High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/107/2021disposed of

M/S United Spirits Ltd v. M/S Sidhi Vinayak Enterprises And ORS

2025-08-21Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel3 pages

!"#"

$% &'&

% ()&*

* )

!"# $"% &&''

) % %(% !"# )(#% ** + ' !"# $"&" ","- . ('

!"# $"&" "/ 00000 * ) +&,-./ , % 1 (!& 2

(%& ' %

'"*+(% ("$"* "$' !% '"

1&$ #("3456-78 8,943 : % !% ' #"

'$"%(!

'& ( % ! & %& &;1"") "

'*% 3 <$"&"# (*"% % ("6$"* "$&#( '

' !" '7 '" (%"$(+"

' 1 &&"("$%( " = & 12%(8"

( ('

+%(%(8"

+%(''2(* &" % (# "$%">1' & 8"

( ! "! #!

$ % & #

'()

*+, *!! , -%

%' % ' ( " "$ #?

( '( &"# (* #(" ,35 "$ % *"( 1'

# ,55, &$ 12 % #"

( $ ''?

'2+(%(%& !(+"$&"!(""#("34:"$ 8 8-,3"$<:@:3%(= (#( ' #( ("+ & (# &" %(& (! (*% $"%& &""$ #"

( #(",35"$%*"( 1'

#,55,%#"

( ( #"

& +(%(%A& (! $(((""$B> '( (% 8 8 ,943< :@:3 8"?

'2 % #"

( ( " #" ( "& % "(*&"# "$)(*&#( '' ! " ' #("3456-7"$8 8,943-,96-7"$<:@:3 %(8"

#" % %#"&

1("$&"!(""#("34:

8 8-,3< (%'21"

" ##"

(*+% = A &" +(%%#"

& (!'2 "+#"$("$#("3456-7"$ 8 8,943-,96-7"$<:@:3+%(#%

%&"# "$ &#( '' !$"

%(*%8"

$" ' ( #?

( '(

(# "+! " (* &"$"

( " % "! #%(* &(#(&' "$ = (# ( (" " &#'

&"# '#%(# '(($"

#'(&(*% 1 (! = (# (""$% # %(8"

( "$

('2 ( ((*% '"%(#%(# '

($( (2= (#("

'2"& "'* % '"*+(% ##"

& 2(*

("67"%#"# ("8"

- !

"(!(+"$% (# "$%">1' & 8"

( ! "! #!

6 & 7 '"%&""

# "$%(8"

(

6 & 7C%& '"*+(% ##"

& 2(* ("67 ( (&" "$ %

6(7 %& '"*+(% ##"

& 2(* ("67( ( "%' ("D *E ( +(% (#("" %

% !(*1$(' #("34:"$8 8,943#("-,3"$ <:@:3 % ( ' ("D *

2 % '"

%( '$ " (* ( " "% 8"

"$ #"

& = ( (#(" $" ( (&" &'

+ 6((7 '"#'

($2% %(8"

% " '! ("% ( "$% ' '" '"*+(% ##"

& 2(* ("67C %

('$"&$"#"( (""$%#"# ' ("8"

+%(#% % ''( 1( 1'2 = (# %

+(%"

*(*($'

# 12 2 "1!

%( 1"! 6(((7 % *(2( (# " A& (("

'2%#"

&' #" "$%& '6(#'

(*%& &;1"")7"% ( ' ("D * ,* )/ :,:@:/ F%%& )(* " "

F%%&" 1' "