← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/40/2003dismissed

Chet Ram v. Raghunandan And ORS.

2019-05-24Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu12 pages

        

    

   



!

 "##   

 $!% &&&''((!

)* +$*& &&&'

!

    

  



!  

       

,! &-&+$ & "!.#!$ &/##+$!$"

%'(#!''((!& 01*'

!/ &

!

"(## !

 & '#+$  "! &%2#$  "!

'

!/ &

3& &$ 42*$#4  "!

'

!/ '

!/ &56#"#& &)#$(7+ #!# (7 8

'

!/

999       

-$#''(##!#!*!+#!!$:*+%! !

3&&  ;!$#!# (# <*+=>!-"4 *!??

>#;.$;'

!/ !

.$ ."$+.#!$ !#



"'*#$;(*"!#  6

3

!$?# ,( #$ !@?,@ $;"1*#!!&

0!

''(1*'

!/ !

3 5 6%(%

  2*%  % ;*  %$  $$# $ ;$ %   # %. +!& 0!

''(1*'

!/

!

%( +$*  # 

(  $*#$#."(##  !

 &

-$''((!$ #("

%'(#!*"!#

3

6 +#!!$'

!.#!$!$((+!# !$!$##!

#((+2$%;#&8$!4 "

(

!$7%,"$! (#!$

'# 

#& 8$'#!$( % !

!$7%,"$!.$#"$$$ !$'

#

!$ (!

$#%&-$(.(# .; 

  &8 $'!(% !&

3 A!

#%' !$(&3& 3$. !*#+ !'( *+$#+!$ #(&!;

*! &'%.$$"$!$ #((+!$""*1*!# $#%!

.$$.'( *+$#+!$(& -$#!$!!$7%,"$!$( *!!$(!

!$% 

&3& 3& %'(#!!

(!$%!$!$$!4!$( (

 '# 

##&&

!

6!$7%,"$!$ #+$!

!

( *!!$(+#!

 % !$' &-$""*!$!!$ "

%'(#!!$!!$.

*(

"#;(!4'

#

!$( !

(( .!$"

%'(#!!

"*(!#!!$%&-$.B"$+

$ !

.

;!.!$"

%'(#!!$""*&-$"

%'(#!!

(!$ ""*!$!!$"

*( !

"#;(#'

$#%&!$#((!$""* .$ .%.#!$ !!"4$#%&""*$ ;$% #% %$"*#:*#.#!$   !$ #+

$##+$!$ *(!#+#$# #+;#+ "!*& #:

%#+$ 2#$  A 7$$% -#4%A  $0( $#$A %$

(;#A %0( ,%A %$"%!

!$"*

!$

"

%'(#!&-$""*"*#:*#!

!$%.((&""*% 2*% 0"$$# #"*#:*#!

 #: $#$ #+$!

$ *(#+$!%&%2*%0"$$ "*#:*#!

2#$ #

$#!%'( #+$!!$*%;$&""*% ;*"*#:*#!

 $0( $##+$!(+&  ""*$ ;$"*#:*#!

$# $ $#$.#!$ .$#(

(+$*$"*+$!

$ (

$#%&""* $$#%$"*#:*#!  (;# $# !$*%;"'*(& $*#$#"*#:*#! ,% $# ( !$ *(%#( #+.#!$     !$#+!$#"# 2#$A #"$ /A )* :*A 8#"%!$ "*  !$%&    -$  ""*  (  "#   %  #:*#  *#+  !$

""*"& %

!$#:*#.*!#.$!$.$#!;!$  

!$#"

""*#!$%(& %#:*#."*!

!$ ""*#(  "& & " "##+ *!

>?/ &55!3& , (#" !!# 8'**"!#  ?,(!#+!

!$% ""*" $(;"

%%#!!!

!$ *!

#

!#(#.$#"$!$ "

%'(#! !$$;;

4*"!# 6 

5?,!$"

%'(#!.( "

%%#!!!

 *!

# & 3& -  *;!!#!  $#  "  !$  "

%'(#!  B%# 

* .#!&  -$!!%!

!$""**"!#

&,&&. "

&  -$!!!$!!$.# "!& -$.'!# "

"!# .#!$*"!#

(!!$#((+$ *'(.$!$. !!"4;!$"

%'(#!'!.$#"$"*%*(!#'(#:*#! ( '  !$##&

!$%%2#$*""*%;!

!$#:*# +#+.$#"$"@!!& #:/# !"&@#'#+&-$'(

 !$!!$.

*((#"# "!

' #:*# !$#' ( !

' !$"#"*%!"#.$#"$#:*#."*! !$% !

%2#$&-$B%#

*.#!# "&

,C  "

%'(#!  '

    '  !$  %!  #  !$ "

%'(#!&8!!!$!!$"

%'(#!'!$+ !

, (#"!!# 8'*

( +#+'

!;

*!!$#"#!&> %!$!$$+  !

7 %!8 '#!( 8'*&-$!$'

(#"!#!$%&-$ .;#( *! !#B% !$!$#!#!*!!$'#!"

%'(#!& ?" B%#!# $%#!!!$!!$.#'*!#!$" *!

 .#!$+!

!$#'*!(&8%#!!!$!$$( !!$" ;

!$  ;*!!!!$!''($; #(+#!!$ 

!$ &8!!!$!$# !4 .#  3& 3,!!.( #'"!

!$!(&8!!$. !'!#!$#((+ 3& 3&8$"$!$#((+!;

*! &'% !$!!$ # !4 .!

.$!$ $''#!$#((+;

!$!&  8 "(#%!$!!#((!$# !4 .!$! 3& 3(!"!# $!4'("#!$#((+#.$#"$%2#$$;4#((& 5& ,C 2#$ !!!$! 3& 3!;

*! &3'%$. + #+  %!$#((+!

.!$ #(&8$ % # !#" !$!$#; !$$!%$;.(#;""*+$*

!$&((

!$%.%.#!$ &-$  %!$#

!$ "

%'(#! #: ,%  (;# $#$-#4%(

"%!$&0B%%2*%""*+ ;( . !$#+$!

#

$#$$& #:.+# ;( .;0"$$%  #""* $#$ "$&-4%.+#(!$# ;( . $##+$!(+;% ;*&$#$."*+$!;

(

" +$*+#;( .;$#;% $#$& (;#. +#  0!$#  ;( .    $#  ( !  $ *(    ( !  %  ;  %$   7$$%&,%.+##:*#;#$# $* $#( !

$$ *(&-$"

%'(#!'!. "*;/#  2#$&?B"#

!$#+$!!

(  "#:*#."*!

# % /!$# %2*% 0B% 7$$%%$& ?"  B%#!# $!!!$! 3& 3!$#'*!(.(  ;!$,"$!&-$# .!4; $**!!&8$ .

# !4 .#  $**!!$%'%!

(% #!$#((+ $ *'(&8!!!$! 3& 3!;

*!

!

'%$.'!!

$##"&!!$!!#%$!%.#!$ #(& 6&  &&2&$%   *:+8 '#!(/. ($# !!!$! & 3!;

*!

&3% $$"

*"!'

!% !% B%#!# !$;



%2#$A % ($

* !$

(( .#+#:*# $#;

#$#'

!DB&        

   

      

   

   ! "  #""$"

 %%  $$"   

$     #"

    

&  '#"

    

 ()  ! "  & *+', #!(B%#!#

!$"('!$#"4

*#

;(

 .!$&-$4*((.'"

%%*! "!* #!$#

 !('#!(+# &-$.!$#"4*;*($%!

%(( ;

!$ ";($%#'$

;#& -$."

!*# $%!

% ;

!$

 !(;#&  *!# ;!."

*"!#+!$'

!% !%B%#!#

# !$.

$ *&-$"*

!$.*!

$#:*"* ;;(*!

"#%'"!&?:*#/  ###*(("

(("!#(. *

#"#!!

"*!$# #"

*&

&  &<+% $#!!(  82*(#>#; !!!$! 3& &3 $.'

!7(8 '#!( ,(.(& !$! $$%#"

(+((B%##%'$#'

!

DB&

*!$

(( .#+#:*# $#'  E-  $! $( $             $ $ !

 "$ 

-  $! $(  $    

& 

 -    $  ! $  .

      "   $  ! $

$!   ! .

$    -  $! $.

   $  $$  .

$    /

$! !  $"

    

        '-"

   .! $

$!   

   , ?:*/ ."(+# * .$#:*/ &. "(#%'(&F.#;$#%#'"!

!

#:*#&(( !$#:*#

*;$#%."*;;(*!.'

&

& !$% $$%#"

(+((B%#%2#$ '$#'

!DB&,<

*!$

(( .#+#:*# $#'  E#!    $ 

    

  )  !"$ 

  

#!      

      

 

0$"

1 2   

    $

$ ! !  #

"

            ! .

$, ?:*/ &."(#%'(.$#(!

!$#:*#. 4'!*F ;!# &

& 8$( B%#7$$% !$%' $#'

!DB&,2

*!$

(( .#+#:*# E3  $! $2 $   

     

  /

$  !        

  &     $

0$"

%    .

$             #  !       "        !  $      , ?:*/ .#%'(.$#(!

!$#:*#.4'!

*F ;!# &((!$#:*#."*;;(*!.' &

& -$  %#"

(+(  B%#!#  

 %$  A  %  2#$ (!$

(( .#+#:*# E3  $! $ 4 $

      

0$"

(    .

 $         $

 /

$!        

  0$"

         

.

$    , ?:*#/ ."(#%'(& -$!.4'! *F ;!# &((!$#:*#.

*!

$;"*; ;(*!.'

 .#!$#' ;;(*!#

$ *&

%

&  %#"

(+(B%#!#

%2*%!$

(( .#+ #:*#.

* -  $! $%  $  

 5    

- $"

! !   ! .

$  

 5       $ 

/

$!   ! 2      5       !    $ ! $    .

    $ /

$!      $     /

$!       '/

$!       , ?:*/ ."(#%'(#!*&-$!.4'! *B ;!# & ((!$#:*#."*;;(*!.'  .#!$#' ;;(*!#

#B$ *&

3& 8( %#"

(+((B%#/!$#0(&'$#'

!

DF&,/$

*!$

(( .#+#:*# $#'  -$

$!    .

$    

 -"

    2           $   "   & ! $" "

! !   ""$       6 &

* !$ $!

 & *!   $ 5  " 7  ,

& -$%#"

(+(B%#!#

0B%'$#'

!DB& ,(!$

(( .#+#:*# -"

 4.

       

/

$! !  $"

! "

   

  $     

0$"

       /

$!       $    $ # !     "  !  $ 

& '/

$!     

&    $ (/

$!   .

$      $ %/

$!       $, ?:*/ &

3."(#%'(#!*&-$! .4'!*B ;!# &((!$#:*#."*;;(*!

.'

.#!$#' ;;(*!#

#B$ *&

5& 8$( !*1!

, (#"!!# 8'*#!#%!#+ ;

*!!$%##

!$#:*#!$$ '#!(&, (#"''(#"!# $ +$# '## !$!%$ /!$# 7$$% 0B% %2*% #%. #!!

%4!!%!& %2#$.* #!!

%4 !!%!&

6&  ?'"!

  ,*  $  ? 7*+   !!  !$!  3& 3  $  .  '

!  #  , (#"  !!#   8'*&    8  "# #

%!# !;

*!3&'%;

*! %(!"!# ##((+2$%;#&8 .!!

#((+2$%;#(!!$!!$#:*$+ !

7( '#!( ,(.(&!7(8 '#!(,(.($"

!$!!%!

#%.$ %!$ "!

$"( #!!

%4!!%!&8!

*1

+#!!#

" .$#"$

%(>?.+#!!, (#" !!# 8'*!6&3'%&8( "

!$!!%!

%$

/!$#0( 7$$% 0B%%2*%.$ ."( #!

 %4#+!!%!&%2#$."(* #!!

%4!!%!&8 !$.!!

#((+2$%;#!;

*!6& 3'%'' *+$#! '(&8"

!$!!%!

7** *!!8##+$*"!#

,& ((!$""*B"'!,%$2$ *!!. ! 3  %#((+2$%;#&-$.'

' *";!$%

 .  !4  #!

 "*!

&   ,%  $    2$  .  !  3&  %2#$# & .$ !!$

". "

!!

*"!#  ?,&

& C *((#$'"$!!!$!$$;'"$

7%,"$!2$%;##"

& 

$#%%!&7!.!$ '"$&   8  ; *+$!  !$  ' "#+  +#!&  -$  ' "#+ 

3& 3!#!$+#!&8"

*( !#.$ $!$ ' "#+."

&8!!!$! 3& 3$%#+$!$; ##((+2$%;#&/ #'*!$!4'("#$#'"&

& -$(-#( *! !#"!$!!$"

%'(#!!$ ""*$#

!# ;

*!!$#"#!

3& 3&+ !$#

!$"

%'(#! !$.+(#+#"

#!"##!$ !!#% #

,C $!%,C 2#$ ;

!$+#+!$'("

""*"!$%

# (#"!#

#:*#.$#"$##!# !

!$ *B'(#(# #(#+!$"

%'(#!# *;!;

*!!$"

!$"

%'(#!&

& ,C $!%!!!$! 3&  !"*(!#!#+!$ ($$!!

$##((+2$%;#&!;

*! &,!$""* %!$#%&-$$(!"!# .#!$$#%.$ !!$!!"4$#% "*#:*# $##+$!$ #+&-$ !$#; !$2#$ 

#: $#;

G$#G$#%  (;#,%( "% !$& -$.( "*#:*#;!$""*& -$## # #"

#!!.#!$$#!#!$" B%#!# !$!$$"$!$ #((+  2$%;#  !  ;

*!  &  ,  (    #   !  4 .  ;

*!  !$ $''#+#!$#((+;

!$!&

& ,C 2#$ !!!$! 3& 3!;

*! &3'%.$$

.+ #+  %!$#((+!

.!$ #($$ % # !#"  !$!  $#  ; !$  $!  %  $  ;  .(#  ;  ""* +$*   

!$&    ?  " B%#!#   $  !!  !$!  3& 3!;

*!

&A &,&& $.'!!$##"&!!$!

!#%$!%.#!$ #(&-$#+#  !1**'.#!$!$ #

$!%!$!$$!*!

!$#((+! &'&%# !4 .;

*!!$$''#+!$;

!$!& 8#"(#% 4 .(+!$!(!"!# $!4'("#!$#((+#.$#"$% 2#$$;4#((&

& ,C 2#$ ( !!!$!""*0B%%2*% $# (#"!#:*#.#!$(!$# $#$#+$!$.$,C

$!%!!!$!#:*#."*!

$#%;%2*%% ;*&,C 2#$ !!!$!;( . !$$

$#$. +#;#%.$""

#+!

,C $!%!$##:*. # (#"!;$ ;&',C 2#$ #:*#.# (#"! !$( !

$ *(( !%

 (;#;%$ $#&""

#+!

,C

$!%!$#:*#."*;% ;*0B%&#%#((

!$!

,C ,C ##"'!.#!$+!

!$#:*# !$ '

,%&',C #:*# !$( !$$ *(

,%.# (#"!;#$# $*&,C $!% !$

!$$!!!$!!$#:*#."*;%$ $ #+$&

& #!$#"

#;(*B'(#(# #(#+!$ "

%'(#!&-$ ""*"#

3& 3.$!$"

%'(#!. #(

6&

3&-$B'(!#

!$"

%'(#!'!!$!!$"

%'(#!

"

*( !; #((#!$.#:#(. !

*"#;(&

 %'(#!  $!  %  $  ;  (    ;#(    &

3&  -$ "

%'(#!. #((% !% !$!$ !&-$#("! *;! !$;

 #

!$"

%'(#!&     !$#:*#"*!

!$ "

%'(#!'!.((%# .$!$ #:*#*!#; !$ ""*.+# *#"(*#+ "!**

;%

!$%&% 2#$#*(!

!$#:*#*!#;$#%&-$(-#(  *!  #+$!(  "

"(*  !$!  !$  "

%'(#!  $  ;  #(   !  * (#;!#       "

*!;(!  !

 !$  "  +#!  +#!  !$ "

%'(#!$#&

3& -$# + *!

#! .#!$!$.(( :*+%!

!$!#( *!& 1*!( !$''(##%#&

'

( '     (  



)*   +# C$!$'4#+A  H C$!$'

!;( HA/