High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/42768/2013disposed of

Perdipt Chaudhary v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-07-04Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri26 pages

!"#!$%&%"'())

( *+,) - ,-. *+,) - ,))

% & &' #

( &) '

& & *+

$ &'(

'& !"

,+ -. / ) -./ + " 012 ) ! $ "

$3+4.56 .17827.6 " 22 9. 1: 4; " .81: $ &"

; " & &,

+! $ $"

" -2/ , ! $ $ ) " " " -6/

! % %"'!0&* $&!

" !&

" & =

!$ " 4 ?

& '

" .9 % & < # .888 &

$" # # $ &"" ; $ && ( !

& &&6..227.9<

&&"

@ " " $=" && " &,

4 " "- ,4B/ !

& 6..227.6 < &"" $ !

$ &$"

&$"

& $ <

& " <& " $ &" & + " " $ " "& " " " " <& -CD";

/ & .8:9 < " " $ && 4 " " "& -/ ; D& ( >E -/ ;D D ( >E -/

-0/

&&# "

& & " " " $ D"$ " & +

"& "

" " && "

$ @

& ,4 - .. "&&/75.727.6 ")$ "

&!"

&&#$ ")

-/ ;D D ( >

4& -/ ; D& ( >

.27796)$ -/

9:707)$ -:/ <# % $

$ &&$

! ! " 7:.727.6 # "

.7"

! "@ " # &

" " " < # &F

G< &$ ! -9/ 42 0-/(&"

& - / -/,

$ %

&" $ ; " & - /E -/,) $ , ( , ; " & - / &&$

! " 75.727.6 .267 &$# "07 97 &"" &

@ # &" @ &"

" # B!, &$ # +!

$ $ 4( 0: .088 460 &

" .77 < &"

&" % &<

!$# " && & # # ) &") ) " < ! & " - # 42/# !"

; " , " % " "" :

9 !"

< " # "

" !"

" $ &# # &"

") # &# #$ # &&#

")$ && &!

"& $ &""

H $ " " $ #

! < &" #! & & & $ $

& ) < ; $+" % &# &

$" " " < # !$ -5/ 460

# $ " " $ 3+ 4.56 .17827.6 " 22 9. 1: 4;" $

; " & -.2/ -1/ 460 &" " & & " 16775.727.6 & !$9 5&"" &

#&& " &&#$ .767

-8/ "

)#71.727.6

42 0 &"" & ! " & $ )$ &")"&&" &" $&$ " "

")$ # & "" ) "

# ") -.7/ # 42 & ! "& ( % &71.727.6> )#

# && !$% & &"

;; % &$ $ !

-../

! !

$&&$ &# "! " 75.727.6 40 ! # 78.727.6 # "! &&$& ) %

# & &" &"!.717"

&# ) 0:7"

) ! # & # < # & &&$ # )# )

-.2/ #$ $ " # " ; $ && ; ! " .2.727.6 # # "& &") < +" < & $ ! #

" $! "

& # $ #

&# "@ # # H &"3 && ; $ && % & "$ " " # $# 67)$; D& ( > ") # & # < # "

# &#

E " # &

! -.6/

# & "& 3+481: 21..27.6 " 610 619 615 611 618 :72 027+ # $ &" % % $

$ # & ! " 21..27.6 ."

& 460 -.0/ +

& ") ) ! $ 3+4.56 .17827.6 " 22 9.1: 4;" .81: $ &"

; " & ,+ $" !

$ #

! & & -.:/ !&1"'2!' &*3!0&%"'( &"- 4. 0/

! B &&$ + &

! 207627.0 D&

3+4.56 .17827.6# $ " @ & " " .1

25 ,-2/ 25 ; ; $ "" .807# & "

=% &# .17827.6 && $

" 4 &($ # # # (# &&$&# $ 4

# " & &$ # $ D"

& "

& & " $# & % "

& > # # $ 4

.7 77 777 & "& 01777"

& "& # ) # "! & %

# "&

#!&!

" " "

" " "& ! %

) %

! , ) %

;& # < # # ?

$ 72.727.6 #

2677 & 3"&& 2 :2 777 " & & .2777"

& !3 - && $/#"! ) %

& @

# "! !%

& ) %

$ "

& $ "& !

# "& # # &

" " $ " $ -.9/ + !

"& "

& && # " $# )#$

" = > % 01 777 & " & # "! & %

+!# "& ) %

# ""

! 3+ &"

# ! 7:.727.6& ?

$ $ #

" & & # # & & & " &+! $ < " " " < +< & &"

&&"&" % " " $ + " &" # # !"+< && &" % " &"

";; # &" &" % &< ; $ +" % & # & ) ( % & # "

& .27227.0 < # & "& %

% &

# ) & ! &-6/ # " " 75.727.6 ..67 "

&& &71.727.6 $ -.5/ + &&$

$ " ! $& & " ! # $& ! $ ;D! & # $ & D ! & " $ " $

"& "

& #$ $ .7)$ A

B # " D #$ $ 9:)$ A; D& ("

&B #&$ D#$ $87)$ & " $" $.7)$ D"

# - D #/ # ) $ " $ .:)$ D"

#- D #/# " ! "& +!

$$ 4( 0:

.088# ..77 "& & # ) 057 "

& ! # "! < "

& ! "!

"! 3" "" > < " "

D 0(" &"! " +!

&&#

-0) ") !$"3!04 56' % 4 !&67 # !0 $8!9%$7 '74&%& .

# 9:)$

2 ; D&

&# 87)$ ; D&

& 6 + D"

# -D #/ .7)$ ;D D

& 0 + D"

# -D #/ - " / .:)$ ; D&

& : + D"

"& #

) -"! +!

/ ..77 ;D D

& 9

& ! -3+!

/ 057 ;D D

& -.1/ &"

" " # &!$ <

! &&" $ ! " +<

& & !$ + "&

& % & &" " &"

& & # ! %

% & > & %

"& # & " -.8/ ""$ &" & $"&&"

B " # 3""">

707627.0 " " $"! && # 4; " "

! $ & &"

&"" $

" $$&$ " $"

! $ & !

#"& "& 207627.0 -27/ +

& !

& ;D D ("

& &

'! + !'

H 4 "

267:27.6 3> .7)$

" # " " " 71.727.6< "

&"! ! "& & & ! " " #

& &

& 4& ")$ + .:)$ # & &&$

!"! " # # & & &"< 3> "

#; D& ( > -2./ &&$ D . "

! +

! && &$ " ""& $$ &"

+< % &+

&"&

$ $3> "

&& # .77627.0< $ ! $

-22/ ; $ &&$

( - 4:9/

!& & $

; $ & " % & &D& $ #" " &&# "

) #"

75=71.727.6+ D&

&&"" &&6..227..

& # & 7.7.27.2 6..227.9

&& " ; + !

! & & # "

! # " " &"

" " && -26/ &,

+! $ - 41/

&& & $

G+ !

# $

% "

&G+ & !

&&# "$ && # (B&

! #

%&&' ##()> &

( ) "

( ) (

G -20/ &,

4 " "I 45

& &= ! $ "

&&"" ;D D ( >-177)$ / ; D& ( >-277)$

-.77)$ /

$ & & $ @

& -2:/

! & ! 277627.0 - &$# "

D 20 28/ &&# 207027.0 -67/ " "

&& 7:7627.0 -6./ <

! & " & " &"

227127.: &$# "

D 62 69+ !

!& @ 787.27.0 ( &" &$ # &$ & ; " .77.27.0# #$!

-29/ &" % & &

! 7:7027.0 & " $ @ =! $

&&$ &!& &" $ : ! @ # " " ; &"-(J/ % &7:7027.0# ""&

F " & "$H & " < @

&& "" &"-9/G

-25/ " " !

$ ! "" && <

"$ &" K4276:827.6 & !"

$ && )

& " & " # "" # & &" $ !

$ $& & & & "

" & # # &!&! $ & " $

) # " && " &&"

&&""#$ + 27.6 & &" "&

! "! 6 26 7:9 " 67 9:2 :87 "

& && # # $ $ &$ < " $

-+ C/ #

" $ "

" && + # "! $ $ + & "

> # & # & & ) $

! ") &&&" $

-21/ 3+4.56 .17827.6 & * #& %

% & # 4

% "

& > &&

"& $ $ # $ ") # $

& & & "" &

! & & &" + " & %

# & "$ "& )

&&$ < "!

! " &

) %

# &

! "" !&

"& "

&&&# " $ #

) &&$&$

" -28/ K

% & !"

I&'

& " $ " &&$ $ &!

"# "

, ,-* , -67/ J $ ! & " " &"

$ &

$ & "

-/ 4.

) %

! $ " $

"& "

" => &&$ " & & &" "&&" !"

# " H

< !" "

&$ " % &" " &" H & "

3+@ " #&& "

# " &$ " ! $ $ $" % & & & " ! & # &"

" & # & && # " &" ! $ $ $"#

$ " < &" " & ""

" $ "

# ! $ $ $" # $ "

$ "! % & > " & " .55 ""$ # !"

&& & @ # # &"

" # " E -/

" " &"

" "" # & &" & " $ " !$ & #

" $ " # $ " 2. 4; " " & & ! $ $ $"

!$ " " @ $" $ "

! $ " " &" "

" &)

& "& "

&H ""

3+# ""

% & &""

" & " % ) "! H C! "

""!

! $ $ $"

!$ " E -/ # &" " $ # ?

$ &"!& &05 " "; $ "

" " & .81:# #&)" ")"

D"&

4 " "E -!/

" .56 " $#

&&$& $ ""

3+ ;& % &# &&$&

% &< "

"& & $$

# $ "

&&$

&$" "

"& " # &) $ "

< $"

!$D ! $ $ &)"

# "

! + " & &,

4 " "E -!/

& $ !&

&" # " " H " < A # B -./ & $ ?

$ 7:.727.6 $ & " A# B< # AK B

!" & " # A K 3 " B

! # & " "

&& -65/ " " &"!

! & # # #

# "! A # B A# B D"& $A# B3 A # B # A( B# ""

=> 4

;;&"

&&" % &

"& && H <

# &!& " 51 58 86 88.77-0/ E -!/

H " # "

&& "

! & $ $ " ! $ + ;; -2/

+ & ( &" # "

$&"

"!$

&" " & % & 4 # ; $

&&$

& & "

!$ $$

# " " 75.727.6 && " 71.727.6 $ &< "

&" # ") 75.727.6 " <&& &

4&) % &$# +!

( 0: .088

2679 2675 "

77 6. 77 68 71.727.6 <

@ H " $

! &

& !

$ 78.727.6E

-!/ 42

&& &"

&&$ & +!

! "&+ # "

"! " # # +!

$ 78.727.6 @ & "!# & && &"

42 ! "&$ E -!/ @ 787.27.0 ( &" & "& &" ""$ " & &"

&&"# ) E ! "& &"

42& (

!$" <&&& 4&)

& -!/E $# ; $ &&$

% &E &"# # E "&

" # ! 71.727.6 &E +!

# ! "

$ "

( &"

$ "

# &&$ $ $ "

3+F

& &"" &LG E -D/

&& 257527.: -65/ "& &$ !" & ! &&$ "< ! $ $ $" "

$ )

&# ! # # # "

&& (#! # & ") & #&"

$ >

-6./

& " & &

!* - / $

! &$ ) ! $ !# "

! " &&#

! $ ,+ $"(" +"

,-* .%&&' ##&& "

! $ "

,+! &$"

&" "& " "#

* %&'0 ## 1 $

($ "

" ! $ $" # $ "

& & ! &).56-1/"

& " # ($ )&) ! $ ! $ " "

"< "

3 "

$-* .%&&0' ##44 -62/

& 2"

2 5 "

5 .%&&&') ##64&# " "& 229 " .55.51 &

& " # " " &""" " " & " # &&$ " # " + 3"+"

5 -7%&&0' ##16 D "&& #5 8 "

- / D&

& " # $ " &"# & " & """

" "" # "& # & F

+ ,

' G -66/ > & '

" B"& & "

) ! $

!""& "& 207027.0

.87:27.0 $ D "" & & " & # # &

& % & " " 3+ @ " .56 D& #

$ @

&&" $ "

& $ # # "!&%

" $

# !& &) & " $ "

" # " > ?

$ # " &

7:.727.6 &&#

# & &

# !

"# ;! '

4. $

# &&#! " # # 7:.727.6 "

! "E

" # " &

" &( &" & 4. # !"

#&& % &, &&

" "

!$ $ &" H && $ $ " $ & E "/

# & # " "& %

% & # ) "$ & ! &( # "&"& $ %

% & # # " " E /

& $" &&"

# # A # B A# B & D"

"& " " & ?

$ 7:.727.6 < "

& ?

$ E /

" & A"B

" # C! $&&" $ ) & " ( & " $ "

# &" "

E /

& ) & @ ( &" # ! "" $ &"

< ! &

&" % &$# &@ & !

4. &" # && & & "$H & "

!" E $/

4; " .81: " & > # !# # " " 0. " & ?

$ # ! " # " #

" " $ "

" "

) "" & = & " < # & & " &

$ E

/ & & " .51-/-"/-/

@ !"

&& " " &" " # " & " # < & ! $ & " # " $ " " $! " &"

"& $

( E /

!" "! &" & %

& ' -"

$ "

/ &

$ ") &&" $ # $ -

/ % & = '& & > $ # # '& 4 '&# $& !&! & &"

4;" - !"

! " #&&/E

$ $ )$ # +!

" && & # 42 - !"

/ & 757.27.:

# +!

4( 0: .088 # "

! & # &$ ) " " &$LG & # ! & # 42E )/

&&$

# &&&"

$!D ." % $

&" & &" &

""" "!

"# %

% & I "& 4. # & "

" "!" " 672+ < & " & "

"& $

$ < "

&& & &4 %

% & -80.9677771/ !

# #

&& % $ I $ $ #

" &)&& " ( &" -60/ > " & & " 75.727.:#$2 11

&4%9 #"

$- * ' "" "

# & # ! $ ,+ $" "

4;" &" $ " &! 27.6 $!$ & "& ! $

$" " " & +! $ < + " )+" ' &&" # " &&

+ # $

&& "

!" !& # " " -6:/ K

!$! &" "

!$ &!

" -69/ $ $# ($ " ,+

$" ! $ "$H & " # " '!

!-* - / D # &

D" $& "

& D" &

!"& &&""! $ # "

! & & "

# $ "& " "$ &$ < &$ !"

# "

# ""

# ! $ "" && " $$! $ "

!" "

&" " " # "" ! $ #&&"$H "

" -65/ C@

&& &!

# ! $ & $& ! "& # )$ " " & &# $$ &" ! " && "

& " " "

$" M -/ 9 # - * "

2#! & %)' # %#' 11E-/

,-* %&' ##

)E -/

:+"

-* %&4' ##()LN

-61/ & ) !&! @ & " &" " " $ H " &"

% &-( /#

& $ #

" &"

(

& # # & ""

&$ " $ 9 #8 "

- /

$ #

# &$ &&#

./0123 "

- #- #

(

#- #

4 -68/ ! !

# " D " 2. 4; " #

# ! " ! ! " & " &"" $

&&L LD & & "&

- / -/-"/< DF D G

" 2-DD!/ " F )

*< + *< + G " ! $ $ $" &$ &) "

!" "$!" "&

$ & &$" " $ $"

$"% & > "&

& &&" $# "

& "" B " $

$ " ""

" 3+ " ""

# ?

$ #

H " 0.02 " "

&! ! !#" :. 4;" ""$ # ! &F " # ! " && # H " G -07/ C! "

4; "

&$ &" ! $ $" & $" $$ " #<

! $ ( &"

" ! 4. # !"

# &&$ $ , -0./ K &

&& # D"& ! & "

"" "

&"! $ "

" $$

( &"# $

H < ) &"

!$ !$ " & && $ !"!$ # &" "

& &" $ -02/ & & &&$ "

$ !# $ " A # BA# B "

"!"$"!# " &

$ 7:.727.6 !

& ! & $ ""

& !"

$ !# $ # &"" &$ " & -06/ "

&! "

" & $ " && " &&"

&= 4;" # & " &

!& )& "D" "&& "!

" ; $ &&$

(

& ; $ &&$

% &K

"&" # & & &! $ ) D -00/ < B! D ! &

"" & & & # !"

" &$# 9 5&"

&!"

H # &"

"75.727.6 -! D" 71.727.6 / "

) "& -.:/D " & .7 .5.727.6C!

&&&! %

% & I "& & ! @ & $ # $ + ! &"

# %

% & # & $ ! "

&& $ $

" "

# &&" $ $

! " -0:/ && !& ! " &" #&&# $ ) & -/ &" $ -09/ 3 # "

! $ ,+ $"(#! !#

& " +< "$ + "9 #-* "

- / $ $ &) & ")!"# " &"&

"&&" " #" +< D " 3+I & &$# " .56

"" "#

!& # " "< +<#&&"& D"#

" " " K & &

&&" ""& && +< # !# # $

! $ "

-604.'

62:! ))

))86280%

62:!