 *$!( #*"> ) ) ) A) $>& !$ ',&(;

'&$ "( %"( *% 3'&'5 90&%0 *!(!9!$ #*"> &>!

&>!

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 11"&( !$ #"*

'1!%&#&% 1*"@!% )

& 0 #"*!'&$ 14!'5 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , '".;0 $&'>&''4 %4&> ' !>!( #&4!$ *!'1"($!( 9"*/!*)

A) # !* %"('&$!*&(;

*&64 ' ($'

1* &!'

4'"

.1"(

%"('&$!*&(;

!6&$!(%!:> !*&4 "( *!%"*$5 4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"95 6&$!

& '

9*$ $ !$ ) ) 7((!=.*!

85 44"9!$ %4&> ' !>!( 5 #&4!$ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* "*$!*!$ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 3!

*!&(' !$ ?

3%/ 9;!'

#*"> $ !

0!* !*>&( &"( &44 @"&(!$ 0!* $. &!')

!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* #.* 0!* 0!4$ !( & 4!$ &( !*!'

* !

1!* ((.> "( 3%/ 9;!'

&44 1,>!( )

) ( #"*!>!( &"(!$ %&*%.>' (%!'5 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 0'

#&4!$ &(' ( 9*& 1! & &"( 3!#"*!

0&'

".* )

) D!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , '.3>& '

&>1.;(!$ 9*$ &'

.('.' &(34!

!,!

49 '

71! & &"(!*+"%&! ,8 $"!'

#44 $!#&(& &"( B($.' *,B '

$!#&(!$ .($!* A % ) D!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , #.* 0!* '.3>& '

4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

!**!$ 0"4$&(;

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 11"&( !$ "( %"( *% 3'&'

;&('

'1!%&#&% 1*"@!% '&$ %"( *% 3!&(;

*!(!9!$ #*"> &>!

&>!5 90&%0 0$ !##!% 3*!/ 0.'5 1*"6&'&"('

+!% &"('

A % 9!*!

114&%34!

0&'

%'!)

4'"

3!!( %"( !($!$ 9"*/ %"($.% *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* ' &'#% "*, * 0!*5 '>!

9&44#.4 (!;4!% $. &!'

0!* '!*6&%!'

9!*!

!*>&( !$ '

0!* 9"*/ .1 "

>*/)

( 0&'

*!;*$5 4!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 0'

*!#!**!$ 9*(&(;

4! !*'

$ !$ ) ) )) 7((!=.*!

((!=.*!

*!'1!% &6!4,8 4'"

1"4";, 4! !* $ !$ ) A) 7((!=.*!

D!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 4'"

%"( !($'

4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

#&4!$ 11*!%& !

!6&$!(%!

!'1!%&44, %*"''

!=>&( &"( *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 90!*!&( 0$ %4!*4, $>& !$ !(;;!$ 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , #"*

1!*&"$ >"( 0'

!%0 "( %"( *% 3'&'

4'"

$>& !$ 9*& !( 1"4";, $ !$ ) A) 7((!=.*!

'.3>& !$ &>1.;(!$ 9*$ 3!

'&$!)

) 06!

0!*$ 4!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 0&'

34!

''&' (%!5 06!

4'"

1!*.'!$ 11!* 3""/)

) '

*!;*$'

%"( !( &"( 4!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , ($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! , 71! & &"(!*8 $"!'

#44 9& 0&( $!#&(& &"( B($.' *,B .($!* A % 5 4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

*! .*(!$ #&($&(;

;&('

1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 0!*!&( 0'

#&4!$ 4!$ (, !6&$!(%!

*!;*$)

D!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 0'

#.* 0!* #&4!$ *&'!

(, 9"* 0 *;.>!( ("* 1*"$.%!$ (, 49 "( &''.!

($&( !$ *"''

+"%&! , 71! & &"(!*8 %"6!*!$ .($!* $!#&(& &"( B($.' *,B .($!* A % )

%%"*$&(;4,5 '&$ '.3>&''&"( 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , &'

*!@!% !$)

*!;*$'

'!%"($ %"( !( &"( 4!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!* +"%&! , *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* !>14",!$ "( %"( *% 3'&'

#"* >"( 0'

!%0 0.'5 0!*!

3*!/ *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0$ 9"*/!$ %"( &(.".'4,5 &'

"3'!*6!$ '

1!* &>1.;(!$ 9*$5 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , $&$ 1*"$.%!

(, *!%"*$ '0"9 0!*!

% .4 3*!/ 0!* '!*6&%!)

(#% 5 4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

"3'!*6!$ 9& (!''

1! & &"(!*+"%&! , &)!) 7.*>& +&(;08 0$ $>& !$ %4!* 9"*$'

0&'

%*"''

!=>&( &"( *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0$ 9"*/!$ 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , '

"' !4 *$!( #*"> ) ) ) A) )

3!!( #.* 0!* "3'!*6!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 &# ;*!!>!( 3!&(;

*!(!9!$ #*"> &>!

&>!5 '

%4&>!$ 1! & &"(!*+"%&! ,5 !6!( 0!( '>!

1*!'.>!$ 3!

%"( &(.".'

'!*6&%!)

4'"

'0"9( *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 11"&( !$ #"* '">!

'1!%&#&% '/ "* 1*"@!% )

%%"*$&(;4,5 3'!(%!

(, 1*""#5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0!4$ 3!

%"( &(.&(;

#"* 1!*&"$ #*"> $ !

90!( @"&(!$ '

"' !4 *$!( &)!) ) ) ) A) )

*!;*$'

%"( !( &"( 4!*(!$ %".('!4 #"* 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 9"*/ %"($.% *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* .1 "

>*/ ;&6!( 9*(&(;

4! !*'

0$ 4'"

'.3>& !$ 1"4";, 4! !* *!;*$5 4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

*! .*(!$ #&($&(;

&''.(%!

9*(&(;

4! !* $"!'

9, *&;0 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* %"( &(.!

!>14",!!

1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 1! & &"(!*+"%&! , 0$ *&;0 !*>&( !

'!*6&%!'

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 9& 0".

%"($.% &(;

&(<.&*, &( "

44!; &"(')

%%"*$&(;4,5 0'

3!!( 0!4$ % &"( 1! & &"(!*+"%&! ,

%4!* %.

6&"4 &"( +!% &"( A % %%"*$&(;4,5 *!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0!4$ !( & 4!$ %"( &(.!

'!*6&%!) # !* %"('&$!*&(;

" 4& , %'!5 4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

*! .*(!$ #&($&(;

*!'1"($!( ") 9"*/!* 0'

3!!( *!>"6!$ .(. 0"*&'!$4, 6&"4 &"( +!% &"('

A %

%%"*$&(;4,5 "*$!*!$ 3!

*!&(' !$ ?

3%/ 9;!'

#*"> $ !

!*>&( &"( 0!* '!*6&%!'

&44 @"&(!$ 0!* $. ,)

) 0!

4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 0'

*! .*(!$ #"44"9&(;

#&($&(;'

! "

! #

$ % #

# &

& &

' # ( )

* '+, - . / , (

(

* '+12'+ - . /

& 0 &

& &

3 -

456+

(

% #

456+%

456+

&( & &(

$ ( &

% # "

#( &

% # "

# &

& 4

( &

0 &

(

$ % # "

# " *

(

( + ( & & ) 8 & &

45 6+ 2 45 6+" &

(

)

* '+,

- . /

6 -

(

7 * '+,('+1 '+ - . /

9 &

:!9 &

& "

& , & 6

;

) 06!

;"(!

0*".;0 #&($&(;'

*! .*(!$ 4!*(!$ *&3.(4 3!4"9 $"

#&($ (, &44!;4& , "* 1!*6!*'& , '>!

* 0!* '>!

06!

3!!( #".($ 3!

%%"*$(%!

49 '

9!44 '

!6&$!(%!

6&434!

0&'

%'!)

) 0!

1!*&10!*&!'

%!* &"**& @.*&'$&% &"(

&;0 ".* ' ($'

. 0"*& &6!4, $!4&(! !$ * <

& = * 6 ( /-6 !

> %%5 90!*!&(

"(E34!

+.1*!>!

".* 0!4$ '

.($!*

?%) & 0

/ !& ) & >

& /

0 &

& 0 (

5 (

5 0 / & 5 0

( >

(

( )

& (

(

0 ( (

& 0

0 >

5 /

)

& (&

(

& &(

( &

& (

& * ( & ( &

( ( &

& & &

) )

5 0

& &

> - 0

> / !

& 5 #- ( (

) &

$ &

& &

A &

(

&( (

( &

- ( &

5 &

- & (

A& & & &

( (&

& & &

(

? ) ( 6&!9

#"*!'&$ $&'%.''&"(5 $"

#&($ (, >!*& &(' ( 9*& 1! & &"( '>!

%%"*$&(;4, $&'>&''!$)

) 44 1!($&(;

114&% &"(7'85 &# (,5 '044 ' ($ %4"'!$) ) )

'@/'

0! 0!* '1!/&(;:*!'"(!$

0! 0!* *!1"* 34!